Is it a bad idea to not prep for case interviews? I have an upcoming round of interviews with McKinsey, and I honestly think I’ll be more creative and genuine by relying on my consulting background rather than studying frameworks, etc.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I once cased with a MBB experienced consultant and he had used his knowledge experience and the brushed up on some casing litrature. The combination was fairly lethal and he did cases like Senna used to corner on rainy days!

likefunny

Casing Litrature- Online as casecoach, preplounge etc and going through some Bschools case books.

like

Preparing for cases does not mean memorizing frameworks, especially if you already have consulting experience, but you should definitely practice both the case and the PEI parts of the interview…

like

Depends how much you want the job…

like

You are more creative if you prepped so much that you don't have to think about the basics (like pyramid principle, profit tree etc) and can use all your brain for creativity and intuition

like

Yes. Part of preparation is understanding the frameworks well enough to apply them but the other part is practicing your communication skills enough to not sound overly scripted. You can only be creative and insightful once you’ve mastered the basics.

like

Great advice. I always describe casing as a dance, where you have to know the role that each partner is expected to play. If you don't know the expectations of the role you're supposed to play, you're going to be terrible at the dance.

like

You can prepare super wrong if you think memorization is key. Learn case structure and if you are an experienced hire, use your knowledge. Framework knowledge can even block you being more creative.

like

I’ve never once prepped for an interview. Worked out well in most cases, really bit me in the ass a few times.

like

Depends on your casing experience tbh. I tend to get nervous and so for me practising with others helps a lot

like

If you’re already a consultant, screw the prep. Most of what’s out there is probably more detached from the reality of the interview process than you leveraging your own experience. Do ask for a practice case with one of us though, just to get acquainted to our style

like

Honestly depends on the recent and depth of your consulting experience. I’ve interviewed loads of former consultants from b school and didn’t think there’s a strong correlation between consulting background and performance.

I also think that the typical pre MBA consulting roles don’t really prep you for case interviews. Mostly modeling and slide building - doesn’t really train to structure a problem in a life client conversation.

like

Definitely agree with the others saying that prep helps you be more creative. Like you, when I first started interviewing, I thought I didn’t need to prep since I’ve done case interviews before and I use the underlying skills daily. But my first few case interviews after 4 years at OW were not great. I think what you have to realise / remember is that case interviews are a very contrived way of having a problem-solving discussion, and so while you may be great at structuring / solving problems IRL, you may not be good at communicating the process in such a condensed format.

Easiest prep is to do a few live practice cases - no need to memorise frameworks!

Light prep only but directionally agree!

What is a case and why do you need to prep for it? Every interview I’ve ever done was just talking about my resume/experience, so just curious about this

Funny because I remember reading a McKinsey article about case interviews not being a very good assessment tool.

like

Depends on your capacity. No one else knows better than you. If you think you can ace the interview without having to do so much preparations then that's good for you. All you need to do then is to be confident.

Related Posts

What is fixed CTC at Amazon/Microsoft for SDE2

like

How do you know if your Amazon referral went through? Started applying, then someone referred me, but I don't have an email to apply through different referral link.

like

What is the eligibility or time period needed to move from 6B to 7A in IBM? I have 4.7 years of experience and joined IBM recently in JL 6B.

Thanks in advance.

1.Wipro will give any hike after completing probation period of 6 months??
2. And is there band change will happen after completion of probation period?
I have joined Wipro as fresher certified SAP SD consultant and my current band is TeamRainbow. Wipro has mentioned 6 months probation period on my offer letter

like

How is CG (consulting group) in Iqvia differs than other groups?
Does they have better pay than others at same level?
What position to join with 7 yrs of ex. Is grade 140 appropriate for 7 yrs of ex?
Any thing important to know about it.

like

Does anyone have any insights on the pay disparity between operations and strategy at Mck? Is Glassdoor really representative?

Got offer from Cognizant and Infosys.. Where Cognizant offering more package almost 1.5 Lpa mor, but heard lot of negative review on social media like they don't have good project, no job security, they will make you to work on other tech etc . Is it true ? Share some pro and cons that will be greate .. thnks

like

I’m in PA school now but in the process of interviewing for what might be my dream job in medical imaging industry. If I get the job pay will start around 120k at a large company with room for growth. If I stay in PA school I will have around 120k in debt and will probably work in vascular surgery. What would you do? It’s literally the second week of school for me, I have my 3rd interview for the job next week

like

What are the benefits like at Rsm? Senior here

like

Is it common to offer signing bonuses for product managers? I've only worked in small companies and I'm currently interviewing at a much larger company. I am expecting an offer this week, but the salary isn't quite where I want it to be. A signing bonus of 5 or 10k would make me feel so much better (obviously) but it would put me right where I want to be for salary this year. I'm taking a cut in salary to consider this new job but I like the company and they actually offer benefits

like

Hi folks!
I am a branding amd marketing manager with 6 yrs of experience. I am efficient in end to end marketing strategies, brand positioning, PR digital campaigns, and have also handled a small team of 8.

I am exploring job options in India, and immediately available.I am facing issue in getting referrals and being shortlisted for Interviews.

I request you to kindly let me know if you are hiring in your team, or if you could please refer me.
#lookingformarketingjobs
Thankyou,
Tarun Nehra

like

Any suggestions on path to crack interviews with 11 YOE ? Tech stack .net angular

like

I was referred to Accenture federal 2 weeks ago, but have not heard anything back yet. How long did it take for a recruiter to reach out to you? How fast does Accenture move in the hiring process?

smart

Hello Guys,

Need to know one thing urgently. Have attended lateral TCS interview and cleared TR and MR..But got to know in the MR round that my preferred base location they cant provide..So went ahead with it. HR discussion yet to happen.. In the meanwhile got another interview scheduled tomorrow frm TCS whose talent acquisition person told its a pan india location and any location can be provided...

Can anyone please let me know If I sit for the interview tomorrow will it cause any issue/not?

like

For Oracle Cloud Functional tech, what is the maximum salary limit for SA-Projects role in CTS?

like

How much hike (%) does Accenture gives during promotion?
(If it differs based on management level then I want to know about promotion from level 10 to 9)

like

help I literally never learned to properly case and have an interview coming up with BCG, what are the best resources for me to use?

like

Hey all,

What's with the probation period with Deloitte India? What's the rate of termination, if there are any, unlike the other firms (who have a probation but 99.99% of the employees are confirmed at the end of probation).

Appreciate your inputs.

Thank you.

like

How many days Deloitte India takes to release offer letter. I tried to contact HR she said that they are trying to get approvals and it is in progress. It's been a week that i have uploaded my docs.

like

How advanced are the coding questions for entry level data scientist? For SQL+ python

More Posts

If tcs gives break up , is there possibility to decrease from that amount or not process the offer letter hr informed she has to get confirmation from manager for budget and it will take 2week time ??

What should be the average Senior software Engineer python salary??

Hi guys,

I am looking for my first permanent UI/UX or Product design role. I am currently working on as a contractor in Canada. It’s becoming really difficult to land a permanent role and I really want job security.

like

Lost my job and just hit midlevel as a brand and creative strategist. Can’t find much for my experience level at all and am getting nervous. In Chicago but willing to relocate. Anyone have any leads?

like

Is it bad to be over-utilized? I just did the math and I could charge zero hours this week and take a 3 week vacation after and still be 100% utilized? Is that abnormal?

like

Has anyone ever left finance (or know someone that has) to do something completely different? My experience is split between FP&A and accounting and while I have progressed, I am becoming depressed b/c I feel like I’m in the wrong field. I am generally a motivated, high performing person, but I al starting to slip up and care less, b/c my work is not satisfying to me. I know I just sound like a complainer, but does anyone have any advice?

like

Today no one came into our restaurant and my boss started crying. Do I... comfort them? Leave them be?

likefunnyupliftinghelpful

Got offer from Cognizant and Infosys.. Where Cognizant offering more package almost 1.5 Lpa mor, but heard lot of negative review on social media like they don't have good project, no job security, they will make you to work on other tech etc . Is it true ? Share some pro and cons that will be greate .. thnks

like

Does anyone have any insights on the pay disparity between operations and strategy at Mck? Is Glassdoor really representative?

Has anyone regretted their decision to become a PA instead of a Physician because we end up doing mostly the same work but for less pay? I'm considering the extra education

like

I’m in PA school now but in the process of interviewing for what might be my dream job in medical imaging industry. If I get the job pay will start around 120k at a large company with room for growth. If I stay in PA school I will have around 120k in debt and will probably work in vascular surgery. What would you do? It’s literally the second week of school for me, I have my 3rd interview for the job next week

like

has anyone made the jump from hospital administration to healthcare consulting?

likesmart

What are the benefits like at Rsm? Senior here

like

What are some cool perks/ benefits at PE firms? I know it isn’t close to MBB but anything?

like

Anyone at Slalom willing to refer? Targeting healthcare projects only. Thanks!

likesmart
like

Anyone in NYC looking for an Associate Strategist? Asking for my mentee, she has 2 years ad tech start up experience.

like

Any thoughts on XPEV? Think it has some upside this year given it’s tech and sales outside of just China.

like

I am a solution engineering (presales) manager, and looking to hire a Tableau Analytics SE for our Canada Public Sector team. Seeking candidates with relevant experience in technical customer-facing roles and/or analytics. Ideally residing in Toronto or Montreal metro areas, public sector experience. Bilingual (French and English) is a huge plus. Please let me know if you are interested to learn more! I don’t have the job posting yet but will share once I do.

like

Is it common to offer signing bonuses for product managers? I've only worked in small companies and I'm currently interviewing at a much larger company. I am expecting an offer this week, but the salary isn't quite where I want it to be. A signing bonus of 5 or 10k would make me feel so much better (obviously) but it would put me right where I want to be for salary this year. I'm taking a cut in salary to consider this new job but I like the company and they actually offer benefits

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Can't wait to go home and go to beer pong with my husband at our local bar 🍻🎉

like

Book recommendations on leadership, career development, etc?

like

All I want to do is curl up in bed with hot tea and a good book. Recommendations for if I ever achieve said dream?

like

Any fish struggle with an eating disorder? How does travel and lavish dinners affect you?

like

Hey all, can you pls recommend resources to get up to speed on Fraud and Risk management for Payments in fintech? Books /sites? I’m not in consulting anymore so no access to internal decks. Thanks!

like

Hello,

Currently, in accenture. I have had very bad billable hours and not much achievement this fiscal year. I am worried of getting fired, so i applied for another job. Got offered may be 5% above my current pay with 5k bonus, but in lower level at Deloitte. I think working lower level will give me more opportunities to learn as i think i have lot to learn. I made decision based on my gut and accepted the offer. I have not talked to anyone on accenture side yet. What you think?

likesmart

Any good business/consulting books on amazon kindle that y’all have read that has helped you in your job?

like

Layoffs at Walmart corporate 😬😬

likefunny

What rental car company do you use when booking personal travel? Hertz because it’s linked with SPG?

like

I want to start bringing my PS4 with me while I travel, but I'm maxed out in carry-ons. 😞

like

Books to learn more about how to drive sales in consulting? Any recommendations?

likehelpful

Best business-oriented, but novel-style books with good writing, style, & interesting characters? Not really self-help/advise focused, more of actual literature with business themes/plots. Any recs?

like

TFW the Sheraton employee questions if you and your SO really belong in the lounge, then you call them on their BS and they send a bottle of champagne later as an apology. That's right 👍🏾👍🏾

like

Anyone still use a pager? I feel like I get weird looks sometimes for carrying mine around but I came from industry and this was more common, not in the consulting environment from what I've seen 🤔

like

Which top consulting firms, if any, will pay for your MBA?

like

Class departs, Crass starts!

like

Anyone have any recs for self help books? Looking for more relatable topics to myself I guess?

like

What’s your go to drink?

I like a Whiskey Sour 🥃 or a Vesper Martini 🍸 (depending on my mood ofc)

like

Is severance taxed higher? I got 1 month of pay but seemed to be taxed much higher

like

I want to exit to a GM or Senior ops director role. Currently 3 yrs in consulting, 10 yrs in ops at well-known manuf. firm, CPIM, CSCP, T20 MBA, Ind Eng undergrad. Anyone have recs on how to prepare?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal