If you had 2 mortgages at the exact same interest rate (1 is a 15 year and the other is a 30 year), does it make sense to put extra payments (say 400 per month) towards one or the other? Looking at it purely from a $ perspective in the long term (not psychological where You prepay the lower balance quicker to ultimately have only one loan).

15 year loan - 125k balance (renting this property out)
30 year loan - 400k balance (looking to buy this property soon)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Might be wrong here but if you can get a better return in the market compared to the interest being paid, I think investing the money in a total market index fund will net more in the end

like

Thank you! yeah, I’ve considered that. I’ve generally been very risk averse though and am sitting on a lot of cash. But Am looking to retire early so decided to finally do something about it. I do have a good amount I can put towards both the total market index fund and towards mortgage, but trying to see if it makes sense to put it towards a higher balance or lower. Seeing the total interest at the end of 30 years scares me, but open to look at it holistically.

like

Assuming both are either personal or business related, it’s better to pay the shorter term/smaller balance one first. Both provide the same yield, but the shorter term provides liquidity/cash flow benefits much sooner.

like

Definitely not. If you have enough discipline to actually invest that extra money, the market will win out by a long shot over that time horizon. Absolutely no reason to put more money towards the mortgage.

like

So I’d have to check this on a spreadsheet but I think making the extra payments to the longer term will have a bigger impact because you will be paying interest on the open balance for longer.

like

Depends on your tax situation, but it is likely you should prepay the loan on your home property.

While it is likely your marginal home mortgage interest will be equally tax deductible as your rental as long as you itemize, once you are no longer able to itemize, your effective interest rate on your home mortgage will be higher than on your rental property, in which case you should definitely pay the home mortgage off first.

TLDR, if you plan to itemize, then makes no difference. If you don’t, pay off home first.

like

I did not consider this at all, so thank you for raising it. We’ve always been so far from itemizing especially since the standard deduction increased but this is good to consider.

like

From a pure $ perspective, put it towards the longer term.

Throw both those things into an amortization calculator and look at the monthly / yearly interest and principal composition. You’ll see the the longer term is more interest heavy at the front. Your regular monthly mortgage payment will stay constant, but if you pay down the principal with extra money, than more of each payment will go towards the principal!

like

That is purely a duration issue. If it’s the same interest rate, your annual rate of return is the same on either loan. Pure interest saved is meaningless

like

Mathematically it doesn’t matter - the rates are the same.

If I were to try to maximize $ saved without changing much from what you have provided - why not refinance the 15 year?

Assuming the only reason the 15 is higher than the 30 is because it was originated when rates were higher; 15 year should lower rate than the 30 year because of smaller term premium.

like

My lender mentioned that since the 15 year is now a commercial property, if I were to refinance it, I would get a commercial rate (apparently ~1% higher). I did think it would be sweet to get a rate of 2.375% otherwise for the 15 year

like

Look at the amortization schedule. You are making much higher principal impacts on the 15 yr from the start, so going toward the 15 yr will only increase the impact on principal reduction.

like

Thank you everyone. This is super helpful!

Related Posts

What other avenues are you using to increase income?

like

Can grad students get $20k forgiven if they got Pell in undergrad but outstaning loans are only for grad school?

like

How do Point of Sale companies (buy now pay later) offer 0% APR make money with customers who don't end up paying any interest due to having on-time payments.

I joined mindtree in Jan 2022. Suddenly there is a 10k deduction in salary in the month of April. The salary slip say 10k deduction as INCOME TAX.
Mindtree says "You come under 20% slab according to the income tax calculations. When all the tax slabs are applied you will have to pay yearly tax around Rs. X amount. So that amount will be deducted in monthly basis."
Why sudden income tax deduction? Why was that not deducted in the month of Jan Feb March ?
How can i recover that 10k every month?

SPG free nights vs. SPG cash& points. What would you do?

Aloft Clagary for 7000 points or 3500 points plus USD 55. Please advise.

like

Any advise on what agreement to put in place when planning to invest $15k-$20k into a friends start up business? Is this considered angel investment and would it be typical to ask for some percentage ownership like on the shark tank show? I don’t want any liability exposure so looking for an agreement that will isolate me from the operations of the business.

like

Thinking of signing a lease for 4.5k/month for a 3BR1BA in South End of ~1500 sqft…

Solid deal or is it easy to find better deals out there?

like

How do you balance wanting to sell higher-priced properties with the thought of them not selling because of how much they’re worth?

like

Has anyone successfully gotten your annual credit card fee waived?

like

Anyone have any area recommendations for buying a house in Houston but have regular commutes downtown? 300k max but would like a house (not a townhome/apartment).

like

**Can I take retirement?**
Hi All,
I have around 29 Lac savings + 5 Lac gold.
And my wife has 28 Lac gold(wedding gift) + 80 Lac(ancestral) Land.
We have a child, his current age is 2 years+
Currently our monthly expenses are around 22k(max), and my CCTC is 15 LPA+ with 8+ YOE.
My age is 29! I don't feel like working anymore.

like

Hi all! I’m new! I started the year off planning to save for a home for myself, then rates skyrocketed. So we’re holding off. Fast forward to the final quarter of the year and we were presented with the idea of a residential assisted living facility. The problem there is we’d still need to acquire property in order to run one. The only difference is the RAL would be a business and is already registered as such. Does anyone have any experience here?

like

Hello
I have joined Nagarro in oct
Want to transfer my pf fund from my old organisation. Where can I find pf account details which nagarro has created ?
Please help

like

I am just so happy with my realtor that helped me with my investment property purchase. Totally worth it. Really helped me navigate through the market and make wise decisions. If you are looking for a great realtor in Orange County, Long Beach, Los Angeles areas… please DM me. Happy to refer.

likefunny

Quick question - my package includes some fixed component for housing. Say if I spend less than that at actuals, I cannot claim the full amount?

Post Photo
like

Hi All,
Really need some input. We have our new construction done by April 2023. Builder is giving us 28,000 credits which can be used towards closing cost and buy lock rate for 6 months from now and giving us the interest rate for 6.75% for 30 years from US bank. But I also spoke to credit union they give us 5 ARM for 5.5% but can lock rate in feb 2023. So should go with the US bank with 6.75% plus incentives or wait till feb 2023 and thn lock rates(us bank doesn’t give us ARM rates).

like

I have 3 rentals and one primary, all rentals and primary are single family homes, all have 50% to 60%. in equity, I want to buy another property, this time a triplex or fourplex but I don’t want to refinance to pull cash out, what’s the most effective way to get a loan for a down payment to a another property. All suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!

like

Have you done a background check on yourself? Why/what error or issue did you find?

like

Saw a undergrad tuition at a private university in ny-51k tuition, R&B of 18k and fees of 1k, for a total of 70k per year. How can people afford this? What is going on with our education system.

like

Thinking about buying a home with my fiancé . We’re not married yet and would like to purchase a home first. What resources can I look at to learn more about purchasing/financing a home with someone else? Also have no idea where to even start, would also appreciate if anyone has any resources for a total new like me!

like

More Posts

PSA for the day.
We don’t want to be single, yet we look for a lot of excuses to be this way.
Everyone has work. Everyone has life, everyone has their own circumstances. Make time, put the effort. One call doesn’t take 5 min.
One text doesn’t take 1 min.
One “I’ll be busy today so we can talk later” doesn’t take 1 min.
Put in the effort. It’s free.

like

Who is the smartest boss you have worked under?

like

So lonely rn that I almost want to text every girl in my phone “miss you” and see who bites.

funnylikeuplifting

Regional Public Senior that left to be a Senior Internal Auditor at a bank. I have a really good reputation here, my CAE tells me regularly he’s glad I’m here. I don’t do any SOX, I only do operational and compliance audits. I also manage an enterprise high risk issue validation process. There is opportunity for me to progress to a VP over 5 years within IA, or 2 years in another department. But I don’t know if that’s what I want to do. What roles could my experience get me in the market?

like

This is a test!!! This is a test!!! Sjsjzjsidhdnnsnndndj ohcodchoshxaixhisxhiahxihwxibxisbwoxohxsohixhwihciwhxihwichwichishxiheihciehifeixhisbxiwbxibwixwibxiwbxiwbxisbxiwbxiwbxihexiheocheixhoenxowjxosnxosnxosjx

like

Hi All,

Is it better to join EY now as the recession looms, or should I get retained in my current company who are also offering to match the offer of EY.

Thanks

like

What is the band hierarchy order in Kyndryl?

like

General Logics here. Listen I need alla youse not to take my posts lightly just because I'm an A1. Listen I am intellectual at heart and mind, I'd make partna in 6 years if I set my eyes too it, or hell even own the whole firm for that matta But I take it slowly baby, so don't let the title fool you for a second. Listen and listen with your eyes and ears open when I tawk.

like

Shouldn't it say "...fuel *imported* from Russia...?" C'mon EY, you can do better than this crap.

Post Photo
funnylikesmart

Hiring multiple positions in Tech/Sales at Fintech GRIP.
Having worked at a startup is a plus.

Website
https://www.gripinvest.in/
Location - Flexible (WFH or Gurgaon office)
Perks -Permanent WFH

Interested folks DM or share your resume at prakruthi@gripinvest.in
The detailed JD can be shared later.

Mention notice period and Job role applied in your subject line

Post Photo
like

I'm looking for an HR Director role.
I'm currently a Senior HR Manager (because the Ops Director didn't want another Director In the payroll) overseeing 4 facilities & 3 companies. I have 1 HR Manager, 3 HR Generalists, 1 Recruiter, 2 EHS Coord, and 3 EHS Leads reporting to me.
I have over 15 years in HR, an MBA, PHR & SHRM-CP certifications & experience in healthcare, retail, logistics, & manufacturing.
I'm in Texas and willing to relocate to San Antonio, College Station & Houston.
Thank you.

like

CxOs in a consulting firm say discovery phase is a bad thing to say. Instead, use roadmapping or planning. Edit: I’m confused. What’s wrong with discovery?

like

You know how if a designer is stuck they like go to Behance & immediately get inspired. What are some go to places for writers? I’m stuck on a manifesto. And I hate my life.

likehelpful

I keep failing interviews because I’m not structured /crisp / polished enough (despite the creativity, insights and “intrinsics” being there) - has anyone else struggled with this? How did you overcome it? Has anyone used any communication coaches?

like

Just came into a bunch of cash like 400k

Advice on index eft to buy and what % for category types and who would buy all at once ?

looking for a Yardi admin role. currently working fully remote on the Systems team at a property management company supporting on-site teams. looking for $60-$70k. happy to send a resume!

like

Does anyone have Vail hiking suggestions? Everyone is in decent shape in late 30s but will have 1 woman towards the end of the first trimester. Next week so will be warm. Morning hike.

likehelpful

So what’s happening in the local shops? Layoffs? Hiring freezes?

Just got diagnosed at 24. I’m always a little weary of taking new medicines as I have dealt with increased anxiety the past two years. How do low doses of vyvanse make you feel? Does your heart race by a lot?

like

What impact will Amazon developing their own crypto have on the market? This is the next biggest potential disruption imo. What crypto would they acquire? What cryptos would be minimally impacted?

like

Additional Posts in FIRE Financial Independence Retire Early

Has anyone taken a mini retirement ( 1-2 years off)?

like

At what point would you suggest working with a financial manager to set up your investment goals & make sure you’re on the right track for early retirement? At a certain age? After you have a certain amount of $$?

(I already handle my own investments but I don’t know if it’s time to get professional eyes at my portfolio & discuss my goals)

like

Best way to fire? And what age?

like

How many people in this bowl are also minimalists?

like

I am just so happy with my realtor that helped me with my investment property purchase. Totally worth it. Really helped me navigate through the market and make wise decisions. If you are looking for a great realtor in Orange County, Long Beach, Los Angeles areas… please DM me. Happy to refer.

likefunny

Good accountant recs for tax filing? Relatively simple (w2, worked in 2 states). Just need to make sure I’m doing a few withholdings and state vs state things right. I’m in CA but open to suggestions. Thanks!

like

Let’s share food ideas we eat at home to help us save on dining out. This is where I need help since I love a good meal and don’t like to skimp here

like

Do people here consider having children and what it means for financial planning?

like

I’m 28 but new to FIRE and want to get started. What are the first steps for beginners? I feel so behind compared to everyone in this forum..!

like

Bought a SFH where I’d barely break even given the realtors estimate of 1.1k rent. Neighbor kindly let me know going rate was actually 1.6k. Put it up for 1.5k to get a nicer long term tenant and signed in 2 weeks. First investment property and learned a lot from here/bigger pockets so feeling pretty good!

like

What is your current age and asset allocation? Im 30, and invest abt 60% in domestic equity, 5% in foreign equity, 5% in bond and 30% in high yield savings so I can have more liquid $ to buy a house

like

Realized I’ve been contributing all post tax dollars to my 401k for the past 1.5 years. Am I able to convert this to a roth somehow? What kind of tax liability might I have? Should I switch to pre tax contributions?

like