My girlfriend has an offer from McKinsey (and several others from T2 firms) but she's worried about the reputation of having a "cut throat" culture instead of one that's more collaborative. Her interactions with the recruiting team indicated that they have improved but obviously they are a bit biased. Can anyone with experience weigh in on what the culture is really like?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Mckinsey. Much better for her longer term.

like

If she has an offer from McKinsey and several others, trust me she has what it takes . She should take McKinsey

like
Recent IconRecent

She should go to McKinsey

like

Lol what a problem to have

likeuplifting

McK is not cut-throat, partly because advancement is based on your own progress. Other people getting promoted can’t prevent you from doing so.

This is profoundly important to a positive culture as opposed to companies where promotion often can only happen when someone moves out or dies, regardless of how much you’ve developed.

It is true that some larger offices are less ‘warm’, but having been in or served 20+ big companies that’s virtually always true.

Challenging absolutely but don’t put that on others. The pressure comes from the self.

like

Thanks for your response M2. What hours do you typically work M-R?

FWIW I felt the same as your gf and haven’t felt it to be very cut throat at all.

like

Marketing and sales

like

This isn’t even a question. Better for her resume to go to McKinsey for 12 months (even if she hates it) than to spend multiple years at a tier 2.

like

She is worried about the wrong things

like

Depends on your priorities I guess. There are more variables in her equation than future career opportunities.

like

What office is she going to? That’s going to impact culture more than anything else

like

Worst is NYO. Chicago is amazing! Laidback and non-competitive, from my experience.

I mean she should take McKinsey no matter what really by comparing to her other offers, but I’ve really liked working here! :)

like

Take it

What’s her long term goals? If she wants to use this as a career springboard go with McKinsey. If she’s serious about making a career of it or 5+ years, consider other firms. But if McK is offering her a position it means they think she can cut it there.

She's looking for more of a mid to long term thing. Not a 2 year stint before MBA (already has her MS) but probably not partner. Ultimately looking to learn about business and exploring what industry she wants before exiting at a director or VP level.

GO TO McK. There is only option here.

Take Mck - it’s too cut throat - jump in a year to a T2 and get a pay raise

I am happy where I am.

First world problems.

What’s her background and what does she do?

Related Posts

Tips for interview as Senior PM for D365? Also, what sort of Salary range is fair if asked? (Based in Tx) 5yoe, MBA, 6 yrs military.

like

Anyone at Ogilvy Consulting? Can we chat?

like

Hello Guys... I just saw an article about Nokia laying off around 1500 employees in India and it was from TOI.
Can anyone confirm about the job security at Nokia as I'll be joining it in coming weeks?
Thanks in advance

Hi! Does anyone know anything about the company Rently? Remote? Great environment? I can’t find anything on here, Indeed, or Glassdoor. Thank you!

like

Got an opportunity with PwC, Global Information Reporting team. Any suggestions? 49% Hike

like

Hello guys. Can anyone please tell me about the work life balance and culture in teradata ? I am selected as an abinitio developer but not sure if they have development projects or only support ones.
Any suggestions are really appreciated.
Thanks in advance !!

like

Hi Sharks,
What is the average hike at walmart every year?

like

Any recommendation after 13 years experience in data engineering how to hunt job in walmart?

like

Received an offer from EY FSO.
Coming in as an SC2 with a comp of 115k with a 5k moving comp to move to NYC.

I have 5 YOE in financial services and 1 YOE in consulting.

Wanted to gather any information on what to target as an offer? Should I be targeting 130k base? EY

like

Can someone please help me with the holiday Calendar for HSBC Bangalore ?

like

Do HSBC BANGALORE, do they give you joining bonus?

like

Hi fishes,

I had my pdm and salary negotiation round on 12th may with ibm. But still there is movement in the portal.
Its still in application under review status.

like
like

Phone interviewed with Amazon hiring manager, and was told by HR that are still waiting for more details on the next steps after 1 week. What does this mean?

Hi anyone working in BDO RISE LLP FS AWM sector- if yes, please let me know how is the work pressure and culture

Could an AWS Solutions Architect chime in on the supposedly bad work life balance at AWS? Is it really true?

like

Whats the work life and culture at Nvidia in India? How does it compare with other product companies ?Nvidia Intel Corporation Qualcomm

like

Is their a Post Merger integration/ deals team in DUSI Kolkata?

like

How's IBM for Oracle Cloud SCM ?

More Posts

Hi.....Looking for suitable opportunity. I am new here.

Post Photo
like

Hi All, I am a Consultant working at Big4 moving to Singapore. Would be looking for accommodation from Dec 1st? Anyone wishing to find a place around that time.. DM me.. we can try to find a place together.

like

Hey 🐠. A buddy of mine is building up CR at a small-mid sized agency... what tools, resources, conferences would you recommend as must explore for someone who is leading and growing the dept?

What will be the procedure after accepting offer letter in CGI? Is it virtual onboarding and when will we receive link? I see to report office on joining day in offer.. CGI

like

Hi Fishes,
I have an experience of 6 years in Production and Application Support. I have worked as middleware administrator as well for Jboss and Weblogic.
But due to the diminishing demands of the role in IT industry , I am planning to switch my career in Devops or AWS which would help me grow.
But I am not sure without any practical knowledge, will I get a job at this many years of experience in a different profile.
Do companies hire for AWS profiles with good packages at beginners level?

like

What’s the typical salary progression like from analyst to senior analyst to consultant for Strategy and Consulting?

like

Hi Fellow Fishes,

Good Day! I have got offer from
HCL Technologies
My YOE is 3 years(Tech stack- Oracle DBA) and CTC I got is 10 LPA gross.
Will it be worth joining hcl at this PKG considering I am switching from TCS. Or should I take retention offer of 8.5 LPA.
Please give your advice.

like
like

Today someone quit and just straight up walked out of the office. Like something you'd see in a movie. My jaw is still open. You ever seen this happen?

likefunnyupliftingsmart

I have 2 offers 1 from Cognizant And 1 from Volkswagen IT Services India Pvt. Ltd.
I am really confused regarding which to join.
I have 2 years experience as java developer and looking to work in latest technologies i.e. spring boot and Microservices as a developer .

Kindly suggest

like

Have 20k, what’s a good small business to start with this fund? Serious question here

like

How bad is the attrition in your team/company?

like

Best movie ever?

like

Do you pay attention to BTC or ETH funding rates? Does it impact your trading/investment strategy?

like

Anyone here have any information on where to invest your money apart from the firm's 401k match? New to investing and wanted to know where do other people invest since most of them wouldn't be investing in stocks directly.

like

Hi Folks,

Recently in sodexo, another card got activated that is multi benefit pass and it says i can use this money for apparels,bill payments and at petrol pumps.. is this real? No physical card is given yet.. did any 1 tried this card? if yes, could you please guide me?

like

Hi All,

I have 4 yrs of exp as full stack developer and my current CTC is 15 lpa and notice period is of 3 months. I got an offer from another firm for 24lpa but they have shared the offer letter of DOJ after 2 months and asked me to negotiate my notice period or look for buyout. What should I do in this case? Should I connect with my current hr to negotiate? Cause I tried convincing the new hr to share the offer letter of DOJ after 3 months but she is not in the favour of that.

like
like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Best online course on Personal Finance?

like

When did you know it was time to quit?

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Calling MBBers... please help my company increase revenue... please

like

I have a n offer from another firm and ey also gave me an offer from one of their new practices. If I take the other firm now, would that be an issue?

like

Any book recommendations for philosophy, psychology, and business? Or any book you read last year changed your values? Going to fly international, gonna read it on flight. 😍

like

many of us couldn’t live at home during or after college, and after working, graduated with debt. If you finished ugrad with student loans, how much in loans, what’s your current age and net worth

like

Deloitte fish: I’m an alum trying to do some retirement planning. I was an SM2 vested in the pension plan (I worked in DTTL for 7 years ending 2013) and want to find out what my actual benefits will be and at what age. I have no paperwork and 800-Deloitte does not seem to have a way to route me to the right people. Does anyone have a human contact or procedure that can help me get this info?

like

Fellow goof balls, how much do you limit your goofiness at work? I’m a straight up clown but maintain stoic asian perception, wondering how much to let loose. Thoughts?

like

Hi all,
I’m currently working for a small technical consulting start-up firm. I make good money, have great benefits, and they seem very happy with the work I’m doing, so I know I could move up quickly. However, tech consulting is definitely not my dream job. I want to get into data analytics, and I have an offer from a big company to do just that. I’ve only been at my current company for about 8 months, but I don’t ever see myself loving this job. How do I know when it’s time to make a change?

like

Interviewing at EY with 1 yr experience for senior consultant role. What can I expect compensation wise given I get the job?

like

Any advice on how to switch from big 4 to tier 1 consulting firms like BCG and MCK?

like

For those that have been laid off, how’s the job search going? Have you gotten offers fairly quickly (I.e. 2-4 weeks after getting the notice)?

like

How do I phrase to leadership that I want to change managers?

like

Best way to study for AWS cloud practitioner certification? (Not very technical but hoping to learn)

like

How do you make the most of travel? I’ve been targeting The Who’s who in the restaurant world but I’ve been packing on the pounds! Other ideas? Or just suck it up and realize it’s all just work?

like

Is anyone running a small nonprofit on the side in addition to consulting? I am planning to start one to carry out some of my passion work. (Any books, courses, places to start?)

like

Best consulting companies in the social sector?

like

Describe your week in a meme or image

Post Photo
likefunny

Trying to pack for 2 weeks 😩 how do I fit the shoes/boots?!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal