Related Posts
Junior writer jobs where are you?
Anyone here ever been to RCA? Is it worth it ?
Hey what's ur number
Additional Posts in Diversity & Inclusion
Hey guy, I have this book out. Wondering if you could help me spread the word. It teaches you how to write KPI’s for an IDB perspective. I am in the market to switch career back to my original so I am open to assist especially non-profits address their data issues. Anyway guys if interested send me a DM. https://www.amazon.com/Key-Performance-Indicator-Development-Guide/dp/B0B5K9W5JC

New to Fishbowl?
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.




Likely because there is a direct way to calculate the value of what was taken and can be repatriated by the taking party for all of those examples and not for enslaved blacks who passed through many hands across many generations.
Who said that?
I don’t mean to start a fight with this comment. It seems like you’re interested in an honest answer so I’m going to try to give you my thought on the question.
With the examples you mention, I think the intention has been to restore what those groups had before whatever nefarious action was taken by government, or at least make a reasonable part ways effort. In the case of African slavery, what they had as a people group in most cases before the transatlantic slave trade, slave trade to Europe, to the Ottomans, etc was life as slaves under African slave owners or free life in Africa.
There was a program in the American government in the early 1800s to build a colony in Africa for ex-slaves. Many slaves families were transported to the African colony in an attempt to provide what they lost and more. The program fell apart because not many loved the outcome, and an upstart Republican Party in the mid-1800s saw political advantage from making ex-slaves voting citizens and making promises to them that they knew they could never keep to create a new voting block.
I can’t speak as well to reparation attempts and history regarding African slaves in Europe or modern middle eastern countries
I reject the premise that enslaving black people is more or less nefarious than enslaving Asians, Native Americans, white people, or a mix. If you were to tell me that transporting Africans to the Americas was especially nefarious, I’d agree (from a practical, maybe not moral, standpoint) that this was probably the worst part of the history of African slavery. This is why almost every country outlawed the slave trade before they addressed domestic slavery.
It’s not foreign. 😊
I support reparations but the USA has stalled so long, and engaged in a century of Jim Crow that there isn’t really a way to pay out that a consensus of “fair” can be reached.
Many descendants of enslaved people may have since had children with the descendants of slave owners. There have been black people who immigrated after slavery ended but still experienced the Jim Crow era. There’s non-black Americans who’ve immigrated long after slavery ended. Some during Jim Crow and some after.
Reparations are owed for slavery. They’re owed for the racial oppression that followed. Who pays and who gets them is a discussion to be had. I don’t know the answer, and any ideas I may have aren’t really in my lane.
Also folks you’re welcome for the rare instance of “I support x but…” that isn’t awful propaganda against it
Also “fair” as in like how is it even paid. Are black Americans having their own tax dollars used to pay their own reparations?
Someone who fled Afghanistan 20 years ago and is now a US citizen? An Italian who moved to the US at the end of Jim Crow (I’d argue yes on this one) ?
Tell me why people who were never involved with anything that had to do with slaves, should have to pay people who were never slaves or had family members that were slaves. EVERYONE who was involved with that has been dead for over 100 years now.
Im Jewish and have aunts and uncles who were brutally murdered in the holocaust, I dont get reparations. When am I going to start getting mine?
Yeah but what debt? Is there a contract or something? Who owes who?