Wanted to get some thoughts. My wife works in private accounting and just got promoted to manager. We prepared for her compensation negotiation for about a week. She goes in and they low ball her with only a 4k raise. She counters with her value to the firm and the office managing partner literally laughs in her face. You guys think she should just bail? I am embarrassed that this is how they treat their employees.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Quit? No. Settle for what they give you and then job hunt? Absolutely. She can snub them when she doesn’t give 2 weeks.

likesmart

100%

like

You’re only worth as much as your next best opportunity.

This is why loyal employees (who don’t search for other opportunities, so they have none) are so underpaid.

like

This. Howmuch ever loyal you are to a firm, it is never loyal to you. Have your options ready. always.

It’s definitely a jerk move to laugh in her face but I wouldn’t just walk away given the economy.

Did her company go through layoffs or perhaps the boss had to fight for the raise she did get and isn’t reacting well to her attempt to negotiate? Not excusing the behavior at all, definitely a terrible reaction, but maybe it’s just a super stressed out partner who’s had to lay people off or deal with frustrated employees who are getting no raise and the first reaction was this...point is, if this is a one time experience for her and she otherwise likes this partner/company, then give them another shot before throwing in the towel over this. Maybe have a separate convo with the partner to hash it out if their relationship would allow for this. If this is in addition to her having other issues with her job there, then perhaps use it as the motivation she needs to start looking.

like

That’s messed up.

She should take whatever salary bump she can get and start looking for employment elsewhere. If they try to counter to keep her, they’ll now have to match whatever the external offer is or risk losing her.

like

What was the counter?

The counter is “Is COVID comiserately driving down bill rates?”

like

Op please clarify, did she counter with an actual number

Wow they laughed at her for an extra 4K? They sound terrible.

like

Usually the raise is bad for internally promoted people in normal industry jobs, so I’m not surprised.

I would just take the raise and start looking if y’all are really unhappy. After all, it’s just 4K diff (8-4)

Sounds extreme to quit over 4K, but she doesn’t sound happy (and neither do you), so yes - she should bail.

Isn’t laughing at a counter offer a negotiation technique? Swear I read that in a book but maybe watched too many pawn stars episodes growing up

I guess you could classify it as a technique but probably not one you want to employ with someone you intend to continue successfully working with.

smartfunny

Never split the difference by Chris Boss if you are going to negotiate a counter offer anytime soon.

Maybe remind them that it will cost more than $4K to identify, recruit, hire, and train a replacement?

Related Posts

Was anyone from this bowl just on the KPMG Australia Town Hall? What do you think of the payback and pay adjustment announcements?

like

How high can google go on signing bonus ( currently $25k) and equity (currently $65k) for L4 position.. total exp 4 years .. should I negotiate?

like

Hi Fishes :
I have 2 offers for Automation Engineer:
1- EPAM Anywhere - 21LPA[inc. Bonus] - Totally Remote
2- Jio Infocom - 21 LPA[Fixed] but with lot of provisions in CTC - Will call to office [location : Mumbai]

YOE: 6 Years
Need your suggestions

like

How much package I can expect as powerbi developer. My current stack is MSBI and planing to learn powerbi. How much package should I expect? YOE -8.5

My partner got a City of Toronto offer. Salary band is 104-121k. HR asked for his expectations and he said 115k. HR came back with a 106k offer stating nobody on the team makes that much so they cant offer it. Also said she is unsure if there is any wiggle room if any at all. I’ve looked at everyone on the team with the same titles salary on the sunshine list and the lowest I see is 121k. I assume there is an OT component of some sort but also can’t confirm. Thoughts? /negotiating advice?

likesmart

What is shift allowance in VOIS morning afternoon? Night

like
likeuplifting

What is the salary for Senior Associate at A&M CSG team? Fixed and Bonus.

like

Whats Average hike in Synechron yearly ?

like

Hi Fishes,
I got offer of 14.2 LPA from Cognizant in Otc 2021.
The lastest offer I have is of 19.5 from Capgemini.
Please suggest how should I reach to the recruiter(Cognizant) for counter offer?
And how much they can provide?
YOE - 9

like

Hi folks , what’s the salary range for Wipro Europe development centre (iDeas D&C) for B3 level Sr consultant ?

like

Will there be any hike if I moved to associate 2 in pwc ac, if yes how much can I expect?

In hand salary?

Post Photo
like

What's the CTC given to Associate 2 position at KPMG GDC?

like

Thoughts on joining EY Advisory PI or Guidehouse as a manager 2. Salary and sign on are exact same.

like

What are some negotiation scripts you people have used to negotiate a higher salary after the initial offer?

like

Hey everyone, would you know how much a Manager in PwC US Advisory make, say in Washington DC? Would be great to understand the fixed as well as the variable component. Also do you guys use a purchase parity index calculator before you change geographies?

like

What will be in hand salary of 30LPA ( 28.5 fixed +1.5 variable) in Virtusa? Please help.

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes, please use the chart to calculate your in-hand salary. Tata Consultancy Cognizant Accenture India Infosys EPAM Systems EPAM Anywhere 🇮🇳

Post Photo
likesmart
like

More Posts

Anyone know much about the start up scene in E Africa? I hear a lot of general talk about how it’s ‘booming’ but can’t find much information online. I’m in a weird position where I’m trying to switch into tech but am moving to Kampala for the next year. I am applying now to remote jobs in the U.S. but would love to connect with companies operating in the region.

like

Hi
I just want to renegotiate with @IBM to revised offer letter, HR is not responding.
DOJ 1 September.
Any suggestions please.

Thank you

Any advice on how to switch from big 4 to tier 1 consulting firms like BCG and MCK?

like

Anyone else feel like calling out black today? With all this overt racism and extreme white privilege going on in Charlottesville and the lack of response from the White House (expected but still insulting), I feel so disheartened.

like

Currently in Atlanta, GA. Looking for management role in wealth management, corporate and institutional solutions, business strategy and consulting. I have an MBA from non-target school, about 5 years in management from financial services, business strategy and development and I’m looking for a great company with salary range around $150k or above. A referral would be highly appreciated!!

like

I have a 401k from my previous employer in Meryl Lynch. Current 401k is in fidelity. I would like to know if it’s easier to roll over ex employer contributions to fidelity (or) open an independent IRA account. I don’t intend to withdraw money from or take a loan on 401ks

like

Which firms have you gotten offers from, but gave them a pass? And why?

like

Interesting all the noise about these PPT, my take:

The pandemic took all the upside of an IB analyst life (client meetings in person, fancy trips, suit up, worshiped at networking events) and left all the juniors with the downside (long hours, monkey-like type of job, aggressive work environment).

Not that the complaints are not sort of legitimate but you may need to revise the decision-making process that led you to accept a return offer. Specially if you were looking for less hours.

like

Anyone on here worked with Edelman? Pros? Cons?

like

Hi All,

I have offer from Accenture with 15.5 LPA with 21percent VPA including 3.25 L variable pay. The pay is for Level 10 and domain is SAP, YOE is 4.6. So what is the pay range for Level 10 and I do have counter offer so can I negotiate further with Accenture.

like

Does Pune HSBC provide cabs for pick up and drop?

like

Hi Fishes, Kindly suggest pls. Sap functional with 6+ yoe. Cctc 8.2 fixed. Got offer from Accenture 11.5 fixed and Deloitte India 12 fixed. Which one to choose considering wlb, hike et. Accenture Deloitte India

like

Anyone do subscription based pricing? I’ve been seeing this a lot lately, curious if it works?

likehelpful

Feeling burnt out and unmotivated with agency life. Throughout the past year I’ve been added to a variety of “problem accounts” with challenging, disorganized and rude client contacts. Since then, it feels my teams have dwindled and I’ve been left to pick up the pieces / manage it all. I’m struggling to feel inspired and am starting to dread my work. Any tips for how to initiate account changes without sounding whiny? Or - any tips in general?

like

190 of us in 5 hours? That’s depressing!

How much time does ADP takes to come back after document submission on portal for HR discussion.

Hey guys.. anyone looking for good friend... Getting saturated with wfh :(

like

I am also being released, however my school has told me that I can come back once i accomplish the tasks I need to accomplish.
For people that are on the fence about the industry, I tell them to try another district. You know what you did and didn't like about your school so you can go in armed to see what another school is like. Don't be afraid to see the school, ask for a tour, talk to the teachers. Sky's the limit!

like

Guys, how's the career and salary growth at a senior level (Sr.manager) at Tata Consultancy? Also what are the distinguishable benefits at TCS?

I am currently evaluating offer

like

What do people recommend for start-up relevant marketing resources/books/personalities/podcasts?
I have a lot of enterprise marketing experience, but making a jump to a startup and want to get up to speed as quickly as possible.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Entering my 15th week unstaffed for the year. Does Deloitte do layoffs for low utilization? Mine is around 60%

like

Best consulting firms with best WLB? Do they exist? Young professional starting to think about where I'd like to work hard to end up in the next 5-10 years.

like

BCG friends - what exactly does the PTO (Predictability, Teaming, and Openness) role do? What does the role entail / how do they work with consulting project teams?

like

Justifying the Sheraton's painful bed to yourself because the Four Seasons don't recognize your loyalty

like

Anyone at EY-Parthenon know if we’re going to match MBB’s salary bump?

likefunny

Has anyone successfully added your parent(s) to your health plan as a dependent? How do you do that? I’ve heard there are ways..

likefunny

Quick question... if I have United lounge access, can I get into a United lounge or an affiliate lounge if I’m flying a different airline? Flying to Dubai on Qatar airways and want to plan in advance

like

Thoughts on Ankura’s restructuring practice?

like

Any advice on how to switch from big 4 to tier 1 consulting firms like BCG and MCK?

like

Best books on leadership and sales skills?

like

How do you keep yourself motivated to keep applying to jobs? Got a rejection letter today from the one place I applied and I’m already burnt out.

like

What kind of work does West Monroe M&A do? I’m interested in learning more about the role

like

Top consulting firms in the Aerospace / Aviation,l or Defense / Intelligence spaces? Looking for business or tech strategy jobs here

like

Strategy 🐠, I'm curious about your day-to-day, and overall work what you actually do. Can you share?
I do business transformation and change management, but I'm curious to get into that side.

Is the bulk of your work slide making and creating a story to tell executives? How much data crunching, or data analysis do you do? On a project, what do you spend your time doing? A lot of research? Interviews?
Sorry I genuinely don't know and would like to know if I would enjoy the day-to-day work

like

Serious question: Sheraton cancelled my reservation and I was stranded for a night last night. Called CS and my useless ambassador and they cant help and “sorry”. How do I escalate this?

like

Can you get monkeypox from hotels or seats on airplane?

funnysmart

After getting kicked out of McK late last year, this gives me schadenfreude 🤣

Post Photo
likefunny

Received an offer from Boston Consulting Group for a PL1 and am curious to what can be negotiated. I assume base is set but can other factors changed? Also, an input on the position would be appreciated.

like

Which resources are good for learning financial modelling? Case studies website, online courses, books…

likehelpful
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal