Why is the concept of reparations to black Americans a foreign concept when Native Americans, interned Japanese Americans, or Jewish holocaust victims have received these benefits? What is fundamentally different? Honest opinions plz.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Likely because there is a direct way to calculate the value of what was taken and can be repatriated by the taking party for all of those examples and not for enslaved blacks who passed through many hands across many generations.

Who said that?

Recent IconRecent

I don’t mean to start a fight with this comment. It seems like you’re interested in an honest answer so I’m going to try to give you my thought on the question.

With the examples you mention, I think the intention has been to restore what those groups had before whatever nefarious action was taken by government, or at least make a reasonable part ways effort. In the case of African slavery, what they had as a people group in most cases before the transatlantic slave trade, slave trade to Europe, to the Ottomans, etc was life as slaves under African slave owners or free life in Africa.

There was a program in the American government in the early 1800s to build a colony in Africa for ex-slaves. Many slaves families were transported to the African colony in an attempt to provide what they lost and more. The program fell apart because not many loved the outcome, and an upstart Republican Party in the mid-1800s saw political advantage from making ex-slaves voting citizens and making promises to them that they knew they could never keep to create a new voting block.

I can’t speak as well to reparation attempts and history regarding African slaves in Europe or modern middle eastern countries

likehelpful

I reject the premise that enslaving black people is more or less nefarious than enslaving Asians, Native Americans, white people, or a mix. If you were to tell me that transporting Africans to the Americas was especially nefarious, I’d agree (from a practical, maybe not moral, standpoint) that this was probably the worst part of the history of African slavery. This is why almost every country outlawed the slave trade before they addressed domestic slavery.

It’s not foreign. 😊

I support reparations but the USA has stalled so long, and engaged in a century of Jim Crow that there isn’t really a way to pay out that a consensus of “fair” can be reached.

Many descendants of enslaved people may have since had children with the descendants of slave owners. There have been black people who immigrated after slavery ended but still experienced the Jim Crow era. There’s non-black Americans who’ve immigrated long after slavery ended. Some during Jim Crow and some after.

Reparations are owed for slavery. They’re owed for the racial oppression that followed. Who pays and who gets them is a discussion to be had. I don’t know the answer, and any ideas I may have aren’t really in my lane.

Also folks you’re welcome for the rare instance of “I support x but…” that isn’t awful propaganda against it

Also “fair” as in like how is it even paid. Are black Americans having their own tax dollars used to pay their own reparations?

Someone who fled Afghanistan 20 years ago and is now a US citizen? An Italian who moved to the US at the end of Jim Crow (I’d argue yes on this one) ?

Tell me why people who were never involved with anything that had to do with slaves, should have to pay people who were never slaves or had family members that were slaves. EVERYONE who was involved with that has been dead for over 100 years now.
Im Jewish and have aunts and uncles who were brutally murdered in the holocaust, I dont get reparations. When am I going to start getting mine?

Yeah but what debt? Is there a contract or something? Who owes who?

Related Posts

My husband said he would buy me a Rolex as a “push present” for our first child. I would want just a classic, timeless (no pun intended) looking ladies Rolex watch that I can wear for many years to come. Suggestions on a style? I really don’t know anything about them and would like to get some opinions on what people like since there are so many options.

like

Does anyone have experience working for a ALSP? How does compensation work (pay and benefits)? Are you an employee or technically an IC? Do you have billable requirements like at a firm? How do you think it prepared you to potentially move in house? I'm currently at a firm but thinking of taking a position with an ALSP but my goal is to go in house.

Killer freelance gig just came my way, but I can’t take it. I want to send some great talent their way - experienced (5+ yrs at least) preferred. See below...

likeupliftinghelpful

Junior writer jobs where are you?

like

Hi everyone,
So I had my NIPT and NT scans last week and I’ve been getting pieces of the results back from my doctor in the patient portal. All seems okay but I’m a bit confused. Does anyone know if FirstScreen is the same thing as NIPT? I was under the impression that NIPT was in 90th percent of certainty for Down syndrome but the result we got, labeled FirstScreen indicate 83% certainty so I’m confused if there are more results coming? I messaged the doctor but haven’t heard back yet.

like

Anyone here ever been to RCA? Is it worth it ?

like

Hey what's ur number

like
like

Can anyone tell me what first year KPMG audit seniors make in the DC area?

like
like

From a financial standpoint in this market, which would be a better approach in Austin -

1. Buy a ~8-850k house that meets most of our ideal criteria (size, schools, interiors etc) to stay long term

2. Buy a ~5-550k house that’s not ideal with the plan of moving into an ideal home in 4-5 years when kid is ready for school.

How easy is it to get a mortgage for the second home?

Household income - 300k

Happy to add more details as needed

Thanks

Hi , I am 48 and from India, recently after covid i had to switch my career from manufacturing to IT. i underwent training in Salesforce for an year and then fortunately got recruited and its been now more than a year in Salesforce plus my 17+ year experirence in manufacturing. Recently due to some personal reason i am thinking of moving to USA, as a 48 year old is it possible to apply for jobs in USA from India and what are the chances i have getting a job, not particular abt the package.

likehelpful

Just found out, I'll be interviewing for a role at BCG next month. Does anyone want to practice casing together?

like

Anyone else getting pay cut during these times?? Our institution just announced that we are getting pay cuts starting tomorrow if we don’t see 3 Telehealth patients an hour .

like

Hello 🐋🦈
Company: Games24x7
I have 6.5-7 yrs of work experience in product design, what should I expect as CTC?

How’s wlb, promotion cycle and performance bonus policy?
Please help 🙏🏽

like
like

Hi Fishers kindly help with in hand salary after deduction.

Post Photo
like

Interviewing for a CCOR VP role in Tampa, FL. Was hoping someone would be familiar with the salary ranges. Thanks!

like

Has anyone ever been asked to stay beyond what they’ve said will be their last day when they give notice? Gave 2 weeks notice yesterday and am now being pressured to stay until one deal I’m on closes (which could slip past the end of next week, which is what I’ve said was my last day).

like

I’m currently a Manager at Accenture and got contacted by a recruiter for a meta EM position. I wasn’t expecting it at all, any tips or resources to recommend to get ready for the interview process?

like

Additional Posts in Diversity & Inclusion

Hi, we just launched Diversity and inclusion committee at our work place and one of our many initiatives is to share some reminders /notifications about safety and inclusion in common employee platforms/portals e.g There’s no place or time when discrimination is acceptable. Please feel free to report to HR if you com across any discriminatory behavior. Anyone has any more similar ideas what other topics we can add?

like

Current DEI Professional, can everyone support me on the likes so that I can unlock being able to message someone. I will do the same in return. Thank you

like

In honor of National Voter Registration Day, The New Yorker released the transcript of a previously unpublished interview with James Baldwin, who gave a first-hand account of "Freedom Day 1963," a Black voter-registration drive in Selma, Alabama. Baldwin's descriptions from that day are so vivid and detailed that you can feel the fear and anger of the event. If you have a couple of minutes, I highly recommend you read it.

like

Hi - I am a career pivot from higher education into tech and have final round interviews for a DEI Coordinator role (which I'm super excited for). I am meeting with three people that I would be partnering with for the job and it was shared with me that these interviews will mainly be behavioral as well as questions on my technical skills. Does anyone have any resources to help me prepare for this? Anything is greatly appreciated!

like

Looking to support a new APIA founded startup? Well look no further!

Have you ever found something online and thought "... if I buy this, what about my anniversary gift, that trip to Europe, the car I always wanted..."

Well I have and founded Okane (money in Japanese 🤑)

Okane is a free Chrome Extension that focuses on goal-based budgeting. We track your wealth and help you save for your future goals while avoiding impulse purchases, right as you shop online. ( okane.crd.co)

Lmk what you think!!

like

Feeling very frustrated right now…company talks a big game about DEI internally, while requiring new hires to move to Texas/Arizona, while the company’s PAC donates to politicians pushing extremist, regressive, anti-woman and anti-LGBT laws

They want to encourage us to “bring our whole self to work” while putting us in situations where we can’t be our whole self.

Anyone else in a similar place, feeling discouraged? Any tips?

like

“I must honestly confess that I go through moments of disappointment when I have to recognize that there aren’t enough white persons in our country who are willing to cherish democratic principles over privilege. But I am grateful to God that some are left.” This quote is from MLK in 1968 about how he sensed the movement was losing the battle for the soul of the nation.

like

I have often wondered if being honest when I fill out EEOC / diversity forms if that limits me from new work / promotions. I used to be able to hide my disability, but it is progressive so now it's not as easy to hide. Thoughts?

like

Our team is about to recruit and we are trying to live our DEI values. Any tangible actions you can suggest to how we can widen our attractiveness to a more diverse candidates? Applies internally and externally. Thanks for any suggestions.

like

Hi everyone! I’m pivoting from working in politics in search of a role in DEI. I have 1.5 YOE managing multiple campaigns and a BA in Global Studies & MA in Ethnology. I have experience working in and with non-profits and a passion for people and culture. I’d love to connect to hear about your journeys & advice for an early career transition!

like
like

Hello!

I am being tapped to translate documents at work. I’ve done spot translation audits, and 1 larger Quality assurance document earlier this year, but was recently contacted about a potential large-scale translation initiative for next year.

Has anyone been compensated for these sorts of projects that would be “out of scope” for their role? How do you go about asking for compensation? Have any of you spun out and created translation service side-gigs?

like

Hi everyone! I’d love to hear your thoughts on EEO surveys during the job application process. Is it more beneficial to self-disclose or refrain from disclosing race, gender, disability, etc?

Which method is more likely to get your application noticed? Any guidance would be helpful on my job hunt. Thank you.

like

I’m interviewing for a newly created position, Assistant Director of Communications & Outreach in my organization’s DEI office. This is the first interview they have requested after reviewing my writing sample. They didn’t say who specifically I would be interviewing with, but said “members of the DEI staff”, and it will be virtual.

What types of questions outside of my marketing/communications background should I expect?

like

Hi all,

My boss makes jokes about me being from a different country whenever there is a work meeting or a gathering with coworkers, even though he knows where I am from. This usually occurs when I meet new work-related people or for example if I am in a situation that involves ethnic related subjects.

What is this? This is normal?

Stereotyping?
Racism?

The first time I ignored that, but now it has become a pattern and is bothering me now. I am south-American working in the UK.

like
like

Anyone looking for a head of people specifically and start ups or small businesses?

like

What are some examples where you feel included at your organization?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal