Should I renege MBB for SWE? Starting very soon in MBB US at undergrad level (cs major and never interned in mbb, only swe). Have an offer to go back to the tech company I interned at. Starting Pay is 100k higher than mbb. My biggest concern is seeing the negativity around mbb on this forum, plus swe is very different from a year ago when I signed the offers and tech/ai seems to be booming more than ever before. Want to make sure I’m not screwing up my life and wasting my cs background. Thanks

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

This depends on which tech company and which SWE role - consider whether your SWE offer (skillset and brand) is likely to increase or decrease in demand over the medium term. MBB is a very safe bet but the upside isn’t nearly as high as many SWE roles. Also consider YOUR effectiveness in the role - are you more likely to succeed as an SWE or consultant?

Judging by your SWE starting salary, it’s probably an in-demand role at a great company, so it’s probably worth reneging. But judging by the fact you accepted an offer at MBB rather than sticking with SWE out the gate, something tells me there’s part of you that believes software engineering isn’t for you.

Spoken from someone who hated being a SWE (even though I was good at it - probably not as good as you though) and now works as a consultant mostly on tech/digital projects.

likesmart

May I ask what type of tech/digital projects you work on?

It depends how fast the SWE company is growing. The reality is that Agentic Coding tools are creating more benefits for more senior engineers. You see the “value” of junior engineers eroding and it’s showing up in hiring of junior developers. There will be pressure at the base of the pyramid for SWE orgs until demand can catch up with productivity gains.

like

And with the way MBB is going, a former SWE from a prominent tech company should be able to find something later at MBB if they so choose. Not true the other way around.

Recent IconRecent

Go to SWE and don’t look back. Just make sure the offer is solid bc renegging will be a one-way decision. If you care enough to switch back, can always go MBA -> one of the other two MBB.

likesmart

Turning down an extra 100k to work 2x as hard would be insane

like

Run to the hills. Avoid MBB like the plague b

like

Do you like being underpaid and overworked? If not, then go SWE

like

Big Tech? Go now.

like

Yes, the big tech companies are better employers and they respect engineering as a profession more too

like

Yes renege

P1, wouldn’t you say there’s a similar dynamic starting for junior undergrad level consultants too? Have definitely heard that being on senior leadership’s minds

Turning down an extra 100k to work 2x as hard would be insane

Without question…

MBB is a much better career choice for 90%+ of candidates.

I would argue that if you’re the top 10% MBB is absolutely not the best path. It’s more geared towards the safe high performers who navigates politics well. Very different than a SWE role building products

like

Obviously a biased sample on this thread since MBB situation is tough right now and it has always been tough, but the truth is somewhere in between "MBB is dying" and "MBB is fine". What you need to understand is that at best, MBB will maintain its current level of relevance. It's not a booming sector that's going to take over the world like AI, software, crypto. Considering you have the hard skills to do that work, it seems like a no brainer to align your career with a booming sector. This is different than if you didn't have the hard skills or background and genuinely need MBB for the exit into tech

This is not a real life situation

I have a pretty good view into Meta comp in particular, and E5 comp nowadays (considered to be the “terminal” level, I.e. where you can spend the rest of your career at unless you push very hard for promo) is just a touch below $500k. The vast majority of Meta engineers will not be promoted to E6.

like

Related Posts

I love Accenture and get top of range raises/bonuses, but I’m getting disheartened that I’ll never earn close to the level of compensation I’d get on the same trajectory at MBB or Big 4. I’ve explored

like

Hey guys, need some advice. I was fortunate enough to get the Consortium fellowship at Ross but am also stuck on the CBS waitlist and am still planning to apply to Wharton in R3. Assuming I get into CBS/Wharton, is there that much of a difference between them to forgo scholarship money? For context, I want to get into product management at FAANG/fintech with pursuing MBB as a plan B. Thanks in advance!

like

Bain & Company What is the likelihood of getting an offer at MBB consulting firms as a GCC National with Western education? Job is in Riyadh. Are the chances higher than elsewhere?Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company McKinsey & Company

like

I was doing some googling and I saw that PWC offers MBA hires 45k in comparison to MBBs at 70k +. Is this a bad joke? I can't imagine that PWC's target for MBA hires is widely different from MBB. In the US, the pay gap isn't that wide. Any reason behind this madness?

like

Which non-MBB firms pay the best for the SC-M levels?

like

Are PE investing role WLB and Stress that much worse than MBB?

like

I'm a recent grad who accepted an entry-level full-time job offer with Capital One. I knew that MBB and other consulting firms rarely ever negotiate salary with new grads, so I didn't with Capital One as well. Was that a mistake? What were the likelihoods that they would have raised my salary? I had no other competing offers at the time

How do I become an MBB employee? Is it possible to gain experience at big 4+ACN and then get referred in??

like

How would you rank in order of prestige/ease of getting in: UCLA, Cornell, and NYU ??

Looking to transition to MBB if that matters.

Hi fish! Recently free MC here. Looking for a referral to a Big 4, or MBB

like

Can anyone please refer me to Roland Berger ? Solved 50+ cases and been on MBB final rounds

Ex-Deloitter here. My goal is to finish working across ALL of the Big 4, and then post-MBA at ALL of the MBB. Will I be considered a flight risk or will I garner the Thanos level respect I deserve?

likefunnyuplifting

Hi guys, I got a feeling that big 4 or T2 companies kinda quiet in jakarta as opposed to MBB where they conduct lots of recruiting events (management consulting). Any reason for that particularly or maybe big 4 prefer internal hiring only?

Do MBB pay a referral bonus if your referral gets hired?

like

What is the payout to front end consultants with 3-4 years in MBB ?

like

(1/2) For those w/ technical backgrounds: how did you develop executive communication skills? I’m a year into MBB (post MBA) and have had really great reviews on client, problem, and team

Do tech companies like FAANG hire strategy consultants? Starting at an MBB/T2 next year and curious if tech companies leverage consultants as much as other industries. Part of me wonders if they are in such high growth right now that consultants can’t add as much value, thus maybe a smaller presence. Thoughts?

like

Hello - moving the NL with my Dutch husband this Summer and am interested in MBB. I don't have a masters (not common in the US), I have my bachelors. Is it possible for me to still get into MBB? Is anyone willing to chat about office culture and willing to give a rec? Thanks!

like

Been working on mostly (about 70%) public sector policy and strategy at Big 4 for most of my career. Often go up against MBB on RFPs and have a decent win rate. Would I be too senior to come in as a lateral hire? I guess it’s all about client networks at this level, and being government, it’s locationally dependent - so which markets have need?

like

I have an interview with each MBB in 3 weeks. Anyone willing to give me a really hard case?

like

More Posts

Hi everyone. Is 15000 AED per month a good salary for a Marketing Manager role in Dubai?
Also Is it standard to have a 1 year bond in UAE?
My current CTC is 18 lpa.

like

Hoping for a bump at next review. Should I mention it now? Will either kick epic ass or fail massively in the next few months.

SO and I got in to a disagreement on the background of Indian tech CEOs. It appears that they are all from 1 or 2 major communities in India.

While he thinks that its genetics/being naturally gifted that got them to where they are I believe it's the environment & discipline that made them successful. We are not from said communities but curious to hear your thoughts on who is more accurate.

like

Hi fishes,

I got a offer of 26lpa(23.5 fixed and 2.5 variable) from genpact and 21 lpa (20 fixed , 1 joining) from epam, not sure which one should I join. Please if someone can advice me which i should join keeping ressession in mind. Thanks in advance@

like

Qualcomm or Cisco ?
YoE : 5+. Tech stack: C,C++, DS & Algo. Both are offering the same CTC.

like

Salary discussion done on 13 Nov, but no further updates on offer letter release from HCL, will they release or not?, hr is not replying my calls or emails. How long will it take to release an offer letter ?

like

Anyone else frustrated with how people conflate introversion with social anxiety? I’m introverted but not socially anxious. And I know plenty of socially anxious extroverts.

like

Check out the Jibrel Network press release today

Arbitrage if I’ve ever seen it

Hello fishes, just wanted to request your help to unlock the DM features

Thanks and have a great day ☺️

like

Hey All, I got an offer from company name MAESRK of 32L, does anyone know about the company and it’s work culture ?

like

Best product legal teams at Google in your opinion (e.g. Ads, Google Play, Chrome, Cloud, etc.)? While I’m assuming it’s all team-dependent, any general, across-the-board ranking based on WLB, culture, morale, most impact, and most coveted?

like

Anyone from Merck how strict are you on YOE requirements?

like

Just hit diamond with Hilton! Garçon, your freshest bottle of grey poupon your most average of rooms if you please, thank you. 💅

like

Finet pros and cons for $600k producer please

like

Engineers who work entirely from home, what kind of work do you do?

like

Helped out an SM on something last week, took all week, sent it off to him and never heard so much as a thank you back 👎🏻👎🏻

like

My RL didn’t have a formal mid year pre CRT review with me. He just pinged me and said: I’ll represent you. Utilization = 75% and average snapshots. Am I at risk?

like

Moving from a boutique (<30 employees, MBB competitor) to the strategy practice of a Big 4. Have only worked for boutiques in the past, so I’m expecting there to be some major differences in terms of working style.

What are the major differences and ‘watch outs’ you would point out to me? Could be anything from culture, to red tape, to compliance etc.

likefunny

Is there a problem to stay contract with your recruiting agency instead of converting to full time with the company? Should you push to get converted sooner rather than later?

like

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

I understand that in most cases folks with <2 YOE will join with the same title as UG campus hires. How many YOE (or months of experience) will qualify you for a higher pay band (compared to campus hires)?

The answers might vary across firms and I’d appreciate if you can specify which one you are referring to - TIA!

like

Anyone with recent experience recruiting for Boston Consulting Group? Got in touch with a recruiter through referral, was directed to submit an application and already finished my pymetrics. Anyone know when I would be able to hear back and what the hiring timeline looks like? Recruiter suggested to get back in a few weeks but isn’t it too slow? McKinsey sent me an invite for 1st interview in a few days after they received my referral.

like

Have McK phone case coming up, has anyone had feedback on why you haven’t passed? Looking to avoid missteps.

like

Re-invited to interview at BCG but also want to cast a wide net and apply for Mck and Bain. However got rejected last year this time at the resume screen stage. I’ve changed firms since I last applied (to a well known boutique) - is this sufficient or am I still frozen?

like

what phone can you get at bcg? how often upgrade. for NAMR

like

How long is the offcycle BCG interview process usually? This is for someone out of school and already working

like

Does anyone have a casebook from 2021-2022 with the latest industry overviews?

like

McK 🐟: Is it helpful if a Senior Partner from another part of the world puts in a referral (looking for role in the US)

Do MBB pay a referral bonus if your referral gets hired?

like

is BCG hiring a experience hire class of associates in march?

like

Can Mck fish please advise on the role of a sponsor? How is different from role of mentor? TIA

like

Been working on mostly (about 70%) public sector policy and strategy at Big 4 for most of my career. Often go up against MBB on RFPs and have a decent win rate. Would I be too senior to come in as a lateral hire? I guess it’s all about client networks at this level, and being government, it’s locationally dependent - so which markets have need?

like

Do McKinsey make your own slides or do you outsource it all to your graphics team? Asking specifically for NA.

like

Read that McK is paying 2K higher than BCG this year which means BCG will probably raise again next year to at least match. However, they can’t just copy McK with 2K to match because that would look bad so they’ll have to beat it again. Then McK and Bain will follow. Barring a devastating recession, I’m guessing this means MBB is all getting raises again next year?

likefunny

Does delaying my interview hurt my chances of getting an offer? Looking at how aggressively McKinsey is hiring, I’m afraid delaying interviews may put me at a disadvantage. On the flip side, I’m working pretty long hours at my current job so I don’t have a lot of prep time. Please advise!

like

Is firm travel back up to pre covid levels?

like

At McK does integrative = generalist? Or are practice aligned consultants also integrative

like

Mckinsey fish, how is implementation practice? How does it compare to general consulting? How is the growth trajectory? Got an opportunity to join as implementation consultant but I am worried it will be a step down (will be taking a paycut as well).

like

Exiting to a boutique for a promo/more comp/WLB? Good idea?

Projects will be focused, long term comp is still great but obv much lower than MBB.

Any thoughts?

like

Does MBB accept applications where you don’t have an undergrad?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal