Am I overreacting?
My fiancé sisters are a part of my bridal party. I asked them to be in the wedding because I knew it would mean a lot to my SO and I’m really big on family so wanted them to feel included. When asking them, I gave them the same speech I gave my other bridesmaids re: would love to have you be a part of our special day, but please don’t feel obligated to say yes. Also went over my expectations for my bridesmaids so everyone has an idea of what they’re getting into (cont)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’d be annoyed too. But I’d let it go for the sake of keeping peace, and also keep it in my back pocket as a “thank you.” Next time you don’t feel like going to something of theirs… don’t (trust me, it will happen). Thank them for excusing you from one of their obligations. Some might say this is petty, but it’s the only way I avoid getting too upset. It also might be worth it to have a convo with them and just let them know you heard they weren’t planning to come to the shower and ask if there are any other events they may not be able to make it to.

like

You invited them to be your bridesmaids because you are big on family and want them to feel included? Or you want free labor and supports at all wedding related events? If it’s the former, you haven’t put any efforts into making them feel included yet, I probably would’ve planned a meet and greet brunch in town for those in town, and then maybe a zoom call to include those out of town, so everyone can get to know each other. Having an out of town bridal shower as the first event just isn’t a good move given the scenario.

like

Yes

like

The oldest, said yes, of course I’d love to be a part of the wedding. I’ll totally be at all the events, etc. Long story short, I was talking to my fiancé last night and he mentioned that his sisters won’t be attending my bridal shower because it’s out of town and they don’t know anyone, and it’s “expensive.” They’re willing to help pay for the shower but don’t feel comfortable attending.

I tried to tell him I wasn’t okay with that because it’s really important to me that my bridesmaids are present to support me at wedding related events, but he doubled down and defended them, stating that the grooms family doesn’t usually attend those type of events.

I’m less upset about them not be able to attend and more upset about the fact that they didn’t tell me themselves. I have 11months until the big day and haven’t done any bridesmaids stuff aside from asking folks, so strongly considering not having them be a part of the bridal party because I don’t want their lack of communication with me to be an issue for future events.

That being said, I recognize that I may have a bit of tunnel vision because I’m the bride and I’m only seeing things from my perspective, but genuinely want to know if it’s the norm for the groom family to not be active in wedding planning/siblings being super involved. Also don’t want to cause a rift in the family by demoting them as bridesmaids…

What is considered out of town? If like drivable they should prob be there but if it’s a flight + overnight stay then they are justified to say no

If they need to book a flight and hotel then I would say you are over reacting. Even if it’s in town and not a far drive, they may have plans. I had to plan my shower 3 months in advance to get folks to come. Better to be more understanding to your future SIL.

I get it, but you’re overreacting. These girls are going to be in your life forever… I’d encourage you to really think about if it’s worth it to cause a stir over a shower, particularly if they’re even agreeing to help pay for it!?
For what it’s worth, my new SIL didn’t attend my bridal shower either bc it was out of town. Did it hurt a little? Absolutely. Did I make a fuss about it? No.

I would feel annoyed especially since they didn't tell you. They definitely should have told you. The excuse of not knowing anyone is bs. However, if they can't go for financial reasons as it's out of town for them I understand. But what does out of town mean? Do they need a hotel or is this a 1-2 hour drive for them? Either way, they could have handled it better

Please recognize everything regarding the wedding will be amplified. I really wanted my future brother in law to join me on my bachelor party but it just didn’t work out that way and at the time I was devastated. Fast forward and we have had the wedding and it all worked out even with him not being at that small part of it.

Again don’t forget these are all extra things. At the end of the day all that matters is marrying your spouse.

You have the right to be annoyed they didn’t tell you themselves but you’re overreacting about them not being there.

Bridesmaids are meant to be people we care about being an extra important part of the wedding, not people who you put to work or need to drop everything for anything wedding related.

Nobody should be expected to be involved in wedding planning to any degree other than you and your future husband, bridesmaids or not. It also sounds like you’re not close with them and only included them for your husbands sake so it really shouldn’t effect your day

Related Posts

Good places to scuba with lower currency value (cheaper hotels, food, etc.)?

Is salary credited for KGS today or will it be tomorw

like

Have you seen an upswing in same sex dissolution matters in your area? If so are you in metropolitan or suburban location?

like

Who hires junior strategists? Where should I start looking? I’m loving my planning internship right now, but I want to apply elsewhere in case I don’t get an offer, but I’m not seeing anything open.

like

Hi guys,
How do you keep yourself going if you are not learning new .

like

Hi People,
I'm looking for opportunities in Investment Banking Analyst roles in Mumbai.
I have 5 year's work experience and a finance major.
Please ping me if there's an opening in your organization and I would like to know more.

like

Is it a good idea to trade indexes like VTI and SPY short term? My logic is in the long term indexes will go up so even if I buy high, I can just hold for the long term.

like

Lady 🐠- any recommendations for a good OBGYN?

I know I am opening up the doors for a troll feast, but finding a good doctor can be difficult- WOM is the best option and I can trust people here more than the average yelper.

How did you make friends when you moved here?

Hi DC fish, what are your favorite local charities and nonprofit organizations? Alternative question, how have your firms been engaging with them in the past year (i.e. remotely)? Looking for ideas for my firm to have a more tangible impact in the upcoming year. Thanks so much!

like

Jummah Mubarak Fam 💚

like

Any recommendations on seaside towns that would be fun for a 5-6 day stay within an 8 hour drive of Boston? Going next week, so not a place that's a ghost town in October.

like
like

Does anyone here in a health system have insurance that covers fertility assistance or get paid parental leave? Really like my position at my hospital but as we start to plan a family - I'm nervous about the cost. Just looking around regionally - it looks like most health systems don't cover this.

like

Hi fishes, I am a dentist and did Masters in hospital administration from IIHMR B. Currently I am working as Cerner EHR support analyst since Aug2021. Can someone refer me to ZS, healthcare solutions. Thanks in advance

like

Hi all how can I get a call from Google, jus applying in career page is enough or
I need to get referral.

Hi guys, I am planning to switch within Kolkata. I work as a Process Associate at PTP Accounts Payable domain. I have complete process end to end knowledge with a year experience. I worked on SAP ERP, Salesforce AP Cora and Savvion. I am from finance background. I have done my Bachelor's on Commerce with Honours from CU. My Notice Period is of 30 days.

Can you guys help me out here please?

I am eyeing for PwC EY Deloitte KPMG Accenture Cognizant Capgemini Tata Consultancy Infosys and others.

I am pursuing MBA +ACCA, currently a graduate with 6LPA .
What should I do to reach double digits in annual package soon?

like

My probation has been increased by 3 months. Honestly, idk the reason because I have worked so well in these months. Like seriously 🙄 Are there chances of firing after those 3 months?

like

Colleague has put in his resignation. They are offering him whatever he wants to stay including 4days a week work from home. He’s not bluffing and plans to leave. However, at this same time I was asked to begin working as a supervisor for the engineering team and I would get a promotion at the beginning of the year. I have been supervising and managing our team of 6 for months with no extra pay or bonuses. I was told yesterday that raises will be light this year. Yet today they spare nothing.

likesmart

Additional Posts in The Wedding Bowl

Anyone else’s mom driving them crazy about mother of the bride dresses? Wedding is a little over a year out 😂 Any store recommendations for MOB dresses?

like

For those who have already had their weddings, what advice do you have? Anything you could change?

like

So, we have a wedding registry and my fiance and I would really like people to stick to gifting us what's on that registry. Yet, people keep asking what they should get us. The thought of dealing with a ton of crap we don't want or need is stressing me out. How can I politely tell people to only buy what's on the registry?

like

For those who had Catholic ceremonies.. What kind of shoes did you wear that had bottom soles that looked nice in pics? In other words, shoes with bottoms that don’t look scratched up when you are kneeling at the altar.

like

Anyone unsure of what to do for bridesmaids “proposals?” I want them to get excited and feel special but when I see how much money I’d be spending on things like custom totes or mugs I’m like is it really worth it? I’d send cards but most of my bridal party I see pretty regularly/they live nearby so it seems odd to send them something when I live down the street. Help! 😅

like

Putting together a wedding weekend itinerary and have been dealing with a frustrating level of questions from some random in-laws who are known for stirring the pot. Would it be rude to say “please contact x with any questions. Kindly do not direct questions to the bride unless there is an emergency”? What is a better way to say this?

like

How much are y’all spending on your videographer and what all are they providing?

like

If I got married on a Sunday, could I use the flowers from the wedding the night before? (Anything they were going to leave behind like hanging installations) Seems like a waste for that decor to be trashed and an opportunity to pay it forward. Has anyone done this?

like

Thoughts on kindly asking your bridesmaids to please not give a gift? I am over the moon excited that my bridesmaids will be celebrating me and traveling for the wedding and bachelorette. I really do not want a gift from them at the wedding. Full disclosure, my fiancé and I have great paying jobs and my bridesmaids are grad students, artists, and teachers. How would you frame this? Even if they were millionaires I would not want a gift, but I don’t want it taken the wrong way.

like

Is a hair and makeup trial really necessary? It seems like such a waste of money.

like

My partner and I are planning to elope. We want the wedding and the trip that will go with it to be for us. That being said, we want to throw a party of some kind to celebrate with our friends. We're pretty lost as far as the general etiquette around this goes. Do you have to tell venues it's for a "wedding" reception? Is it expected that we will still make a gift registry?

like

How much did you spend on your wedding? Do you regret it? Also please share the location of your wedding if possible. Thank you!

like

Thoughts on uneven bridal parties? I would have 5 vs my fiancé having 3 people.

like

Tux budget NYC?

like

Has anyone hosted their own engagement party? All of my friends and family live far away from us so it is just easier for me to plan it but I feel odd doing so. Any tips?

likefunny

So my fiancé and I are having a microwedding in Rocky Mountain National Park next year, and we’re working with an elopement planner.
She sent over a sample ceremony (intro, sweet poems + passages to be read, and example vows), and we read through it last night. I was reading it out loud while my fiancé made dinner, and it just hit me that this is really happening. I’m just really happy that I found someone who is willing to take a vow to spend his life with me and I’m so excited for that day :)

like

Looking for craft ideas for the first evening of a Bachelorette weekend getaway. All ideas welcome!

like

What is your total “wedding look” budget/est. spend? (Everything including dress, make up, jewelry, shoes, outfit changes, accessories, etc.). I have put so much emphasis on my looks (no regrets) and I actually just tallied up my spend and my head almost exploded. Frankly just seeking a little validation that I am not the only crazy person out there 🙃

like

How much are you all spending on decor/flowers? I am in north jersey and want to spend no more than 4000, and wondering if that’s enough? Medium/tall centerpieces are 150+ and I’m trying to do some faux floral backdrops/arches myself

Post Photo
like

What do you think about lab-grown diamonds? My fiance and I are trying to be as ethical as possible, and lab-grown sounds like an awesome idea, but we're wondering about the quality and longevity. Any thoughts would be appreciated!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal