Why do firms get so mad when people claim they have been laid off, stealthed, etc.? Obviously, at-will employment is the default legal rule, so firms can generally fire whoever they want. But it also seems obvious that, when an employer fires people routinely, at least some of those people will not have nice things to say about the employer. Is this simply narcissistic rage on both sides ("how dare you fire ME" versus "how dare you speak ill of MY world class firm you literal peon").

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It stems from deep seated insecurity that most lawyers have, including those in the upper echelons of firm leadership. They don’t want their precious firm to be perceived as struggling so they do stealth layoffs and give website time to keep up appearances.

This has the benefit of helping the individual affected too, but it’s not done out of a motivation to help that individual.

From the individual perspective, I believe you’re right. Lawyers that make it into biglaw often think they’re better and smarter and harder working than those that didn’t. Thus they often have an inflated view of themselves that may not match reality. Perhaps they did better in school than they did working a real job and they act that way out of insecurity.

However, some of the best lawyers and people I’ve worked with have been stealthed so I know for a fact that sometimes it’s just ruthless cuts and not “performance-based” despite what firm leadership may say. In that case, their response may be warranted.

likesmarthelpful

It’s a combination of firms not wanting to admit that they are struggling, lawyers not wanting to admit that maybe their performance wasn’t so great, and employers in general being bad at performance management, so attorneys (especially associates) not even realizing they aren’t doing a good job.

like

Even when the motivating factor is economics, who gets picked is still usually based on performance to some extent, even if it’s just relative to the rest of the group.

In this economic environment. The firm is struggling (or just behind desired annual profitability metrics due to change in demand) and they have to cull the heard. The system was never meant to keep everyone around. Plain and simple. If you were doing a bad job you would know about it long before your review in realtime lol The tell tale sign is uneven hours and seniors/partners hoarding work across the practice/group. Paying high salaries in that environment kills the bottom line and people with low hours tend to go first even through no fault of their own (because they don’t bring in the work). That is standard big law practice. You essentially need a partner/sponsor to protect you during those times. If you don’t 👋

like

I am all here for P1's "My firm has never fired anyone who didn't 100% deserve it" take. That's the type of vitriol that makes this website fun.

Going through my second stealth termination right now. Rip

I’m now jaded about law firms. All the same BS.

I think firm leadership is insecure in general. However, I can see why there would be some annoyance if the firm gave three months severance and website time. If they don’t provide three months severance and website time, and it must be those two together, I don’t think firms have any right to even be annoyed. The lawyer who was fired/laid off/stealth has every right to name and shame the firm to give him or herself the best shot to find another job.

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

Does mindtree accepts counter offer?? If yes how should I approach them and how many days before do I need to do it?

like

Who here actually owns a car and what kind of car is it?

like

Success smiles on those who do things with passion, not with reason!

Post Photo
like

Can anyone having any idea what will be the CTC range of mindtree for C4 grade with 9.4 YOE. And how much joining bonus can be claimed?

like

Does anyone know how to declare in my individual tax return, RSA and Stock Options from a US Company that I have? Non exercised yet.

like
like

Folks - please share your thoughts on True Wind Capital.

Hello fishes


Want to start my career in data science
I am 2021 mechanical engineering graduate having one year of experience in cognizant in support.
!!!!!! Help please

Thank you in advance

like

Currently I am in Deloitte India with(6.5yrs exp) 13Lac WFH Pune hometown
I am interviewing with SAP LABS India how much should I expect for banglore location (hybrid) will need to relocate
Would it be a good decision to relocate as I am staying with my family in pune?

like
like
like

Just curious: how much time would you bill for on prepping instructions to a FA for a response? Feel free to break down by how long you’ve been practicing, complexity, or any other factor you think is relevant.

like

SO and I recently moved to the DC area. We are both new to federal consulting. They have a few interviews this week. When a job description mentions " an understanding of federal contracting vehicles and procedures".
What should they be ready to talk about? CLINs, GSAs, color team reviews etc.? Would anyone have insights on this? Much appreciated!

likehelpful

I am moving to Bangalore the next weekend, by 17th July. Seems there is a slight increase in covid cases, would it be better to come now or should I ask my manager to come to office after some weeks once everything seems fine?

like

When your client is understanding of your schedule, listens to your recommendations, and thanks you for your hard work.

Post Photo
likefunny

Here you go

Post Photo
like

Hy guys
I’m looking for a job as a associate project manager, in market research company. Like CINT , KANATAR and all. Can any one help me in this!
Thanks in advance

Need 11 likes to DM. Can you please help me?

like

I’m starting my PhD in environmental engineering and would like to know what jobs there are to apply to after I complete my degree. Is it true that companies are hesitant to hire PhD-degree holders, and if so, what can I do to advocate for myself in job applications?

like

Additional Posts in Big Law

Is it possible to transition from antitrust litigation to general litigation?

like

Worst luck ever. My group was very slow from Jan through may, so I won’t hit my hours, but am now (and will continue to be) very busy…. About to do 1990 hrs the most painful way possible. Fml.

like

Any insight into Fenwick’s tech trans practice? Are they still hiring fully remote associates?

like

Fish, I trust your advice. Anyone have leads or recruiter recs for SF biglaw litigation? Looking to lateral as a to-be second year, mostly antitrust/white collar.

like

How much actual court experience should a junior litigator expect to get in the first year? I've been my firm 6 months as a civil litigator not and have yet to go to a hearing. There have been a few (all relatively minor) but each time the partner tells me it's not important enough for me to attend. As a junior, I feel like I need to learn and no hearing is to minor. How else am I supposed to learn?

like

Do you remember when “office closed due to inclement weather” meant you had an easy day at home because remote wasn’t a thing yet? Now with a foot of snow coming, office closed means wfh with no backup childcare available….

like

Corporate associates — do you feel it’s harder to meet hours vs your litigation counterparts? Billing in increments of 0.10 vs driving to the courthouse that can be billed in large chunks, as an example (pre-covid obvi)

like

Anyone at Ogletree Deakins, Jackson Lewis, Littler, or Fisher Phillips who can share the latest on their remote work policies?

like

Is an offer after only a first screener a red flag?

like

Anybody have thoughts on Troutman Pepper’s Consumer Financial Services practice group? SoCal particularly.

like

Mid-level when she's leading the call: please make sure you take notes. It's expected of the person not leading a call (note I always take notes)

Me(jr): asked to lead a call for a different deal as training. Mid-level doesn't take notes (also on call) and tells me it's the job if the junior to take notes.

likefunny

Anyone worried about firms over-hiring? Our firm has hired a LOT of people. I know we need it now / the past year, but will this bubble pop?

likehelpful

As a mid-senior level associate in litigation/investigations/arbitration, do you feel like what you’re currently doing is actually holding you back in terms of professional/personal development? We spend so much time going over the nittiest and grittiest of details that I feel like I’m not actually learning anything new anymore or expanding my skill set. I work in a super lean team and as a 6th year I’m still doing a lot of the grunt work. Is this normal?

like

Which Big Law firms in San Francisco/Bay Area have good L&E groups? Good as in legitimate group and not some group that claims to do the work but really just writes blog posts and answers some advice and counsel questions. Amongst those, any intel on culture, WLB, etc.?

like

Anyone here deal with Phantom Share Agreements? Would that be in the wheelhouse for an ECVC lawyer? My BIL is being offered a job with a company and received a proposed phantom shares agreement. One condition states that he must remain in good standing with the company even after the 3 year vesting period to receive distributions. Is that atypical?

like

Anyone have insight into Goodwin’s remote positions? They aren’t listed on their careers page.

like

Anybody have info on Manatt?? Rep, hours, comp, quality of work etc

like

Anyone with insight into the real estate group in Orrick’s LA office?

like

Any insight into pay at Proskauer’s satellite offices such as New Orleans or Boca Raton?

like

Thoughts on getting fed government jobs? I'm a first year associate in a specialized transaction group in DC and I fucking hate it. I had an internship at a federal department in school but after that went 2L SA/firm. Any hope of finding something? Right now my plan is to just start spamming USAjobs and hope something eventually sticks.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal