Oh wise fishes of the corporate seas, Is it a good idea to go back and negotiate the salary?

I have 2 offers in hand. One for 27 fixed from company X and other for 25 fixed from Company Y. I am only interested in joining company Y. Do you think it is wise to renegotiate the salary?

Note that Y was reluctant to increase salary and 25 was given after much convincing (meagre 23% hike over my current fixed).

Can Y rescind their offer because I renegotiated?

PS: I'm a CA with 6 YOE in FP&A.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Related Posts

like

What total comp should I expect at at a Series D Bay Area start up at Director level?

like

What would be a reasonable salary for a 3rd year lawyer in house at a real estate development company with a total of 3 lawyers (they are co-gcs for different parts of the company)? I’d be the 4th lawyer in the department as a whole. HCOL area.

like

Any insight on pros and cons of lateraling as a midlevel litigation associate to Paul, Weiss?

Generally happy with the cases I’m working on at my current firm and I love the other attorneys I work with and partners I work for (for the most part). Compensation would be the same. Mostly considering the move because things are so disorganized at my current firm and I end up pulling a ton of unnecessary all nighters, and I have virtually no administrative support.

like

Hi All, I've been offered 6L fixed with 15% variable for F&A in Accenture, and my last drawn was 4.10LPA. Could someone pls tell me if I should negotiate for more or is this the slab for level 11?

Please help! Accenture

like

Can anyone please tell what will be the in-hand salary after all deduction hcl

Post Photo
like

Does anyone know of a good resource for in-house counsel salary? If it is broken down by practice matter that would be a plus.

like

Hi Fishes, Please help me choose which company to join on the basis of work culture and job security.

TCS -> 20 LPA

Mindtree -> 24.05 LPA

YOE -> 8 years 

Tech Stack -> Frontend (Angular)

CCTC -> 18.10 LPA

like

Hi! Does anyone knows the salary of a Compliance Sanctions Analyst at Citi? Thank you!

like

Can anyone tell me the difference between a senior and lead validation engineer( no direct reports in both cases) in Pharma/ biotech ? I am not sure what’s the hierarchy and which level must get a higher salary. Or is it just referenced interchangeably in different companies ?

Does EY pay $300K to consulting Senior managers in T2 cities?

like

Interviewing for a CCOR VP role in Tampa, FL. Was hoping someone would be familiar with the salary ranges. Thanks!

like

PWC SA2 got an offer for 34LPA fixed.
Currently at DUSI at 24 LPA.
Worth the jump?

like

Hi ,
I have 8+ years of experience and UKG has offered me 18 LPA fixed plus 10% variable. Is this fine for 8+ yoe ?
And they were offering me some amount for buy out but things didn't work on out at my current company ,so now can I ask ukg to give that amount to me as joining bonus ? Please reply.

Hi Folks,

Got this rating with promotion to Senior - 1 at EY GDS India location

How much hike and bonus I can expect?

How QRMTE rating is given?

New to EY GDS request you to help me with your insights☺

Post Photo
like

Microsoft is hiring an account executive and I’m really interested in the role. I have B2B sales experience in a different industry, but my skills include lead generation, prospecting, account management, negotiating, etc (all within the C Suite and other decision makers).

Would appreciate knowing if this is something I have a shot at with no tech sales experience and what I could expect for promotional opportunities and compensation.

Thanks for the help!

What is the Protiviti senior consultant 1 salary? Also thoughts on Protiviti vs West Monroe?

like

Hi Fishes,

My current CTC is 8.71 LPA and overall experience is 4.9 years. I have an offer of 14.5 LPA. I am currently giving interview in HCL. How much should I ask from them? Does HCL have variable component and how much they pay of that?

I am looking for a balanced work life and job security so want to get in there.

like

Hi Everyone,
Im looking for a switch ,
I have 2 years of experience
Having good problem solving skills using java
And my current pacakge is 5.5CTC
So , How much I can expect from switching...
Please Help me

like

More Posts

Hi folks,What is the wfh situation in fidelity?

like
like

Deloitte M2 advisory salary in SF?

like

What salary Kyndryl India provides for band 8 and how many subtype in band 8? Domain is networking and yoe is 8+

like
like

What is the salary range for Senior developer with 5.5 yrs experience?

like

What can I expect in the oracle welcome kit?

like

Are there any grade levels for Senior Consultants designation like 1/2/3 in Deloitte India?

like

For people who post links to news first - how do you do it? I send stuff to people and they're like oh saw that, and it was two hours ago...

likefunny

Has anyone set up an NY 529 for their kids? Know there’s a 10k tax exemption for NY state taxes, but does anyone know if that per child, or across all children?

like

Hi Fishes ,
From tcs I got mail to upload documents 20 days before (10th June)

There was no documents section under my profile in tcs I begin portal. One of HR confirmed that they are creating new EP id for me

Can anyone help me how much time this takes ? Most of the times no HR is replying to my mails and calls not answering

Has anyone joined TCS recently after completing in person onboarding? When did you receive the induction link and employee id? My in person onboarding was completed yesterday but I haven't received any email yet.

likefunny

Have been struggling to context switch between different projects that I am working on simultaneously. Any tips? Thanks in advance :)

like

Bbdo or McCann?

like

Just started medication - adderal helped but if I didn’t take it for a day the withdrawal was UNBEARABLE. On vyvanse now.. tbh feels like my brain fog started when I started meds?

like

What skills to have to make it to PO/PM in Faang?

like

I want to dispose my office chair and i live in Newton. Anyone knows if i can leave it curbside or where i can check for the details?

funny

Any one here from HCL Bangalore working DBS project as a L2 Enginner?

like

Hi All, I have completed my technical interview on 6th Dec,2022 and received mail from HR on 7th Dec to upload documents on ibegin portal my status is changed to evaluated yesterday. I still haven't received any mail from HR regarding the HR interview or any further steps. What does this mean? Can I consider that I have chances or am I rejected?

like

So I internally transferred from audit to FDD last year but my old audit team still reaches out with questions (especially because it’s busy season now). What do you y’all do in these scenarios?

like

Additional Posts in Financial Services - American Express, Mastercard, JP morgan, Citi, Barclays, Goldman sachs, capital one and similar Fintech/Companies

Any opening for a Business Analyst with 5 YOE?

Does citi accept counter offer after releasing the offer letter?

like

Can anyone help me with the average pay range of business consultant at Societe Generale?

like

Anyone aware about relocation assistance at Goldman Sachs or Capital one?


I have got comparable offer at GS Marcus and capital one (Fixed 50 lacs YOE 6). I am more inclined towards GS from growth perspective. Please advise

like

Need referral to Bank of America. Please can someone working at BOA refer my profile, I will share the job ID and resume. Thank you in advance.

Post Photo
like

Hi fishes!

Looking for switch, I have overall experience of more than 4 years in IT, FinTech industry combined.
I am Engineering grad in ECE, Post that I have worked in TCS for around 3 years in SAP ERP as implementation Team member.

Post my PGDM- Financial services from reputed institute and got placed in Arcesium a FinTech company providing hedge fund accounting solutions to Hedge fund managers. I am working as part of Client onboarding Team.

Have exposure to data migration, recons.

Thx

I have offers from Amex and GS with similar Fixed component but the joining date of GS is two months after my last day in the current organization whereas Amex joining date is immediate. Should I wait for GS date or go ahead with Amex?

like

Requesting referral in Wells fargo.i have the job id.Thanks

Hi Team,

Looking for some suggestion on below mentioned query. Please help me with your views.

Barclays VS UBS , which one will be preferred as Sr Big Data Engineer

like

Are Mastercard, AMEX, Visa - Product based companies??
Also, what would be the best choice for data engineers?

like

Hi All!

Can someone please refer me in Mastercard?

like

What is the average salary at Morgan Stanley for Business Unit Controller for P&L controller team supporting TCM?

Welcome and post your queries about offers here for our experts to provide their opinion.

like

Hi All,

Need a referral for an in-house legal role at any of the Financial/Fintech Companies. Kindly connect through DM or comment here if you can help me with your referral for any of these companies.

like

Need help friends Recieved offer from citi 21 lpa ctc Current CTC 14.85 ctc Exp 5

They have already shared the offer without negotiating much also I don't have any counter offer.

Did they low balled me?

like

Which university is good for MBA (Distance) and which specialization is best ? I am a computer science engineer and currently working for BFSI Projects. YOE 2.5 Tata Consultancy Infosys MBA Finance

like

Does KPMG india gives any joining bonus for immediate joiners? If yes, how much? KPMG KPMG India KGS Yoe 4

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal