How much spec work is too much in your portfolio?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Craig Maizin wrote Chernobyl on spec.

Spec work is what you do when nobody gives you the opportunities you believe you deserve.

likehelpful

I mean that’s kind of on spec too

At 3 years in, you have a little bit of freedom.

You probably shouldn’t still be *making* spec work, but it’s completely reasonable that some of the better student campaigns you created a few years ago are more comprehensive and show your creativity more than whatever you’ve worked on as a junior does, especially if you’re working on banner ads, direct mail, etc.

You also shouldn’t over-inflate your role in produced work to get spec work out of your book. You’ll have peers who seem to be advancing faster than you, putting full campaigns in their book when all they did was help out as a junior and write post copy for a social post, not create the whole campaign. You’re better off sticking to what you’ve actually done.

You’ll also likely know someone who made it to ACD in 3-4 years (there’s another thread on that now). They’re an outlier, and with a book that still has student work, that probably won’t be you, and that’s okay.

Sincerely, a creative whose book 3 years in was so bad that I DID add some spec projects, and a 7 or 8 years later is winning awards, producing a lot of work, and actually on track to become a CD.

likeuplifting

Yep as long as you caption it “spec,” it shows the way you think and design. I’m an ECD and still have 2 spec campaigns in I did as a junior in my book (at the end) bc they’re fun and I still love them. Just make sure you have your work stuff up front and you label the spec and you’re fine. Wouldn’t do more than 2 pieces/campaigns.

like

Personally, I say don’t label it as spec. Only say it’s spec if someone asks you about. No need to give more info than you should.

like

How many years of experience do you have?

likehelpful

Many mids pitch directly to clients. And even if the ACDs/CDs are presenting, the book is still reflective of the work they sold to them.

I’ve never really been impressed by spec because it’s usually off tone or not rooted in a business problem or rarely actually new or just silly to be silly. Or all of the above. What it shows me is: can you think of an idea — without any shackles at all — and then articulate it? Great. I don’t need more than two examples of that.

At 3 years, I want to see what you have done. I’m sure an architect would be interested in seeing spec designs for a zero gravity world but would they hire someone whose work was half spec designs that didn’t adhere to laws of gravity? No. 1-2 projects, sure. But more than that and it’ll look like you have no experience or a low batting average.

You might think your one-off social post for cat food isn’t exciting but it tells me you have experience with the pet food industry and writing for what is likely a warm/friendly tone. Now I know maybe you are a good fit for a role I have on, say, the Chewy account (this is an example).

Also I don’t recommend following the advice someone said about throwing them all
in there. You need to show taste and judgment. Best spec work only.

like

Separate them from your actual work and you can put as much as you want

like

What about ideas that died because the CCO didn’t understand AI? Or the internal team was fearful of the idea, they just didn’t see the potential, or said “a lot of production needed”?

Would that be spec work?

like

Glint, I think you missed the point. But your perspective is still welcomed!

SPEC work

I was asked for spec work and a marketing plan for the company. It was 2 job interviews and a 2 day turnaround. For a low paying job.

With a 40 year career and a low wage 60k on one and the 25$ hrs a part time job.

Both asking did you design this work in AI?

I don’t know about the future of the next generation of marketers and designers. I have seen major changes back in the 80s and this will be another change in the field coming up.

Sad to see. I have an agency and I never asked to do spec work on the designer. It was on there merit and work they did. Never had a problem hiring and good designer. I had the time to train if needed.

Related Posts

Hi, I am new here. Would anyone mind 💟-ing this do that I can send DMs? Thanks!

like

I don’t understand how people keep posting about the bench and being unassigned. I’m in advisory(not audit) and my entire LoS is trending 90%+ utilization

like

Any one looking for job in SAP-IBP profile then please Dm me

There is an opportunity with in EY India.
Role will be SCon

like

UBS has mentioned 2L of relocation bonus in my offer letter.
Do I need to submit any bills to claim the same?

like

Is anybody here a notary? And how much are you making from that? Is it a potential side-hustle?

like

Hi Fishes,

I have been offered an on-site opportunity for Toronto, Canada. What should be the decent yearly pay in Canadian dollars that I should ask for ? I have around 6.5 yrs of experience.

like

Today's dinner: Zucchini noodles in butter, garlic, lemon, and basil sauce with a side of chicken thigh.

Post Photo
like

Any of you psychos don’t listen to something while working out/are content with listening to whatever is playing at the gym? I’ve had my headphones die at the gym before and I left.

likefunnyupliftinghelpful

Is it smart to invest in Apple right now?

like

Someone talk me out of buying a entry level luxury car!

like

There is someone from Vodafone group services limited who is continuously writing against Scaler Academy and applied ai courses and continuously promoting ineuron, I don't know why he's doing so, both the courses are good in there own perspective Scaler Academy data science program is awesome and on other side ineuron is good and cheap as well

I want exact review

likesmart

Can anyone recommend a reliable handyman serving SW London? Some painting, correcting plumbing fixtures, fixing a few shelves etc. DM me pls!

like

DBS Bank vs Bank of America (BA Continuum India Pvt. Ltd.) Agile Business Analyst role,

Which one to join?

Culture, Learning and Growth(Knowledge +Financial) wise?
Offered CTC is approximately the same

like

Hi ,
Could anyone please suggest which company to join for 9+ experience guy
Hitach Vantara,
Epam system,
Netcracker technology,
CTS
Except CTS-everyone is offering good package

like

I am going to move in the next few month to a location with a higher cost of living due to personal circumstances. I love my current company but I’ve only been here a little over a month, how should I go about requesting if it’s possible to get a salary increase? Might be a stretch but thought it might be worth mentioning.

like

Now that the rents are going higher and housing is not affordable. With wfh option is it good idea to love to ranch with house?

Anyone here invested or opted as primary living place outside of cities?

Cheers

like

Hi Sharks,
Pls suggest me between these companies…..
Tech M- 15 LPA Cognizant-15 LPA Mindtree-14 LPA Technology-AEM Developer Yoe-3.2 yrs current ctc in tcs-4 LPA

like
like

Additional Posts in Creatives

**This week** Stay safe everyone! (Yes I made this meme)

Post Photo
likefunny

Are Creative Directors rich?

likefunny

Where do you stay up to date in the best ideas from the industry?

like

CDs & the likes: What types of books do you prefer to review? Image heavy ones? A description of each part of a campaign? Or a couple sentences of the challenge and solution followed by images?

Post Photo
like

Hi I’m looking for a CW to join the Young Lions this year, does anyone would be interested? 🤙🏻 📩

like

Do agencies outside of pharma have Art Supervisor roles? Or does it go Sr AD > ACD. I just got promoted to Art Sup & honestly don’t know if so should update my Linkedin since i’m working...

Can someone describe the difference between Apple in Culver vs Apple in Cupertino?
(Types of work, culture, pay, teams, etc.)

like

Hi Creatives! What tool does your Resources Management team use? Also, what software are you using for creative workflow? Also include if you like it or if you have any favorites. Thanks in advance.

How do agencies decide how much to bill clients? How much is their retention usually?

How can I help our UX/UI people and developers become more familiar with conceptual advertising? One Show books? Hey Whipple, Squeeze This?

likefunny

I want to become an art director with zero design skills. I’m going to have someone else comp everything up for me. The ideas might be solid. Who wants to hire me?

like

My first jr ad interview is coming up. What can I expect? What kind of questions will I be asked? Any device would be lovely.

like

Has any creative here ever tried to make the leap to leave advertising and be a film maker, photographer, illustrator, etc.?? I’m so tired of ad agencies and how draining the “creative” can be. Happiness is more important than a nice paycheck for me. Any inspiration success stories advice would be so helpful right now...

likefunny

Anyone have the story behind how the atrocity that is “taste the feeling” got made?

FCB Health Chicago - What’s it like?

like

If you were offered a job at a great agency but working on just one brand, but it was a big one like Nike or McDonalds, would you do it? Being siloed sucks, but maybe worth it for a big account?

like

Did you ever lose all hope in finding happiness in this career but then did something pivotal that helped you achieve it?

What did you do?

I’m spent.

like

Anyone know of headhunters in publishing or entertainment, or good ones in our world who are savvy in such things?

Would a CD here look at some line edits I made for a campaign? Would be great if I could email you them?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal