{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Hello MBB squids, I need your valuable advice.\n\nI am on course to getting an offer from Mck for the role of Data Analyst. Salary negotiations are pending. I also have a pretty neat offer from a tech product company for a role of consultant. If the Mckinsey compensation is almost similar to the product company, should I go for mckinsey ? I am in two minds because it's an Analyst role with no customer facing. Will that still add value to my career ? \nAlso please advice on career path for Analyst", "post_id": "6173824436d6fc002534cdc7", "reply_count": 8, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "5d7901c370a602001eff88c8", "bowl_name": "All Things MBB" }

Hello MBB squids, I need your valuable advice. I am on course to getting an offer from Mck for the role of Data Analyst. Salary negotiations are pending. I also have a pretty neat offer from a tech product company for a role of consultant. If the Mckinsey compensation is almost similar to the product company, should I go for mckinsey ? I am in two minds because it's an Analyst role with no customer facing. Will that still add value to my career ? Also please advice on career path for Analyst

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Squids hehe

funny

This might be different for different paths as well, but if the goal is money, McK traditionally has a faster TC growth than other places. That being said it’s also likely worse WLB.

I would not take consultant role as industry job

Related Posts

likehelpful

Hi All, Need some help deciding an offer for IT Audit Senior Internal Auditor Role 1. Job A - 90K + 3500 Fixed Bonus + Unlimited Leaves Industry Based Role 2. Job B - 84K + 12K Joining Bonus + 20 Leaves Please help. Big 5 Consulting Role

like
like

Anyone else expecting a rush of bonus news around COB today now that it’s the start of December?

like

I am a fully remote EA at KPMG feeling like I, and my team, are vastly underpaid despite having more responsibilities than traditional EA's. Salary was set for $60k but after yearly bonus this year went to $62k. Anyone else care to provide insight on other Big 4 fully remote EA salaries? KPMG EY PwC Deloitte

like

Thinking about applying to b-school this cycle. I started current role in Feb 2017 out of undergrad. Is it too soon?

like

Any suggestions on how to find referral for FAANG/MBB? Tried message recruiter on LinkedIn not much reply:(

Does anyone know the bonus range for a OT&T consultant 3 rating?

like

Does MBB outside of the US (especially Europe) work as many hours as in the US?

like

I’ve heard the recruiting strategy at lots of firms is changing from MBA to experienced hires and PHDs. I see that is true at MBB but what about Big 4 and smaller firms?

like

Has anyone made a switch out of accounting and more info with an FPA (financial analyst) or operations role? I would imagine it can’t be too hard to leverage an accounting background to do this. I never want to deal with SOX controls again, and continue getting stuck on awful projects within Deloitte advisory. Feeling silo’d and looking for an out. Away from accounting and into FPA or Operations.

like

What does a writing sample for a transactional position look like (applying to lateral)?

like

Can anyone shed light on Deloitte consulting salaries? Specifically the M&A Group. Looking at a senior consultant role and am a non-MBA candidate.

like

🐟 friends, which health care consulting practices are still hiring given slow advisory pipelines? Looking to refer an upcoming MBA grad from a target school

like

Anyone managed to move from Big 4 (non Strat&/Monitor/EYP) to T1/T2 (MBB, OW, ATK etc)? How did you do it? (Networking? Special project experience?) I'm in CBO at Deloitte and wondering how to make the next step to T1/T2

like

First interview with Apple for a non-tech role in their operations team - what should I expect? It’s a junior position. Apple

like

How does BCG evaluate their candidates, had final round interviews, hoping for a Project Leader position, but unsure of if they have a scoring rubric, if they collaborate together or separately

like
like

Full Focus How many of you work with at least 90% focus 12 hours daily like you do for finals back in undergrad? The SMs and Partners I've worked with appear to be fully invested in work all day. Do you increase your stamina to give 100% the higher up you go to CxO levels or MBB/FAANG, and people do not progress in career because of slacking?

like

Interviewing for a manager role at Deloitte consulting human capital team. What’s the typical salary at this level?

like

Additional Posts

How easy is it to get an MBA sponsored by Deloitte USI (consulting)? How many people get it every year?

like

Has anyone exited to a FAANG equivalent (uber, airbnb, Tencent) from Big4, then further exited into MBB? Interested in seeing if it’s a possibility

funnylikehelpful

That short period where the air on the plane shuts off is HELL 😓! Stop sweating us out! Signed, every passenger on every flight.

like

I've been required to work from the office, but it adds 3 hours of commuting each day and I feel way more exhausted at work. Can I speak to my boss about getting a special privilege to continue to work from home?

like

Hi fishes, I'm an MBA grad working at PwC US as D365 F&O functional in india, any referrals for D365 positions in Canada?

like

Anyone done an HEC Paris interview yet? Need help deciding on my presentation topic 😬

like

I really don’t understand why some employers are going to force employees back in the office after they’ve proven to work just fine fully remote for almost 2 years. Is this worth losing employees over?

likefunny

I just took a 60k salary cut to get experience in a new category. Also not working with a-holes. That’s a plus.

likehelpful

Hi! I am in need of some art directors and art sups on my teams. Launches for rare disease states. Live anywhere because this is permanent remote. Please DM me if you’re looking for a new challenge.

like

Can anyone help? Does anyone know what a fair ratio is for the amount of money you bring into a company VS the amount you should be paid (i.e. salary + commission)? I work for an IT partner / Tech company, and from outbound cold market selling have added over 40 companies to our books, which over the last two years has generated €850,000 revenue, and will likely be in excess of €5 million in the coming years. What do you think I should be earning?

like

The role I’m interviewing for has an opening for the same position in the city I want to move to. The problem is that the recruiter mentioned that relocation is unlikely atm because of covid. If I were to receive an offer, is there any room to negotiate relocation at a later time? How long do people normally work at an agency before switching office locations? This agency is 100% remote if that makes a difference.

like

If a kid is born in your country, grew up there, and later became famous in other country, you don't necessarily have to take credit for it. Be humble. Ever seen China taking credit for the coronavirus thing?

funny

Anybody know what a fair salary would be for a data analyst/data scientist who just had his Master degre and has 1 year of experience in data analysis field and 5 years of work experience in total.

like

New employee making careless mistakes - but he doesn’t report to me. How would you handle? I sit in a PM-type role, where I work with various people for projects, but don’t directly manage any employees. We recently hired someone whose work seems generally ok, but I’m noticing a lot of careless mistakes. Things like referring to the wrong month for an event invite or referring to the wrong legal case, or misspelling a major city name. Con’t in comments…

like

How do you reflect after a second or third round interview with the team/managers where the conversation is mostly chatty and light, there’s no real technical questions or anything and then you get rejected? With more technically driven conversations I can usually tell if I did a good job answering or not.

like

What level does McK's Expert equate to at Big 4? Director?

like

What are starting bonuses like at the manager level at big 4 strategy? Having a hard time finding info on this…. Do forms typically forego starting bonuses at that level and index more towards performance bonuses?

like

So what kind of roles do managers go to that seniors can’t go to? As a manager, I’m getting manager of accounting interviews. Why is it worth staying an extra year and a half to be manager? What other roles open up?

like

Trapped as a senior in mobility tax and the job hunt to go into Industry isn't going well thinking of applying to smaller firms as an experienced staff in groups with more applicable skills to cont

like

I’m trying to come up with ways to not make each week feel like a drag being a working mom who has her daughter home and not planning on sending her back to daycare anytime soon..I’m her go to parent during the day even though my husband and I have a schedule in place for me to care for her in the mornings and him to care for her in the afternoons. Even on days he has off I tend to still care for her more than on days I have off. It’s fine I’m just realizing I feel like I’m living for a cont....

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal