Does anyone find an attack on the Examiner’s prima facia showing of obviousness a lot more effective than distinguishing each and every prior art reference.

I recently underwrote a reply to final. Didn’t even bother with the references since I just got the case. Overcame the rejections.

Can anyone comment on how effective this is?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

after 20 years doing this, including writing my own and reading the replies of others, I think attacking the prima facie case devolves to boiler plate that examiner's easily dismiss with their own canned response in the next (final) rejection. What I do find promising in most cases is that examiners routinely mischaracterize and misapply their prior art references. they say it says something but when you look, it really doesn't. examiners get uncomfortable knowing their work is going to get scrutinized on appeal.

like

I mean, it obviously depends on what the examiner asserted was obvious and how strong their point was. In some cases sure, it could work, as you obviously know. But in terms of general best practices, no, the examiner is usually going to dig in if you don’t actually address the references. This obviously doesn’t include a situation where you’ve had an interview where the examiner agreed with you and just wanted you to put your arguments on the record.

like

Mind you this was a final rejection, so the differentiations were already made prior, before I got the case. Mostly just feeling out other situations.

I only find this to be successful when there is something blatant I can point to - like elements/limitations left unaddressed. Examiners really don't like to take the hit of a second non-final, so they'll often give you a final even when you actually have a point, unless it's a really good point.

like

Canadian here, but have worked on US files...I have seen this done successfully in many US files I've come in on, but have also seen it fail and there be several more rounds of argument with the Examiner... In Canada I definitely argue the idea of 'no motivation to combine Ref 1 & 2', or 'not obvious bc POSITA would have seen X teach-away in Ref 2...' all the time if possible. But I'm biotech/pharma so not sure if its similar for high tech and engineering practice...

In general, I think you’ll have stronger arguments if you point to something specific in one or more references to help make your point. Sure, you can argue the examiner failed to articulate any sort of motivation to combine refs 1 and 2 (or whatever the case may be), but unless you point to something fact-specific from the references, you’ll likely get another office action where the examiner modifies the rejection to address the deficiency.

I agree with you completely. For context, the claimed invention recited a specific and narrowly construed structural difference. The prior art of record spanned about 100 years. No reference remotely contemplated the configuration. Examiner just kept on with “obvious to try” and “finite predictable solutions”. I had zero confidence the Examiner would budge, so I just attacked KSR E. and then went for the Graham factual inquiries.

I wasn’t going after failing to articulate motivations for combination. I straight up went after KSR point E. (Should have been more specific in the post).

Related Posts

For PwC AC Bangalore, Can anyone see the Tier Impact & Bonus amount in Workday ? Can see my revised annual compensation but not the Bonus and Tier. PwC Pwc AC Bangalore

like

I’m leaving my job soon but I’m wondering if I should be truthful when I hand in my letter of resignation. There’s a ton of reasons but it boils down to: I’m worth more than they can pay me and I need to pay off these student loans. What should I say?

like

Hi what all we need to do before joining ? I have taken the print out of all the forms that we need to submit but do we need to mail them to someone or do we need to submit the hard copy of that.

like

Does anyone know when agile promotions will be communicated to the counselors?

like

Been in Austin for a while now and have never dated but would like to start. Any tips/suggestions on where to find quality people? (F, 28)

likehelpful

Is anyone willing to refer for any roles Capsule? I can share more details as needed, but looking to get into product or implementation work.

like

Hi Fishes,

Is S&P planning to open offices?

like
like

Hi Fishes,
Can someone please share some best resources to learn data structures and algorithms in Java.
Thanks in advance.

like

Hi,
I cleared the interview in tiger analytics for senior software Engineer.
Tech - big data, spark scala
Yop - 2 years
Having counter offer for 17 fix.

How much can I expect from tiger?

like

Is Assistant Director at EYP same as Senior Manager at Accenture?

like

Hello Fishes,

I have 11 Years of experience in Physical Security, I presently work for BIAL(Bangalore International Airport Limited). was looking for reference for Corporate Security positions. if any one could help me in referring me for any of the positions in Corporate Security it would help me in my growth.

Thanks.

like

@Manager1 what’s the JWN play today?

Received bad news from Accenture today. Unsure of what they were looking for. I was referred for on a JMO application.

Post Photo
like

Can anyone post the link to the Single Consultants bowl? I can’t see it anymore!

like

IBM should close down some of their buildings and give those that want to work in an office subsidized co-working memberships.

like

Any book recommendations about human psychology / thought processes?

like

Epsilon is hiring for given engineering roles-

Java Full Stack/Java BigData
.Net Developer
Scrum master
Quality Engineer
Product Owner
UI/ UX
Product Support Analyst
AWS Devops

If interested, DM for referral

How does underwriting compare to PIP litigation in terms of flex time (ability to stop/start work throughout day, work at 2 am if needed, etc)

For example.. in PIP Litigation I can review my suits at 2 am if needed (as a result of having a rough day or other emergency) and still be in compliance

Does Underwriting carry any time sensitive tasks?

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Patent Prosecution

Can anyone give me a how to for making a Request for Rectification under PCT rule 91.1? ISA is the US, filed with the USRO.

like

Any recommendations for a document management system that automatically saves emails into the proper folders?

like

In prosecution, if a patent attorney does not try to remove prior art cited by an examiner (eg a 130 affidavit to assert an exception under102(b)(1)(A)), but instead makes arguments to overcome the art, may the attorney made an admission that bars removing the art later in prosecution. Just received such a transfer case, looking for options.

Any recommendations for free or reasonably priced CLE courses for patent prosecution?

like

I am working on a NFOA for a design case. The Examiner identified a primary references and four secondary references. The Examiner also pointed out five differences between the primary reference and the claimed design. For the reply, I found nine additional differences between the claimed design and the primary reference, two of which are not present in any of the cited references. Should I clarify the level of a designer having ordinary skill in the art first? Complex/Expensive article. TY!

like

Bit of a niche topic: I’ve been in TS/SCI processing for a Science/Tech/Weapons analyst position with the CIA for 3 yrs since I finished grad school in chemistry, but CIA positions are sort of set it and forget it since they can take so long. I’ve since been focused on a Patent Attorney track and am with a firm that will support me taking the patent bar/law school. If I get through processing and go to the CIA for some time, do you think would I be accepted back into patent law later on?

like

I’m looking for a tool that allows me to search for text in Office Actions and responses. For example, is there a way to search for ‘written description’ or ‘improper Markush’ issued by Examiner John Smith? Does something like this exist?

like

Do you work somewhere where quality is valued over efficiency? Where can I find this? In-house? Small boutique?

like

How long does it take you to draft a patent application on average?

like

Any recommendations for patent prosecution practice management software for a small firm? Currently not using anything and want to be able to better manage and monitor associates.

What are the pros and cons of the following IP boutique firms: Finnegan, Fish, Banner Witcoff, Oblon, Knobbe?

like

A frustrated colleague asked for help with a difficult prosecution. I agreed to help. I just reviewed up the case and the examiner is combining NINE references. I think that’s a record for me. What’s your record for most number of references combined?

like

Any insight into life as a patent agent with stern Kessler? Are there directors to avoid in the chemistry area?

like

Taking the patent bar in a week and it’s been so tough studying while working. I’m so behind in my hours this month, and my firm (midlaw, IP only) was pretty clear that they expect my hours to stay on track this month regardless of the exam. I don’t know how I’m going to get through this week and then make it through 6 hours of testing. Please tell me the afternoon session is easier than the morning session, like some others have said 🙏🏽

like

What do y’all use to draw informal figures? I currently use powerpoint but am curious if there are more efficient ways. What have you found most efficient/convenient?

If a client asks law firm A to transfer a couple of patent prosecution cases to law firm B, does law firm A need to deliver all relevant documents to law firm B? Can law firm B just submit POA and access all the files via Private Pair? Thank you

Has anyone regretted going in-house as patent counsel? If so, were you able to successfully transition back to a firm?

like

First year associate thinking about making the just from medium sized reputable IP firm to In House. Started at said firm summer of 1L year as a law clerk/patent agent in May 2019, have worked through school and full time as associate since Sept 2021. Feeling very “stuck” in day to day work. Love the patent/IP space but drafting and pros w/minimal human interaction is getting very difficult. Thinking In House would be better, but not sure how much experience needed. Thoughts?

like

Any good recommendations for patent industry magazines with regular print editions? too much of my keeping up to date is by blogs.

How many billable hours do people in prosecution tend to average each month? I’ve gone through waves of feeling like my billable hours requirement is reasonable to feeling like I’m drowning and can’t possibly do it for that long.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal