In prosecution, if a patent attorney does not try to remove prior art cited by an examiner (eg a 130 affidavit to assert an exception under102(b)(1)(A)), but instead makes arguments to overcome the art, may the attorney made an admission that bars removing the art later in prosecution. Just received such a transfer case, looking for options.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Haven't looked it up, but I would think an admission wouldn't be an issue for an actual bar here. i.e., it might be an admission if you fail to argue that something is non analogous art, but if something is objectively not prior art, an admission wouldn't make a difference.

My first step would be to call the Examiner, tell him that this isn't prior art for the following reason, what do you want in my affidavit? Wouldn't even mention the previous arguments.

Downside is that there are already unnecessary arguments in the record that narrow your claims.

like

FYI, my answer for issues like this is almost always call the Examiner. They usually won't know the answer, but it doesn't matter because you get to write in your response that "as discussed in the Examiner Interview of XXX, we are submitting herewith . . ."

like

As long as prosecution is still open, you can argue that a reference is not prior art and provide the affidavit. Of course, this should always be been done in the first place to avoid having to put any arguments on the record that can be used against the patent owner in litigation.

like

Related Posts

Is there future in transaction risk investigator position will i get job in other companies

like

What are everyone's thoughts on executive MBA vs. traditional MBA? I'm currently pursuing a traditional MBA but sometimes I wonder what could've been 😅

like

Anyone have peak frameworks referral code

like

Friends:

'Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.' (Matthew 5). I am so glad that the Lord showed me that I am poor in spirit.

like

Associate producer salary at MAL?

like

Hi, offer coming through from AWS - is there scope for negotiation with them, or is the offer just the offer?

like

Need likes to unlock DM for advice on how to win ladder matches during summer slam ☺️

like

Anyone know anything about trying to work in house in certain industries? I’d like to move into media (publishing, entertainment, etc.) because I don’t want to stay in law forever but am having a hard time connecting to the right people

like

Hi, I am bringing together a team through a reorg any suggestions on how to bring a new team together remotely?

like

Here to restate the understated truth of our profession..

Post Photo
likesmartuplifting

I wouldn’t even mind the hours of this job if people were kinder.

likesmart

Best podcasts, YouTube, TikTok, or um books for interview prep for consulting?

like

Any folks here moved back to IBD from PE? Left IB in NY for an Emerging Market PE ($20 bn+) but region has very weak deal flow and a so-so culture. Debating if I should go back to banking in NY

like

Looking to buy a new women’s watch. Already have a Tag Heuer and absolutely love it. Looking for something more classy (leather band perhaps)? Any suggestions?

like

Interested in everyone’s opinions on replica luxury. I ask because, as noted in the previous thread re: Chanel’s price increases, the quality of authentic luxury bags is going way down while the price increases consistently. Specifically Chanel and LV. I’m fascinated in the online rep community and it looks like rep quality has increased exponentially (with genuine materials and 1:1 markings, stitching, hardware, etc). What’s your argument for or against replicas?

like

Opinions on BagYork(dot)com? It shows great deals on most branded items and is a verified merchant on Pinterest but I’m worried if it’s legit

like

Has travel started in Accenture S&C customer sales and service strategy. How many days of travel can one expect

like

Additional Posts in Patent Prosecution

What do y’all use to draw informal figures? I currently use powerpoint but am curious if there are more efficient ways. What have you found most efficient/convenient?

Subject matter eligibility "doctrines" .... lol amirite?

likefunny

Any insight into life as a patent agent with stern Kessler? Are there directors to avoid in the chemistry area?

like

Any tips on starting a solo patent law firm from working in Biglaw? Worth it?

like

How long does it take you to draft a patent application on average?

like

Just curious: how much time would you bill for on prepping instructions to a FA for a response? Feel free to break down by how long you’ve been practicing, complexity, or any other factor you think is relevant.

like

Does anyone find an attack on the Examiner’s prima facia showing of obviousness a lot more effective than distinguishing each and every prior art reference.

I recently underwrote a reply to final. Didn’t even bother with the references since I just got the case. Overcame the rejections.

Can anyone comment on how effective this is?

likehelpful

Any recommendations for free or reasonably priced CLE courses for patent prosecution?

like

Having some severe Executive Dysfunction atm. I can't imagine that the patent attorney bowl here is short on the neurodivergent. Suggestions/tips/tricks/advice are all appreciated. I recently moved, bought my first home, got vaccinated, etc. - basically just a huge load of stressful events that are probably doing a number on my brain, but I also just can't seem to get on top of.

Please, if you're neurotypical, think thrice before posting - I'm not normal, and want help, not stress or dismiss

like

It was suggested I repost this here. Figured you'd all appreciate it.

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi, are there any women-owned patent firms in the SF Bay Area that focus on patent prosecution in computer technologies? Thanks!

likehelpful

Any recommendations for patent prosecution practice management software for a small firm? Currently not using anything and want to be able to better manage and monitor associates.

Any recommendations for a document management system that automatically saves emails into the proper folders?

like

Anybody know anything about Nicholson de vos Webster Elliott for patent pros? Culture, pay, hours etc? Mid level looking to lateral

Has anyone regretted going in-house as patent counsel? If so, were you able to successfully transition back to a firm?

like

First year associate thinking about making the just from medium sized reputable IP firm to In House. Started at said firm summer of 1L year as a law clerk/patent agent in May 2019, have worked through school and full time as associate since Sept 2021. Feeling very “stuck” in day to day work. Love the patent/IP space but drafting and pros w/minimal human interaction is getting very difficult. Thinking In House would be better, but not sure how much experience needed. Thoughts?

like

What would you say the going rates are for (i) non provisional application drafting and (ii) office action responses?

In what order do you draft a patent application? I know the official answer is “it depends.” But what do you find yourself do most often? For me, it’s claims —> drawings —> spec.

like

Taking the patent bar in a week and it’s been so tough studying while working. I’m so behind in my hours this month, and my firm (midlaw, IP only) was pretty clear that they expect my hours to stay on track this month regardless of the exam. I don’t know how I’m going to get through this week and then make it through 6 hours of testing. Please tell me the afternoon session is easier than the morning session, like some others have said 🙏🏽

like

What do hiring partners (or HR in in-house) generally think about a lateral that are in the middle of a part-time MS degree program (STEM MS program)?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal