Urgent!
I received an offer from Amazon today, and I countered while adding I think the offer presented was lower than I expected based on my YoE and research I've done. I ended my counter with asking if he could increase his offer. He responded with "Your counter is out of scope for what we can offer. I understand of this isn't the best option for you. Your time interviewing with us is appreciated. "

WTH did he just take back the offer?? This is supposed to be a negotiation! Help!

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I talked to the HM and she said the recruiter can't retract an offer without the HM approval. So they countered back and I accepted. I start in 2 weeks.

likesmart

Hey Brother, can you get me a job in Amazon? Would be a great help!

like

Consider this a blessing. I think you now know everything you need to know about the hiring manager and team.

likesmarthelpful

Something like this happened to me once (not Amazon) and I said I was sorry to hear that, and asked to negotiate other things (bonus, stock, etc) if the salary wasn’t negotiable. I ended up getting a bigger bonuses, more money for relocation and a slightly (10k) larger base.

likehelpful

How far apart was their offer and your counter?

Part of negotiation is being willing to walk away and that goes for both sides.

like

AC1 - I mean…math is math. 50k more TC is a huge jump regardless of where it comes from. People act like RSUs /equity etc is like candy and easier to give away but as someone who has started/sold a company I can tell you that is not the case. And even if Amazon had a bajillion to give away it doesn’t make sense to bring TC higher if it’s not in alignment with market value or current team TC, etc.

like

Is there any update here OP? Curious how this panned out.

likesmart

They may have other just as qualified applicants or your offer was too far outside the range they are able to offer. If they can’t pay you want you want, it’s better to walk away anyway. They can’t hire you and risk you making more than your supervisor. Your TC may have put into the next level and that’s a bad place to be.

like

Can u share the numbers?

likesmart

Be grateful. I think you may have dodged a bullet. Remember the articles about how Amazon encourages employees to knock each other down? I used to live on the bus line to the Amazon headquarters and actually witnessed it. Most everyone I have met who works for them hates their job.

like

The boss of Amazon didn't become the richest man in the world by chance.

like

Rule #1: Don't counter the mighty Amazon who have an endless line of people trying to work there.

likesmart

Don't forget, sometimes you can price yourself out of a role. They might have some flexibility to make you a Senior this or Lead that but if you go outside the brackets for the role, that probably means they'll need to backfill it with someone else as your responsibilities in the higher role may well be different to what you originally applied for.

like

It doesn’t sound like they have receded their offer. If you want the job, let them know you are happy to take the position and ask for a greater sign-on bonus.

like

Should have gave a number but that is weird

I did give a number but I never said "it's this or nothing" and I ended by asking if there's room to negotiate.

likefunny

In the first sentence, it seems like he wants to stick with the original offer. You should have negotiated other things like bonuses and other benefits. The last sentence sounds like he wants to end the negotiation.

Something I’ve learned is that HMs can (wrongfully) want to keep their org costs low to allow for more headcount. The nay should come from TA, NOT the HM.

What r u joining as ?

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

What is the expected in hand salary for the salary quoted below and assuming tax savings of 1,50,000 through 80C and HRA of 35,000 per month

Basic: 15,22,500
Flexible allowances: 25,71,567
Provident fund: 1,82,700
Monthly gross: 3,62,000

like

Hi everyone, I have endorsed a friend and he is in consideration for a role as a CSE. How long does it take for the interviews to start ?

Can some confirm me what is the take home salary after all the deductions? Company HCL

Post Photo
like

Anyone have background/ can share information on ECS for federal/management consulting roles? Currently going through interview process.

like

Is it Bad to change the Sector from 'IT' and move into 'Investment Banking sector'?
Work Profile - Project Management Office
Some people say once you move out from the IT sector, there is no chance of getting back to IT.
Is this really true?

Please guide me.
Will it be good to accept the offer?

I'm working with an IT MNC in PMO profile and got an offer for the same profile but with the Investment Bank.

YoE- 3.
Current CTC- 9.5lakh (Pune)
Offered CTC- 16lakh (Mumbai)

like

Does anyone know the starting salary for Jackson Lewis in the firm's Connecticut office, as well as the billable hours requirement?

like

Hi,

I just want to know a fact , upto which ctc can be adjusted to minimal tax deduction under new slab?
Like 15lpa ,20lpa

like

Hi Fishes, I've got an offer from CGI that is less than 10 LPA. Then I got offer from other company that is 14 LPA. Can CGI match that offer? (YOE - around 3 years) #CGI

How much time does Infosys takes to share the offer letter and proceed with documentation and stuff. I have cleared 2 rounds of interview and still waiting for HR to contact me.

like

Hi All I have an offer of 30 lpa ,yoe-9 years at Publicis resources,any leads on how is the company?wlb,job security and other perks?,thanks...
Designation -Business Analyst?is it similar to a lead or managerial role?

like

Hi Everyone, I interviewed at Deloitte Australia last month and as of now there is no update on feedback. Talent point of contact is saying that he is still awaiting feedback from interviewers as there are not responding to him. Should I consider this is as ghost or negative output.

I started in my first SDR position in a small SaaS start up few months ago. I am the only SDR and their first ever.
The base salary is ok but I haven’t received any commission structure up to this day.
I book an average of 3-5 demos per week. People always show up, but the thing that worries me is that I do not have a way to track how many meetings I book in our CRM,and to be honest I feel like I didn’t get the best training overall. Should I start looking somewhere else? Thoughts?

Thanks

likehelpful

I'll be applying for a Service Desk manager position in the coming months. I'm looking to get a realistic salary range (online ranges vary drastically). I have 7 years experience in IT end user support. 4 years of these 7 years include having direct reporting employees in a supervisory role.

What is an average salary of senior BA?

like

The division I work at seems to have some weird shady Ora’s about it, unexplained spending, intentional lack of raise’s, and pay scales that are all over the map. Do I go above my supervisor to bring this to attention or do I just Run! Problem is I like my coworkers enough to not want to see them taking it in the dirty end if they do a corporate review?
What to do, what to do?

like

Can anyone tell me the difference between a senior and lead validation engineer( no direct reports in both cases) in Pharma/ biotech ? I am not sure what’s the hierarchy and which level must get a higher salary. Or is it just referenced interchangeably in different companies ?

My interview is scheduled with PS, i have 4+ years of experience as Automation QA. My current CTC is 9.81 how much can I ask them now?

like

Is there any variable pay included in Virtusa for lateral hires or is it only fixed pay? Virtusa

Hello folks!
Wondering what is the ideal package for a 5+ years exp with AI and Deep learning skillset?

like

Hi fishes

How is work life balance for Manager role and what is the salary band for Manager position?

like

More Posts

COME JOIN US!!!

Post Photo
like

Love this bowl! Here's my memorial day avotoast + taters

Post Photo
like

How many days walmart takes to roll out an offer. My hr round happened on Friday 24 June still no updates

like

Would like to organize events/speaker panels throughout the year, to highlight and empower the latinx group at my agency, are there any ideas or groups I should reach out to to help kick this off?

likehelpful

Anyone here familiar with the medical records field reviewer positions at Change Healthcare? Looking to get a little more info on schedule, workload, and pay specifically. TIA!

like

Which advisory group has the least travel out of AAS, FDD/TAS, and risk advisory? Or is it all dependent on the client and team nowadays? And is the travel schedule comparable to consulting? (ex. M-Th on a plane)

Any suggestions on what to ask during an introduction interview? First time in a corporate setting, going for an experienced associate role!

like

What are my chances at M7?

White male, 3.6 GPA at top public school (like UVA), 700 GMAT, 3.5 years work experience (2y in big 4 MC, 1.5y in corp dev), letter of rec from HBS grad CFO of my company.

like

Every day is Monday

like
likefunny

Has anyone here ever been sued by an agency? I’ve had a few places recently ask me to be insured. And was bugged out. Ended up being a good experience but still.

like

With so many layoffs and the strange uncertainty of this industry right now—is anyone scared to death?

likehelpful

What should be the avg salary of an IC4 in Oracle? YOE: 8 Position: Principle Software Engineer

like

Since I can’t really post anywhere else rn lol, I’d love some feed back on this offer I received. It my first one for a pr account coordinator in nyc: 45k, pto 17 days (but doesn’t start until next year) and thats pretty much it. I have 1 yoe + master’s and I plan to negotiate but working out how much

like

*Checks watch* Yup about that time

Post Photo
likefunny

90 minutes in a nutshell

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Hi people actually i got a call on 30th april that you have been selected to Barclays but still on the career portal it's showing completed. But the hr has told me the joining date but i didn't received anything

like

Any pharmacists on here? I am trying to read a label and the notation doesn’t make sense.

Oral Solution 100mg/M

What unit is M? Is that pharmacist for milliliters (ml)?

like

Hi Fishes,
What are general responsibilities of BA4 designated employee in Barclays as Salesforce developer?

like

Hi Fishes,
My brother completed his MBA from a good institute and am currently a CFA L2candidate (appeared from my exam in August 2022). He is working with Capgemini for an leasing investment bank client. He has approx 2.5 years of experience and is interested in roles like FP&A, Financial Modeling, Portfolio/risk management, valuations or fixed income. Would appreciate referral in Financial Services companies please.

like

Additional Posts in Tech

someone please save me from ad agency land 😩 im a catch of a hire for a data analyst. i specialize in marketing measurement 📊

like

If I move to the Bay Area from Austin, are there any major negatives that will be really hard for me?

like

I’m new in tech and curious why people consider product so…intense? Sorry about my ignorance on this topic or if my question is too vague. I don’t get it either

like

Has anyone received an offer from GitLab recently? How long did they give you to decide? I have an offer coming from them plus a couple other companies and am trying to figure out timing to hopefully consider all of the offers at the same time.

like

I'll switch to a startup as the only data engineer and will closely work with all the Head ofs + the CTO.

Any advice/books/... on stakeholder management at that level? Especially when things fail/discussing budgets/new hires etc.

like

How do referrals work? Do you apply first or wait for the referral, then apply? Looking for a tiktok referral.

like

Been trying an abundance mindset. It's put me in debt.

likefunny

Hi do you interview from time to time just to check what’s your market worth?

like

What happens to your shares if you are partially, or not even 1 yr vested at a pre-IPO company and the company goes public? When you continue on your vesting schedule, what price do you purchase your vested shares at?

like

My take home interview question is literally online. I don't want to cheat, but I've already seen the solution...

like

What is the common salary of a Java developer in Canada?

like

I got a job as a infrastructure consultant right out of college 3 years ago and later became a solutions architect at the company I am at now. I have a degree in CS and never really got the chance to use my programming skills (Java, python, Springboot framework). I’m finding that I’m not really in to platform engineering or cloud infrastructure and would like to pivot to software/app development. And suggestions on where I could get started on making this transition?

like

I've been building a side project with my friend, but they're not putting in as much effort as I am. We've been friends since we entered college together, but it's starting to become too much. Should I talk to them about it?

like

EPMs at Apple - what’s your TC like? Interested in knowing base and rsu range. I’d appreciate your help. Thanks! Apple

like

If you had to choose between Microsoft and Facebook (in the Bay Area), which would you work for? Dreaming for the future...

like
like

Can anyone at GitHub give me a referral? 👀

like

Hey folks. Any thoughts on EPAM Systems? How are they to work for?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal