AI is replacing more writing jobs than AD and design jobs, right? Seeing so few available writer positions.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I spend an inordinate about of time correcting, or having other people correct, AI writing slop. I can’t speak for everyone, or every industry, but it sometimes causes more work than you’d imagine. I don’t see it replacing all jobs, I see it causing more work loads for people in existing ones.

likeupliftingsmart

That’s good to hear. I’m hoping they eventually realize AI is better suited for things that require less human ingenuity and creativity.

Just not sure how much longer they’re going to keep trying.

Buckle up, portrait photographers: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQw7xgniY4p/

like

Yikes! Are we now doomed to feeling inferior to AI's 'perfect people' images? Human flaws be damned. The future is not imperfection-friendly. How the heck did we get here? And how do we fit into a fantasized world of perfect people that don't exist? I'm shook, to put it mildly. Ugh... 😳

I guess it’s affecting both sides?

like

As a seasoned copywriter, I'm bailing out and retraining in a new field. The end is nigh, unfortunately. Musicians, designers, photographers, and artists' work can all be created in AI within seconds for mere pennies now. It's time to find financial stability elsewhere IMO.

like

I saw the Gayle King interview with her. Those have to be faked streams. What real person is listening to that garbage?

I don’t really see AI “replacing” writing jobs, but the writing profession is drying up in the US for two main reasons:

1 - Hybridization. In the old days, copywriting and content writing used to be their own separate profession. But with the “less is more” philosophy of the modern American business landscape, that’s being phased out.

It’s not enough to be just a copywriter anymore. Now you also have to be an email automation expert, graphic designer, web developer, SEO specialist, UX designer, PR specialist, and project manager all rolled into one.

That’s why you see these marketing job descriptions that go on forever, with qualifications that are 2-3 pages long and require mastery of 50 different systems and 20 different writing styles. And now, being bilingual is also becoming increasingly mandatory.

2 - Creative marketing jobs are being increasingly sent overseas, particularly to countries like India, Nigeria, Vietnam, Pakistan, and The Philippines.

Why would a company pay an American worker $100K+ a year when an Indian, Nigerian, Vietnamese, Pakistani, or Filipino employee will do the same amount of work for $2 a day?

Look up any creative networking group in LinkedIn. 99% of their members are Indian, Nigerian, or Pakistani, with some Vietnamese and Filipinos sprinkled in for good measure.

And if you dare join any of those groups as an American, be prepared to get absolutely bombarded with connection requests from them. Why? Because they’re all looking for US citizenship, and they want you to recommend them for a job with an American company so they’ll get sponsored.

And the “copy tips” they post are absolutely nauseating. Full of broken English, misspellings, out of context quotes, grammatical mistakes that a first grader would make, etc.

One Indian guy posted, and I quote: “main key to great copy chance is feeling hot nodules and not make sale-ing (yes, he actually wrote “sale-ing”). It is about making hot connections that make persons want to do it.”

Another Pakistani dude wrote, and I’m not joking here: “NEVER announce products on sale or tell people how they can save money because it attracts cheap customers and a “loser” clientele base.” Yes. He actually wrote that, and then got mad and called me an “American pig humper” when I told him that was not a smart marketing strategy.

But you can’t call them out on it. I made that mistake once and got booted from the group because I was “being culturally insensitive” and “unprofessional” for “publicly embarrassing someone who is doing their best and just trying to help others.”

And companies wonder why they can’t attract and retain quality employees. This is what we’re up against. And companies don’t care if their work is grossly inferior. They’ll just run it through Grammarly or ChatGPT to fix the blatant mistakes, then send it off to the public.

like

I couldn’t believe it when I saw that. I was like “is this guys serious?”

AI is replacing literally zero jobs. As we’ve seen recently, it’s merely an excuse for unrelated downsizing.

like

I don’t know if it’s replacing jobs or not. We’ll see where we net out in a few years. But it’s definitely being used as an excuse for downsizing, merging, and cashing out for shareholders.

I don't think writers will be replaced. But we will be expected to work faster and increase our output using AI. That level of churn will be its own kind of hell but I guess it's better than being replaced altogether.

Related Posts

Welcome ESG enthusiasts/experts! Let’s support each other to change the world.

likeuplifting

I am looking for a referral in marketing /operations role in flipkart at Bangalore location.

Anyone please out here who can hive referral

As homicide detectives, what has been the worst experience you have had?

like

Thinking about trying to change into a career in new biz dev. What is the earnings potential of top new biz dev people in the US? For example “Head Of” or CMO level at well known agencies?

like

UM Nurses - what do you like and dislike about your role

My wife has her joining date extended from Randstad and no joining date has been provided. What are the chances of her offer getting revoked. She has around 1 year of experience in HR. She got to know about this just on the last day of her notice period. She doesnt have any other offer as she didnt expect the joining date to get extended. Randstad. If anyone is open for hiring, please let me know. I can share it with her. Morningstar Tata Consultancy Accenture JPMorgan Chase Wells Fargo Infosys

like

For Plaintiff's attorneys, how big is your caseload? What kind of cases are the majority of them and are they in suit? I am currently handling 150+ mostly MVAs and premise liability cases, just about all in suit, (on top of about 10 DUIs and other small traffic matters) and I feel like I'm drowning and looking to jump ship. What is normal/to be expected? In NYC area if that matters

like

Is this bowl still active?

funny

Hi background in audit and soc compliance now working for a non-public firm but delivering support to the auditors. Being that I am new I am still learning all the processes however cannot find a single process narrative. In order to better my experience performance I have attempted to find some type of structure.
Nothing is compliant…..

Would you send over a file for review with your name on it when told for job security or respect yourself and understand why first

like

What's going on this weekend? Any fun holiday shops or pop-up bars I could check out?

like

Hi. I got selected as a consultant in Global business services role (SA&MA) in DI. Can someone throw some light on this practice as what it does? Will the clients be India based or overseas?

like

Hey Fishes Looking out for a job change and came across vacancies at Deloitte India as per my profile and experience. Can someone kindly help me with the referral. That'll be great help. Have been trying from a long time to switch but nothing fruitful yet. Your referral might make the job hunt a bit easier so kindly help. Yoe: 3.3 Profile: SAP SD associate consultant Immediate joiner
Deloitte India
Thanks in advance for your help.

like

Currently I am in Deloitte India with(6.5yrs exp) 13Lac WFH Pune hometown
I am interviewing with SAP LABS India how much should I expect for banglore location (hybrid) will need to relocate
Would it be a good decision to relocate as I am staying with my family in pune?

like

Deloitte India vs Deloitte USI.
Please answer if you have worked for both and have significant first hand experience about the difference in WLB, annual hikes, work culture, any other observations.
I see a lot in of this same discussion but very confusing and repetitive answers.
So would like people with personal experience to answer.
Thanks in advance 😃

Thoughts on $50k for a visual designer in NYC?

like

NYT must do better

Post Photo
like

What is the average salary for business analysts with non-IT background having 2+ yoe in large banks?

like

Renting out a covered parking spot in Southie, W Broadway, close to Lincoln. DM if interested

Hi Sharks,

I need an urgent reply.

I have Joining with CTS today at 10:30 AM and some documents required for Virtual Onboarding.

They need EA form and they said it is part of offer letter.

So I need to print entire offer letter and sign and send back to them please reply?

like

Mom went back to home country and I’ve been moping around holding back tears all day! Tell me it’s gonna be ok, I miss my mom 😭😭

likeuplifting

Additional Posts in Creatives

I put in my two weeks! But now it's weird here haha. Agencies should ask you to leave and pay you out. This is silly.

like

Would a CD here look at some line edits I made for a campaign? Would be great if I could email you them?

like

Are there any CDs working on Post Mates, Grub hub or Door dash. I just wrote out a whole campaign for fun. Print, commercials, activations, etc. Would love to pitch it.

like

Anyone have the story behind how the atrocity that is “taste the feeling” got made?

What’s a gal got to do to get an interview with Droga5? Any CDs in here willing to check out my book?

like

Are Creative Directors rich?

likefunny

Has any creative here ever tried to make the leap to leave advertising and be a film maker, photographer, illustrator, etc.?? I’m so tired of ad agencies and how draining the “creative” can be. Happiness is more important than a nice paycheck for me. Any inspiration success stories advice would be so helpful right now...

likefunny

FCB Health Chicago - What’s it like?

like

I came across a copywriter position that I’m interested in, but one of the requirements is 8 years of experience. I’m currently just over 5 years. Would it be ok to still apply?

like

Did you feel “ready” the first time you managed a team? Or insecure?

like

You’ve had a 360-campaign brief for about a week that’s essentially a brand refresh. The expectation in the first-round creative review is scripts and adlobs for each concept. How many concepts to you come back with?

like

Are memes ideas?

What do CDs think when a junior team answers a (non-social) brief with a bunch of memes?

Not original ones based off brand insights, but rather recent memes that have been tweaked to include the brand.

My partner does/suggests this a lot and I never know if I’m being boring / a boomer for thinking that’s not really what advertising is…

likefunny

Did you ever lose all hope in finding happiness in this career but then did something pivotal that helped you achieve it?

What did you do?

I’m spent.

like

Does anyone have any experience with the agency Brand Buddy?
(Working under contract for)

like

Some days the ghosting and radio silence comes off as blacklisting and soul crushing. How hard of an ask is it to copy and paste "thank you for your interest, we decided to go with another candidate"

like

Can someone describe the difference between Apple in Culver vs Apple in Cupertino?
(Types of work, culture, pay, teams, etc.)

like

Which is the right move for a young creative: free ride to portfolio school, or take a full time junior position where you’ve been interning?

Kind of wanna move to Europe, where do I find an awesome job europeople? CD.

like

A branding question. If FIFA stopped calling it the Women’s World Cup, would more of the world start treating it with as much reverence as the men’s World Cup, which is just called The FIFA World Cup?

likefunny

Hi Creatives! What tool does your Resources Management team use? Also, what software are you using for creative workflow? Also include if you like it or if you have any favorites. Thanks in advance.

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal