I had a really weird interview for Creative Director today.

It’s a small startup. HR interviewed me and asked all the hard hitting questions (how do you get design inspiration, how do you deal with design roadblocks, what sets you apart for this role?) which I thought was odd for a screening interview.

They made some affirmative noises then said the next step would be a design test (one pager) which I would present to a panel of interviewers including the CMO.
Anyone else think this is odd?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Doing a “test” is a very startup thing and I would advise not to do this. Find out if it’s how you present then ask if you can present previous thinking.

likesmarthelpful

@SGD always follow your gut instinct, i promise you will find someplace deserving of your time, talent, and brilliance very soon. ❤️

like

It’s a startup, there are no rules when hiring. Can confirm I’ve been asked to do tests before as a CD that were more extensive than a one pager, and it’s certainly more common brand side. Those are also not out of the blue questions in a phone screening — that just means they’re important to the hiring manager and they’re trying to weed out the candidates who don’t align. That being said, if your gut is telling you to run, run free my friend!

like

as a creative director: no.

like

If you have time and it is a good opportunity, say ok to the test and charge your hourly rate.

like

Lee Clow had to present a whole Campaign to get steve jobs business. You’ll be fine.

funnylike

Spec work should be paid, any sort of “test” to me is usually a red flag 🚩

like

Thanks all for the advice. I emailed the company (Relay Network) a week later, after getting a follow up email from them demanding the spec work, telling them their request was out of the ordinary for this position and that I would complete spec work for them for $85/hr.

They replied back saying thanks for my offer and they would pass as they had selected a final candidate.

IF that is true I think it makes them look worse that they were still demanding free work when they had a finalist. Really skeevy. Def not a culture I want to be a part of.

like

Im glad you stuck to your guns, a better job awaits you in the new year 🍾

like

Normal BS.

Related Posts

I am currently in negotiation with Agoda Bangkok for senior software engineer position. I am currently working in India. How much I should ask them during the negotiation? Also, if any Indian working at Agoda Bangkok can guide me with the kind of expenses in Bangkok as an expat?

likehelpful

Hi Fishers, What can my expected CTC be for a PO role at Servicenow? My current profile is 6 years experience with 19 LPA. I have couple of offers with 23LPA and 25 LPA.

like

Hi Nagarrians,
I am having 8.7 YOE JAVA Backend developer and having offer from Nagarro now.
So I wanted to know about the BGV process, like what docs they ask like docs from all of the past employers ?
And do they ask after joining or before joining ?
As I dont have exp letter from my 1st company (with 1.6 yoe) which was a small startup.
It was a absconding case so couldnt get any exp letter but I do have payslips, bank statements, appointment letter & last appraisal letter from that company.

like

I applied to a job at KPMG and did the first two rounds of interviews, general interview, then case study and competency. Never before have I had such a positive feedback at the end of an interview of the 2nd, both said really like me, I did well etc.
It's now been 3 weeks since the interview and I still haven't heard back from the team other than the odd HR email saying they are following up with them. Is there something going on internally, I.e hiring freeze in the London office atm?

like

I accepted a 95k systems engineer role in VA with KBR and is currently going thru a clearance.(MAY START DATE)
Northrop offers me 92k w/ 3k sign on which is 30 min from home in MD for an associate systems role. They also want to give me a clearance but it will start as an interim so I can work sooner than may. MY DILEMMA: Kbr states that they know I need money now so I can accept an offer with Northrop to see if I like it until may.BUT can I have 2 security clearances running at the same time?

like

I completed all rounds of interviews with capgemini. HR took all the documents about 10 days ago. However, offer letter is not yet released. HR stating that she is waiting for client project confirmation. Anyone faced such delays ? Ans what was the final outcome?

Got a random email from a supposed Amazon recruiter for a SDE position (which is not at all a fit). The email is amazon.com domain and there are no red flags in the body but it doesn't feel like an Amazon recruiter due to the tacky signature, etc. Has anyone seen this kind of cold-calling from FAANG recruiter?

like

Need some help finding a SWE job. I’ve been trying for a long time with no luck and just want to get my foot in the door. Any help is welcome whether its some tips or a referral. You can DM or comment here. Thank you!

like

Workday HCM Consultants who switched between Accenture and Deloitte, which one would you rate better in terms of work culture , wlb and opportunities. I have offer for S..CON role in D and Associate Manager in D.

like

Hi Fishes, I immediately need to switch my role related to Data science/ML/AI with good hike. Suggest some companies and ways. I'm willing to learn new things after deployment.

YOE : 1.5 years as Python developer

Skills : C, Python, Excel in writing SQL queries, Swagger, Microservices, PostgreSql Aws(Lambda, Api gateway, SNS, SQS), Angularjs, PHP.

Hi Fishes, I received a mail with subject line 'Accenture Recruitment Status - You've made it to our final interview at Accenture!'. What does it mean? As I Have cleared technical aptitude test and technical Interview can I assume this will be an HR round?

like

Hello!

Anyone hiring for full time Recruiters? I’m in the market looking for a new role. I have over 5 years of experience in the tech industry.

like
like

What is the total comp for a bus dev manager role in a vc firm? New York based.

like

I've an interview tomorrow for .net developer with Siemens, yoe : 7. What type of questions can I expect? Siemens

Exl offices not opening anytime soon right ?

like

I have started the process of looking for a new job, is this bad time to change companies? I have 3 phone interviews next week (1st step for all of them) but I feel maybe it’s not the right time?

like

Hello Friends... How long does it take for the HR to come up for a discussion or offer.... In SAP, SAP labs..

I have cleared all the rounds on 9th June, 2022 and awaiting HR round and offer proposal...

Kindly shed more light...

I was so keen on this position... Now I am worried.... Disheartening after almost 5 rounds...

like

Those of you hiring non-union talent: what's a typical broadcast buyout for an onscreen principal? Do they still do buyouts non-union or could we get away with a one year license or similar? Thanks!

like

How much for a M3 role in risk advisory Deloitte?Transferring from deloitte Belgium to London

like

More Posts

Recently left consulting to join a big tech co in a BizOps role. While I like what I am doing, I get quite bored at work. I barely work for 5-6 hours a day, sometimes even less. Anything I could do to upskill myself? I don’t know much about tech world, any trainings/courses I could do? My role involves heavy interactions with engineers, want to be able to understand the foundational tech stuff

like

what tech companies are still hiring?

I have uploaded the documents in pre-joining formalities for HCL. What if I don't join, will it create an impact?

helpfullike

Average salary of a QA Automation lead in Canada?

like

Selling two tickets to Hannah Einbinder - 7:30 PM, June 2, DC Improv. Paid $61 with fees, would sell for $50 or best offer

like

We stay until 8 or 9 everyday and then at the end of every week my manager tells me to book only 40 hours. It sucks ass and now I have to explain to my counselor why my utilization is so pedestrian...

like
like

Can anyone shed light on Tata Play General Manager role....whats the work culture

like

EY GDS is hiring
DM me with requisition id
Will share the JD
Deloitte McKinsey & Company Publicis Sapient PwC KPMG Boston Consulting Group

Post Photo
like

Anyone Joined Orange business services recently???

like

How do you manage your LinkedIn with a few full time jobs and each company asking you update your LI profile to reflect the job?

like

Hello Everyone,
Please let me know if there are any requirements for Oracle PPM functional consultant in India. I have an experience of 2years and 8 months with 2 end to end implementations.

If I’m just looking to slim down is the best thing to do at the gym run?

like

Hi Fishes,
Timesheet needs to be filled from the DOJ?

Referrals for Miami biglaw commercial litigation positions?

like

Travel with a baby and forgot my laptop at tsa checkpoint. Anyone managed to recover their stuff before?

like

Thoughts on taking a position in the same practice group and same class as your spouse?

like
like

Recommendations for montana?

like

Best places to shop for dresses to wear to summer weddings?

like

Additional Posts in Creatives

Junior here. How common is it to be nudged off a brief when you can't get ideas through internally? My partner and I are often put on the same briefs as more experienced (sometimes senior) teams. As a result, their work tends to make it through to the client presentation while most of ours dies somewhere along the way from CD to CCO. Is this worth worrying over?

like

Looking for an AD to comp up work I’m going on my own. I will pay you.

like

For creatives who work at PR agencies, what’s the work like? And how is it different from an advertising agency?

like

Serious question time:
Do you have everyday work (banner ads, generic social, microsites, brochures, etc) in your portfolios and what's your stance on this?

I’m a Sr AD about to step into an ACD role. This will be my first time being direct report to creatives and being involved in briefing process. Any tips on how to be an awesome direct report? How does a creative successfully contribute to a brief? Please, teach me your ways.

like

What’s the best way of selling work to your boss if he’s just not current on new stuff? I keep getting handed references from some directors from 10 years ago and I want to say “hey, what about something from this year, not last century”

likefunny

What are benefits of working with a content strategist on a project?

What are strong must-have traits of a good content strategist?

Trying to build a case for my agency to hire our first CS!

like

Any other copywriters write on their phone when the computer seems too daunting?

like

What was your “That’s it, I quit” moment

like

Any good packaging places in NY? I’m looking for more packaging focused than branding so not JKR, elm wood etc

like

For those who take the time to write back. Who give critique and tips for the portfolio. Who give guidance and advice, even if it's only a couple of sentences. Thank you. Thank you so much.

like
like

Bay Area fish!

My friend just recently got promoted to a sr. ad and he knows he’s going to eat a pay bump but wants to know what the norm is. I’ve never moved so my viewpoint isn’t normal. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I hate it when I hear an AD say they "can't draw." No one is expecting a work of art, just a shitty sketch that illustrates the idea.

like

Is it bad or is there a polite way to ask an agency to see their work when they haven’t updated their site for a few years, during an interview?

like

When sending a cold email to a recruiter, should you include a reason why you’re interested in the agency? Or keep it short and sweet with your book, resume and what you’re looking for?

What’s the worst review experience you’ve had?

like

Raukten covers Rocket Man. Smh. I feel bad for Elton John.

like

If you put your two weeks notice in, are you obligated to show up? I told my friend, yeah, of course unless your agency asks you leave. Right?

Anyone want to work for us in our chicago office and make me some referral money?

We’re looking for ACD’s, seniors, and a mid-level writer. Send me a DM with your book(s) and i’ll refer you.

likeuplifting

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal