Is it appropriate to bypass someone on a 3% cost of living increase during their performance review when they were given a promotion/title increase 10 months ago that resulted in a $20,000 increase? Understanding they took on a whole other part of the business that was merged with their current Director position. Understand that the performance review went well and all requirements were met. Also, there was large cost savings for the company.

funnylike
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

No one should be penalized for getting a promotion!

like

No- it not appropriate- I would give the increase

like

If you have the money for it, why hold back on someone who seems to be doing well and benefiting your company? This is how you lose good employees when you take a stingy mindset.

like

If it was more recent, maybe. However 10 months is almost an entire year, I would say it is not appropriate.

like

No because that is shortchanging someone who has performed well and acquired a promotion.

like

What would be the rationale for denying the cost of living increase?

The other details provided suggest that their comp has just caught up to their workload. With a good review and additional cost savings to the company, 3% cost of living increase sounds like the bare minimum.

like

I was told that because I got a raise during the year, I don't get one until next year. That's the only answer I got.

like

Have had this happen to me and I don’t think it is appropriate. I have never done this to my direct reports.

like

The way I look at COL increases is: with inflation (and let’s be honest, lately COL increases are not covering inflation) - you want that person to do the same job w less buying power at the end of the day?

I have been dealing with this for 2 years at my current company and have just about had it.

Give the COL increase.

like

I had this happen to me and I am still upset about it. It really doesn't make sense

like

My promotion happened in a June (15k increase) and my company’s annual review and merit increase and bonus is in February every year. So for me it had only been 6 months. I received a merit increase in February. I work for a major healthcare insurance company; how they factored the increase was by my current salary (4% increase on current base salary). For bonus, they prorated based on my old title/job grade for the number of months I was at the old title and the remaining number of months at my new title/job grade.

likehelpful

Yes, if they have done their job and saved the company money and it is on 2 months shy of a year. You want to keep good people

like

Is appropriate to give the company below average performance in exchange for below average pay?

uplifting

A cost of living adjustment is not a raise!

smart

JFC

No

Is it a written co policy that you do not get it in the year? Do you know if she has a pool to distribute? 10 months seems unreasonable but maybe her hands were tied.

No his hands weren't tied. I know many others who received 10% from him but not all were recently promoted. Also my husband works here and received the same amount in increase at same time but lower paying position and he still got 3%. I was on maternity leave for 8 weeks and believe he factored that in as well however I couldn't type that in the initial post due to limited letters.

Bah. You should've gotten it. This is why we unionize.

A lot of organizations have a policy of 1 increase per year but if that is not the case 10 mos is a long time and if a top performer then a merit increase in excess of cost of living adjustment would be expected.

Any time you receive a promotion or equity increase it is good to get in writing if you will still be eligible for annual merit.

That does not seem to be appropriate, and it can seem retaliatory. How do you correlate the cost of living with performance? Inflation is not indicative of performance. If anything, the employees performance may be suffering due to lack of financial resources. Lack of money causes a lot of stress

If I recently received a promotion, should the 3% be added to that new salary base if it wasn’t included in the job requisition post.

At my company, we get merit increases every year at performance eval time. If you get promoted at eval time, our merit increase is included in that new salary and we get a bigger bump. If we get promoted at any other time of the year, we obviously only get the increase for the promotion

Why would you penalize them? From your description, they deserve the increase.

Related Posts

Hello Fishes, I have 7 days for joining. please help me decide below

UST Global - 19 Fixed + 1 Variable + 1 Joining bonus

NTT Data - 16 Fixed + 2.2 variable

i can ask NTT to match the offer, if they match which is good to join??

Techstack - Backend engineer with Python, Django, DRF, SQL

YOE - 5 years

like
like

Folks onsite,

Are you all satisfied with US and USI raises?

RSA, RSA Security LLC Does anyone have experience working at RSA Security? If yes, how is the work environment there, and what is the salary offered for 6 year experienced developer? Thanks for answering..

like

Anyone have advice for advancing in your current role? My co-worker was hired in at manager level but somehow “proved” he was actually doing director level work and got a title promotion and salary increase in less than a year. I also went above and beyond my job as well (covering for him for a month while he was away on paternity leave) while taking on other projects outside of my job title and got zip—no raise or recognition. Any advice would be appreciated!

like

I'm an MBA from the batch of 2020. I got into Social Media marketing (ORM) but want to switch to pure digital marketing as I don't see any growth in ORM & I'm terribly underpaid (Graduate level). I have a 1+ YoE. Looking for a job/profile switch. Any helpful suggestions/refs are appreciated.

like

So I’m charging jobs due to unforeseen situations to another company as a assistant manager and I wanted to know is it unprofessional to turn down a job after you already accepted the offer to take another companies offer if the pay is better by $5000-?

likesmarthelpful

Microsoft hi, in the process of speaking with hiring manager for a learning and development lead within next week, anyone know the pay range or interviews techniques?

like

I am a Chartered accountant and truth be told given the current times CA is a really low incentive education any potent person can get. Today I see engineers barely with a few years of experience earning lakhs per month. Whereas me despite being in the right place at the right time is working hard 10-11 hours each day even today. We as a forebearers of this profession must really rise together

like

How much an application development team lead gets @ accenture YOE 6 ?

like

Hello everyone, I wanted to ask about pay ranges for Cloud Infrastructure engineers or Devops in Toronto/Vancouver for a mid-senior position, especially if anyone has an idea about Telus pay ranges.

Also, if they have a good culture or not.

likesmart

I have 7 plus experience in c++. I am trying new job within Chennai location but I am getting 1 or 2 interview calls for a month. I know c++ is old language and openings are very less and competitor people also less.
Shall learn new courses like AWS... its totally different from my experience I am not sure it will help to my career.

Could you please suggest shall I continue with c++ or shall I go with other platforms. Since I am getting very low package.

like

Hi everyone

What's an average salary of Marketing and Content Manager in Hyderabad for a mid-sized IT firm?

like

Can anyone share the pay structure for the company? I'm new and trying to learn.

Got an offer for Sr. Financial Analyst for 85k & 10% annual bonus. What's a good counteroffer? I told the recruiter 95k-110k when I first interviewed. This position is 100% remote, headquartered in VA. I live in NYC. Have roughly 2 YOE.

Thanks.

like

Hi Fishes,
Please help me to choose between two companies with respect to work life balance

Domain - Embedded Automotive Stream(Powertrain)

Renault Nissan(RNTBCI) - 9 LPA
Tata Elxsi - 9.3 LPA

YOE - 4

Thanks in advance

like

Hi,
I have 5 yoe in Java with 5.65 lpa.
How much hike i can expect .
I got a call from a recruiter and I said my expected CTC is 14 lpa, she said according to the current market, they can provide max 30-40% hike
How much I can expect according to the current trend .

like

How much are project specialists making in Florida?…I’ll go first, I’m making $46,000/yr with 2 years of experience in the electrical sales and distribution industry.

like

Which one to choose between Optum and Tiger Analytics for Data Scientist position? Where can I expect better data science domain expertise (In my previous companies I found very less understanding of Data Science practices as team)? Heared good things about both of these. Also hearing Tiger is expanding rapidly and getting some crap projects as well in the name of data science. Could someone put light on these things?
YOE: 4.5 Years
Tiger: 18L Fixed + 1L JB
Optum: 21L Fixed + 1.5L JB

Salary of a solution architect in cyber security( pre sales and with RFP experience) industry with 7-8yrs of experience.

like

More Posts

My supervisor gave me 8hours of AWOL because I couldn't show up one day because I was under anxiety. I have gave him letters from psychiatrist,psychologist that I'm passing through this. He didn't care and gave me an AWOL. I want to leave my job because my department is very toxic but I don't want to leave having that on my records.
If I move to another job later on (private or federal) this 8 hours of AWOL will show up?

like

Diversification is the key. My portfolio includes a bit of most of these.

1. Debt/Liquid mutual funds (direct)
2. Gold
3. REIT (fractional ownership and distribution)
4. Equity mutual funds (ELSS, direct)
5. Direct equity (India)
6. US stocks and ETFs (tech & genomics)
7. Crypto currency (interest deposits)

helpful

What does anyone know of real estate in Web3? I keep hearing about it but it feels so foreign that I wouldn't know where to begin.

like

Any single girl in Bangalore?
25 M

like

I haven’t seen a group that caters to this specific age range, so here we go :) don’t be shy. Share your info and let’s connect!

like

How long it will take for infosys to release offer letter
HR interview completed and hr said I will receive offer letter within 15 days
It's been 3 weeks in still not received but I am getting calls from infosys projects and they are asking for project allocation but I am not even received OL.

like

Hi,

I have experience of 3+ years in HR recruitment and employee services....looking for any openings in HRBP associate role.

Please share any open positions that I can apply for.

Thanks and regards.

like

Hello All, what is the difference in Data Scientist and ML engineer positions at Tiger Analytics. TIA.

like
like

What is the hierarchy in PWC India Advisory? What is the YOE needed for Senior Associate?

like

Anyone heard of NTT Data? It's the tech consulting arm of NTT group.

like

Hey, I am looking for a Project Manager opportunity in Bangalore. I have nearly 3 years of experience as a Product Owner and as a Project Lead

Appreciate any leads

like

In-house creative team for major American brand HIRING freelance designer who loves to concept/make social content.

Could lead to full time. Send book!

in.house.team.fishbowl@gmail.com

like

What are your must have artsy picture books for your classroom? For read alouds and also just for the bookshelf for early finishers :) I teach K-5

Anyone recognize the artist who created this?

Post Photo
like

My school deliberately cut the number of classes that the specials teachers teach so that we could be building subs for quarantined and sick teachers (we are hybrid). So... I teach fewer classes (which is a relief because specials teachers teach way more classes than core teachers normally) but I'm pulled for most of my planning periods to babysit classes. I need my planning periods so I can redo my ENTIRE curriculum... and I just feel unappreciated, used, and nothing more than a babysitter.

like

Incoming MBA, I have my tuition paid for and rent covered (I will be an RA). So the only thing I need to pay for is food and entertainment. Do you think 20k is enough to last me through the 2 years? I will make a little money interning in the summer, so that would be a safety valve if I blow through the 20k.

Or… should I take a small loan?

Received offer from BCG for ECT AD role. Read numerous comments about ECT being not attractive compared to Generalists track. Also heard challenges about billability/utilization. Any views/guidance is appreciated.

Background - I am not super keen to become an equity partner and comfortable to stay on ECT track. Main reason to join will be opportunity to work with different clients, smart talented people and good brand. I may consider going back to industry after 3-5 years in ECT.

like

Anyone have a recommendation for a research firm that specializes in teen recruitment for focus groups? Don’t need full service offering, just the recruit. Appreciate any help.

like

8.7 yr yoe, how can I negotiate with hcl ?@hcl

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal