I had a really weird interview for Creative Director today.

It’s a small startup. HR interviewed me and asked all the hard hitting questions (how do you get design inspiration, how do you deal with design roadblocks, what sets you apart for this role?) which I thought was odd for a screening interview.

They made some affirmative noises then said the next step would be a design test (one pager) which I would present to a panel of interviewers including the CMO.
Anyone else think this is odd?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Doing a “test” is a very startup thing and I would advise not to do this. Find out if it’s how you present then ask if you can present previous thinking.

likesmarthelpful

@SGD always follow your gut instinct, i promise you will find someplace deserving of your time, talent, and brilliance very soon. ❤️

like

It’s a startup, there are no rules when hiring. Can confirm I’ve been asked to do tests before as a CD that were more extensive than a one pager, and it’s certainly more common brand side. Those are also not out of the blue questions in a phone screening — that just means they’re important to the hiring manager and they’re trying to weed out the candidates who don’t align. That being said, if your gut is telling you to run, run free my friend!

like

as a creative director: no.

like

If you have time and it is a good opportunity, say ok to the test and charge your hourly rate.

like

Lee Clow had to present a whole Campaign to get steve jobs business. You’ll be fine.

funnylike

Spec work should be paid, any sort of “test” to me is usually a red flag 🚩

like

Thanks all for the advice. I emailed the company (Relay Network) a week later, after getting a follow up email from them demanding the spec work, telling them their request was out of the ordinary for this position and that I would complete spec work for them for $85/hr.

They replied back saying thanks for my offer and they would pass as they had selected a final candidate.

IF that is true I think it makes them look worse that they were still demanding free work when they had a finalist. Really skeevy. Def not a culture I want to be a part of.

like

Im glad you stuck to your guns, a better job awaits you in the new year 🍾

like

Normal BS.

Related Posts

I have an interview coming up for an AE role at a cyber security company, as part of this I need to give a presentation on companies I would target and why.
Any advice on trends in cyber security at the moment or industries that are currently vulnerable and would be a good to target?

like

What is the best tool for hiring teachers?

like

I have a Amazon DS interview lined up. Can anyone please suggest some good exercises to revise sql? I’m solving few leetcode problems,but is there a set of problems which covers all SQL functions? TIA

like

Hi, I have a collaborative interview(second interview) tomorrow with a tech startup for a product marketing manager position. I haven’t experienced a collaborative interview before and I’m not sure what to expect. How should I prepare?

like

Hi All - I’m at a firm that has some infrequent in-house training but not enough to help me develop skills to eventually become a trial lawyer. I know cases rarely make it to trial anymore, but I’d like to develop my skills as much as possible to position myself well when they do. Does anyone have any mock trial programs they’ve participated in outside of their firms that they would recommend?

like

Just secured a legit ft new grad tech role starting in july not big tech. Should I keep applying all these highly leveraged companies are rescinding offers so im worried about mine even though its a stable company.

like

Bain & Company 2nd year MBA candidate interviewing with Bain in 2 weeks. Any tips? Very new to interviewee led casing style. Bain & Company

like

Hey Hey all. Can anyone help with a referral?
There are a few real estate positions available that i think i would be perfect for. Background - Head of Special projects at a real estate developer (building data centres and tech hubs), former McKinsey EM, MBA from London Business School, IB real estate experience and CFA

likefunny

I have an interview for an in house position (only attorney) at a small non-profit focused on conservation easements. I am a transactional associate at a mid sized law firm. The prospect of freedom from the billable hour and contributing to meaningful work are the draws. The cons are that while the salary at the non-profit would only be slightly less than what I am making now, pay increases and opportunities for advancement will be much less than where I am now. Thoughts on making the shift?

like

Wondering if anyone can share the approximate timeline after applying to Target Corp. to hearing something from them. Applied 9/1 and on the applicant portal the status still says “in progress.” I got a great internal referral, but I’ve not reached out to the hiring manager. 😬 I know there were a few hundred applicants — what’s a realistic timeline and what could I say to the hiring manager if I reach out to them. Many thanks.

like

Hey Everyone, I’m interviewing with Accenture strategy (UK) for a manager role. Can someone please provide the salary range for a manager

like

Hey,I am looking for a job in Accenture but I'm applying for a job its showing your resume is already uploaded and I have change my mobile number as well mail id also but my pan details have been already submited

SA at big4 making 126k in advisory. Offer from Cog to join at M with 155k and 10k sign on. Also interviewing with other firms where it’d be a lateral switch with ~170k base. Thoughts/guidance/opinion?

like

I’m in the process of interviewing for an HR consulting role that seems to be more of an outsourcing role..

Is this already a red flag or could it potentially be an opportunity for growth?
What clarifying questions should I ask?

(I’m a new consultant, trying to break into the field)

like
like

Company wants me to come in office for an interview next week. What’s the best way to tell my team I need to take off the morning or afternoon? Usually would use the doctors appt excuse

like

Hi all

I am looking for a referral for switch on a position of Business Analsyt.
Currently in my role I work on MySql scripts, testing, analysis and documentation.

Current exp - 1.3 yr.
Current company - TCS

Dear Friends,

I had my package discussion with HR and they asked me to submit the documents for approval. In the meantime I received a link from Capgemini to take the Mocha English Pro test.

Can anyone help me understand what this test is about and what kind of questions we can expect..I would appreciate your quick response as I have 2 days left to complete the test.
Thank you in advance.

like

CFP thinking of taking a few month career break to search for a new position. Need a recharge and to reevaluate, not to mention time to search. Would this be a mistake? Thanks

like

LAST DAY TO APPLY!!

LTI-Larsen & Toubro Infotech is Hiring

Drive on 1st OCT.

*DM your Emailid with JobID to Apply*

Post Photo
like

More Posts

Just realized excel has a new feature to analyze data in excel. Do you think this will impact the need/want for data analysts? Will the compensation go down or do you think it’ll have no impact?

like

Nine months in and already feeling so unmotivated. Busy season was tough but nonbusy time is even worse.

Fishes profile ma kya likhu
Jo phle se likha hai vho bekar hai

Thanks in advance

Post Photo
like

If you are a direct promote to the post-MBA level, do you get the same exit opps + comp as the MBA hires?

like

Someone jumped in front of my truck a few weeks back (trying to kill themselves, luckily it didn't work) and now I'm feeling so much anxiety. I don't want to leave a job I loved though. How can I cope with this?

like

Need 11 likes for doing chats, please help

like

For Deloitte India, Manager level how many references are required to be submitted from the previous organisation for background verification (bgv)?

like

Hi will KPMG blacklist if we reject offer letter after accepting it.

like

Anyone here from Barclays finance/investment banking domains. Since most of the roles and packages discussed here are for technology/IT related. If anyone from finance background could share, whats the package Barclays offers for BA4 level in finance for anyone with 6-7 years of experience? Barclays, Barclays global service center

like

Thinking of exiting into equity research post mba/via mba internship. Anyone do this and have thoughts on equity research vs consulting?

like

Boston Consulting Group , is GAMMA Solution Track a good role ? I got Offer Solution Lead , but not sure about that track. I have not been able to find anything and it seems pretty new// PLEASE HELP! I dont want to make the wrong decision...

@Boston Consulting Group

like

McKinsey & Company Hey! Could anyone here help me with a referral to BCG or McKinsey? Happy to chat and share my resume McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group

like

Bain & Company Hello, I received an offer as a Senior Practice Manager at Bain. The profit sharing range is 0-12% in the offer letter. Is it typical to receive the midpoint (6%)? Also, what do the annual salary increases typically look like? Any insights are much appreciated. Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group McKinsey & Company

How much does internal operations director at McK or Bain make a year in NAMR?

like

What do you think of Prudential's VUL policies? Do you think their prices are competitive? What do you think of the investment options inside their VULs?

like
like

LTI or EY GDS
OFFERED SALARY SAME

I had customers tell me how amazing the salads I make for them. It’s great that I can make salads that good!

like

What is the average time required to get canadain visa after biometric done?

like

Yup. Good rainy day…gaming with kitty

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Additional Posts in Creatives

I am beyond stuck in my first 1.5 years of my career.

I was over promised opportunities at my first gig and then Covid hit. Leading me to have no portfolio worthy pieces from this 💩 agency with nothing great in sight. (place hasn’t won a pitch in my entire time here + lost clients)

I’m juggling re-vamping my site and a side project to hopefully make my book more robust.

With no kind of leadership or mentor, I’m just figuring out how to dig myself out of this hole. Any advice for this chump?

like

Getting a tour of an agency tomorrow.
I've done my due diligence and researched their clients, awards, culture, etc to ask question.

Any other tips or questions to ask?

Anyone make a move from advertising to firms like ideo and frog? Would love to chat!

like

What are the best social media work you’ve ever seen?

like

Does Google hire freelance designers?(Graphic Or Multimedia)
If yes what is the best way to approach this?

I'm happy to invest a few months to prepare and get the right role.

like

Hi friends,

What are some good in-house creative teams? Just curious.

like

My book is just spec and side projects. I’m trying to get a new junior-to-mid role because I’ve gotten nothing good produced where I’m at, and I have zero faith this will change if I stick around.

I’m asked for work samples from recruiters and CDs even though I make clear that what I’ve done doesn’t reflect who I am as a creative. Think CRM/DM/B2B stuff. They insist on it, and I never hear back afterwards.

Not sure what to do. Almost feel like I’d be better off erasing my agency experience.

like

Thoughts on FCB'S "Bullyhunters" dumpster fire?

like

As a Creative, do you prefer voice or video for initial project discussions with vendors? How do you feel about follow-up video conferences to go through vendor treatments?

like

Tips for my first interview? I have it in a few hours and I am a bit nervous!

Is the interview process at Rasorfish also infinite? How is it?

likefunny

How do I ask for a role change? I currently work as a designer for a company and when I have down time I work on social media for the company. Social media doesn’t seem to be a huge focus at the moment but there is a lot of potential in the industry. How do I go about asking to run social media full time instead?

My ECD keeps changing our work before it goes to client and it's cost us making good work. Our books are suffering because he can't get his hands off the tools. Our books are only full of spec now.

like

Pre and post production routines/tips/etc? Ive always worked with my CD on productions, but going into my first solo. Any tips? Thank you!

like

Hello!

I'm about to start a new job with my main account being a big beer brand.
I want to study and prepare as much as I can before it starts, and influence myself as much stuff as possible... Both from advertising and outside of it.

Can you please share your tips and recommendations?
Specially Art Direction focused - I really want to arrive and be prepared to perform to the best level possible.

Thank you!!

like

Hey! Anybody have experience working on the Brand Innovation Lab at Amazon? Would love to hear your thoughts positive or negative

like

Production feels like a constant battle to preserve the original idea against everyone‘s unnecessary creative flourishes. How do top agencies manage to turn out such well crafted work?

like

I made an entire ad campaign against a green screen for a protective hand chalk company. Would love some feedback if you're curious.

like

What are things that you’ve seen brands do for women’s appreciation day that aren’t cliché/opportunistic?

like

How do you start your concepting process?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal