How is it legal for agencies to make you work unpaid overtime on nights, weekends and holidays with the thinly veiled threat of losing your job for lack of "performance" ?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Right to work laws.

like

Canadian law is completely different from American. Check the contract you signed when you started. You're likely salaried which means you're not paid by the hour and overtime doesn't apply. There is no salary limit to this (at least in Ontario where I live) it's simply a matter if you're salaried or hourly. Good bosses will give you a lieu day or two for working overtime (and you can /should ask for one) but there's no legal obligation.

like

It is legal. Some countries have work “maximums”, meaning you can’t go above X hours (I think it’s 90 in Japan? Someone please keep me honest), without the company facing consequences. The US is about what the market can bear. If the labor market tolerates (ie: doesn’t quit) with those work conditions, it’ll continue. There are a lot of unsafe biz practices and loopholes in the US. Long hours in advertising is just one little nugget.

like

Didn't mean to conflate the laws. Just saying the tendency to ignore the law which seems present in american agencies is also happening here in canada

I see some people saying it’s legal, but not. Some countries don’t pay overtime if you make more than X but there’s a healthy limit of working hours (usually 2h extra). In Europe and South America companies needs to pay overtime to whoever is not manager with employer powers over employees, so after 8hours you SHOULD get paid and don’t go over 2 extra hours.

like

What you can do to fight against it. From an anonymous email source starts to email you HR, head of department, with other agencies in copy from same group but different countries, with pro labor rights in copy, newspapers. .. everybody that could make them feel ashamed and worried about the repercussions. Add some cases of people that died overworked in advertising like Li Yuan from Ogilvy China, that girl from McCann india that died last year or Matsuri Takahashi who died at Dentsu Japan, what also put light on how Dentsu was operating and generated a big fine for them. The shit needs to get big so people starts to change things.

like

I can't remember when but somehow creatives got lumped in with the Professional exemption. IBM used to pay coders by the hour, but got the Federal government to exempt them in the 90s.

like

Are you putting all of the hours you work past 40 on your timesheet? If so, it will be easier to make the case for back pay if you determine your company is shortchanging you. If they are, and you get ridiculous pushback, get your $$$ then find a more honest shop. Good luck.

Thank you. I am brutally honest with my time sheets and no one has noticed (or cared). Think its time to start the search 👀

Related Posts

Anyone here from HSBC? Need a referral

like

Can anyone refer me for an opportunity at JP Morgan ? :)

like

Customer service advisor vacancies at _VOIS Vodafone
Walk-in interview only

UK Tech voice : 20 positions
UK Voice : 20 positions

Yoe : 6 months - 5 years
Dm for referal and more Info

Let's post salaries, I'll go first senior 2 ITS 83k big 4

like

I’ve created a strong network with Senior Lvl Execs @ my current company, and work on high level task forces to develop enterprise biz. I’m ready to move beyond the AE Role, but not into traditional sales leadership. I’ve also been interviewing b/c our systems are a mess currently. On the verge of getting offers higher than my current pay, I’d be starting from 0 with building reputation, book of biz, etc. My exec mentor suggested I pitch new roles & $$ and she’ll endorse. Thoughts?

like

If the new Sub comes with a 41mm and slimmer lugs like the GMT, does that mean that its new bracelet (I know it wouldn’t be with a PCL) fit the new GMTs that come with a Jubilee bracelet?

like

Currently being interviewed for a Sr Consultant at KPMG Global Advisory. Can someone share what the work culture and hours are like? Also please share any insights on the pay range.

like

Billable hours in Europe. What is the expected at big law ? I got an offer and I am not sure if these are reasonable or impossible to achieve

like

I should probably ask for work but...it can wait until the beginning of next week...right?

like

Anybody around. Looking forward to Michigan-Michigan State tomorrow. On another note, I am secretly pulling for Herm Edwards at Arizona State. The media mocked his hire but I love his passion

likehelpful

UCF - path to playoff? Thoughts?

I want to know your opinions on thank you notes: is it better to write a handwritten thank you note and dropped off at reception desk or is it better to send a thank you email?

like

think it might come today?

like

Thoughts on Klick? (Bonus points if you’re in Philly) Culture? Benefits? Work/life balance? I know they’re pretty flexible with WFH, but heard that may be changing with the new CCO! Thanks!

like

Looks like he’s standing over defeated enemies

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

If I did the final round interview and the company is asking me for references, how likely is it that they will give me an offer? Would love to not waste references’ time if there is no offer in the end

like

Ubud hotels in Bali. Anyone have luxury hotel recommendations? (FS, RC, Chedi). So many to pick from and I can’t decide.

like

I have a village with 3 employees in a 457 plan. They want me to take over plan. Assets are under $200k. Who would take that?

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Advertising

What's your honest opinion of Ad Ops?

like

Is it Friday yet?

like

Ogilvy NY 🐟: What were your feelings about your former creative manager. (I'm trying not to mention any names. )

like

Anybody else not taking vacation leave in case they get cut, they’ll be able to walk away with more severance pay? I’m not planning on using any this year, it’s a great deal for the agency if I keep my job I guess.

like

Getting told by white british men about american culture when you grew up in america but just "happen" to have a non white face

like

What’s the worst way you’ve ever seen an agency lay off employees? Our last round of layoffs involved calling people into an office one by one in front of the entire open-office agency. Felt brutal.

like

new Heineken ad "when you drink, never drive." had zero clue where u were going with the vid until the end, but great job team.

like

Still waiting for my goddamn H1B Visa results Uggh
*Fingers Crossed*

like

Writers: how far into your career before you were able to start writing the good stuff? Not social posts or YouTube taglines. The big picture thinking/writing?

like

Best leadership books you’d recommend? promoted to manage a large team and looking for some books to get practical advices!

like

I looked up the creatives on some of the funnier super bowl ads that got pre-released, almost none of them are still at their agencies lol.

The great resignation indeed

likefunnyuplifting

What's the story with Media.Monks these days? Anyone have insight into working there as a producer?

like

Which NYC-based brands are taking media work in-house?

like

Looking for good social listening tools... any suggestions before we start the search? TIA!

like

This is kind of wild lol. Is anyone seeing this at all?

Post Photo
like

Show of hands, how many times have you been laid off during your professional career ?

like
like

What’s driving you to work so hard?

like

How does one switch from agency to client side? And who are the recruiters who can make this happen? Time to get out.

like

Thoughts on The Wonderful Company? And their internal creative?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal