Anyone who has been through both rounds at MBB - does case difficulty get any harder between round 1 and 2? Or is it just the level of interviewer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Depends on what you mean by harder, but generally no. My experience has been that the first round tests if you can do the job, the second tests if you can do it consistently

like

Agree with McK1. They test if you can nail them all consistently. I did find one case of my second round more difficult but it was probably due to how the interviewer guided , vs the case itself. Thought I bombed it but got the offer. Just stay calm and do your best! Good luck!

Agree with M1 but will add that it’s a little more nuanced. From my experience, it differs from firm-to-firm. McKinsey’s interviews were all pretty consistent in terms of case difficulty - both structuring and quant. But Bain’s interviews weren’t. The first round cases were pretty easy and straightforward. The second round ones seemed to be a lot more vague and open-ended - probably by design to judge how well you work through ambiguity, which when compounded with the fact that you’re speaking with a Partner, I found to be more difficult.

I also think it’s partly the structure of the case that allows for such a difference. McKinsey’s cases are generally well-explained and packed with lots of context right out of the gate, sometimes designed to inundate you with useless information to test your focus and attention span. Bain’s and prolly BCG’s on the other hand, are more fluid. They run the gamut from a 2-liner (as was one of my Bain interviews) to as long as 2-paragraphs. So this gives the interviewer more wiggle room to design and communicate the case as they see fit, which might it more difficult to solve.

Hope this helps!

like

Very helpful. Thank you

Just went through the process with all three and my experience was that the cases themselves don’t get harder.

Main difference is that partners int eh 2nd round are more likely to mix things up or go off script, would just be more open minded, less framework focused, and roll with the punches

Related Posts

What do you put in a thank you email after an internal mobility interview?

like

In capgemini, documents submitted, 2 rounds of interview over, and now they are sending an email to provide amcat test?what is this now?im well experienced employee. Lol .can someone comment

like

Looking at a job in Kobo (Rakuten) for Data Analyst, any insights as in the technical portion of the interview ? Also, any recommendations regarding the company? Thank you!

like

Hello Fishes.. I had applied for a position and had completed the cultural assessment. Received an automated mail that said “we will be in touch soon”. It’s been more than 20 days and haven’t received any communication. Should I expect any reply now? What’s the usual procedure like?

How do find a recruiter in the legal field? Have been looking for a job for a year now and trying to transition into another practice area. Applied to more than 20 jobs and still no offers. I feel like I might need some help.
Also, I have no idea how these arrangements work. Do you pay the recruiter to look for the jobs or do you pay them when you get the job? Or does the employer pay them?

like

How much do people make on average in VC after 2-3 years out of undergrad in MBB/IB?

like

Application status in Infosys is Attend Interview?
when will they Schedule interview?

like

I have my on-site rounds starting now with Google , will one of my interviewers be my potential manager?

like

If I reject Accenture Technology offer, will I be able to appear for Accenture Strategy interview later on? I have an MBA.

like

Hi Folks,
Just wanted to understand how is the interview process of Guidewire software? I appeared1 hr discussion which is followed by 1 technical and 1 techno managerial round. Yet to hear from them. How much time they take to get back with feedback and do they send regret letter in case we are not selected? Could someone please help on these questions?

Planning to apply in Fall 2020, taking the GMAT in March.
4 YOE at Big 4 (2 years audit, 2 years strategy) what can I do between now and August to bolster my resume and application?

like

how long should a resume really be?

like

I had two recruiters today reschedule a meeting. And this is the second time rescheduling. Honesty, not sure what value recruiters bring. Is this common now? Is it hard to have respect for people’s time and their schedule? Reschedule once I can understand. But twice is just stupidity. I hope AI wipes out all bad recruiters who don’t give af. Sorry for the vent. Maybe it’s just my bad luck then.

like

My AD coworker (not currently my partner) just got hired at a new agency and wants to bring me along as his writer. I'd love to join. He told the recruiter at that agency about me and sent my book. I also have another former coworker (creative) who put in a good word for me.

Should I reach out to the recruiter, too? Or is that overkill after two recos? I don't want to be bothersome. But I do want to show interest..

This all happened on Friday, if that matters. Thanks!

likehelpful

Anyone interview at Apple before? What’s the interview process like?

like

Looking for feedback, I'm updating my resume and I'm wondering at what point should I start removing past work experience. I've heard anything older than 10 years should go?

likesmart

Is there any difference in the interview process (including evaluation) for generalist vs. specialist positions at McKinsey right now?

like

McKinsey & Company McKinsey & Company I have my first rounds (2 cases) for a position at the risk practice. Will I be interviewed by consultants in the risk practice? I wonder if I can ask some risk practice specific questions at the end of the interviews. (Didn’t get the names of the interviewers yet so I cannot google)

like

I am a young professional... But every job interview I’ve had so far pretty much just wants to know what kind of person I am. They are as interested in my leadership/communication as much as they are in me talking about my experience.

(“Real jobs” in accounting, finance and private equity.)

Is this how it will always be? Or is this predominantly because I am in lower positions at this point in my career?

like

Any insights on how to prepare for program/project manager interview with Facebook? TY!

like

More Posts

So, Red Bull car launch tomorrow. Going to be renders only, or an actual car?

like

How is teksystems in terms of job security and wlb for Bangalore location for 9 years experience as Java backend developer.

like

Hello everyone, please help with 12 likes to unlock dm!

like

Hi my friend is moving from Microsoft India (10 yr exp) to Canada - he is a software engineer makes 40 l.p.a in India but got offer of 140K cad for intra company transfer. Isn’t that low or is it normal?

like

Hi, I got offer from Sap labs blore. My joining is in August mid. The team im going to join is CPI( cloud platform integration) . Do anyone know about the team and growth in terms of tech stacks and all. Also heard currently there is hiring freeze, will it affect my onboarding?

Has anyone dealt with chronically itchy and painful legs/shins? What was the cause?

like

Is it irrational for me to get an “ick” for this?

I went on a “date” recently. I paid for the tab as they were going to the bathroom. As we were leaving they said “thanks for lunch” — I was hoping they’d at least ask to Venmo me half as a kind gesture. Following lunch we grabbed dessert. I was hoping they’d offer to cover dessert since I covered lunch but it didn’t happen.

I am fine w/ paying but I was hoping the gesture would at least be presented… am I crazy?

like

What are your top 3 favorite pharma directors? I haven’t shot pharma in a while and don’t have extensive experience in it. NY based directors a nice plus but not a must. Forget COVID, just trying to refresh my memory and look at reels. I’m based in NYC, if that matters. Budget is decent. Thanks!

like

Where are you alt traveling or vacationing for long weekend?

like

Please and thank you!

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Best website or realtor o company or way to find and buy a condo in NYC(Queens, Bronx or Manhattan), 2-3 bedroom.

like

I am a UX designer and have spoken with a potential client who intially wanted to redesign the navigation and landing page of their site. They showed me analytics saying only .35% of users open the main menu (most access different pages through Google search and then leave the site) so it's not worth the time to redesign. I see a lot of growth potential here, but they don't see the value in good nav if users don't already use it. How do I show them the value of good nav? Should I just let it go?

like

I want the juice from the food industry workers 🧐

like

Hi Dolphins,
Please give me 11 likes on this post so I can get DM access. Thanks in advance! 😊

like
like

Can anyone can tell me about relocation policy in Salesforce. Is there is lock-in period or something like that Salesforce

like

My old employer asked me if I wanted to come back to the company as a manager. The pay will likely be much better and the position holds more responsibility than I’ve had before, so overall it would be a step up. The issue is I left the company because of an abusive manager who constantly put me down and made me feel like I wasn’t doing anything right. If I come back I’d be working under her again. I’m torn because the opportunity is great but the stress was awful. Continued in comments…

likesmart
like

Thoughts about associates and in-house counsel (i.e., attys with no control) unionizing? I have friends who are required to go into their offices despite 'Rona! Collective bargaining helpful here?

like

After how many years of joining American express I can go for IJP?

like

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

A friend is interviewing for a role managing one of the pieces of software McKinsey uses/sells to clients and has a case coming up. Anyone know good resources for him to use to brush up?

Had a final round at BCG last Friday. After the interviews they said that the would release results today. Then I got an email today saying they will only give the results on the next Friday. What could have happened?? I also know some people how interviewed on the same day as mine and got a rejection email today.

like

Currently at a T2, thinking about applying to an MBB . Question for you MBB 🐠 — if I have a referral and a solid resume, is it pretty much a guarantee that I will get an interview?

like

Is a 2200/2400 sat score worth putting on my resume/application?

like

How much does the case bot case matter for Boston Consulting Group? Heard that people where able to make it to the next round even failing it?

like

McKinsey & Company Any tips for prepping for PEI? Number of examples per category, anything to stay away from, etc? Thank u :) McKinsey & Company

like

BCG fishes: If you make a temporary transfer to another office for 12-24 months, will your salary (& taxes) come from the home office or the office that you transferred to?

likehelpful

If a senior partner referred me, and I still haven't heard back after 4 weeks, what could be the reason as to the delay? Am I not getting an interview?

like

What is the perception of a McKinsey solution role that is a CSP? Can I exit to tech? Would the role be better than the T2 role I have now?

like

Would MBB firms ever pay for your MBA tuition if you got your MBA prior to joining? Like if you agreed to stay on for X number of years and they pay down your loans. Does that happen?

like

Tier 2 to MBB fish... How has recruiting for other jobs compare at the two firms?

like

Insight about knowledge specialist roles at Bain? TC + relationship to associates would be helpful to know

like

Is it worth making the time/money investment to make the switch from big 4 FDD to MBB. This would require getting into and paying for a top MBA program and my net worth would be way negative after that. Are the MBB financial returns worth it? Im 26 years old for reference

like

Did I lose my chances at BCG north America by giving a preference for middle east?

Recently applied to consultant at BCG with Canada offices as first and second preference and middle east as third (with a 15% interest).

Recently got an interview invite for middle east but nothing for Canada. I'd love to work for BCG but I'd love to be able to do so in Canada. Where do I go from here? Can I request HR to change office or would that make it seem like I'm not interested?

like

Fellow MBBers, any of you think the banking raises will trickle over to us (110k starting) or nah?

like

I finished McK power round 30 mins ago. When can I expect the results ? lol

like

McKinsey 🐠: how much did you practice before your case interviews? (i.e. how many weeks / months in advance, how many hours per week, etc?) any tips on most effective ways to prep as an experienced hire coming in at the associate level? (No MBA or finance background so may need some extra prep to learn key concepts / terms)

like

Just got out of one of my final round interviews. It’s been over 8 weeks of prep. Got a little nervous and may have messed up on the case, PEI went okay. Have the other later this week. Trying to focus on that but difficult knowing how this performance would impact the outcome. Has this happened to anyone and they ended up getting offers? Searching for success stories or tips.

like

What are the hours like for MBB data scientists? 50-60? 60-70? Or more?

like

Moving from T2 to McKinsey. How do vacation requests work? I have family and friends getting married this fall in weddings delayed because of covid, but I’ll just have started so wanted to get a sense of how realistic taking vacation this fall would be and how to approach taking it (e.g. mention to HR, staffing). TIA!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal