Why do advisors say not to pay off your mortgage? Mine is 7.3% and I’d like to get rid of it over the next few years and be debt free. I’ve been told liquidity is preferable and while I have retirement, I would be illiquid while I build the reserves back up. Not sure I understand the rationale for not paying off the mortgage.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Does the advisor charge a percent of AUM? If so, you paying off your mortgage directly impacts their fee

likesmart

Assets under management, the total value of the assets you have which you pay them to manage for you (generally an investment account of yours which they manage how to invest on your behalf).

Some charge a fee based on AUM (say 1% of the AUM per year), and others charge a flat fee or different fee schedule, regardless of the AUM. As it relates to this thread, if you were to pay off your mortgage faster instead of throwing that money at investments and they charged a fee based on AUM, you’d have fewer assets invested for them to make money on.

like
Recent IconRecent

I got 6.125% 4 years ago. At that time I didn’t want to be above a certain amount of $ interest paid over the life of the loan but that required me to budget monthly extra payments that were a bit on the high side so I settled for 500 extra month which would save me 8 years and over 200k in interest. Recently, I have started using my annual tax returns to pay off extra principal and hopefully shave off another few years. I wish I was making partner /md salary which could potentially allow me to pay off much sooner. 500 extra a month allows me to sleep better that I’m not paying the bank an extra 200k and that I will at least pay off 8 years before full term. And also at the same time have enough liquid funds to invest, however small.

like

About 2500/ month into taxable investments and other vehicles.

I lost my job earlier this year and plan to have my mortgage paid off by the time my severance runs out. Luckily, we were already within a year of paying it off anyway so it's just a nine month escalation. Since I haven't had any luck finding another job, knowing that our largest debt will no longer be hanging over our heads is huge to me, even though we have a low interest rate. Not having a large monthly financial obligation is more important to me than investing my money elsewhere right now. I can't wait to send in that final payment in a few months! Plus. our mortgage interest was so low that we couldn't even get the advantage of itemizing it on our taxes anymore so why continue to carry debt that we don't have to carry?

like

When it comes to your credit score, a mortgage paid timely every month has the greatest positive impact on your score. There are also the tax benefits of mortgage interest which this year made zero difference for me. These are mostly why. If you are prioritizing paying off debt start with the one withbthe highest interest rate. If the mortgage is all thats left and you want to pay it and are not interested in more debt, then pay it off if you want to.

like

Why do advisors recommend to not pay off the mortgage? It is because the law of compounding numbers works against early pay off vs. investment. Example: a $200K mortgage at 7.3% you will pay about $293,610 over 30 years. If you have $200K invested and receive an average of 7.3% return/year (same as the mortgage) you would gain ~$1.455m in interest. A $1.1M gain. However; as many have stated it is also personal. I have a 2.875% mortgage and yes I pay extra. Why it is personal choice. I want to be debt free when I go into retirement and yes, I do plan to invest my mortgage payment once I pay it off.

like

The math here is wrong.

smart

paid my home off in 10 years and it had a 112% increase in value in the time. sure I could have invested that money, but now i’m in a position where I have much more cash in hand each month because of no morgage payment. I can invest it if I want, I can do whatever I want with that money without waiting for things to grow or any sort of rules or stipulations. very freeing and even tho my interest rate was quite low at 3%. id do the whole thing again in a heart beat. I actually would have started paying it off early even sooner if given the chance.

smart

The calculation includes taxes, inflation, and what you might have made investing those funds in something else.

F

Because they would rather invest your money themselves

It really is more of an emotional decision in your situation. At 7.3%, that is a pretty decent rate of return compared to a 70/30 portfolio. Some will say, historical returns over time say the market will out pace that but what if we go into a bear market like the lost decade starting in '08? It sounds like it is a piece of mind thing for you so that should carry significant weight. If you do pay it off, immediately apply for a HELOC so you have cheap access to the equity in an emergency. It costs you almost nothing and if you never tap it, no harm, no foul.

Your mortgage interest can be a tax write off.

But you only recoup your tax bracket rate x the interest in dollars.

e.g. You pay 1,000 in interest. Your tax rate is 25%.

You would reduce your taxes by $250.

Meanwhile you still pay $750 in interest.

The tax write off is usually only a factor when calculating the viability of an investment property.

Being free of personal debt will free up that $1,000 (plus the rest of your mortgage payment) for real investments with the possibility of actual earnings.

I do itemize so it does help me. But it deceases and caps out ofer time. So not applicable over the life of the loan, sadly.

They are wrong. Paying it off is the same as earning 7.3%, which is significantly higher than the rate on a CD account. If your rate were much lower, that would not be true. Of course, you start by paying off whatever debt that has a higher rate first.

But is the OP's marginal investment a CD?

What I was told in the past was you want to keep a mortgage, as your property tax is rolled into it. This makes it smaller, broken up month-over-month and easy to manage. The pitfall for some people with no mortgage is that they don’t always plan for it and get a huge property tax bill that they can’t pay. Take it for what it’s worth.

if your home is paid off and you’re not planning for a tax bill meanwhile you have no mortgage each month. that’s a skill issue lol

Related Posts

Hoping for help w/ studying. TRANSACTION CYCLES?? I see inconsistent lists online and in books: (Revenue, Purchasing, Inventory, Payroll) vs (Sales, Purchasing, Payroll, Financing) vs....

like

Any recommendations on alternatives to the Patagonia vest? Looking for something similar without a logo plastered on the front but still slim fitting, and having some trouble. Thank you!

like

I’ve been with my company for 4 years and I’m thinking about applying for a new job. For references, I would like to use my coworkers but I also don’t want to bring up the fact that I’m applying to other places. How should I handle my references when it comes to applying or interviewing with other companies?

like

Has anyone used Google AdWords, or hired a firm to target and re-target?

like

Which firms that pay market have no hours requirements for bonus?

like

I accepted an offer to work at an Am Law 100 firm in June. I just graduated law school in May. They offered a stipend and reimbursement for bar expenses. I am currently still waiting for any word on when the money will come. They have not started onboarding me or anything. Should I be concerned? Why are they dragging their feet? I have contacted them 3 times since June.

like

Hi all,
I need your favour here.
Do anyone has job referral for Business Analyst profile?

About me: 3.4yrs of workex-
Worked as a Sales Manager and across sales-Ops. 75% Team management+ 25% Data analysis and interpretation
Want to shift towards more data driven role.
I know advance Excel and SQL fundamentals.
Last drawn Ctc: 14lpa fixed

Any leads/suggestions would be helpful.

Thankyou :-)

like
like

Big 4 : How would you evaluate this offer in consulting : 170 k, HCOL, 9 yoe, Manager in HCOL?

like
like
like

Anyone have experience with rentopia for Brooklyn listings? They seem to control most listings in the area I’m looking and are very unresponsive

like

Anyone still being asked to come into the office for pitches?

like

Hi guys,

Which companies wait fir 90 days notice period?

I am wanting to change bt its really really difficult bcuz of Notice period.

Pls help

What's the dress code, is it strictly formal or smart casuals.

like

Partners, what are signs/examples that a project’s leadership is prioritizing the clients needs over the team beyond the normal ‘nature of client service’? Is a convo is worth it?

like

Feeling like it's only a matter of time before I have to tell the new marketing dept head that the snazzy jargon just makes him sound like a tryhard and alienates our customer base

like

Wipro sends welcome kit via frens and petals?? Wipro HCL Technologies Tata Consultancy Infosys Accenture IBM

like

Additional Posts in FIRE Financial Independence Retire Early

I would like to hit fire between 40-50. Currently 27, 185k total comp (125 for me and 60 for partner). Like my job don’t hate it don’t love it. Does an MBA make sense? I’m guessing it could take me to 170ish with that schools I’m looking at but wondering if the 40-50 retirement range makes an mba not make sense since I’d only have 10-20 years to save vs 12-22.

Would have to finance the whole thing myself. Current net worth is 140k. Thoughts?

like

Where online can you invest in rental properties/real estate as a non-accredited investor?

like

Need an opinion on the Vanguard VIGAX/VIGIX. I’m index riding with that fund but am wondering if I should shift my risk and go with VT or another Vanguard fund. Thoughts?

like

Since the fed rate is now zero.. What does thst mean for mortgage rates and savings rates? They gonna plummet to nearly 0%?

like

Saving for a house down payment in the next 20-24 months. Where should I put my savings. Just in a savings account right now. Was thinking about ibonds, but is my timeframe too short?

like

Tax planning

Anyone has innovative ideas on how to reduce federal and state income taxes? I am in CA and my sources of income include salary, rental income, and some business income.

I already max out retirement benefits (401K, IRA, SepIRA etc.) and we have no kids.

like

If you had 2 mortgages at the exact same interest rate (1 is a 15 year and the other is a 30 year), does it make sense to put extra payments (say 400 per month) towards one or the other? Looking at it purely from a $ perspective in the long term (not psychological where You prepay the lower balance quicker to ultimately have only one loan).

15 year loan - 125k balance (renting this property out)
30 year loan - 400k balance (looking to buy this property soon)

like

How do people here reduce their tax bills? Me and my SO earn about 400k gross and take standard deduction. We don’t own real estate, only S&P500.

like

Anyone here from NYC? Be cool if there was a meetup.

like

Thoughts on staking crypto? What’s the safest way.

like

If you could right now, would you buy a house in full cash or invest in the market?

like

I think I need Ex bankers as friend and accountants. I need people who we can discuss deals in the swift world with from time to time. I need people with great ideas in my life

funny

Anyone know of a good cross-border US/UK financial fiduciary?

like

Should I be reducing my contribution to my 401k at the moment? Based on the drastic 🐻 market?

likehelpful

Have 700K USD worth of invested assets (less real estate, cash/receivables, and precious metals). if I need 4K USD per month for expenses, can I now coast?

like

Custodial or 529 for child?

like

Anyone here read “Die with Zero”? What are your thoughts on the principles from the book?

like

What to do when your spouse is on a diff tangent in terms of finances? My wife wants to spend spend spend and I want to save save invest.

like

At what investment size should you typically start using fee only financial advisors?

like

How to FIRE with kids? No kids for us yet but wife and I do FIRE and we’re wondering if it’s even possible with kids. Just takes longer maybe?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal