Related Posts
More Posts
I recently joined Allstate india and my manager is forcing me to come to office twice a week. During negotiations, I had made it clear that I didn't want to work from office due to personal commitment.
Please suggest:
1. Is my understanding correct that Allstate india is currently not forcing employees to come to office and my manager is an exception?
2. How can I say no without pissing off the manager given I have just joined the company?
hi Recently I had an interview at Airbus for Technology analyst ii role. That was the final round but HR did not give me a number after my expectation and said that they would offer me as per company standard . can you tell me what is the pay scale at this position? this is for e2 level
Additional Posts in All Things MBB
Anyone from MBB office the Netherlands?
Bain & Company Is anyone else getting their application to Bain & Company pushed backed?
As of yesterday, even though I applied in May, and that while they liked my application, they will not be considering me till early 2023.
This is the second time they pushed back their consideration... 😞
What’s paid better at McK? Associate or Analyst?
New to Fishbowl?
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.




Sounds like typical cop out, ignore and move on
Mentor
I would say if the feedback was not detailed enough that’s a reflection on PEI and your friend probably did not dive into the details of the story and like you said only stayed at 5 points. The PEI is a true deep dive into a single story so if you only have 5 things to say that’s gonna end pretty quick vs the typical 15-20 mins the PEI usually takes.
Mentor
The interviewer isn’t going to tell you you’re missing something. A couple things could be going on here. Either the interviewer asked on open question to give them a chance to add to the answer and they didn’t, or they didn’t have the chance because the case was running slow because it was taking longer than usual to come up with or communicate the answers (e.g. if they were slow on the math)
Are you the friend?
They 100% are😂
I’ve heard you tend to get very generic feedback primarily when
1. The interviewer doesn’t want to have detailed conversation or
2. There was an issue with your PEI which as far as I know they can’t comment on
Cool, thank you.
If you have missed major portions of an answer, (e.g., talk about a profitability question by only focusing on cost levers and completely ignore revenue levers), then your answer is not “detailed enough”. The interviewer makes the judgement on if they want to dig deeper, but unlikely to point out big gaps in thinking
Unsure how feedback is given at McK, but that response seems kind of generic for such a large mistake.
In the instance you mentioned, I would have expected feedback along the lines of “candidate missed key components of case review”. But, I’m an outsider and don’t know how things are done within the firm.
Which part of the case was this in reference to? The initial framework? The brainstorm?
Hi OP, can you give the details of the feedback?