Is it worth switching from McKinsey to BCG? Enjoy the work but hate McK’s networking, staffing process, and promotion process

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I did the reverse to McK recently and 100% agree with your view. Staffing/networking materially different at BA/A, Promotion/sponsorship materially different at EM/AP. I would switch back yesterday if I could :) One thing to keep in mind though is your preferred industry/function, McK works in some spaces the others don’t, and no, that’s not because McK is the best, but due to they price flexibility from creative staffing :)

like

Wont the manager of an M be a partner at least? not in mck- so curious about the system

Try Bain. We’re the most different on those three points.

like

Agree, best system (excl the M/SM timeline, which is good for learning though, and overall comp)

Why would it be any different over there?

can you elaborate on the differences

No I want to kms

How confident are you that it’d be materially different and positively so? What do you dislike about McK’s networking, staffing, and promotion process?

Related Posts

I guess I'll try my luck out... Isn't the ideal thing to have the passion and romance of teenagers, but with the maturity and experience of adults? Hopefully I could find someone here that has that mindset.

likehelpful

Anyone have a standing desk recommendation between the Fully Jarvis vs Uplift V2 vs Autonomous Smartdesk 2? Leaning towards the Jarvis but the Autonomous one seems 50% cheaper, but can’t really tell what the drawbacks are according to their website/reviews

like

Hello! I’m thinking about doing a destination wedding. Does anyone have any suggestions on good resorts? Any tips? Thanks!

Good places to grab a drink solo? Im a 25yo woman.

like

What do hiring managers want to hear when they ask "What's your process?" because I don't think I have one.

And when I explain something from Lean UX or something then apparently that's too cookie cutter.

I've done 26 interviews in the last month and I half and I've gotten no where 🥲

like

Where is a great place to find Graphic Designer positions, with solid companies that are willing to compensate at fair market value? I’ve tried Indeed and LinkedIn, but no luck landing even so much as an interview.

likefunny

What is exactly the location? Kharadi or Viman Nagar?

What is the pay difference at consultant level between Dubai and Riyadh? Thanks

Anyone here who moved from India to Singapore in a VC/PE firm or FANG (business roles) in the last year with new EP issued (not an internal transfer)?

Any chance SG rental prices will be coming down soon ? I'm returning to SG after 3 years abroad and debating staying at figment or hmlet for a few months before locking down a 2 year lease.

like

Hi All,
I have 3 offers - Cloudera, Epsilon and TIAA.
Tech Stack - Big Data
TIAA and Epsilon is offering around 4 lakh more fixed CTC compared to Cloudera. As I belong to Big Data I'm inclined towards Cloudera but needs suggestion

like

Can anyone say the hike percentage and bonus for TC at PwC AC for Associate 2 level?

like

Do HSBC BANGALORE, do they give you joining bonus?

like

When will the hike letter be released ?
Will the hike be reflected in Nov salary or in dec salary ?
I would like to know avg expected hike for career level 11

Can someone tell me about the profile for Deal Analytics – Restructuring in KGS Deal Advisory

like

Any idea on what's the average market pay for a Salesforce developer with close to 6 years of experience in India? ( Point to be noted i have 2 years of experience in diff technology and 4 years in Salesforce)

like

Do tech companies in Canada give out RSUs or equivalent?

I was Listening to a podcast today about people in US tech getting rich from 50k to 100k of annual RSUs in the US that vest over 3 to 5 years then making millions when the company exits.

Wondering if there are similar opportunities in Canada or is it less common to receive a decent amount of equity here?

like

Working Moms/Dads: Do in-house positions exist with flex time hours? I need to be able to leave work at 4pm to pick up my son from daycare, but i can get back online at home to resume any unfinished work at 8pm. Is this realistic to convey to any companies in an interview? Pandemic aside, is face time 9-7pm really important? Or should i just try to find a job with a salary that covers a nanny salary and accept that i will never see my son on weekdays (which would be sad for both of us)? TIA!

like

Hello everyone! How do you manage holiday pay when the holiday is on a Saturday/ Sunday. For example, if I have someone working on Christmas (Sunday), they should be paid 1.5 but what if they work on Monday as well?I know this might sound silly to some people but I’m covering for payroll for the holidays and I don’t want to mess up!

like
like

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

Summer intern at BCG. I've been told by a few people that you need to spend your first few cases "earning your stripes" to gain staffing optionality or be servile/loyal to a pyramid to gain access to the cooler case work within that PA. It's seemed particularly emphasized at times.

Is this the standard at McK? I'm trying to guage the staffing optionality and openness of McKinsey culture to direct your random walk.

like

Anyone willing to chat from the Platinion group at BCG?

like

Best GMAT prep books/ material ?

like

How is performance measured at MBB?

like

Is firm travel back up to pre covid levels?

like

Do McK/BCG usually send rejection emails after you apply? Or do you just get ghosted without an interview invite?

like

Anyone willing to dm about climate/sustainability roles at BCG?

like

BCG fishes: If you make a temporary transfer to another office for 12-24 months, will your salary (& taxes) come from the home office or the office that you transferred to?

likehelpful

Is “Hacking the Case Interview” any good?

like

is BCG hiring a experience hire class of associates in march?

like

If Kanye becomes president then I can get into MBB. All things are possible.

likefunny

What’s the standard RTO (return to office) plan for MBB as of now?

like

Is Bain done with exp hiring? Was thinking of applying for an AC role but recent posts seem to indicate Bain has wrapped up exp hiring

like

Is it possible for someone with anxiety to have a career at MBB? Anyone currently in this situation? How do you cope?

like

For the ppl that got BCG offers lately, what were the start date options you received?

like

what phone can you get at bcg? how often upgrade. for NAMR

like

Good answer for “what motivates you” for MBB interview without the mention of 💵

like

Is it just me or was the logical reasoning on Bain’s SOVA test for the London office extremely hard? Does anyone know if it’s a big part of the interview process (compared to the Resume / CL)?

like

Slowing it down and coming across as more articulate / interactive vs speeding it up and come across as fast (but sometimes talk too much / make it hard for the interviewer to interject)? Are there certain parts of the case I can be quicker on vs others?

like

Anyone up for practicing McKinsey style cases together? I have availability on weekends and after 7pm on weekdays.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal