Gathering requirements is not a Product Manager’s job.
Sometimes PMs actually come into the picture after the requirements are already gathered.
But here’s the tricky part:
When there are loopholes in the requirements, who should be held accountable?
Who was supposed to audit them in the first place?

Developers aren’t mind readers. They can’t guess what you want to see if it’s not written down clearly.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I have worked 22 years across 6 organizations as a product manager and senior product manager.

The answer is always…. everyone is accountable.

The agile methodology takes into account imperfect knowledge from imperfect people creates imperfect requirements. That is why we break work down and iterate to develop into a solid solution.

You don’t waterfall into development with absolutely complete perfect requirements that took two years to write and hundreds of review meetings.

like

In my opinion, the executive team is fully responsible for the these types of failures for not placing direct responsibility on one person. Understanding the market is a product manager's direct responsibility. Only product managers who understood this were allowed to work for me. Requirements for how a goal can be achieved is a distillation of understanding the market. Unfortunately, most companies implement product management incorrectly as a technical supporting role. Product Managers must be a sales-supporting role. There are many dysfunctional tech companies, even the big ones because they are afraid, yes AFRAID, to place someone's head on the chopping block.

like

I find it interesting you say that gathering requirements is not a PMs job. Whose job do you view that as? I personally hate when I’m handed requirements and told to execute as that feels like the opposite of what I’m there for - which is to understand what we need to build and define that with my cross functional partners.

like

This was my thought as well. I'm curious to know more about this environment, I'm assuming something 1500+ employees to break jobs down that small.

like

Wondering - at the start of the process, do you not check with stakeholders that the requirements are right? Is it not checked at every stage of the process?

I remember this from PRINCE2 - you should break your project into stages - understandably in PRINCE2 it is the Project Manager who has a larger accountability but in the real world of Agile, Product Managers need to own the product, and as such the requirements. They need to understand the hi-level requirements end to end.

Product Owners need to know the basics as well, and any minor stuff that can come up for clarifications.

like

Related Posts

What's the salary brackets for grades gcm5 and 6?

Hi,

Can someone please let me know how is the annual appraisal and growth in SLC?

I have gone through lot of posts in Glassdoor where existing employees are not happy with increments and slow growth.

What’s the earliest you’ve seen them start checking bags? Today the overheads were full after Group 1 for ORD>BOS

like

Anyone know best way to position industry hire (pharma r&d) for PwC pharma roles? Any guidance would be appreciated

I'm overworked and I miss my family. I know some states are talking about "reopening" but I don't see an end to this.

like

I know everyone will have different answers for this but how did you know it was time to get sober? I think it might be time for me to find a new job and pursue sobriety, but I don't feel like I'm a rock bottom which is the only time I've ever seen people really commit to it (my father). Apathy isn't the right word but I just kind of feel numb about everything and I think being sober would maybe help.

like

Hi All,
I had salary discussion call with Cognizant HR on 6th Sep and submitted all the required docs on same day. But I haven’t received any response yet. I sent multiple emails, but no reply on that. What should I do in this case? Any suggestions please.

like

How many days it will take frm joining cg to complete all formality, getting laptop.?

like

What's the best way to gain visibility by those holding 3-4 positions higher than you? I like learning from them and growing mentorships but can't break the AE-level wall with my responsibilities. Being remote also makes it harder to interact.

I'm on the client/business side but would love to hear anyone's thoughts.

like

Which Big 4 is best by work wise.

like

When does capgemini release annual hike letters?
Which month joiners will be eligible for hike?

like

We at HyperLinq are looking to fill two GSP positions for our would be Broker-Dealer entity. We need someone with FINRA Series 7, 24 and 63. Any experience level is ok.

If it’s you who fits into the above role and would like to explore this opportunity with a fast growing venture backed early stage startup, please DM me.

If you know someone who fits the profile, please share with your networks.

like

Hi Fishes,

Is S&P planning to open offices?

like

Anyone wants to be referred for roles at Avanade , send me the job link and resume.

like
like

Does anyone know who is running production out of Kohler up in WI?

like

With the various RTO rumors/fear out there and in the absence of spring/summer/fall(?) bonuses. Would you consider coming into the office more if your firm offered bonuses linked to days in the office (coupled with billable targets, of course)?

likefunny

Hi all

Need 11 likes to active DM. Please help

Thank you

like

Average starting comp for MM PE associate in bay area? 250k?

like

I have been having occasional very mild chest pain once in a while. Have had a generalized anxiety disorder for a while which is now pretty mild with therapy and exercise too. Wondering if the chest..

Additional Posts in Product Management

anyone here with Salesforce and do product willing to chat?

like

I'm being asked to be involved in product pricing for the first time, and lack any knowledge or experience in that area. Any suggestions on courses or books or websites? I'm considering the Pragmatic Marketing pricing course, so would be interested to hear from anyone who has taken it.

like

Are there any good PM certification that’s worthwhile? Not something that’s on Udemy for 2 hours of coursework.
Most “certifications” I’ve seen seem a bit superficial… but my current PM job feels like a glorified project manager role so I was hoping to use my extra time to study/earn a certificate to show my skill. If possible.

like

Please share your best tips/process of building and prioritizing product roadmaps. Any templates or resources will be super helpful too.

like

Anyone else have experience leading product managers across multiple groups who don't have much to do with each other? Or leading a group whose teams don't really make sense as a group? Feels like a lot of context switching on my end all the time, which sucks up my energy to go deep with leading each of my product managers. How did you deal?

like

What tool/ paid website do you use for roadmap planning? Looking for something to present to the uppers.

like

Which companies have PM roles that are more strategy focused than PO focused (e.g., focusing on overall product strategy and not leading a Dev team to deliver specific product features)?

like

How does this Amazon offer look for an L5 non-tech PM role in Seattle? I’m coming in with 2 YOE as a startup PM. No MBA.

$130K base, 20 RSUs, $45K sign on over 2 years ($25/20). 1st year TC $160K.

It was extended before the recent announcement that TCs are going up but I don’t know if I’d be impacted regardless.

like

Hey all ,
I’m looking for a product manager role . I have approx 8 years of experience including my MBA. I have about 1.5 years of experience in a hybrid role between customer success and product. I additionally have approx 4.5 years of experience in retail and e-commerce marketing roles.

Does anyone know of any open roles within their company I could apply for ? Would appreciate any leads.

like

Anyone here a Product Mgr at Cisco? Would like to connect to discuss the hiring process, and get some pointers towards prep

like

Do product management roles transfer well across industries? For example, would a director of product management role at Visa be interesting on an application to FAANG?

like

Hi! Anyone from Tesla or know of Tesla salary structure for Entry level Product Manager? Thanks!

like

What is a Product Craft interview?
Tell me everything. How do I prepare for this?

like

With product design questions, I struggle to identify user groups. Once I do everything starts flowing and I’m confident. But the initial identification of user groups is something I find challenging. What’s your go-to way of doing this? For example, the question “design a podcasting app for truck drivers.” What types of truck drivers can I select so that I can prioritize a user group to focus on and begin identification of pain points and solutions?

like

As a first time PM at a company with no PM structure, I’m finding it difficult to learn good practices and bring myself to “the next level”. Has anyone here had a similar self taught start that made the break through to become a solid senior PM? Anything will help, books, etc.

like

I’m currently a PM in a startup in Greater NYC area looking for other opportunities. Any insights or advice on what salary/compensation expectations I should have with 2,5 YOE in this area? Any guidance would help. Thank you!

like

What should be the average pay for a senior product manager in a series A startup?

like

Any one recently joined Indeed? Want to know if Indeed asked for a reliving/experience letter from the previous employer. I am joining Indeed in July. I am going through a rough patch with my current employer, ever since I put in my notice 🤦‍♂️ Its got to the point of them threatening to not provide a experience/reliving letter…
I can provide references and recommendations. Before leaving, I just want to ensure that I am equipping my successor to take care of my product and build it further…

like

Where should a data and insights team sit within a company org?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal