I recently interviewed with a company that I have worked for in the past. Left on good terms. This time I wasn't chosen for the position. I have over 25 years experience in my field, plus the time I had in this company previously. Before I even interviewed, I was told I was asking for too much money, I said that I was willing to negotiate. There is a new manager in the department, I'm told because of how much I was askng, she probably thinks I want her job. Do you think that's why?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Sort of a dumb comment by the HR team but then why would you apply a job that’s so much below your salary expectations?

like

“I expected possibly a little bit lower, but not that much”. You had no chips to bargain with but acted like you did. You had experience but were not employed. No leverage whatsoever to negotiate. At least it’s a lesson learned.

like

Well is the open position the same as her role???

like

No

like

I wouldn’t be surprised if this was Citibank, the company is a hole.

like

Depends on the attitude of manager really, but I would certainly have hired you because you would already be familiar with the systems and processes (often the upskilling is the main risk\cost in hiring).

like

Thank you.
I would have thought that due to my experience in general and experience with the company....

like

Depends on what you were asking compared to what they can offer/afford and what the other applicants have to offer and are asking for. It could be any number of reasons also.
I know managers that want people with less experience so they can train them the “right way” (their way). If you have 25 years experience you are probably set in your way.
Maybe it is a diversity issue. They may need to hire someone of a certain group, this does happen.

like

Just too old, they want new blood

They probably wanted you to work for them, but for less salary than what you were paid. Don't contact them again, and continue to find one with your salary expectations.

like

No. Has nothing to do with your wanting her job. Has everything to do with you asking for more money than they are willing to pay. Even if you negotiated down to an acceptable pay rate, they would worry that you would use the job as a stop gap while looking for something more in line with your compensation requirements.

like

No, the hiring manager just didn't lik.e you and like.d someone else. Also, I wouldn't rehire someone who previously left.

I'm in a similar situation. I left my company 23 years ago on good terms and have had 2 interviews or positions that I am over qualified for. I've gained more experience and I've been an FA since I left. I was told I wanted too much. I'd be making less than when I left. She asked where did I see myself in 6 months, I tried to assure her that I'd still be in that position and contributing to the team but that when I did have that job my goal was not to remain in that position forever and I always had goals outside of that department. This was my 2nd interview for 2 positions that I'd held in the past, that I'm definitely overqualified for. The proverbial elephant in the room. I'm not going to leave the company like Gen Z so I'm just confused.

PS.. I left to be a stay at home mother and haven't had a full time job since I worked for them. I self sponsored for all of my licenses sie, 63, 65, life health annuities in past 6 months. oh well?

Related Posts

Hey folks, I gave round 2 interview in sap labs and got an email from HR that they have kept my candidature on hold. Does that mean the chances of selection has been reduced??
Also to let you know I am an experienced professional.

like

Would like to move to industry in the future. Currently a senior 2. Is it better to leave after making manager as opposed to now? Looking for max financial gains. With Data and Analytics practice.

like


CFP study programs:

I'm a little confused on Danko - does he offer a self-study option for the coursework requirement? On his website it looks like each module has a 4-day virtual class which I wouldn't be able to attend due to working full time. Does this program also include self-study material, and the classes are just supplementary/optional? I was also looking at Dalton for self-study and Danko for test prep. Thoughts?

TIA

like

Learned an interesting lesson today: don’t mention wanting to go into government at some point in the future in a biglaw job interview. Had a callback where I mentioned a desire to be an AUSA. They passed on my candidacy apparently because of it.

likefunny

We are hiring for Azure Data engineers. Dm me if interested in accenture.
Exp - 2.5 years or greater

like

I have cleared 1st round of technical interview in Mphasis and was told next round will be managerial round any idea what kind of questions can be expected

like

Hi Fishes,

I am looking for the job change in ServiceNow profile and having a experience of 4+ yrs.

Currently I am trying to create network in linked in and naukari but still not getting the response from some companies like JP Morgan or mindtree etc.

Can u help me to understand what is the best way to create a network to some major companies.

I know applying directly to the company site mostly doesn't have any benefit or will take long time to schedule the interview.

Had a detailed an hour interview (just one) without job description being provided by HR
Received mail saying that you have cleared MR and will go ahead with HR interview. Request you to upload docs in "My documents" portal.

I could not login to ibegin portal and have to create a new profile... Toll free no on tcs portal does not help? It seems confusing

like

Hi all,i have been taking interviews for my department since the last 3 months.Should the company be paying me for the extra efforts?

like

If You need a referral have Cyber experience and a clearance DM me!

like
like

can anyone help me with standard package for Customer success manager/ key account manager salary. I have 2 years of experience. Need to know what can I expect for this role.

like

4YOE @Amazon & trying to lateral to a similar role @FAANG. Have my undergrad GPA (3.8/4) on resume from top 15 school but colleague says to take it off (looks silly). If it’s a good school & high GPA, why ever take it off your resume? Even if 10 YOE...can’t hurt?

like

I’m having the hardest time finding a new job. I have 12 years of HR experience, a masters in HR, SHRM certification, and all I keep getting are rejection emails. I’ve never experienced this difficult of a time searching for new opportunities. Is this normal once you hit a certain level in your career or is it just me?

likehelpful

I had offer from company A and B. A was offering only 22% hike on my CTC but copany B was offering 30% hike on CTC. After accepting the offer from company A and just before 20 days of LWD I asked for making it to 30% hike. Company A is not responding , no communication , No reply to mails and not picking up the call. What to do? any suggestion will be appricaited.

like

Hey folks, I got an offer from IBM ISL, But the offer is dated 2 months as joining date, but my notice period is 3 months. This was agreed by the hiring manager. He also offered Joining bonus if I could join in 2 months. HR said the date is tentative and they will renew the offer, so I accepted the offer. Now am running behind the HR to get the offer renewed. Can I trust their words, or will they backout from the offer after 2 months. Please help.

Considering an FP&A role at a credit fund. Anyone have any insight into what this would be like?

like

Hello Fishes,

So far I received offers from PwC India, Capgemini and Lexmark for Data Engineering.

More are in pipeline from KPMG GS, TechM, Accenture.

But one peculiar thing is happening. I have appeared for 4 Cognizant interviews but in all I have been rejected. Whereas most of my friends had easily cleared Cognizant. I am switching tech, so I am a bit concerned like whether my knowledge is too shallow😐

Is it sign of an Imposter Syndrome 🥺

Pls help🙏🏾

Yoe - 3.2

like

hi BA's how much are you guys earning and your YOE? which company can i switch to next? i started off my career as a BA after engg, and then break of 2 years MBA. joined wipro in feb ,26.5 ctc and 8.8 YOE now. looking for 40lacs minimum next switch. it would be my 6th company

I accepted a 95k systems engineer role in VA with KBR and is currently going thru a clearance.(MAY START DATE)
Northrop offers me 92k w/ 3k sign on which is 30 min from home in MD for an associate systems role. They also want to give me a clearance but it will start as an interim so I can work sooner than may. MY DILEMMA: Kbr states that they know I need money now so I can accept an offer with Northrop to see if I like it until may.BUT can I have 2 security clearances running at the same time?

like

More Posts

Mie Prefecture... I love the way the sun on the ocean looks like burnished metal (NGO–TPE)

Post Photo
like

For a male, I have extremely skinny wrists (think skinny girl wrists) but I’m looking to invest in a nice watch. What do you all recommend? Leather bands are preferable

like

My gorgeous baby Merlin

Post Photo
like

Sharing my WFH colleague who somehow always seems to be more exhausted than me after a long day 😅

Post Photo
like

Post A/S/L here

likefunny

Anyone play Legends of Runeterra? I think I might be addicted 😂

like

Ok. I am lowly platinum on AA. I am taking a redeye and have a choice of LA to Philly or Phoenix to Philly. Is there any way to check which specific flight would give the best chance for upgrade?

like

I think hospitals would benefit tremendously from hiring designers to help facilitate better space utilization, communication, etc.

like

Loads of Tech Roles open at WebMD. Message me if you need referral for any of these roles.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Hello,
My skillset: Oracle Identity and Access management, Java , YOE:3.5

My current CTC is 8lpa, i have an offer from VFISLK 11lpa, and expecting offer from Accenture 12lpa.

Can Wipro match the offer?

Considering wlb and job security, i can stay in Wipro if they match the offer.

like

What's the most exciting project you have done as Data analyst/Analytics professional?

I am an entry level Data Analyst trying to find motivation for this career. Like what are some big or fun projects that I should aspire to

like

Opportunity identified for fresher as well as experienced.
Location is Mumbai.
Interested folks can DM with name and email address

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Looking into a CAMS certificate. Does anyone who have this want to talk with me about the benefits process of getting this?

like

Family Law Software? Pros and cons?

like

When your client is understanding of your schedule, listens to your recommendations, and thanks you for your hard work.

Post Photo
likefunny

Music I play in the team rental car vs. music I play with my headphones on in the team room...

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

How to leverage personal connections for personal gain?

I am a 2nd year and my spouse is a higher up in engineering in big tech. He has some (but not a lot of) sway in outside counsel and could make some intros to in house counsel.

My firm will gladly use my connections for their own gain, so I’m making sure that if/when this situation comes, I take full advantage of it.

Looking for tips on short term and long term strategy.

like

I currently work in Transactions Tax but I am keen to move into Corporate Finance or FDD.

I dont have any prior Audit experience so I am just pondering how realistic my aspirations are given my tax background. Can anyone advise as to what would be the best route of transition?

Thanks

like

People at EY not use the corporate card? The expense system is horrible. But might not be worth using my Marriott card...

like

Hi team, Cgi is hiring for below skillsets: Senior java developer ( Java 8,11, spring boot, Cassandra, MQ, TSQL and cache )

Java and unix

Automation Test lead

Informatica, ETL, SQL

IOS, Swift, objective C

LDAP OSB, SQl

Forgerock IG product

Please dm me if you are interest in any of the above positions.

like

Additional Posts in Finance

Used to be in a quant group. We had an underperforming staff who we let go. He claimed to HR he was discriminated against bc he was an MBA. To which they responded: that's not a protected class.

like

Which firms have you gotten offers from, but gave them a pass? And why?

like

If I had a penny for every time I had to look up millennialisms...

like

Is it just me, or is Soros getting uglier every year? It's like the dark side is twisting him up.

like

What is considered business casual in SF? Is it suit with no tie or Polo and chinos?

like

Does anyone have an idea on compensation for JPM Wealth Management Division?

Associate
V. President
E. Director
Mgng. Director

like

Health insurance Q: I’m choosing between 2 Anthem PPO’s, gold or silver. Gold is higher monthly fee, lower deductibles. Silver is low monthly fee, higher deductibles. In Cali. Any advice on deciding?

like

Any former consultants on here? If so, why did you switch over to banking?

like

Cryptobros on suicide watch

like

No disrespect. Why is it that the most "successful" bankers amongst us are elitist assholes?

like

I freaking love wearing khakis

like

What book has inspired you the most in life principles, or your career in finance?

like

what is cross asset structuring?

like

NASA What is the salary range for JPL- Financial Analyst III?? @nasa@JPL

like

Simple life hacks that make a huge difference:

like

Accidentally sent a cold networking email thinking they lived/worked in City A when they actually worked in City B. How do I recover?

like

Charter holders, any advice on level II studying? Just started going over the jumpstart material and feel like it’s pretty intense. Any pro tips from those who have conquered it?

like

How do you guys stay up all night working and still look as fresh as a daisy? Meanwhile, I'm here looking haggard and a good ten years older than I actually am.

like

Hypothetically what’s the shortest amount of time you should stay in a job without switching. I kinda wanna try my hand at a different industry but don’t wanna kill the experience I have now by leaving too early

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal