Looking for advice:

If you received two offers for very similar HR roles you feel confident doing, how would you choose?

Option 1: Higher pay, leadership opportunity promised in ~6 months, but high turnover, multi-site travel, untrained managers, and low morale.

Option 2: Mission-driven organization, lower pay, newer company, no guaranteed leadership path but growth potential.

Which factors would weigh most in your decision: compensation and title trajectory, or mission and stability?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Travel. Time is precious so the one with least travel would be my choice. Everyone has different motivators

like

2, unless you are driven to make an impact on morale. Otherwise you’ll get sucked in. Low morale will make the best employee leave the highest paying job they’ve ever had.

like

I would say option 2 for the choice of progression, but it all depends on what pros motivate you the most.

helpful

I would prioritise the option that gives learning, visibility, and credible progression, even if the pay is slightly lower. Early leadership signals and scope often compound faster than salary alone, provided the role is sustainable and well-supported.

Related Posts

What is the salary range for Project Manager(Senior Manager) in EXL.

like

So supposed to head out of town for a long weekend with friends starting the evening of 4/21. My one friend and her son tested positive for Covid on 4/13 and have been sick. She says she is coming on our trip. On the following Thurs 4/28 I need to spend time with my 92 year old diabetic father. Do I go on this trip? I don’t think my friend has quarantined long enough to be sitting with 6 people driving in a van to our location unmasked as well as in the hotel room. Would you go on this trip?

like

If I start a full-time position as a Product Engineer, what salary should I expect within the Metro-Detroit Area?

like

Hi all,
Yesterday my people lead told that there is no variable pay for me as my previous people lead put negative remarks on portal. Here in the screenshot as you can see yearly bonus on November is zero. But there is a monthly bonus amount. What is that monthly bonus and when shall I get it?

Post Photo
like

Wondering if anyone can give insight as to what salary range is for an insurance compliance role as an IC3 or similar?

like

Do you pay your credit cards in full every month?

I ask because I’ve let my credit spending get a bit lax since moving and adopting a puppy recently, so I haven’t been paying them off in full every month like I used to (though still well above the minimum payment, and keeping utilization at 30% or under). It got me thinking about how many people adhere to this advice.

like

What's your absolute favorite dinner spot in Chi-town? I'm willing to travel, but I'm moving soon so want to hit all of the greats I haven't been to or didn't know about.

like

PwC AC Bangalore: In 2 months notice period, do we get salary month wise or all 2 months salary together around LWD in full and final settlement?

like

Is it difficult landing an in-house position as only a second year corporate associate in big law? I know some people who went in-house straight out of law school and some who had no transactional background but went in-house after just a year of practice. Not having that same luck on my end.

like

Can you guys advise me if a salary of 150 K CAD before tax is good for a 3 member family? It is in Quebec and we will be shifting from India to Canada with that.

like

Hi I am a Tax Analyst in EY GDS for my career growth what are the things I should give importance. By when do we get salary hike usually? EY.

like

Anyone had pay review conversation. How much is hike/bonus

like

Currently exploring an opportunity to join RSM transaction advisory, any insights into culture, WLB, comp progression?

like

When you finally got your CPA license how much has your salary jumped ?

like

What are some exits that provide similar pay and intellectual demand to consulting without the travel? Mostly finance paths like IB? PE?

like

Is it a bad idea to commute to work on the subway? Moving to Nyc in July and a little intimidated by the idea, given what’s in the news lately, but the rent within walking distance from work is a little below 1/2 monthly salary🥲

like

Hello Fishes,

I want to understand the work culture of HCL.
I have cleared many interviews but i got one offer from Cognizant For 14 LPA
And HCL salary negotiation still needs to be done
My ask is 18 LPA
YOE :4 .2

Thanks

like

I have experience in node.js and react with 3 yr fulltime and 1 yr internship. Current ctc is 6.5 lpa. How much be my expected salary?

like

I had my kind of hr round with TCS
They did not have a detailed discussion regarding the compensation .
But they told i will be getting link for uploading documents and then hr would be discussing for compensation.
Its been 2 days. No update. Can anyone guide. Why 2 hr rounds ? N how much time it takes?

like

What are good companies to work for that also pay WELL and hire remote? This inflation situation has me worried and my current company is great to work for, but on a budget freeze so no promotions or salary increases are approved for the time being. :/

like

More Posts

Can I get permanent wfh in wipro for mainframe. Working mother. Yoe 7 years. offered position team lead b3

like

I’m quite close to finally being able to get a Sub at retail and it seems it’s not that special of a thing, all of a sudden? So many people have one…

like

Is the SPHR or PHR license necessary to pivot into human capital? I have a MBA from a Top 15 school. Any thoughts?

1M net worth, 450k total comp, age 35, just paid off tons of student loans TONS, want to retire at 50. What’s the move?

like

What’s been the typical sign-on bonus for second-year transactional laterals?

like

What is it like to work in a core immigration role at infosys Bpm.

like

I’ve been thinking about looking for a new job, but given everything going on with the Coronavirus and layoffs, it doesn’t seem like this is a good time to start looking. What do others think?

like
like

Hi All,

Hope you are doing good!!

I am looking for a job change my current profile is in Accounts Payable (P2P) with overall 6 years of experience in the same, Currently, I am working with TCS, and Prior experience with Accenture.

Key areas- Vendor master data management, Invoice processing, disputes, and query management.

I am looking for Hybrid work or WFH.

If you are able to help me with any lead will be very helpful.

Thanks

Neha Bawaskar.

like

Hi all,

Can any one let me know What is the difference between designation Associate I and Associate II in JPMC ?

Which one is better and why?

like

I’ve been in a relationship now for two years. We are living together. We talk about the future etc. I could easily see myself marrying her. However, I have an issue… cont

like

How do i find out if I will be happier divorced or more unhappily staying married. 2 kids; 2 & 4 YO. They don’t hear the arguments after bed time and don’t understand the bruises yet but I know it’s just a matter of time. It would be so much harder not seeing my kids everyday than living with the pain, loneliness and lost friendships. But I’m tired. And so sad. Lost. So alone. Does anyone have something that turned it around? He changed? You changed so he did? Ayahuasca retreat maybe?

like

730 GMAT. Unknown LAC UG, 0.5 years in Industry. Top 10 business school master and 3 years experience in tech consulting at PwC (1.5 years as senior). Asian Female. Target on M7. Any chance?

funny

Anybody have a mba consultant/consulting company they would highly recommend?

like

Best/most interesting questions to ask admissions reps or current students?

likefunny

Is it ok to take a gap year premba? How would that appear to future employers?

likehelpfulfunny

Suggestions for places to visit in Maine (3-4 days) during mid of october?

like

Any tips for securing freelance work with US agencies when you live abroad? My work is pretty solitary and I could fly in for workshops or a major presentation.

like

If you’re in the final stages of interviewing with multiple companies at the same time and they inquire about other offers and interviews, should you tell them? Obviously not who the other company is but at least that you’re interviewing / expecting another offer?

like

Is there an online marketplace for SquareSpace portfolio templates, i.e., a place where you can buy a template, download it, then build it yourself? Alternatively, is there a place where I can hire someone to recommend a SquareSpace template, gussy up said template with type and/or color tweaks to make it less template-y (no functionality changes needed), and then design a simple logo? Looked at Squarespace Experts but seems a bit intense for what I need. Google isn't giving me much.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal