Would you make a switch: 8 YOE, MCOL (Texas), currently a M at 165k base + 10% bonus. Up for SM this year

Offered director level - 200k base + 25% bonus + relocation to HCOL (Boston)

Company is growing and the job matches what I want to do in industry but I'm not sure if the pay makes sense with the COL difference

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

At 8 YOE, that base is pretty decent for Boston too (although you’ll be paying state tax in MA which will dent a couple of hundred each paycheck) What is your skillset ?

like

What type of company/industry is this ?

Do you want to relocate, specifically to Boston? If f*ck yes, then go for it. If you're indifferent, I'd wait it out. If it isn't f*ck yes, it's a no.

like

Indifferent, I like the city but moving is a pain. Ideally, I'd get the same offer in Texas or be able to work remote, but that isn't an option for this company

A ~20% raise? With the potential to make up to 25% bonus? I would do it, although I have a preference for Boston over Texas.

If you do it, though, think of the bonus. It is already the end of March. If they give out bonuses next winter, you don’t have much time
to prove your value. And you likely won’t get much of a bonus this year as a result.

Therefore, you should expect a 10% signing bonus (at the minimum) to help cover for the fact you won’t get much of a bonus this year.

As for SM at ACN, do you have a realistic chance? What are your stories so far this year? What does your boss say? If you already have a good story, then it might be worth it to stick around. If you don’t have a good story, you don’t have much time to change it before decisions are made.

like

I have project and practice support for promotion but the list of folks who were not promoted last year is high so I might fall behind them. Realistically, I'd assume 50-60% chance of promotion

like

Financially, you might not be making anything extra or even might be losing out due to COL. It is a non-financial decision with primary questions being - do you want to move to Boston and move out from Accenture?

like

Indifferent to the city and leaving Accenture. I mostly don't want to travel extensively for work any longer. If post-pandemic travel goes down to 25%, I wouldn't mind staying. If it's going to go to 50%+, I'd rather move to industry.

Have you worked in the industry before? If not, I would try to negotiate and move to new company. It would be a good experience. One can always come back to consulting.
You are doing good in Accenture in TX. No major downside if you decide not to move.

like

Travel will not go above 25-50% for another year at least based on what I have been hearing in the market.

like

SM means you’ll get at least 15% raise. Your base would then be about 190k. That is what you should compare against. 10% vs 25% bonus is the real difference. 190 > 209 vs 200 > 250. Questions to consider:
1) What does your YoY raise look like at both places
2) Cost of living comparison: Rent at both places / mortgage at both places
3) taxes (income, property, sales)

If that gap of 41k starts to get smaller then additional questions to swing you one way or other:
1) WLB / travel
2) Is it worth switching to a colder location for that increase?
3) Will there be better opportunities out there after you become SM?
4) Is it worth sticking it out considering significant travel is still about a year or so away?
5) does the Boston opportunity have something unique worth leaving ACN regardless of $$$?

like

Thanks, yeah, I don't think it'll be worth it from just a money perspective if SM goes through. I've never lived in cold weather so am in the "how bad could it be" bucket - but it's probably worse than I'm imagining.

FWIW at my firm Texas is not medium col, it’s low. And Boston is not high col, it’s medium. Hcol is New York, San Fran, LA, etc

like

...and congrats! Either way sounds like a win and good option.

like

I would do it, the salary difference is significant personally I avoid Texas like a plague, and would welcome the chance of a liberal city like Boston.

Texas has 5 liberal cities with higher populations than Boston, but alright.

like

Related Posts

Anyone works in public sector/government audit what is your salary progression?

like

Hi,

can someone highlight as how much we can expect for band 8 with 14.6 yrs exp as a security professional.

like

How's Fiserv overall ?

Like WLB
Job Security
Salaries
Variable
Stability atleast for 4-5 yrs

My YOE 8+
Tech .Net Full Stack Angular
Holding an offer from TCS of 21 l.p.a

How much could Fiserv Give ?

I already heard good things about the company..
But need a genuine feedback

Job offers. Got an offer from Parker hannifin within 2 weeks of application. Still going through interview process with Rockwell automation, 3 interviews and over a month. Operation manager said I will be hearing from Hr soon on next steps. Leverage offer with Parker or take the job?

likehelpful

Which is better to join between IBM and Deloitte India? IBM giving band of 6B with salary 11.5lpa fixed and 1LPA JB Deloitte india giving the designation of Consultant with salary 13lpa fixed and 1.3 lpa valiable Tech stack : Front end Developer Reactjs YoE : 3.5 years Please help me to decide as i have heard there is no WLB in deloitte Big4 IBM Deloitte IBM

like

Hey, I'm quite surprised and would like to know why many stay for long duration ( on an avg compared to others) at Novartis despite slow growth in salary

What is the usual hike percentage one should expect after RT?

Has anyone ever had their salary reduced?

like

Anyone know if you can cancel your Chase Sapphire Preferred after 3 years and get Chase Reserve and still be eligible for the signup bonus points?

like

How abut the job security and appraisal in BNY chennai . When is the appraisal cycle ??? And what is the maximum % they provide .

like

How much will I get from 1.5L benefits provided in CTC from Thoughtworks if I don’t reimburse anything?
Liked fixed in a year?

like

Leaving this summer to PE, bonus pays in June. When should I give notice? Don’t want to burn bridges but don’t want to risk a slashed bonus (or none at all)

like

How do some of y’all manage to go 2+ years without a raise? Like are you just really good at budgeting?

like

How is SAP SDC for SAP Consultants?
I have offers from CG, IBM & SAP India. So, please suggest which will be better to join.
PS- IBM is paying100% more than my current organisation.
SAP has not released my offer yet but I had an interview with VP and he said he is impressed with me and will release the offer letter soon but they have not negotiated for my salary. But he was saying if he will give me less than IBM then will I join the SAP or not? I assumed this is a trick ques., btw, I said yes

like

Anyone know Deloitte core business group in Deloitte consulting LLP?

Salary range, business outlook of this group amid layoffs and green card initiation timeline?

Post Photo

Left PA for industry during pandemic. Considering going back to PA, seems like there is a need in my market... Any insight into what top 8 PA firms are paying to lure corp tax managers? CPA, 7+ years exp. Looking for ballpark in MCOL area.

like

Does anyone know the salary band for clinical program consultant at United Health Group? What is the typical bonus associated with this role?

like

Hi all,
Yesterday my people lead told that there is no variable pay for me as my previous people lead put negative remarks on portal. Here in the screenshot as you can see yearly bonus on November is zero. But there is a monthly bonus amount. What is that monthly bonus and when shall I get it?

Post Photo
like

Anyone had the experience working in the US as a consultant? Apart from higher comp, do you feel there are more opportunities there?

like

More Posts

Which firms have you gotten offers from, but gave them a pass? And why?

like

Hi, anyone successfully subletting their apartment (TF Cornerstone)? Would love to know how you went about it. Thank you in advance.

like
like

Have you implemented a translation plugin on your WordPress you really like? Ideally I’d want one that allows us to edit content for better accuracy.

like

Damn! Why's it so silent in here 😅 35M NYC

like
like

Hello fishes. Does anyone in this bowl has joining tomorrow in KPMG?

like

I’m looking for a new partner to help us secure big name music rights. Anyone have suggestions on who to use?

likehelpful

Hey Folks, Can any one suggest a good name for this bowl

Cognizant Recently cognizant have changed their internet wfh allowance policy.we use to get 1800 per month as internet allowance without submitting any bills or transaction details. Now they changed the policy as we need to apply for icici/axis/hdfc credit card from there we need to make the transaction and reimburse the same. I am ok with everything but why i need to apply for credit card? How a company can force me to have a credit card? It will directly/indirectly alter the credit score right? Cogniza

How confident were you that you landed a job after the second interview? My friends tell me the fact that I had a second interview is pretty much a guarantee that I will be selected. I am not so sure. So I thought I would check with the fish bowl.

Software Development/ Tech Consulting/ Product Management. Which pays the best in terms of money and WLB in the long run?

like

Why is it so many parents won’t let their kids watch SpongeBob?

like

Day of remote interviews at a tech co for in-house. 5 YOE. Planning on wearing a suit. Tie or no tie?

like

Anyone work for USAA as a bi adjuster and doesn’t mind sharing there yoe and salary? I heard good things about them and am considering applying. I’m currently at 76k with my current company 8.5 yoe.

like

Any ideas of the expected comp range for a strategy manager role in industry?

like
like

🤬🤬These freaking mosquitoes are killing me. I hate that bug spray needs to be included as part of my going out routine.

Does anyone have suggestions for fragrance free options?

likefunny

3 types of food to describe your firm?

like

Additional Posts in Compensation in Consulting

Has anyone ever had their salary reduced?

like

Any know the salary for a senior solution analyst at BCG in the Chicago area? Glassdoor doesn’t have that job title listed, surprisingly.

What's the approval process for changes in comp after you've negotiated with the recruiter? Does it go to hiring manager, department head, and then HR as next steps?

like

Interviewing at Deloitte for the position of Retail/Consumer Data Management Manager in a T2 city. What's the expected salary, is 190k too much to ask for?

like

Product Manager offer is 120k salary, sign on bonus of 15k. 4 YOE total. Undergrad degree in computer science. Am I underpaid? This is a legit question lol. I’ve only done federal contracting/consulting work.

like

Interviewing as a senior 1 position at EY advisory in the Washington DC area. How much should I expect to get salary wise?

like

4th year manager S&O federal manager at Deloitte with 10 years experience. What is normal base salary range?

like

In my offer letter it stated a signing bonus to be paid on the first available payroll after my start date. Its been a month since my first paycheck and HR and the Payroll team are incredibly unresponsive to my inquiry on where this bonus is. What’s the next course of action? Legal? I’m not at ACN anymore so not looking for ACN-specific advice.

like

how much does an sap senior consultant make at deloitte consulting?

like

What are my options to negotiate better salary without an MBA as a M-3, Seattle, Tech, now@150k?
1. Boomerang
2. Get a better offer & ask to match
3. Speak directly with HR/senior leadership

like

How much of a % increase is average when leaving consulting for industry? At the Senior Manager or Principal level? Have 17 years in industry and 2 in consulting - was hired as a SM. Thanks 🙏

like

PwC question: Is there any small wiggle room (+/- 5 - 10k) in the cohort pay band you're assigned to or is it dead set on a number? Fully understand between cities and non/MBA the numbers are different

like

What would be a fair range for total compensation (base, rsus, bonus) for Senior Product Manager role in FAANG in Bay Area? Wondering if it’s worth relocating with family given cost of living there.

like

What is the BCG total compensation range for experienced Consultants? (5 years industry + 1.5 consulting)

Was interested to see it broken down by base, signing bonus, and year end bonus if possible!

like
like

Anyone have a sense of the salary range for a Data Science Consultant with Adventure Federal Services? DC area, TS-SCI but no master's degree.

like

I’m in my 3rd year out of college. My salary is 85k with a bonus of 30k (35%), which brings my total comp just slightly below market. How can I ask for more base and less bonus?

likefunny

How do you begin a compensation conversation with your partner? Do you discuss it during your annual compensation discussion? If so what is a good way to ask for a raise?

like

Idk if this is the right bowl, but it's technically comp related. What do people say when asked about current salary during interview process?

like

MBA? / yoe consulting / title / company / age / salary

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal