I’ve been helping the creatives deliver great work. But it seems like the creative leads aren’t trained in bringing planners in as an asset to achieve direction and strengthen ideas. What can i do?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I believe that creatives need to make the work that makes sense for them. I know there’s a place in the creative process for strategy, after all, strategy as a discipline was the creative’s job until it was spun off from creative as a way to increase billing.

I guess, to that end, I believe that the role of strategy is to tee up the ball for creatives so they can step up and hit the long drive. The way you provide direction and help strengthen ideas is by bringing them the juiciest, most inspiring insights. I wouldn’t expect that creatives will necessarily continue to involve you intimately throughout the process—but if you provide enough real value to them from the jump (great insights), I bet they will.

like

@Dir, The reason Strategists exist is to research clients at a very high level, to plan 3 to 5 years out, to collect audience and market information from testing...to have a 30,000 feet, long term strategy.

But no one uses them like that now. No client will invest in all that. In the last 10 years or so—as clients have wanted to spend less and less money on production—Strategists have indeed been turned into billable hours for decks, meetings, rebriefings, talking talking talking, more meetings, and more opinions in the room. It’s the “new model,” where producing actual ads is replaced by revising decks about the “ideas” we “could” do.

I always like it when strategists build on the execution in new media channels more than when they try and build on the idea itself.

Find ways and places to extend the idea, make the campaign more well rounded, more 360.

I feel like after you do that a few times, they'll come to you more proactively going forward.

like

For proactive thinking. Trying to work on creating open briefs that address that, but that’s a whole other conversation

Recent IconRecent

A good strategist is a godsend, and can offer a POV different from that of account people, who often just play wannabe creative director. A bad strategist plays wannabe creative director. If you’re good and can offer genuine insights, people will beg to have you on their accounts.

like

Try making the problem creative needs to solve more interesting, more focused, and more important (without losing your honesty).

Nothing makes the difference between ideas more clear than an understanding of what problems they really solve.

Aside from that, I just try to imagine the best possible version of the idea they’re sharing with me and help build to that version.

Also, really helps if they have seen the clients put their trust in you. My creative partners know that I can sell in an idea differently than they do, and so they know my feedback and reactions are oriented to help make their favorite ideas (often the best ones thank god) better.

Lastly, get time with them outside the office. Hit the bar, go for lunch, whatever. Go somewhere else that feels less like work and have a talk through the ideas like two humans who care about the work. The work environment and meetings just makes it feel sucky.

helpful

100%

Thanks! Will try that.

The answers were so predictable... @OP. Go find a place that values you and has evolved beyond antiquated models. They exist.

like

For me, a great strategist distills all the info that’s out there into a clear insight. And gets the client to agree to it. That way I can focus on how to convey it rather than what needs to be said. They don’t give me all the info, they clear it away.

If you’re good at that, if you give me a good place to stay, I’ll trust you and want your guidance making sure we’re true to it, talking about where else it can go, etc.

But a lot of what you guys do is before the creative work starts. At a certain point, it’s now my job to take over and to assess the subjective execution stuff. And yeah, I can imagine that’s super frustrating for someone who’s spent weeks on this before I ever get to it. But that’s kind of the gig.

I do find a lot of the same excuses:

“Most strategists are bad, so better to cherry pick involvement” 

And...

“Just give me the brief and vanish”

I think everyone in an agency needs to help each other. A planner needs to help creatives just as much as creatives need to allow and empower planners to help them in key parts of the process. The problem is, that for creatives, the “key” part is only the brief hand off and NEVER casual conversations that nurture additional builds on the insight without intruding on creative work.

Having the last word is really important to you, huh?

Related Posts

If consumers prefer diversity in ads, wouldn't it make sense to have a more diverse industry? Why does agencies lack diversity?

like

This is dumb, but. How can I pull and average the numbers in column b associated with the 4 values in column a? So, (sum of all As/total number of As) without filtering?

Post Photo
like

Creatives who left for tech. What is it exactly that you do now? Is it still writing or art directing? Or a different creative role? Hearing about people leaving for tech so I want to know what it means exactly aside from the benefits.

like

Things to do in town for Christmas? I'll start in the comments!

like

DM me for more details.

Post Photo
like

Medicaid plans are so dysfunctional. Has anyone else experienced this? I feel like I’m being gas lighted after working for big commercial enterprises and now working on a Medicaid plan. I’ve never seen so much resistance to change or legit resistance to doing anything to improve operations.

like

My current ctc is 13.8 lpa.Before scheduling L1 interview, HR told me for this role the maximum pay is between 13lpa and 5lpa.. I said ok.. and i have celared the interview as well. HR negotiation is pending. Now if i negotiate for a higher salary.. what will happen? Would they be able to go beyond 15lpa?

like

In the beginning of my career I absconded 1 company who had 3 years bond and I worked there for 5 months. My pf account is created for that company and it has been closed with reason cessation (short service). After that I worked in 1 company for 6 years and since January I'm working in TCS. Should I mention my first company experience. So far I'm not mentioning it anywhere.
Please help me out with this
Requesting you to like the post even if ur not able to help so that it reaches to more poeple

like

Hey Fishes,

I'm looking for a job switch in HR domain. Having 4+ YOE and holding a master's degree in MBA HR.
Looking for your support.
Also, I don't have sufficient Likes to DM so struggling to unlock the same.

like
like
like

Opening for below roles at Impetus technologies inc ... Company with great work culture, pay and learning opportunities... There are other openings also for aws and bigdata roles... DM if interested.

Post Photo
like

Having trouble landing a decent job, I am 4 years post bachelors, environmental science. I can not seem to land a job above minimum wage. My last position (horticultural assistant) found myself taking on a good amount of projects that were being left unfulfilled, due to coworker politics (a few co worker’s wanted to see the supervisor fall short of expectations) in addition I had difficulty with my manager( sexual harassment) I rejected their advances, and I was laid off in December

likesmart

Hello Sharks, What is maximum salary for C2 Manager role in Capgemini and Manager in Cognizant. CCTC : 33 LPA. Total experience : 10 Years

like

I get so frustrated and annoyed when people make stupid common sense mistakes and I think it’s starting to affect my relationships. Don’t really know what to do.

like

Seeking employment as a Financial Analyst in the New York and New Jersey area any suggestions? Please help thank you.

like

I just stop breathing whenever I get a meeting invite. What is life

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Creatives

A small part of me wish I would get laid off and be forced into freelancing so I can make 💰 💰 💰

like

I hated the Cheetos ad when I saw it last week until I saw all the other ads that came before it today :/

like

Does anyone have a Getty easy access account they can share we me?

likefunny

I want to become an art director with zero design skills. I’m going to have someone else comp everything up for me. The ideas might be solid. Who wants to hire me?

like

Tips for saving/mocking up social posts of your work once it’s posted? Like is it easier to take a screen grab or what? Sorry I’m not super tech savvy. Haha

Newly minted Creative directors: What's the going salary these days in a major US market? SF, NYC, Boston, Chicago, LA.

like

Do you ever get stoned before/during work? I had always steered clear during work hours but recently I broke my own rule and wound up writing what felt like some of my best work in months.

likefunny

Anyone worked for an in-house agency? Pros and cons? Did/do you enjoy it? Would you recommend it? More stable? More money?

The creative contingent has convened and voted to disavow A Writer from the post 16 hours ago in hopes of keeping in tact the great PM / Creative alliance.

likefunny

Any book or podcast recos for introverts to work on their leadership?

like

Hey guys, question regarding new years resolutions. Anyone know some good books about how to lead better and step up to become a great CD?

Has any creative here ever tried to make the leap to leave advertising and be a film maker, photographer, illustrator, etc.?? I’m so tired of ad agencies and how draining the “creative” can be. Happiness is more important than a nice paycheck for me. Any inspiration success stories advice would be so helpful right now...

likefunny

Where is the best place to look at inspo for directors / style for TVC/OLV?

like

Someone should get fired for this

Post Photo
funnylike

Random Q unrelated to advertising but is anyone investing through Fidelity? And what mutual funds/stocks are you investing in that show potential?

like

I always wondered what kind of side jobs that copywriter could do?
I barely get an offer and when i do, i felt bad for charging it much so i always go with “pay as you wish”

like

Anyone know the salary range for an Art Director in LA?

like

For the 1st time in my career, I have it all: at an agency I respect, with CDs I like, on a brief with potential.

I have no excuse. But my ideas just aren’t as good as the other teams’. What do I do?

likeuplifting

Does anybody know which are the best in-house agencies to work for? Thanks!

like

Anyone else have a client that wants to communicate “informally” over weekends? I’ve got a client that can’t seem to turn his work brain off. It drains me M-Fri. I don’t need it Sat/Sun too

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal