I have about 5 years of PM experience and am looking for a senior PM role in a company that makes ML based products and it's been hard. I've gotten feedback that I seem "really smart" but I'm not a good fit for X role. It feels like a hiring manager saying you seem "really smart" is code for something.

I'm also in the position where I've had real successes but my current role is stagnating to the point where I don't know if I can claim any real big achievement in the last quarter to 6 months.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

The "you seem smart" sounds like general acknowledgment that you look good on paper, have the right skills, have good experience, and you're intelligent enough to do the job. Sounds like the issue is they don't like you personally.

Do they think you're boring? A jerk? Overbearing? Awkward? Too extraverted? Something else? Even if you don't think you have some negative characteristic, do you come off that way? You might need some tough feedback from people who you trust to tell you this stuff. Companies are not likely to tell you that, especially if you are a member of a protected class, as that kind of feedback could be viewed as a risk.

like

That's really useful insight. I might run through some practice interviews with some people I know in the industry and get their feedback on how I come off as. I've never had to do video interviews before and that might be one of the things tripping me up.

Definitely sounds like the move to be looking to jump ship. My question, different from the others, is how much ML specific experience do you have?

I had a job interview recently for a Product role where I got similar feedback and they straight up told me that I seem like a smart person and if they hired me I’d probably learn and do ok, but I didn’t have enough experience in the industry and they wanted someone who already knew it.

This interview was through networking not through a resume drop, so in your case I’m not sure why they’d call you in at all if they were going to give you that answer. Maybe they wanted to dig more into seemingly related experiences and then didn’t really find anything?

likesmart

We have a lot of interviews like this at my company. Person is accomplished and obviously gets up to speed fast… but we just can’t afford any time lost to training. OP, what is your evidence that you understand ML, proper data science, and the industries you’re working in? Have you taken classes, done Kaggle, played with B2C offerings?

At what point are you getting this feedback? Curious if your salary may be out of range and that’s an easy way of saying “we can’t afford you”.

smart

It's after I've passed the recruiter screen plus the first or second interview.

So many diverse opinions and rightfully so. So I agree that you seem really smart is code for something, and I'm assuming that's coming after an interview. If you were able to press them for more specific things that they didn't feel were a fit or areas of experience that might be helpful to pick up before reapplying - and they weren't able to give an answer - it's probably a personal thing. If you sense that might be it, definitely work on your interviewing skills. Interviewing.io is a good place to go.

like

But make sure that when you use the interview service you do it exactly as if you were walking into the room - commenting on someone's shoes, asking them about themselves, whatever you typically do if you were having the entire experience of you.

Why ML?

Feel free to DM me, happy to answer any questions you might have of me.

There is also a chance that they think you're underqualified for the role you are applying for. Like "you could probably do the job but you don't look good on paper."

Good enough to get the interview though?

It's likely that either you look good on paper but can't perform to expectations in practice, or your salary expectations are outsized. Is it possible maybe there's something coming up on a background check or from a past employer that could be putting them off?

Related Posts

How much maximum package range is offered at Natwest group with 6 years of experience in trade settlements senior analyst b6 role

Anyone know how long it takes to get an offer or rejection from Accenture after the final interview? Interviewed for a consulting role.

like

I am a US attorney with a very reputable environmentaL firm. Passed the MCT and will take the OSCE in May. Would love any and all advice about how law firm or in-house hiring in London works.

like
like

So I’m engaged in an interview process for a top FinTech company. It started the 1st week of August and just now I’ve gotten word from my recruiter that they didn’t update on any decisions made. I had my 3rd & final interview last Friday. My recruiter doesn’t communicate well nor does she let me communicate with the company direct. May I being led on? Am I still in the race for this role in your opinion with the details stated. Please message me if you would like to know more in detail.

Any US companies hiring remote @ Canada ?

like

I have been in an awkward reporting structure for 2.5 years. On record I’ve reported to the VP of Marketing, who was crazy toxic, and technologically inept. I’m a senior website manage and she had no interest in my role. She shirked me off to also report to her two directors, PR and Call Center. Needless to say, that’s been a difficult situation for me. She’s gone and the new VP starts tomorrow. Any guidance on how to ensure this ends with the incumbent VP?

Hello fishes,
I'm looking for referrals for QA lead role in Bangalore. Kindly DM me if you have any. Thanks..

like

Hi
Can anyone tell me if there is any opening at PwC for Angular developers / Salesforce Developer fresher?

Does anyone here freelance (in design or deckmaking) on top of their full time position? How does that work?

Is the EA role fading? What other roles can I transition to with 6 years of experiences as an EA?

like

Hello All, I’m a project manager but seeking to pivot into UX Research. I do have some experience but don’t have a portfolio yet. Can anyone advise if I should focus on going through a bootcamp or focus on getting a Masters in HCI? Or just building a portfolio with the experience I do have? There are very few entry-level roles and many places are only hiring “Sr UXR” with 3-5+ years of experience! Any tips on how to break into this field and/or stand out as a junior applicant?? Thanks!

like

Hi Folks,

Hope you all are doing well.

I have multiple offers in hand from the below-mentioned companies.

Need your inputs and suggestion regarding which company would be better to join in terms of career growth and opportunities in Data Engineer role.


ITC Infotech
Telstra
Teklink International
Factspan analytics
Bosch

All companies are giving offers around 18-20(Fixed +Variable).

YOE - 3.4 years

Tech Stack - SQL Server,SSIS,Azure ,ADF,ADB,Pyspark,Azure Synapse, SparlSQL

like

Openings in Wipro
Linux Admin - 7+ years
Windows Admin - 7+ years
Infra Managed Serv Project Management- 9+ years
Network Admin - 7+ years
Mongo DB - 4+ years
VMWare ESXi - 5-10 years
Oracle DBA - 4-7 years
Webmethods - 5-12 years
Microservices - 8+ years
If interested, please DM your full name and email id for referral

like

How much annual % hike does Amazon offer for L4 Non Tech role (Finance), YOE =1

like

Dear fishes,
Looking for referrals for the role of a product owner.

experience - 6 years.

Available to join immediately. Any referrals would be highly appreciated.

Regards

like

Hi, does anyone know the pay range for Syneos Health Engagement Manager role?

like

Hi, I have a collaborative interview(second interview) tomorrow with a tech startup for a product marketing manager position. I haven’t experienced a collaborative interview before and I’m not sure what to expect. How should I prepare?

like

Do MBB pay a referral bonus if your referral gets hired?

like

Hi folks,

I have been offered a position on Senior Consultant/ Deputy Manager at Deloitte India for 4.5 years of exp.

Is this position/role normal for years of experience I hold?

like

More Posts

What are your best tools for self-motivation at work? There are days when it takes a huge amount of effort for me to get started and in the groove and I'm looking for ways to make work days easier.

like

When amd how to submit Medical report aa virtual joining is there. Medical certificate is one of mandatory document from TCS at the timw of joining

like

TCS Ibegin showing invalid credentials when tries to login ..any idea

like

How many days before onboarding and recruiter clearance we will get from HCL? I see status as BGV Completed is this means am I fine with BGV ? can someone please let me know pre boarding process and onboarding process

Post Photo
like

Hi Fish,

I have attended an interview with Airbus recently and have passed the technical round. They said the next HR round is expected to be after 9th of August. What should be the salary expectations?

I am currently drawing 12.1 LPA form Accenture with 6 yr exp - 10Lakhs is fixed and rest is variable pay which they never pay. When I see on Quora & Linkedin people are getting 40LPA with same experience in other product companies. What to discus? How much to ask without risking the job offer?

likeuplifting

Forcing me to use my standing desk

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Can someone share the interview tips for GCA round?

like

Has anyone considered meal prepping their own food and bringing with on road? Ex. Cooked chicken and vegetables. Could it be doable/safe with a 2 hour plane ride?

Feeling like it's only a matter of time before I have to tell the new marketing dept head that the snazzy jargon just makes him sound like a tryhard and alienates our customer base

like

Do you have to be flying Delta to go to the skyclub? Or American to go to their skyclub?

like
like

Hi Everyone,

I am in need of a job in the field of Human resources, i have 3 years of experience.please do suggest/ reffer me it would be really helpful. I can join in 30 days.

like

How are you all getting wine/beer during this time?

like

Looking for a solid receiver to run outdoor speakers, one that has bluetooth and alexa capabilities. Was using zone 2 on main Home theater but it doesnt push out enough power.

Hey guys! I joined my current organisation as a fresher with 19k PM, it’s been 3 years with 2 promotions I am now a business analyst (1 year) earning 35k P.M. I feel I am underpaid, please tell me what is the right pay for my exp and designation.

like

Today I have received background verification form from EY GDS. I have already received offer letter and my joining is on March 2. How much time the background verification process usually takes, any idea? EY

like

Need some urgent help can anyone DM me, Please

like

Moelis IB analyst/associate? Pay? Expectations? Interview process?

like

How is Wipro as an organisation for B3 level employee.
Can you give some honest reviews ?? Any info regarding onsite will be helpful as well.

Tech Stack: ServiceNow
Wipro

like

Additional Posts in Product Management

Is there a way to land a job in Google/Facebook without knowing how to code?? Looking into Program/Product Management roles.
P.S. Currently working on IT & Cloud security engagements and is good at it.

like

I'm working at a startup where I feel like I've spent as much time trying to deal with product issues vs working on roadmap items. I get this is bound to happen in a start up but is this common? I'm not sure what to do. It seems like no one really thought about the architecture or ux as much as they should have in my opinion. I need some advice.

like

Where should a data and insights team sit within a company org?

like

For product analytics alone which is better? Heap or Pendo? Has anyone had any experience using them?

like

Are there any specific resources (books, articles, individuals, courses) for someone who wants to focus on being a Group Product Manager?

like

I'm being asked to be involved in product pricing for the first time, and lack any knowledge or experience in that area. Any suggestions on courses or books or websites? I'm considering the Pragmatic Marketing pricing course, so would be interested to hear from anyone who has taken it.

like

I’m trying to pivot to PM after >3 years in finance and I have a 2nd round interview with CPO this week. Company has 3.7 on Glassdoor with complaints about CEO, “bro-y” culture, and hard to wfh. It’s a data analytics company with 5 PMs, was bought by a PE firm this year, and has a new (female) CEO as of Oct. Role is 50/50 hybrid, pays well vs what I make, and most importantly would be a foot in the door to PM. Is this a good place to be for PM? What else do I need to find out to know for sure?

like

I’m currently a PM in a startup in Greater NYC area looking for other opportunities. Any insights or advice on what salary/compensation expectations I should have with 2,5 YOE in this area? Any guidance would help. Thank you!

like

What tool/ paid website do you use for roadmap planning? Looking for something to present to the uppers.

like

@microsoft folks, any prep advice for a Senior Business Program Manager interview Friday? Especially coming from consulting? Got 3 interviews with people from the team on Friday

like

Your favorite resources for learning just enough UX?

My baseline is a data scientist background: stats, data visualization, storytelling with decks

like

Feeling lowballed received an offer to PNC product management development program. Excited to be making a break into product but it’s paying 20% less than what I’m currently earning.

like

Would you recommend Decode and Conquer as good book for PM interview prep? I’ve seen there’s a new version out

like

Does anyone here have experience working as a PM for a non-profit? I have an interview with one that I would love to be a part of. I can’t find much information online regarding salary expectations.
I am willing to take a pay cut to join a non-profit I am passionate for. That being said - I’m trying to balance knowing it may be lower with not accepting a low-ball offer due to lack of information.

like

How often do you see people going from solutions architect to product manager

like

Working in a start-up and love having an impact on the product. Things have been too chaotic tho. Thinking of recruiting for a big tech company but not sure if it's for me- anyone willing to chat?

I think I'm really bad at communication, storytelling, active listening etc. I'm good at 1-1 relationships, but really bad in 1-many scenarios. I just sound stupid often. Feel like I'm surrounded by people who communicate so much better. Has anyone improved their comms skills as they progressed in their careers? Any tips or courses that helped you on the way?

like

Would would a senior product manager do over and beyond a product manager. We don’t have any seniors at my startup and I’m trying to figure out what I need to do/achieve to get promoted. Any advice would be much appreciated.

likesmart

Have an explorative call tomorrow with Amazon for a Sr Financial Specialist, Catalyst - FSI Angler. Anyone know the comp range on this?

likesmart

How many hours are you all , on average, working in a day?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal