Got the following offers on the table:

1. Big 4 - Manager, $180k + $20k sign on, told a good expectation is 12-15% bonus next year. 1.5% 401k match and 3% pension contribution. First year cash would be around $225k
2. New, well funded advisory arm of an established business - Engagement manager, $210k, 20-25% bonus. 2.5% 401k match. First year cash closer to $250k

Big 4 is a defined path with history, reputation, and exits. Other place is largely unknown but a lot of comp.

What do you think?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

#2, you can pivot back to big 4 if things don't work out. Low risk, high reward for being on the ground floor for #2

like

Yes, it's realistic - just add your interviewers on LinkedIn and reach back out if option 2 doesn't pan out

Agree with #2

like

Do you want to be with big 4 10 years from now?
If you seek to be a partner then go that route. If partner and its requirements/lifestyle are distasteful to the other.

Don't look as much at year 1 but rather happiness at year 10, assuming you settle in at this place

like

I figure that if I go big 4, 10 years from now I'll either be partner or in industry. At #2 I have little idea what 10 years from now could look like. Maybe partner? Director? Homeless? No clue haha

Big 4 will always be there. Go option 2 without question. If it fails then go big 4

like

if Deloitte, and you’re okay with the travel/not seeing kids once travel ramps back up then I would do that. Longer view of money w strong name recognition. The other big four for consulting have lesser brand value for exit props in my experience.

like

Good point - the big 4 is Deloitte, yes. From all conversations, my D team will be traveling about once every 3 weeks (weekly on short turn projects, much less on longer projects like implementations). Other option looks somewhat uncertain re: travel, but the last conversation I had made it sound like there would be a heavy travel expectation (weekly or close to it).

#1 is Deloitte. Pass.

like

Can I ask why?

How many yoe

10 YOE, all in consulting but none at a name brand. No experience with good structures

uplifting

What sre your career goals? If you want to leave for industry in a few years, then big 4 may have better name/role recognition. If you want to make partner or equivalent, investigate and what that would look like at #2

Say more about #2. Sounds like the expectation is to build an advisory practice. Is that really what you want to do? That would entail a lot of struggles that might not exist at a big 4. E.g, at big 4, you would do some bd, and maybe interview and train train new hires. But at a #2, there may be a bigger focus on sales due to a growth focus, you will need to win business without a big brand name or case studies, not only will you need to hire/train people, but you need to come up with the interview cases and training materials too. At big 4, promotion timelines and criteria are established and well-understood, but at #2, these may be unclear due to lack of track record.

Appreciate the thoughtful reply. I'm open to staying in consulting or going to industry. I want options more than anything. Not hell bent on making millions; more interested in making a good living and doing good work.

Option 2 is with a primary market research firm (I believe that business is north of a billion a year) that is starting a healthcare advisory practice. You're right on all accounts about the expectations and likely challenges I'll face. My background is consulting, 3 years of which has been in pharma commercial ops. No strategy experience, which makes me a bit nervous about likelihood of success at 2, but they seem very confident in my ability to pick things up quickly

Is big4 deloitte? But second option seems better.

Deloitte brings stability. In uncertain career times, I might place more value on such a big firm that brings in such high revenue. If the second option is heavy travel, might as well do Deloitte anyway.

Does Deloitte have a pension contribution? I know pwc does but I think it’s higher at mgr.

Related Posts

Currently working as SDET-2 at Akamai
TC - 24LPA, 5 YOE
Got below offer from epiFi for SDET position
Base - 23LPA
15% variable - 3.5LPA
ESOP - Approx 58,000 PA
I know it's too much a lowball for Sr SDET position when entry level roles are getting this much.
Have told them to update the offer per senior band, yet to hear back. I'd mentioned 35LPA as expected base over phone. But got response that they can't increase numbers.

Anyone who can throw some light on pay at epiFi?. @epifi #sdet

like

What is the salary range of Manager in SAT division?

like
like

Does anybody know what the typical salary range is and total comp for someone starting out as an internal or external wholesaler? If you are one of these, can you share about your experience in terms of whether you liked it or not, work life balance, travel, etc?

like

I was approached on LinkedIn for an early career recruiting role in DFW, TX. I don't have direct experience, but I have the university experience/connections from working in career services. This is the first time I've considered work outside of higher education. I said my salary expectations are minimum $90k and that didn't seem to be an issue. Am I asking too little, too much? How can I know I'm getting the best salary and not just settling at the low end of the range?

like

Expected SalesForce packages for a manager level? Base, sign-on, yearly , list YOE too please.

like

How much willl be my in hand Infosys Tata Consultancy Accenture Wipro @Deloitte

Post Photo
like

My TC is 150K, I’m already maxing out my 401K, and am thinking of putting some money into I-bonds. Should I try to get the backdoor roth IRA? Anything else I can / should invest in? Currently have a lot of cash lying around.

like

Hi does anyone know the pay range for an entry level hardware engineer with an MS?

like

Any Capgemini employees here? I have a second round of interview scheduled this week for 'Lead Data Engineer' I would like to know what's the average pay for Lead Data Engineer in Capgemini my current CTC is 20.5L with all variables..Fixed is 16.2L though so how much can I ask during the interview if they ask what's my expectations...I don't want to low ball or over shoot

Does anyone know how much a senior copywriter in Toronto makes?

Agency fish who have their yearly reviews soon, whatcha thinking? I chatted with a few coworkers who have theirs coming up... a lot of them seem concerned about how much leverage they will have with rising inflation, economic downturn, and rising layoffs.

For those in the same boat, what are you hoping for? If you get a merit or promotional offer - did you plan on negotiating? Or are you going to take what you get and try to stay under the radar just in case layoffs are coming your way?

like

I have offer from HCL for 12LPA and cleared Infosys interview how much should I ask in Infosys?

And If I get that in Infosys can i again negotiate with HCL?

Yoe:3+
CCTC: 7.5 LPA

like

What’s the salary for a junior at Grey healthcare?

like

I so badly wanted to get offer letter and resign from my company.

Now I have OL and serving notice, still I’m not happy and want to go for higher package and better offer.

Seems like, This is a never ending rat race, what do you guys do to relax? To have some quality time? I am somehow not able to enjoy my life and this hits me hard quite often.

Also it’s easy to see people earning double with same YOE. Do you guys feel the same?

like

Hi Fishies, I have an interview scheduled for Wipro, data engineer, band B3. My YOE is 9.5 and I have an offer in hand of 18L fixed. Is the band appropriate for my YOE ? How much salary can I ask from Wipro based on this ? The HR said they have a budget of 20L for my YOE and tech stack.

Tech stack: AWS, Python, PySpark, SQL, DW and BI

Does anyone know how to explain a 1 year 4 month employment gap on a resume? Took time off for health/family reasons and I keep getting auto rejected by the ATS. Sent out 100 applications, only 1 interview. Applying for financial analyst roles, 2 years corp tax Big 4, 3 years audit senior at smaller niche mid sized firm w/ an international office 1.5 years Internal Audit $22B healthcare Company in that order.

like

How much are you making at Tavisca?
CTC , YOE and designation.

This will help us create a chart that can help other people to negotiate salaries when joining or already working in appraisals.

YOE 8+
CTC 26
Tech Lead

like

What's the salary band for senior associate at ey gds with 4 yr exp?

like

Hey all,

New to this app , please engage if possible.

Wold like to know what is average salary (market trend) in-hand for business development executive(IT OR DIGITAL MARKETING) with 3 yoe.

like

More Posts

Hi Fishes, I have an offer from PWC as Data Engineer Senior Associate. Want to know about work life balance as in will i be working late night? Extended hours?
Working on weekends etc? What should be my salary range?

like

Kotak Life Can anyone help me, to know.... Does KLI has any salary band at L 8, level I. e. Vice President level

like

Hi! I need some help negotiating a raise. I have been working for this company for exactly 3 months now, but I was hired as an AGM. I'm not specific on what my responsibilities are as AGM.
However the GM at the time, quit 1 and a half months in. I was thrown into the role and have been handling it since.
My regional calls himself our GM but is never on site.
Was reluctant to cover my shifts when I became sick and requested time off for a few days. (4 days)
Any thoughts?

like

Hi guys im a .net developer with 4 years of experience. I have worked in support project throughout my tenure and want to switch to development. I planning to switch so what are the skills that I should plan to learn and how should I go about it? Any suggestions are welcome and also if someone had any similar experience , it will be great if you could share it!

Thanks in advance

Any infrastructure Automation Engineers from Snowflake Inc. . here? Have a scheduled interview and would like to know your experience.

like

What’s the base salary for a Relationship Manager II in Business Banking?

Seeking general salary range for Commercial Lines agency Director of Marketing 20+YOE - for context HCOL

like

Officially “Royal Broke”

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi! How do one get from admin assistant role into an executive assistant role? Thank you for all your responses!

likeuplifting

Hi fishes,

Can anyone let me know..which certification is good in the resume for the business analyst.
Also any idea about the certification cost...
Also can anyone let me know..which tools and what is mandatory skill for BA

Thanks for the suggestion

like

SO made a pretty huge promise to me a year ago and just found out he’s been going back on it behind my back for the last 6 months. It’s a relatively specific thing I don’t really want to give details on but big picture, he broke my trust and he knows it and while he’s been very apologetic, i’m really feeling quite hurt. we’ve been together for 2 years - do I end things?

like

Happy Monday…grateful for another beautiful morning expressing gratitude for all the wonderful a d amazing things we got in our lives.

likeupliftingfunny

It’s me again complaining about trying to buy a house on my peanut salary. So my parents don’t want me to contribute to my 401k while I’m saving up for the down payment. Bad or good move?

like

How do I open a wine bottle?

funnylike

I lie about how many plastic bags I’m using at the self checkout.

funnylike

Any other ladies have an end goal of becoming an entrepreneur? I'm looking for some inspiration whether it be in the form of books, events, whatever!

like

Truly wish Delta cut its pre flight announcements by 80%.

like

Anyone know of any networking events coming up soon? Agency after hours or something of the like?

like

Has anyone tried hair vitamins? Especially curious about the brand Viviscal if anyone has experience... do they really work or are they a scam?

Hi Fishes,

I have 3 YOE, got offered 10.5 LPA in pwc. I had asked for a higher package as I have a counter offer of 12 LPA, the HR came up with some logic of variables, performance pay etc and gave me the offer. I have been offered a role in Data Analytics dept ( SAP tech stack).

I have another offer from msg of 13 LPA, could you help me what should I choose. I have pwc in my mind just because it's a big 4 and I'm looking for such exposure.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

Does anyone have good a good source for resume templates? I haven’t updated mine in years.

like

If you had to buy a small business what sector/industry would you buy in?

like

Anyone know of any firms in NYC currently hiring for financial services consulting (risk/capital markets/aml etc)? I have 3 years of exp out of undergrad. Mainly looking for firms with local projects.

like

Is A&M Forensics hiring? If so what’s the pay range for a manager in the south East?

like

What FAANG companies have take-home assignments pre-MBA for corpdev/analytics/bizops positions? I know Apple does, not sure about the others…

like

I’m so burnt out that I can’t seem to get myself to complete a deliverable, and would rather quit than finish it.

like

Hi everyone, hoping to get some feedback on an offer:

Current - EY staff 2 in tech, 75K in HCOL (not NY/SF). EY just promised PBB for staff, bigger raises, but that won't be until October.

Offer - Sr. role, 100K all in, would have to move to a MCOL, room for growth.

Wouldn't say this is my dream job, but aligns with what I'm good at, and I have been charging 50-60 every week at EY, so not eager to stay. Worth it to leave now or should I wait until after promo?

like

Startup people - can the strike price of your options change? Let’s say I sign today, but then have to start a few months later because of a personal emergency- can the strike price change and dilute your value? How often does this happen / what magnitude? Thank you!

like

Opportunities in Life-Sciences/Healthcare PE or VC ?

like

@EY tech Fish willing to provide referral in Supply chain/ EAM space?

like

Lateraled to M from a T2 3 months ago, and realize that I don’t actually enjoy consulting anymore (hours + work + hate going into my local office 4 days a week and traveling the other weeks) - is it too soon to look for other opportunities and will companies even consider me since I’ve been here for only a few months?

like