I just got a job offer I’m excited about, but of course, now my current firm wants to talk 'retention.' They’ve dangled a counteroffer but didn’t value me until I had one foot out the door. Would you entertain the counter or leave on principle?

likefunnyhelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don’t forget your excitement about the new job and your frustrations about your current job when you are making your decision. I brought an offer to my current firm and they matched it. I told them why the new firm was tempting and my concerns about the current firm. I got a raise but beyond that literally nothing changed. In fact, it probably got worse because they are a little resentful that I contemplated leaving. Now I’m giving my notice this week to move somewhere else and I will not be entertaining any offers from my current firm.

like

The general rule is to not accept a counteroffer. I have seen it work out for some though.

likesmart

I am one of those people. Leave now! It won’t get better.

likehelpful

LEAVE. A partner I know went through this and regretted staying after the fact. They’ll be one way to your face but the conversations behind your back are different. You entertained leaving for a reason. Focus on that.

likehelpful

You’re not leaving on principle! You’re leaving because of a better opportunity! They may give you some more money, but firms like that will triple your workload, and you will be remiss for letting them manipulate you into staying! Come on, leave them in the dust!

like

Onward and upward. You were looking for a change for a reason, so don’t forget that

like

Never accept the counter.

like

Don’t take the counter.

likesmart

If you stay, you’ll be viewed as disloyal and expendable. Take the new job

like

It would depend on how long I had been at the current firm, the work I performed and my relationship with my supervising attorney.

likehelpful

The statistic used to be 90% of people who accept a counteroffer are gone within 6 months. Not sure if this has changed in the last 3-4 years, but I doubt it.

like

Never ever ever ever take the counteroffer. Leave.

like

LEAVE! You were unhappy enough to look for a new position - why look back???
Don’t let the door hit you in the *ss.

like

If your firm makes a matching offer, remember it means they had the money and saw your value, but didn't pay you accordingly until forced to.

If you*do* stay, make it part of your contract that you can't be fired without good cause for at least a year.

likesmart

Money should never be the sole reason to stay at, leave or take a job. As an HR Director and attorney I can tell you that money will not make it all better. You will spend more awake hours working then doing anything else, you need to love what you are doing or it will affect everything else. Make your decision based on what will make you happy in the long run

like

Go. See this article. If you even thought about leaving you probably should.

https://80000hours.org/2018/08/randomised-experiment-if-youre-really-unsure-whether-to-quit-your-job-or-break-up-you-really-probably-should/

like

Leave. Your old firm will resent you for forcing their hand.

like

Well trust your gut. Something made you start job searching. Is money enough for you to stay? You can always leave on good terms and then seek to return 3 months in the future. I've seen lawyers come back to firms two times and leave again.

like

Pay attention to their actions. Is their actions that speaks volume. Don't let anyone disrepect you PERIOD. Set your standard from the beginning. Don't entertain it. And forget the principle. If they didn't give it to you--- why would you? RESPECT is RESPECT period.

like

No

like

Did you take the counter?

like

Related Posts

How do I get better with frustration with family (even though warranted)? Therapy?

like

Nice Leather laptop bag recommendations pls. Looked at Tumi website. I can’t expense ~$600 for 💼.

like

I am super excited to have reached platinum premier with ambassador. It's been over a month but I still don't have an ambassador. Do I get notified or do I need to call Marriott? Thank you

like

Any other 🐠 enjoying this HOT mess at JFK Skyclub? Is there some sort of bake sale on diamonds I missed?

like

Any realtor recs? Looking to buy in Seattle

like

Has anyone successfully switched from a claims management role to the risk side as a risk manager/consultant?

like

Boston Consulting Group , is GAMMA Solution Track a good role ? I got Offer Solution Lead , but not sure about that track. I have not been able to find anything and it seems pretty new// PLEASE HELP! I dont want to make the wrong decision...

@Boston Consulting Group

like

Hi,
Quick question: Do you think is it fine to be asked for preparing an outline for marketing plan as an assessment test so, employer decide if you will be the right fit for position ?

likesmarthelpfuluplifting

Which ERP solution will be the most competitive and relevant in the long-term?

Currently in Workday Financials consulting and curious as to what SAP S/4 and Oracle Fusion consultants think. Do each of these products address different markets? Any perspectives from consultants who have implemented multiple systems?

like

Boston SFA 5 years exp (Corporate finance). My research shows 110-120k for comp range. Does that sound right to others here?

Wish I could get some purell delivered rn

Post Photo
like
like

New to trading and investing in equity. Have $200k in equity and $20k in MUNI bonds. How do you plan to diversify?

Hi All - unsure if this is allowed but I have an unopened/unused follistim 300IU cartridge (in the fridge). If anyone is in NYC and can use it, please let me know and I’d be happy to hand it off.

like

Facebook (Meta) business product strategy interview coming up next week. Really want the job. Any tips or suggestions? Facebook (Meta)

like

For a full time opportunity in Infosys for various roles: Full stack dev, AWS dev, Data on cloud, Cloud engineering and so on. Ping your profile in rohit.mukherjee .dak@gmail.com for referrals.
Infosys

like

How difficult is it to transition into banking when your experience in mainly from Fortune 500 businesses like FP&A?

like

Happy to announce my new book Food & Beverage Magazine's Guide to Restaurant Success!

Post Photo
like

Thoughts on Netflix culture?

like

Does IBM providing mac books to new hires this year or is this domain specific? Lenovo ka thinkpad chhod k dell Hp b chalega.. macbook ki chah ni hai. Plz batao kya process rehta h.

like

Additional Posts in Law

How are 1st year litigation associates dealing with WFH? I’ve been having terrible anxiety/panic attacks, and pretty sure my billables wont exceed 110 for April. I’ve been super stressed about it and don’t know how to move on to May with the proper mindset to make up for as much time missed as possible. CA courts are still closed, and I’m worried I won’t be able to exceed (or even meet) my May goal after April.

like

Does anybody work in a rule for a litigation finance or legal funding company who doesn't hail from a big law firm in background? Basically I have a lot of interest in the area have read a book about it in my free time and was wondering what sort of entry level opportunities I should be seeking.

like

Anyone else here kinda like doing doc review? (In moderation of course)

likehelpful

Enviro/ natural resource lawyers— what’s your dream job?

like

Second year associate here. How should I deal with the one partner in my practice group who seems to exclusively give me lousy assignments that we’ll never get paid for? I get great work from everyone else.

like

Those who are voluntarily returning to the office — how often are you going and what days seem to work for you? Looking to slowly incorporate a few days here and there for change of scenery etc. — will add there is no pressure to do so (yet).

like

Layoffs. Most big firms say they're sitting on a conservative pile of cash - which I believe is true - but work will obviously not return to pre-COVID levels in the short term, probably not even in the medium term. Are Biglaw layoffs coming?

likefunny
likeuplifting

Thinking about getting a MBA, partly for personal enrichment but also for professional reasons. I know schools all have different “cognates” but do people have recommendations that pair well with corporate/securities/financial legal practice fields?

like

Hardest part of navigating maternity leave and WLB as a junior partner?

like

Oil and gas attorneys what do you do?

like

I’m on the Board of entity A (volunteer basis) and I’ll have an interview for a legal counsel position at entity B. Entity A and B have a partnership such that me working for entity B will create conflict of interest. Should I disclose my relationship with entity A during the initial interview with entity B’s hiring manager? If so, what should I say? I don’t want my volunteer job at entity A potentially jeopardizes my full-time job at entity B.

like

What’s average salary in ID firm mid size (NY) about 350 attorneys ? Class of 2019 but was in public sector (criminal law) for 2 years! 2000 billable hours minimum

like

This is not my wheelhouse so I’m not sure of the answer. If someone is writing a “memoir” and is including me in it, and I DONT want to be in the book, do I have any legal recourse? I understand since it’s been published it doesn’t meet any invasion of privacy or potential defamation yet, but is there something I can do preliminarily to protect myself and stop my inclusion?

like

For associates who have lateraled in the last 6 months or so, what made you decide to move? Has your situation improved since moving? I’m a transactional mid-level & I’ve interviewed with some great firms recently. I’m struggling to get excited though…it just seems like no matter where I go I’ll be overworked & under appreciated. Hoping there are some positive stories out there to give me hope. Haha

like

How do you recommend dealing with a partner senior to you trying to do anything possible to push you out, force you to quit, or get you fired for years? Owner knows my abilities and likes me (contd)

like

What is everyone’s: (1) billable hours this year; (2) practice group; (3) year; and (4) size of law firm?

like

Last associates committee meeting is coming up. Partners have asked each associate to come up with... not one... but FIVE marketing ideas. Other than reeling out “we offer competitive pay” in job postings, what are some good ones your firm does?

I’m struggling a bit. If I knew how to market well, I certainly wouldn’t be in this position.

like

Transactional junior associate in biglaw. Working for a dedicated practice group rather than in an associate pool. For the past few months, I’ve been loaned to another practice group for a good chunk of time. While the people are decent and the hours aren’t terrible, I detest the work and don’t see a future in this new practice. My main partner says it should end in the next month, but I don’t expect that to happen. Is it a terrible idea to ask to be taken off?

like

How does client secondment work from time mgmt perspective? Do you still have to bill even though you're essentially in-house?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal