Would love some honest input. I’ve received an offer for a Supervisor role at a Big 10 consulting firm, with a base salary of $130K.

I bring 10+ years of experience and was previously a Manager at a Big 4, earning $180K base. My past roles included leading large-scale transformation initiatives, managing global teams, and engaging directly with senior client leadership. The scope of the new role feels very similar—just at a lower title and significantly lower comp.
Contd in comments

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

For those who’ve navigated similar moves:
• Is this kind of step back ever worth it for the long-term brand or promotion trajectory?
• Or is a $50K+ cut too steep given my background?

Appreciate any real-world insights from those who’ve been in the same boat.

I haven't been in consulting, but I recently went from a large company to another after 10+ yrs. Technically it was also a lateral move for me with a similar role scope (same title, same nature of work). I was dying to move as I needed a growth trajectory and I didn't have it at my previous company.
But when I searched, I personally set a very clear boundary on what I was willing to accept. I was willing to take a pay cut if growth was clear, but only up to 15% from my base, and ~5% of total compensation. It was a math exercise for me; I have bills to pay and a (rather expensive) lifestyle to sustain! Ultimately, I moved with a 14% lower base but 30% higher expected total comp (much higher bonus expected based on bonus structure).
Personally, after 10yrs of experience, I wouldn't take that significant of a cut.
Assuming you're in your 30s, if there isn't a significant new skill you will gain or a sure path to becoming a partner, this doesn't sound like a good deal.

What's the rationale behind considering this offer? Unless I'm misunderstanding, this looks like a step down in both compensation and career progression and is a clear no.

I took a sabbatical for a year

A $50k pay cut is pretty steep. Do you not feel like you can find another role that is closer to what you were making? I’ve had to take pay cuts before, one was $20k and the second was ultimately larger but it was right after covid and it was a contract job that I was able to turn full time and eventually outpaced the salary I was making pre covid. $50k pay cut seems like a lot to make up for in taking another ft job

Related Posts

Let's talk hourly versus salary pay for advanced practitioners. What are your thoughts?

like

What do I say if my employer asks me if I’m looking for other work, or want to know if I plan on leaving at a certain date?

some context - I am a temp to hire, and the company wants to bring me on full time now that my contract with the agency expires this week.

Ps. I am looking for other work, but this job is holding me over.

like

What's the best way to get your project changed in IBM?
Working in energy utilities account for last 10 months as a BA, but the work is not good at all.
Should I try to check with my people manager or look outside IBM ?

like

Had a recruiter tell me that investment firms only give 24 hours for you to accept an offer - is this true? It seems crazy to me

If you've worked at Humanaut, would you tell me about it?

What was the interview like, how's the pay, the hours, etc?

Account & Creative: 2 puppies in a meadow or 2 beta fish in an acid rain tank?

likefunny

Has anyone taken the SHRM-SCP? Any study suggestions and impressions of the test?

like

Recruiter shared post on-site feedback and she mentioned that she would like to do the team match and do 1-2 additional rounds of interviews because the feedbacks now are borderline and have a very low chance of HC. Any team here who's hiring SAP Program Manager role? Please kindly keep in contact with me :)

like

Age? Gender? Location? Fav food for suhoor and iftar? GO!

like

New wage code...what is in it for us?

like

Hi folks,
Please reply me if you are working in
Capgemini , Talwade or have a good knowledge about the nearby area like bus stops, how to get to pune station, where to live. I have to see where to find accommodation accordingly.

PS: I don't have my own vehicle and totally relying on buses trains metros

like
like

It's fairly easy (technically if not consensually) to upgrade the cryptography to stay ahead of faster computers.

I've had three interviews so far: 1) with the recruiter, 2) with the hiring manager, 3) with the lead of an adjacent division. I was contacted by the hiring manager (just 5 days after interview 3) asking if I was still interested and if I'm available for another meeting. He mentioned it would only take 30 minutes. Any thoughts on what to expect?

like

Hey fishes,

Can anyone help me with the below questions on RTO-

1. When is optum planning to open offices fulltime and in how many phases are they planning to open
2. Do they provide cab servies
3. Do they provide breakfast/lunch/dinner inside office
4. Do they follow any dress code
5. Office timings

TIA😊

like

How to get an interview for my cousin at Optum? Tried referral portal already, not getting a call back when referring through the referral portal. He is trying for a data analyst role. What is the best way to get him an interview?

What is the minimum and maximum hike and RRP ,i can expect from optum as part of this year end hike.
I joined
Optum in Aug.
When will we receive a hiked salary (letter and hiked salary).
When will we get the RRP credited.
Optum Tata Consultancy EY Deloitte Accenture

like

Hi Fishes,

I am going to start as a Big data Developer. I have an experience of 3 years in non-IT MNCs and current CTC is 5 lpa for me. What is the salary I should expect as my earlier experience is not relevant to the field. Please help.

like

Ritz or JW in Cancun?

like

Mumbai office ka shuttle chaalu hua?

I had a great review and a 5.5% raise and a great bonus at my company. But I also got a new Director and a peer manager of mine left the company, so I will be absorbing her team. In addition, my director said I will be receiving 'deep delegation' from them. I don't mind more work, but deep delegation is a new term I've never heard. What does that mean lol?

like

Additional Posts in Salary Negotiations

Posting this for a friend. She has 20+ years experience as a resource manager and is is trying to leave Microsoft. She’s currently making 157K base. what salary expectations should she have. She has interviews with Amazon, Deloitte, and a few others I don’t remember lol.

Post Photo
like

Does anyone know how much Licensing Manager should get? I am currently a licensing specialist and waiting for my promotion. My boss said it is happening before Oct so I just want to have my number set.

like

Does anyone know the salary for a private banking operations associate for Morgan Stanley?

like

I received a job offer from company A and am currently negotiating salary. I have an interview with company B next week and know that they offer a higher base pay. There’s no guarantee that I will be offered a job at company B but my gut is telling me that company B would be a better fit for me. Should I accept the offer from company A, continue interview process with company B and then rescind my offer with company A if company B offers me a job? Will I be burning bridges?

like

I got a job offer but it's 3k less than the low end of my happy range. But there will be a review in 6 months with the potential for a raise. I'd rather start at the low end of range. What is the best way to ask for that??

like

What is the average base salary for most account managers in the tech space?

like

Does anyone have salary information base for a UX Researcher at Meta?

like

Corrosion lab tech salary.... 10 years of experience..

like

If job posting pay was $36.66 hourly (no range) what would be an acceptable offer and counter offer?

like

I renegotiated my start date and it’s different from the date I signed on the offer letter. Do I need to request a revised offer letter or is the email thread with the recruiter sufficient. By the way, my background check is already in progress.

My husband just received a job offer on an opportunity he is really excited about. It would be great for his career and they are giving the 15% jump in base he asked for, however they won’t share what the target bonus amount would be. It’s an executive director position, so I would assume it’s a decent target bonus, but without that in writing it could honestly be a gift basket at the end of the year. Is it a red flag for them to not share this? His total comp could be less at this new job…

like

How to discuss higher salary based on change in expected work hours per week

like

Started a new job a year ago, high performer. My manager suggested a promotion to Product Manager since that‘s the work I’m doing, but that would be a 50% raise. Higher ups decided instead to make a “new role” (not PM), that has no analog in the company and is hard to price via Glassdoor, etc. I feel like this is to limit my promotion salary to something like 10% from where it currently is. Is there anything I can do? FWIW: I have a PhD from top 5 program and am working in that field. Thanks!

likehelpful

Hi there. What is considered a good salary for a project manager?

like

Any Hazmat drivers here? Just curious on the going salary for CDL A hazmat driver. Home just about every day. Off weekends. Any info would be appreciated.

like

I have been in my current job for 1 year now as a booking coordinator for a logistics company. When I started I had no idea of what my workload would be, now I noticed that my coworkers took the opportunity to pass most of their job to me. I’m burned out, can barely take break and end my days totally drained and exhausted, also the same people is harassing me with questions like: “why are you working that slow?” Or the “quality of your job is questionable because…..” continue in comments

What jobs are currently paying 85k?

like

Should I Go Back and Reneg? Recently I was offered a role as a Project Implementation Manager (In Retirement Services) .The salary range for Colorado residents was 65-89K. I’m located in NY so the recruiter said he would try to get me more. Ultimately he came back at 90K which is a bit inline with that I was seeing on Glassdoor but approx looks like I may leave 10-12K on the table. I accepted already but may get an offer from another HR company in account management around 90-100K. Need advice

I was approached on LinkedIn for an early career recruiting role in DFW, TX. I don't have direct experience, but I have the university experience/connections from working in career services. This is the first time I've considered work outside of higher education. I said my salary expectations are minimum $90k and that didn't seem to be an issue. Am I asking too little, too much? How can I know I'm getting the best salary and not just settling at the low end of the range?

like

Current situation: company A- was hired as a specialist and proved my worth to become a category manager but ended up on the low end of the salary range because of my lack of experience. Have voice my concern about my pay several times to my director, with no action in return.
Company B - Recruiter on LinkedIn approached me regarding a position open at an out of state healthcare facility for the same thing I do now, I would be working remotely where I currently am today. Cont in comments..

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal