When an associate is looking for employment in their field of law, how often are they passed over due to over achievement or too much experience? I’m just wondering if some firms are rejecting candidates because the attorneys are already set in their approach and strategy with various types of cases.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I do lots of hiring and regularly pass over candidates that are more experienced than the position requires. It’s partly for the reason you say but also because generally the salary expectations won’t line up with the salary range offered.

like

Thank you P1. That gives me more to think about. I need to now temper my expectations as I can’t honestly deny my experience.

like

Totally agree with P1. One major problem we face with hiring is that there is so much downward pressure from clients to lower bills that most firms have to find candidates that can be billed at the low end of the spectrum.

like

Exactly.

It's the same as being under qualified. If you're looking for an attorney with 5 years of experience, you don't need someone with 20 years any less than you need someone with 1 year. Same way you wouldn't hire a paralegal when you need an attorney.

like

Thank you P1 and P2. I appreciate you both. Let me make a further inquiry: If you both are fine with the associate’s extensive experience, expertise, and references; and the associate is fine with the salary and benefits, at this point - how much does it matter which law school the associate attended and where they ranked?

Some of us are still employed, but are looking. Others have been unemployed for several months. Many recruiters are not being exactly forthcoming in explaining some of the barriers with our employment search. Hearing from some of the decision makers brings more clarity at least to me.

like

Just an added point from another common recruiting partner. Firms of any size, particularly with multiple offices, are faced with balancing overall expectations regarding compensation and ascension. Often the easiest way to do this is to organize people in bands that have minimum and maximum compensation. Annual compensation reviews are made easier (read, possible) on the firm by limiting the conversation in this way. If there are 10 associates, having bespoke analysis and conversations is a grind, but it can and is done. Less so when there are 50 or 100 or 300.

helpful

What makes it hard is if we want a 3rd year associate and a 6th year applies, the expectation from the 6th year is that we will bring them in as a 6th year. Would I rather have someone with 6 years of experience doing 3rd year work and getting paid a 3rd year salary and charging at 3rd year rates? Absolutely. But the 6th year doesn't want that - they want to get 6th year money and 6th year work. So a lot of GREAT candidates with too much experience get passed over when we are hiring juniors. In some industries it's much easier to just be like, here's the role, do you have the experience to do the work, but in law (and especially big law) with a "years from graduation" based approach it is different.

likehelpful

I mean, yeah, this is a profession that is very much tied to perceived prestige. But in reality I almost NEVER see two candidate resumes where one is a T14 and a other is a regional law school, both with excellent grades and the right experience. I care more about experience and commitment to our practice than the best grades at an elite law school. But we rarely compare apples to apples - a lateral process is very one-off.

like

Related Posts

How many hours a week are you working? I’m generally clocking about 50-60 and I’m exhausted. I’m busy, but it’s mostly because no one I work with has any boundaries.

likehelpful

How does client secondment work from time mgmt perspective? Do you still have to bill even though you're essentially in-house?

like

Top 10 keywords on this thread: girl, boy, desi, visa, smell, daaru, asl, abcd, chutiya and fob

Hi Fishes,

I am a Senior UI / UX Designer, Product Designer

YoE - 12.5
CCTC - 14 lakhs per annum

I am looking for a job change. What would be the good hike as per current market standards.

My portfolio is good and skillset is strong.

Thanks.

like

What’s FDD like at Bain, BCG, or McKinsey?

funnylike

Can people share their Manager level salaries and what they know about the Manager bands at their companies? EY, GT, PWC, Deloitte, Accenture, KPMG

like

I need marketing help and am trying to find someone on Upwork, but so many interactions don’t match how they sound in their profile. How do I find a good freelancer on Upwork?

like

Chocolate Walnut Babka - A Jewish braided bread made with buttery brioche dough intertwined with chocolate and walnut filling. Saw it on the Great British Baking Show and had to make it. 😁

Post Photo
likeuplifting
like

Is it mandatory to WFO for 3 days in TCS? And is it necessary to work from base location? If i work from open ODCs , can i just work from any tcs office in any state?

likehelpful

Left the previous firm, should I rollover to current firm’s 401k or rollover to my Roth IRA? (Currently has contributed $2k so far) would the amount (8k) rollover to my IRA exceed the $5500?

Hi, i have been selected as Senior Security Analyst in VMware. Wanted to know how is work environment in VMware banglore? Also my current ctc is 12.8 with 9Yoe. How much should I pitch for?

like

Hello Fishes

How is the WLB, annual hike, work culture in MasterCard?
Role- Middleware

Please help me in choosing which one to join for 5 yrs mainframe exp guy in terms of job security and WLB -
Current location Noida
NTT data - 15LPA noida (band 8)
TCS - 13 LPA kolkata (IT analyst band c)
Legato - 16 LPA Banglore (SSE)
Wipro - 14.5 LPA noisa (SSE)

please suggest!!!!!

like

Hi fishes i m completely new to salesforce
Wanted to apply for the salesfoce devoloper role
My current yoe with diferrent domain is 6 years
And my admin devolopment course is going on
What should i do?
Do certification or directly apply for the job

like

Will try to keep this short - After parents visited a few months and I visited India and left, i feel like a void, everyday i feel like a machine with my mind still back home. Though its been a month

like

Is anyone at Spotify willing to entertain a conversation around the culture, pay, interview process, and a potential referral? Let me know, thanks!

like

How have you negotiated an hourly fee for your services?

like
like

Which type of job needs to do in Specialist - Data Engineering in LTI?

like

Additional Posts in Law

Those who are voluntarily returning to the office — how often are you going and what days seem to work for you? Looking to slowly incorporate a few days here and there for change of scenery etc. — will add there is no pressure to do so (yet).

like

I’m so bad at writing the background/ facts section for briefs… it always gets heavily edited and no one is giving me constructive feedback other than “advocate more”. In contrast, my legal argument section is generally without edits. For context, first defense lit job post appellate clerkship. Is this normal?? Any tips for getting better other than “advocating more”?

likehelpful

Is there an appropriate way to turn down an assignment because it is non-billable? Two of the partners I work for keep asking me to write client bulletins and articles with them, which is great, but now I’m starting to worry about meeting my billable hours requirement.

like

How do you properly vet a law firm? I feel the associates I speak with talk up the firm and aren’t always candid.

like

Best divorce lawyer in NYC?

like

Considering becoming a consultant lawyer. Any advice/tips from someone who made that move?

like

How do you wind down after a rough day?

like

Has anyone transitioned from litigation to corporate counsel/contracts type work? If so, how’d you like the change?

like

What is a reasonable pay increase? This will be my first pay increase. I make 70k now and will be starting my second year at big law. I had 3 years of prior experience before joining the firm.

like

How does client secondment work from time mgmt perspective? Do you still have to bill even though you're essentially in-house?

like

Workout before (4:30 am) or after (6:30ish) work?

like

Second year associate here. How should I deal with the one partner in my practice group who seems to exclusively give me lousy assignments that we’ll never get paid for? I get great work from everyone else.

like

Idk, maybe it’s time we bring these engineers and techs down. If my 🧠 links to a 💻 , all of my non-billable work will come to light. 😤

Post Photo
like

How long is acceptable to ask to decide on an offer, especially when another place you really want to work at is moving a bit slower? I know this question has been asked before but I feel like 2022 has been its own beast in the legal market and would appreciate any advice. Thank you!

like

Negotiating a settlement. I’m at $10k, opposing counsel is at $20k. My client won’t go higher than $15k. OC has come down to 17.5k and says his client won’t budge from that. Do I offer 12.5k so we can hopefully meet in the middle at 15k? Is that how the settlement game is played? Seems dumb we can’t just say let’s meet in the middle now and be done with this. (I’m a first year, first time negotiating a settlement on my own and I don’t want to screw this up!)

like

What is a typical starting rate that young attorneys charge for per diem side work? First or second year lawyers should ask for what? Client is a big firm.

like

Does anyone know how litigation finance works on the plaintiff side? If someone wanted to bring a lawsuit against their former employer would a general contingency arrangement with a plaintiff’s firm make sense? Or would one need to find funding and then contact a plaintiff’s firm to actually handle the case? I’m a transactional lawyer, so this is out of my wheelhouse.

like

I was hired by client to draft a form MSA and SOW (the client is a freelance HR coach). She showed her form to another freelance HR coach and now they want to use the form I made for my client and my clients asking if that’s ok? Any advice?

like

Anyone suiting up for the office?

I’m in Chicago, and I feel like I’ve been seeing a lot more suits in the loop.

like

Confused why Wachtell qualifies as BigLaw when they have one (small) office

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal