Just had an interview at a large holding company with their internal recruiter. When did the interview process get so superficial and like talking to someone in HR? This recruiter lacked any personality and spent the time talking about the agency like it was PR convo with adweek. When did being a creative become such a robotic transaction with the interview process. Can’t we just be real and honest and not try to pretend that everything is great - but try to be open and talk about it?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It’s a window into their culture.

like

They’d know better if they weren’t all 25 year olds in their first recruiting job…

likesmart

We’ve reached the stage in society where literally everyone hates their job because they see someone on social media with a “cooler” job. No one is passionate about being good at what they’re capable of so they just go through motions.

like

We reached that point in society with everything.

It’s a ghost job. The purpose of the call wasn’t to hire you. It was to promote the agency

like

You are right - the recruiter kept name dropping and talking about Cannes. I’m like who cares, can we get back to talking about me lol

likefunny

tbh it depends on the recruiter. i just interviewed at IPGH. the one recruiter i was placed with was so bland, not helpful and didn’t give me any information. they went away and their counterpart really changed the whole experience for me and was really communicative and helpful

likehelpful

If you’re comfortable, let the counterpart know their attitude and energy changed things for you. I’m sure they’d appreciate the recognition.

Agree. It’s become painful.

like

Recruiting has been cut to the bone across all sectors. Odds are this recruiter has dozens, if not more, roles to source for.

Doesn’t leave a lot of time to actually dive in deep and get familiar with candidates or positions - hence the superficial interactions.

smart

Yeah, and then you wait 3 weeks for them to get back to you (if they don’t ghost you). This just happened to me. After 2 weeks I emailed the recruiter for an update and she replied that the hiring manager had been working on a pitch and traveling so she hadn’t been able to connect. Plausible. But also sounds like a generic “advertising” excuse. My sense is that she forgot about me and dropped the ball entirely.

Nothing like an experienced middle aged creative being interviewed by a 20 something HR person whose mommy still does their laundry.

Related Posts

Updating Resume resources and tips? What can and cannot be on the resume as a consultant? It’s been a minute clearly

like

Done with technical round, HR round and also background verification. And got a call from HR for negotiation. But till now not received offer letter. It's been two weeks. Is it always like this in tech Mahindra?? Or should I consider I won't be getting any call back.

like

Hello. I have a job interview coming up. When asked the question by the interviewer, “Why do you want to leave your current employer for us?” What is the best answer?

like

Is there anyone who works at SOTI Canada? I’ve an interview coming up. Need some advice.

like

Hi fishes, I have an interview tomorrow with factset for Client Solution Advisor. Any tips for the questions they'll be asking? And if ajy of the factset employee can tell me the work we will do in this role will be good.

Should all the on-site interviews have a feedback of "hire/ strong hire" in order to proceed to HC?
What if one of rounds was not up to the mark?

like

Hi Guys,

I have completed my tech interview rounds with UBS and have received email for fitment round.

Can anyone share what happens in this fitment round on interview?
HRs have asked to submit documents even before this fitment round; which seems unusual. Is this normal for UBS and this is how they progress?

Thank you.

like

How much does the case bot case matter for Boston Consulting Group? Heard that people where able to make it to the next round even failing it?

like

I got call from HR saying I will get mail to upload documents for LTI does that means I am selected and how much time they will take to process and do HR rounds? For 4 yoe how much can I ask ? And currently tcs have given me 10lpa breakup not official offer letter

like

What should I do if it’s been two weeks since I’ve heard from a recruiter after doing interviews at EY I’ve already emailed twice due to a couple competing offers having upcoming deadlines and still have not gotten a reply from the recruiter. Should I just assume that I didn’t get the job?

Hello Fishes,

May I know what all the topics will be covered in the first round of interviewfor the role of "Data Analyst" in Comcast Company...

Thank you 😊

like

Some recruiter just called my mobile, sneezed and hung up.

I am getting sick of these cold calls.

funnylike

Meeting with the hiring manager again. I already got the offer but trying to get a better feel for role and team. Any questions you wish you asked before accepting the job?

like
like

Any tips for a candidate who is currently in working in a bank in IT operations and interviewing for a tech company for a role they don't have technical experience at all? Moving from a BA position to another BA role but tech is completely different...

like

I’m interviewing for an in-house brand position at a tech company... after 10 years in the agency world. Any big things to watch out for or ask? Thanks 🙏🏽

like

Interviewing for a risk role when I’ve barely ever done any risk or ERM lol Please let me know what the heck I can say to be chosen cuz this role is interesting!

Does anyone have Organization Design case study experience?? I’m hoping to get some insight to help prep for my Consultant interview in some days with Deloitte.

like

The biggest lie you've told during a job interview? And did you ever get caught?

like

More Posts

What health tech (or adjacent) start ups excite you most these days?

like

Spending a weekend with my fiancé’s family out of town and quite literally my future FIL burps out loud 10x a day with no shame and his mom is a narcissistic monster in law just have no clue how these bizarre ppl created such a lovely person in my fiancé. Don’t need advice, just want to bitch. Can anyone relate??

funnylikehelpful

Is booking 40hrs a week freelancing for one company a good idea? Or does that seem like you don’t have anything else going on? I would like a good work life balance with the ability to take off weeks at a time in the middle of all this.

like

Has anyone ever pivoted to Product Manager at big tech? Thinking about making a switch and would love to hear some of y’all’s experience. Thanks in advance!

like

Please who knows about the advisory practice within the PwC financial crime unit (Canada Acceleration Centre)? I understand it is a client non-facing advisory role. Would it be a good career decision for someone coming from GRC firms like Kroll, Control Risk or Exiger? I am concerned about the negative reviews relating to the PwC acceleration centres in general, and getting stuck in a role which does not provide growth opportunities. Thank you.

like

Fri-yay Wordle

Wordle 251 3/6

⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
⬛⬛⬛⬛🟩
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

like

Could anyone suggest a good ladies pg in Marathalli area? Preferably single sharing or double.

like

Hello, looking to to grow family real estate / property management business and looking for an attorney to join our payroll to work on real estate matters full time

like

Trying to find an investment property to rent out for about $300k - what are your recs for location ?

like

Hi all, I'm planning to join Accenture. Also in the next one year, I'm planning to apply for express entry into Canada at my personal capacity. Is it easy to get transferred to Canada in such cases? Accenture Accenture India

like

UHG vs Legato, which will be a better company to join for similar package?

like

Will Siemens Technology (STSPL) block list a candidate if the candidate accepts and later rejects the offer. Siemens Technology

like

recommendations for firm with good real WLB and open to remote work in Dallas or Atlanta? Doesn’t have to be true big law. Terrified to get it wrong…again… for the 4th time. 6th year Real Estate.

like

What’s your favorite part of the M&A life cycle to work on and why? What about least favorite?

like

How much of your income do you all target to save, invest, and use for expenses, respectively? I’m currently at 40% investing, 10% saving, 50% expenses but hoping to bring expenses down soon.

like

𝐏𝐞𝐨𝐩𝐥𝐞 𝐀𝐧𝐚𝐥𝐲𝐭𝐢𝐜𝐬 - 𝐒𝐭𝐨𝐫𝐲

𝐖𝐨𝐫𝐤𝐟𝐥𝐨𝐰 𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐜𝐞𝐬𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐜𝐬 (Story) reports y lists the total number of workflow requests per workflow status according to the request types and the event reasons.

#SAP #SuccessFactors #PeopleAnalytics #Story

Sample Below: 👇 Isn't It Beautiful?

Post Photo

Let's start a new weekly thread: Pop in here every Wednesday to share events, shows, and activities that are happening this coming weekend!

like

McKinsey & Company McKinsey & Company I have my first rounds (2 cases) for a position at the risk practice. Will I be interviewed by consultants in the risk practice? I wonder if I can ask some risk practice specific questions at the end of the interviews. (Didn’t get the names of the interviewers yet so I cannot google)

like

Do we have salary advance policies in the big 4s either in Indian or global offices?

like

Which certifications are considered high value right now?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

If you could change one thing about the ad agency culture, what would it be?

like

The socks I like are left and right footed and indicated as such on the bottom. Honestly, some mornings it takes two tries.

like

Remember this: you can only do one thing at a time. Make one decision at a time. Be in one meeting at a time. So for everyone overwhelmed about what they’ve got to do today, go out there and gettem!

likeuplifting

Anyone participate in the 4A's Institute? Philly presentations are coming up this week! Any recommendations?

like

Not sure if if this would be helpful to those furloughed, laid off due to C19, but here is an open source document of agencies currently interviewing. Please edit, add as needed.https://docs.

like

Books on human psychology that have affected you. I'll start: influence, sales Bible, on killing.

like

How long were you a junior?

like

Marcel here. So instead of talking behind my back, how about saying it to my face? Here I am, ready to answer questions, concerns, or just talk sports. So what would you like to know? 🤖

like

The moment you say something is going to be "LIT AF," I no longer want to come.

like

Creatives (or anyone really) who have depression and/or anxiety, how do you keep creating when your mental health issues become really overwhelming? Do you guys have particular strategies?

like

Somebody please in tomorrow’s WPP Global Townhall meeting ask if they’re going to give us a cost to living inflation raise. A bonus. Gas cards. Anything. They are taking questions. I don’t have the balls. I can’t go through another meeting hearing them brag that WPP has earned millions and millions.

like

🤔 Could we still do our jobs if we didn't have email? #MadMenStyle

like

Hipster fishies: what's some aggressive, disturbing noise music I can play loud for my obnoxious reggaeton-blasting neighbors?

like

I've seen quite a few people make jokes about being "aged out" of advertising. Could someone please explain what that looks like and when that typically happens? Forgive the dumb question, I'm a newbie to the industry so I'm a bit confused. Wouldn't agencies want people with more experience?

like

Are there any agencies where creatives actually have good work-life balance in LA, SF or anywhere else for that matter? Like no weekends or no working more than a 40-50hr week? Or do I have to go in house for this? Or do I have to leave advertising altogether?

I feel like I’m either getting burnt out by work or trying to heal myself from it. There’s never much time for real life and I don’t want to be on my death bed reminiscing like, “Wow, I made some cool ads.” Nothing scares me more.

like

Do you feel it’s appropriate for a non-Latinx/Hispanic Producer to ideate or create a Spanish US/Domestic ad for the Latinx audience?
(ie Spanish spot running on Univison for Walmart) **Not referring to LATAM ads**

like

How would you handle a person at your job that makes inappropriate jokes in public? Just curious ...

like

Do LinkedIn skills endorsements mean anything? Has any recruiter said... "Whoa! She's got 47 people that think she's a great writer... we gotta get her in here!" ?

like

What small or mid sized NYC shops are doing good work right now?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal