Columbia or Anderson ($80k Scholarship)?

Post MBA goals are Consulting (MBB)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Columbia not close

like

As in go for CBS??

like

Anderson. You will end up with exactly same positions with the two schools. Only difference is you will need to pay back your loan at a very high rate (no low interest rate time any more thanks to FED) for a long period or stuck with MBB for more years than you expected if they pay back the loan for you.

like

Columbia is the stronger school, up to you how much the scholarship means to you vs the brand value.

McK BCG and Bain all hire at UCLA, look up the employment reports to see % of the class to compare how many percentage points you’re sacrificing for each dollar of scholarship money.

Also consider what recruiting pool you’re putting yourself in (UCLA student body vs Columbia student body). Columbia might have more placement but could be harder to get placement given your competition (impossible to quantify whether this is an advantage or disadvantage). Consider this cost benefit analysis as your first practice case.

like

It depends on you, but you might be better at Anderson, considering you’ll be saving money to get to the same job as Columbia students and might be MORE competitive in the Anderson pool, compared to Columbia. Both are great though! So it might come down to what interests you at what school, in terms of personal interests, classes, etc.

like

For your goals Columbia is the better choice. Also to consider do you want to be east coast or west coast based? Your goal is still attainable via Anderson, but will give you a more west coast-centric network.

Thinking about LA for full time office

Both are fine with me, but LA is my first choice

Congrats on the generous scholarship from Anderson.

Did you already get into CBS through rolling admissions? Curious because I know folks who submitted non-ED in September and just got invited to interview in the past few days.

Read in one of the threads here that the BCG NY office has about 20% of incoming MBA head count blocked for CBS, so maybe that’s the move for you

Congrats. I was in a somewhat similar position. Feel free to dm.

Bump for more insights

Related Posts

MBB folks, I’m a Product Manager (non-tech company) and interested in working at MBB.

Which level/role does MBB can offer me ?

like

Has anyone had an MBA sponsored by the firm? If so, would you be open to connecting to discuss the process?

smart

I just had the initial call with HR. I was told that Senior Analysts start at 56k and Business Operations Specialists start at 67k. I was told the next step was Junior Manager but they rarely started anyone at that level. I'm shocked. Is that accurate or are they trying to lower my expectations? I have an MBA and an MHA and 20 years military experience.

like

What is the general consensus on online I/O psychology programs? I’m looking to pivot into HC consulting and am strongly considering USC’s online MAPP or Harvard Extension School’s I/O Psychology graduate program.

like

Any Oliver Wyman fish willing to chat/refer for associate-digital operations strategy role? Background: 3 yrs post mba experience leading projects in dig strat, process automation, analytics.

like

To keep it general across tier 1 consulting firms...what would be the typical pay band for a practitioner with ~6 years experience and a MBA

like

Best GMAT study plan?

like

What is the post MBA sr consultant $ for MBB Canada?

like

Could someone take a look at my about me section for my LinkedIn pls. Would appreciate some feedback. Trying to transition from reception job to selenium or lean six sigma. Please dm me!

like

Hi All! I am a PM at Cap1. I’ve been managing projects for roughly 6 years off and on. I’ve been thinking about getting my PMP for several years, but have made it a goal this year. I get very overwhelmed with choosing who I should go with for my training course. Does anyone have any recommendations? Thanks!!!

like

Good morning all I hope all is well. So I'm currently a Computer Engineer (Glorified Help desk support) for the MGM Resorts International Corporate IT office here in Vegas.

I currently have a Bachelor's in Computer Science but want to be Cloud Security Engineer. I'm debating whether to go for second bachelors at WGU in Cybersecurity while self studying Cloud certifications, or doing the Cloud Computing while self studying Cybersecurity certifications. Or just go Masters with IT concentration.

like

Enrolled in an executive MBA program at a top uni, and I have to say I’m very happy I did that vs FT/PT.

likeupliftingfunny

Does anyone have their PHD or DBA? If so what are you currently doing and was it worth pursuing? I recently obtained my MBA and I’m looking into some programs but trying to see what’s the best fit for me.

like

How can someone having a tier 1 mba move from corporate banking to private equity?

like

Are all the Oracle certifications free irrespective of our team after we join Oracle? Or WT can do certification only of our manners assigns any to us?

like

What's the most fun certification you have studied for?

likefunny

Why does EY not sponsor internationals working under CPT for one day masters program? Can we all ask for the firm? Or at least provide a better GEOC program.. They will send us to a random country..

like

Any current MBA students on here? Any wisdom/things you wish you knew before starting??

Moved from consulting (non MBB) to VC (investing role) recently, happy to take questions!

likeupliftinghelpful

More Posts

Arrived just in time for Microbrand Monday - the Direnzo DRZ-04 Mondial!

Post Photo
like

Can anyone refer me in Capgemini India?

Please note that I'm on notice period and looking for urgent requirements.

Capgemini

Best consulting firms for PE work (CDD,Value Creation)? Looking for the best firm for exit ops to PE ops eventually. Thanks!

like

Does anyone have any insight into attorney salaries at the Hartford in NYC?

like

Would it be realistic to aim for Tuck with 3 years Risk Advisory experience, 3.39 dual degree undergrad at top 20 liberal arts college and 710 gmat?

like

Anyone want to discuss salary? $145k, called to the bar in 2016, target 1800-2000 hours

like

Did anyone recieved 30 day notification of your scheduled return to office mail
Today or before ?

like

Is anyone from Kroll or Security Brigade here?

what you buying?

like

Hi!

I recently did a job interview and I made it clear to the HR my expectation salary is 60k a year, non negotiable.
Today I got the job offer and they are offering me 54k. My current company is making me 50k with tons of benefits which is why I am asking for 60k.

Should I accept the offer or renegotiate?

like

Hi guys, should I buy lumpsump for coffee can investing or do SIP ? And one more question if you guys can help . At what point let say I hold a coffee can stock when should I exit. I am planning to hold for 10 years but how do I know that this stock is not relevant now or some red flag I should exit .

like

Any thoughts on Peter Millar suits? Quality, look, wear over time, etc..thinking of buying a couple while on sale at Nordstroms

What kind of ML/AI work happens in PE and VC firms, if any? I've been trying to get some understanding around, but there's not much shared except some marketing funda.

like

How is the City account in Wipro ?

like

Is it possible to talk to any recruiter from MBB, Big4?

I had a job interview for a role that I really want. The hiring manager scheduled me for an interview and did not show up. Emailed me an hour later stating that he got super busy and couldn’t attend, and would like to reschedule. This is a major red flag, but I can’t help but feel that I am missing out since this role pays 50% over what I currently make. Should I let the recruiter know? What’s your take on this?

like

I'm graduating in a few weeks, is to weird to send a holiday gift like wine or a Christmas Card along with my resume? I haven't been hearing back from the companies i have been applying to and I'm looking to stand out.

like

IBM delhi giving 10,17,000 and wirpo bangalore giving 950000 .
which to choose for job security .
i heard ibm fires sometime? ? does it right? ? ?

like
like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

Enrolled in an executive MBA program at a top uni, and I have to say I’m very happy I did that vs FT/PT.

likeupliftingfunny

Aside from Georgetown, any other MBA programs recommended for international development/finance? Looking to pivot from my current business/tech strategy work.

like

When should I tell my manager / “recommendor” I am planning to apply to bschool? Applying R1 this fall

like

If anyone needs bschool admissions interview help, feel free to DM me. I’ve helped dozens of candidates get into their top choices over the years and feel like I can help a lot more of you based on the questions being asked. Not offering pro bono services but significantly discounted. Hmu!

likehelpful

Did you use admissions consultants? Who was it and was he/she worth it? Advice on selecting one?

like

I have been looking at the curriculums for Harvard Business School's Master of Business Administration and Harvard Extension School's ALM in Management. They both have the same requirements (generally speaking) including a capstone course that serves as a field immersion course with the Master's in Management, which is fairly new. If I am not able to gain admission to Harvard Business School, but wanted a similar educational experience to become a consultant, should I attend Harvard Extension?

Anyone who can share their experience with the Harvard Extension School?

like

Is it harder to get into business school than business school itself?

like

How worried should I be if I haven’t yet received an interview invite to my safety (a T15/T20)? I have already interviewed at 3 schools including my 2 top choices so I’m super happy about that, but not feeling super “safe” about not having heard from my safety yet because anything could happen with my targets?!!!

like

Did anyone do the Jumpstart MBA Diversity Forums? Wondering if they are worth it/helpful. Thanks!

like

Somehow the weekends are the worst part about GSB invites. It’s like it hits you that another week went by without anything 😔

like

Can you get pdf score reports of gmat online exams?

like

How close are the official GMAT prep practice exams to the actual in person exam? Any data points would be appreciated. TIA

like

In one month is my mid term review.. Should I let my mentor know I'm applying for mba this year now or should I wait till after the review session? I'm afraid mentioning going to b school would hurt my "fast promotion". What's your guy's experience? :)

like

Ross or Fuqua?

like

Dress code for HBS interview day when I am not interviewing that day?

like

Taking my GMAT in 7 weeks. Just finished the large Kaplan book and have done 2 practice tests so far. What should I do next? Worth investing in a GMAT tutor? Getting 600 on practice tests but want a 690~.

like

Why is it that those in IB can’t get an MBA and return to IB the way people from other industries have returned post-MBA?

like

Anyone had luck getting back a deposit? I got admitted to my dream program, but sent a deposit for a different school's earlier deadline.

likefunny

Hello, has anyone filled in the Forte Fellows Kira video questions?

Are they any different from usual Kira interview questions?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal