Does talking to a hiring manager change anything if you’re already rejected by the system?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You need to tread very carefully in how you approach the manager. Don't ask them to change the decision. If you must reach out, word it along the lines of "I enjoyed meeting with you, and even though it didn't work out this time I hope you will still consider me for future opportunities." I've had candidates reach out to me after a rejection still insisting that they're the perfect fit for the role, and that disqualified them from any future consideration.

likehelpful

Not at all, go ahead and send it.

It depends on a TON of factors. Why were you rejected? How far along are they in the process? How much decision making power does the hiring manager have at this stage? Etc.

like

It wouldn't hurt to send it along.

I would say “thank you” in an email and let it go. From my experience, I think they consider it pestering

Related Posts

After asking for docs , how much days it will take in cognizant for further process ?
Please let me know

like

Hi Fishes,

I am currently looking for a job change in backoffice. I have 6.8 years of experience in BPO.
Preffered location is Pune, Maharashtra.

Please let me know if there are any openings for me.

Thanks!

like

Good afternoon all, I hope all is well. Just out of interest, how long do EYP come back to after your final interview with an offer or rejection typically?

EY

likehelpful
like

Hi fishes,
I would like to know the career progression of senior engineer at Mercedes Benz R&D, bangalore. Is this a good role ?

like

I recently graduated with a masters degree in Data Analytics from University of Texas at San Antonio with a CGPA of 4.0. I am also awarded distinguished graduate student award for great academic standing and leadership skills. I have worked in india for 3 years for Uber and Amazon as Risk Analyst and quality specialist respectively. I am currently in my F1 OPT and have 30 days left before I submit my offer letter to USCIS. I can share my resume and any help is really appreciated. Thank you!

like

My Team is looking for a few Sales Representatives with Medicaid, Commercial, or TPA business experience. I major plus if you have a network of Broker/Consultants within the PBM space. Let me know if you or anyone you know is interested in a direct referral!

like
like

Hi all, negotiating with HR on salary for a new AS position and want to know what’s fair. I was an AE for two years, took a promotion at another agency for SAE for only 8 months and am now being recruited for AS at 80k. All of my agencies have been large, I’ve worked on pharma and a large global account, I also started “managing” at the AE level due to my team’s structure. Is $80k fair? Thanks!

like

Graduating in two weeks and got a job offer from Amazon for tech support specialist role, in job application they asked for expected compensation and i put 55k, and they offering me exactly 55k should I have asked for more instead, I feel like I might have shot myself in the leg there a little bit

like

Hi everyone, applied for an investment consulting internship few weeks back.
It's a client facing job, but it might come at a later stage of a job, maybe after finishing my internship and getting a job offer.
I'm interested to know what is the must develop skills, must take courses or must read books to get insight, develop the required knowledge and skills for the position. I majored in business management finance and currently preparing for CFA level 1. Thanks in advance ☺️

like

EY FAAS, are you expected to participate in Bus dev efforts and win work as a senior? Also are you solo or have a team/ mentors to work on engagements with? had only 20mins interview, no time for questions. Lol

like

In your current role, what do you think is the most prevalent challenge the industry faces?

like

Does Deloitte USI respond back after the salary negotiation.HR told like she can only give an update on Monday and no response after that.is it normal like delayed response or ghosted ?

like

What is the pay for power bi analyst at infosys and what are the interview questions usually asked ?

like

Hi fishes,

I have passed first round of interview with aws.

Now they are asking me to schedule next round of 4 hrs long interview.
My question is what to expect in this 4 hr round interview what kind of questions will be thrown on my way.

Any help will be appreciated.
Thank you.

like
like

Hi fishes , hope all is well with you.
Currently working @Genpact as an Data Analyst , mostly working on Advanced Excel / Spotfire / powerBI and small work into Python. Looking out for all the APAC aviation customers and others aswell.
It's been a year and I want to make a switch with possible good job role.
Can anyone provide me any refferal for the same?
Roles interested in -
1)Data Visualization
2)Analyst
3)Data Integration

like

Salary offer of $82,500 with 9% bonus for an RIA based on Los Angeles. Is this comparable to the market at the moment? Position is for an advisory associate that handles project management rather than advising.

More Posts

Used car prices are going crazy! Should I buy out my leased car if the kbb value is much higher than residual?

like

How bad does it look to quit without anything lined up? My goal would be to build skills I need to learn in order to pivot to an industry I’m more interested in and to build up my resume. Just wondering if not being employed will kill my employability

like

What sort of work is considered corporate finance? This was referenced in a energy practice related interview and am not sure what sort of work that would entail.

like

I’m thinking of deleting my portfolio app. This is just stressful. I have a target for holding that isn’t influenced by the price.

like

Recently received notice from landlord rent is going up ~20%. For reference, it is privately owned condo and did not sign at a COVID discounted rate. Super frustrated. What are others seeing for rent increases?

like

I’m looking to chat with BCG fishes in climate and sustainability. Pl lmk!

like

Just joined Scaler Academy for sales role. Which means, I am already in a bad place mentally. So, can I at least find a good place to live there physically? Please? Of course, after you've finished laughing. Near Green Glenn Layout would be very helpful. Thank you.

Post Photo
likefunny

What kind of projects and clients does Strategy& have in Toronto?
Also does anyone know the salary range for a manager?

like

toronto folks (gta, too… im desperate), how should i go about finding a family doctor? havent had one since high school under parental care, and emailed a handful from this govt link but all either no capacity or no response. much appreciated 🙏

likesmart

Does anyone have a good spreadsheet for estimating the value of donations to places like Goodwill? I made a ton of contributions and need to itemize them for taxes. Thanks!

like

CFA or CAIA?

My friend recently joined with an IT company in Procurement field before joining with this organisation he worked in an NGO. Since he got an offer for an immediate joiner he joined here while serving notice period in the NGO where the Date of reliving and Joining is clashing right now and the NGO is not ready to change the date of reliving and this has become an issue in Background verification what would be the best solution to fix this issue.

Pharma DTC or HCP?

like

Have received joining date of may and my pregnancy is due in april and so I may be able to join only by august. What do i do ? Shall i inform the HR to extend the joining? (but I am afraid, I don't want to lose this opportunity) or I join now and then take an ML ? or I accept the offer letter now, try joining and worst case postpone in the end ?

Will the org support me through this ?

like

Are BAs comparatively safer than Dev’s when it comes to layoffs?

like

Finally got my keystone master achievement!!!

like

WHAT DOES Solution Architect C10 band means in Natwest?

What are HMT-3 Clients & Project?
What does HMT means in CitiusTech?

funnylike

Additional Posts in Interview Tips

Hi everyone. I applied for a couple of roles at a tech company, I have a panel interview coming up but since that’s been arranged another HR coordinator has reached out to do a screening interview for the 2nd role I applied for.

How do I approach this, the screening call is a couple of days before my panel interview?

like

Looking for help/advice for case study interview in consulting firm in Canada. It’s a role in supply chain/retail vertical- I come from a merchandising background in retail

like

Does anyone else just feel incapable of doing interview prep after several instances of making it to the final round and getting rejected? I have another final round interview tomorrow but I just can’t seem to care because this is the fourth time in 6 months I’ve made it to a final round! I’m tired lol. How do I stay motivated? Should I even “prep” or should I wing it?

like

I’ve been with my company for 4 years and I’m thinking about applying for a new job. For references, I would like to use my coworkers but I also don’t want to bring up the fact that I’m applying to other places. How should I handle my references when it comes to applying or interviewing with other companies?

like

How soon do most companies let you know if you're not proceeding to the next round of interviews? Do they let you know within the day, a day after, or a week usually?

like

A company was pretty aggressively recruiting me until 4 interviews in — no movement. I haven’t heard back in a week and a half about next steps. Should I assume I won’t be moving forward any longer? I emailed the recruiter a few days ago to check in, and no response. (She typically replies very quickly and I was told I’m one of the top two final candidates 😕)

Just confirmed an interview Salesforce as a Financial Analyst! Looking for tips from anyone who has gone through their process, would be greatly appreciated. Nervous as this is a position I'm been trying to get!

like

I've gotten feedback that I'm too honest in my interviews, is that really a con for future employers? 🫤 How do I refrain from doing that anymore?

like

Citi Bank I would like to know how much % hike one can get in internal mobility within citi ,Dublin.jump from AVP to VP Citi" class="linkified" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" >position.Citi Bank Citi

like

Hi,
My current company is going out of business next week. I am rushing to get my next job lined up (probably won’t happen in time but I’m trying my best). My question is: should I be honest about why I’m looking for a new job? Is it wrong to not share this info during my interviews? Is this situation going to affect my interview process somehow? Please share your thoughts and wisdom! Thanks!

like

Got a job offer with a lower base salary but a guaranteed bonus structure that puts me ahead of my current pay at the end of each year. Has anyone moved to a position with a compensation structure like this? Was it hard to adjust when it came to your monthly finances?

like

Johnson & Johnson Services, Inc. What salary should I be asking for with a masters degree in process and chemical engineering and 2 years industry experience ?Pfizer Bristol Myers Squibb Alexion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Janssen Johnson & Johnson Services, Inc. Pepsico GE Healthcare Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany

like

I am a Business Analyst. I have 10 years of working experience in India. In May 2022 I will complete MSc Business Analytics from Maynooth university.
In the past I have lead a team of analyst performing multiple activities like sales analytics, web analytics on Google analytics, I have also worked as a scrum master in certain projects
I have worked with tools like tableau, power BI and now alteryx any suggestions for the job role I should look forward to?

like

Any tips on how to approach a life story interview at Shopify? I heard it's a one hour long conversation that touches upon personal and professional experience.

like

Have you started a new job without taking a break? How was it? I thought I’d have more time to give my notice but the background check took longer than I thought so now I have no wiggle room between my start date and the two week notice.

like

Hi, after each interview, the recruiting agency will call me to get feedback and ask me if we're still good on X salary?

What's a good way to not agree on a set number on these calls until I get my offer?

like

I accepted an offer from Cognizant for a consultant position a little less than a month ago. My joining date is 5th September and I would need visa sponsorship. I have completed my pre joining formalities and background verification. The thing is I haven’t heard from HR in a while and no update as yet on visa sponsorship process. Should I be worried?

like

I hope I don't sound foolish, but I was asked to "please attach a CV?" What is that?

like

Does it matter if you use the same examples for behavioral questions for first and second round interviews?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal