When ad agencies black ball former employees — how do they do it? What happens when a hiring company manager calls to confirm employment dates? Is there a code word for do not hire that person? Think Breakfast at Tiffany’s/Sally Tomato/the weather report

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I do think the concern over being blacklisted is mostly needless, unless you did something illegal/truly out of bounds. Also? Turnover is so high, institutional memory is basically zero.

like

This almost happened to a freelancer for me at Publicis - offer was out then we were told the person was a “do not hire” at the last minute. RM ended up inquiring further and someone reversed the decision / said it was an error…after she came on to the team, I’m pretty sure it wasn’t an error- she was a grifter who was working multiple full time jobs and would disappear for long stretches.

Blacklisting only really works within a holding company or an individual agency. Holding companies do have systems in place but yeah I’d assume that after a few years it might not matter.

The bigger issue is the word of mouth. Ad world is a small world and people will talk.

likesmart

It depends on who you pissed off tbh. Depending on employment law where you live, they can’t say anything outright negative to someone who calls for a reference but they will say next to nothing which says everything.
I had a partner that pissed off a CCO with a lot of pull. They had to move across the country to find work at a marketing firm because agencies wouldn’t hire them.

like

There’s a field in our HRIS that indicates whether someone is “eligible for rehire” and it’s rare for someone not to be. The times I’ve seen it is when someone is a legal risk (have had verified complaints against them or they made a legal claim in the past)

like

Wouldn’t doing that due to a legal claim be retaliatory? I kind of assumed this was the case. I had a case in the past I could have pursued, but figured the payout wouldn’t be anything close to making it worth killing 25 years of my future earning potential.

In my experience, recruiters ask HR if they are eligble for rehire. Or the recruiter will ask the former managers if they would want the person back.

like

It’s a tiny industry, so what you’re describing doesn’t happen via HR. They’ll usually call someone they know personally and get whatever uncensored version that person has.

like

Don’t — I repeat, DO NOT — poop on anyone’s desk. People don’t actually find it funny. Learned that the hard way.

like

Not sure actual black balling exists. But an agency calling a trusted friend for an opinion on a potential hire is very common. And the industry is small. So, if a prominent former employer has a negative opinion of you, it can have the same effect.

I think it’s more a word of mouth thing. This is a small industry—even smaller if you’re in a specific niche. Chances are you’re applying somewhere where someone you’ve working with in the past also works, if not multiple people. They will be asked about you, and if you burnt any bridges or had any issues, chances are this will be communicated to the hiring manager

Related Posts

What watch do you wear? I've been wearing an Omega Seamaster Professional Chronometer since Pierce Brosnan was playing 007. 😋

like

Want to start using one of those casting sites to try to get gigs but I’m afraid of getting scammed in some way. Anyone ever experienced something like this with an agency?

like

Who’s your favorite person you’ve ever had to interview?

like

As other global firms are calling their employees back to office ? Will pwc ac follow the same or will continue to provide option of working from home .

What questions to expect in ubs UI dev interview for 4 years exp candidate. Can someone share their experience

Need advice. I’m at my first job in private accounting. Previous experience is as an auditor. I am struggling to figure out the way JEs are posted at my current company. It’s never straightforward even for simple entries. There’s things like settlements which confuse the crap out of me. I’m curious if it’s just my company or if every sophisticated accounting department will have non traditional ways of posting their journal entries.

like

I am on a career break looking for domain transition into Analytics. More than one year I am not having job. My previous experience was of 1 year and 9 months in Content Engineering not experience of Analytics. Please help me.

like

SCARED MONEY DONT MAKE MONEY. BUY NOK 🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀

like

Does anyone know if Timothy Keller is still preaching in NYC? Otherwise church recommendation for NyC ? Will be flying in from Europe so evening service would be great !

like

Anyone work for Uber? Thoughts on culture, benefits, etc..?

like

I'm a corporate slave, whether I have a hangover from Thursday night or not, whether I'm tired or not , sleepy or not ; I must go to work.

like

Any advice on how to improve embryo growth drop off rate? Just finished our second retrieval and I’m frustrated by how many dont make it to blastocysts. We have good fertilization rate through ICSI. Is it normal for about 25% of fertilized eggs to make it to day 6/7? Husband has low count & motility and i have endo, both 33

like

Thoughts on serial dating, via social media apps?

like

Any romantic date ideas in Manhattan for an anniversary? Would also love ideas for nice restaurants with outdoor seating. Thanks!

like

I am so beyond ready to leave my current job, but can’t yet, since bonuses are paid out in January. 😬

In the meantime, I’ve applied to a lot of similar roles (slightly higher) but have not heard - good or bad - from any. Is it common for companies to slow down hiring in December because of Q4 rush, people on holiday, etc.?

like

What is meaning of BGC scheduled.in ibigin.. I submitted all background verification documents..

like

Any company (consulting or others) still sponsoring h1b visa or green card for new hires?

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Advertising

Looking to learn more about the people behind the agencies. Could anyone tell me who’s actually driving the best work at:

-WK
-Droga5
-Martin
-Goodby Silverstein

Feel free to call out any top talent from an agency not listed above.

likefunny

I'm reading this book on boundaries. In the work section it says I should tell my boss that I can't work after 5 PM. Knowing that advertising work commonly goes past 5 PM...would my job be in danger if I said that?
There's not really a rule book that says I must work until the work is done even though it's an unsaid expectation. Thoughts?

like

Didn’t know who the CCO is when I was asked about it in an interview... is there anything I can do to redeem myself? I feel like I really dropped the ball on this lol

likefunny

Remind me why they got rid of Greg Hahn in the first place? Too expensive?

funnylike

Don’t ask me why but would anyone know where I could download McDonald’s font? Preferably for free... I think it’s called Speedee? I can’t find it anywhere... help

like

Time to hire—I've seen dozens of fledgling lists/databases of available creative talent & diverse talent. Which ones are people actually using?

like

Giphy said it's delivering 1 billion giphs a day. Does Giphy support advertising?

like

Considering taking a Jr CW job in pharma in NYC after being on the job hunt for 9 months. I’m terrified of getting stuck, but I also want to switch to brand strategy. Chances of escaping if I hate it?

like

👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼
A-list #2!! And congrats to wieden I guess whatever

Post Photo
likefunny

Calling all managers with junior, intern and mid teams: Who is taking (or is being given) the time to train their juniors on the necessary hard and soft skills? If not, what’s stopping you from providing that support?

like

I find it insane that recruiters have been calling me on Teams. How is that ok and not seen as disruptive?

likefunny

What do you guys think of JvM / Sports these days?

like

Hi friends, I am reading this book ‘radical cander’ and was wondering if you have Fav way/ example of receiving and giving tough feedback? Or have any stories about feedback that have stuck with you through your career.

like

What was your most amazing day in advertising?

likeuplifting

I need infographic tips please!

likefunny

How do some of y’all manage to go 2+ years without a raise? Like are you just really good at budgeting?

like

give this man a raise.

Post Photo
likefunny

How many of you have met your significant other at work?

like

Brands closing for climate change? Wouldn’t that lost income be more effective/useful if they donated it to clean energy alternatives instead? Do a spot about it to promote it & it’s content. Win. Win

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal