Has anyone heard of a judge forcing a case to trial without discovery? (Or can point me in the direction of case law, rules , etc on if this is within judge’s discretion?) Short story is that both parties misunderstood the effect of a jurisdictional appeal on the case in the lower court, and took no action for months. Judge is forcing us to proceed with trial next week though neither of us have conducted any discovery whatsoever. We’re at a loss & have jointly exhausted other options. Federal ct

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

How does this even happen? Sounds like the judge is trying to force a settlement.

like

I don’t even understand how this happens - were you guys not getting the cm/ecf notifications? You should have been receiving notices of missed deadlines for filing discovery schedules, etc automatically if you were properly registered with the court -I’d at least try to get on a conference call with the judge and submit some sort of stip from both parties stating they feel unprepared for trial. You may have to ask for a voluntary dismissal and refile if the judge is really set against but I can see lots of reasons the parties wouldn’t want to do that

like

Exactly. How have you not had any contact with the court through to this juncture? No status conferences or anything? And why wouldn’t the parties have jointly moved to stay the scheduling order if there was a trial date (along with all the other deadlines) on the docket during the jurisdictional dispute at the outset?

like

To answer your questions: 1) yes, it was a bad move for the opposing party who appealed to not file a motion to stay. Both he and I mistakenly believed that a stay would be automatic when there was an appeal. FWIW, he is a very experienced attorney and I’m a first year but the partner overseeing me also assumed that. There have been absolutely no communications from the Lower court about missed deadlines, etc. There was a scheduling order issued for July trial months ago, before the appeal, but all of the other deadlines bedsides trial (including status conferences, etc) went by without a word from either party or the court. The judge called us in to a status conference about 2 weeks ago, where he chastised us for our mistakes here, and said you’re going to trial as scheduled; no ifs, and or buts about it! We’ve been scrambling to prepare and exchanging discovery but he’s denied motions to stay as has the court of appeals but the appeal is still pending.

All around bizarre situation. We’re going to trial as it seems we have to, but.. just trying to find ways to repetition the judge to reconsider

like

Lol I wish I could say without revealing anything. He is on senior status though.

like

I have had it happen in state court many times but my jurisdiction allows the parties by agreement to strike a case from the docket and toll the SOL with the case to be refiled within a year. So, it’s not a big deal. I have not seen it in federal court because the case deadlines are so clear. Obviously, the status conference did not go as planned. Not sure if the judge would allow it, but you could set a mediation date with a mediator and request a continuance to allow the parties to complete mediation in advance of the trial. Judge might be more willing to grant a continuance if you are working to settle. Meanwhile, you can work on discovery together with the other side.

like

Oh good call - especially if you pick a retired judge as the mediator, your judge won’t want to be rude to a colleague

This is weird but you need to file a motion to continue, make sure to preserve the record for a motion for new trial.

like

Completely agree. Jointly file a motion for reconsideration that comes out and says whoever wins will appeal based on this grounds alone and it’s not in the interest of judicial economy to have this remanded and tried twice. I also suggest conferring on mutually agreeable alternative dates that you propose in the motion to show the judge you aren’t just going to kick this ball down the road.

like

That’s absolutely crazy

Will opposing counsel just stip to a dismissal w/o prejudice, then refiling? Seems like the most streamlined way of getting what you both want & the judge can't stop it.

Yeah I would say unfortunately the judge is going to be pretty proud of themselves for finding a solution…

Related Posts

My partner hates my long working hours.

It is really hard to do well in this business without sacrifice and my partner doesn't like it. To be fair that sacrifice is her... Most nights,over the weekend, and during every meal. She deserves better but I either sacrifice time or sacrifice earning potential.

I don't know how to solve this problem.

like

This is an emotional dump rn. It may be lack of social interaction but I'm really frustrated lately. I feel like I lost last 2.5 years of my life with ongoing lockdowns and job instability in the first half of the pandemic. I was 28 turing 31. I get good dates but -ve self talk
Inflation is high & coming from a low income family where you're supposed to help your parents is driving me nuts. Although I make a good salary, after rent, car insurance, there isn't much left (unfav currency exchange)

like

Guys, I am looking for a project in RPA technology. I have basic knowledge in Uipath and Automation Anywhere. Any leads please DM me.

like

Hi everyone, what is a good asking salary for CFE Associate Consultant in SAP Ariba? I have asked for CTC of 9 LPA during salary negotiation, is it a good ask?
How much do a CFE Associate Consultant usually get with 2 years of prior experience?

SAP Infosys Consulting Wipro Amazon

likeuplifting

Hi everyone, i am looking for new job as software developer, m having 1+ year of experience in developing software using python, mysql and some data analysis using pandas, metplotlib, also i have good experience in web development using javascript, html,css. Any help & referral would be appericiated , thanks in advance. #refer #referral

like

Republican here. But what kinda guy we have here. Disgraceful!

like

What are your favorite management books?

like

Can anyone help me understand what the typical comp / structure for operating partner in mid-market PE firm ($1-5B under mgmt) might look like?

like

Anyone have tips on writing a cover letter without referring to anything in the resume?

like

Me when the new hire I’ve coached opens their mouth in a client meeting

Post Photo
likefunny

If you had a job at a big name agency in a smaller market, where you loved everyone you worked with and had just gotten a (small) raise, would you leave it for an amazing offer from a big market shop?

Pro tip I wish I received: when lateraling back up your phone before leaving so you don’t lose it’s contents when your previous firm remote-factory resets the device.

likehelpfulfunny

My company is trying to get us all to vaccinate, even though I work remotely. Is this unconstitutional?

like

Has anyone actually gone through with accepting an offer from the Siegfried Group? I hear from a recruiter representing them probably once a week. How is it?

like

Hello Techies,

I have YOE 6.3 CTC 7.7. I am a Sr. QA with Kalkine Media. Basically I am a Manual Test Engineer. I am working on my Automation Testing skills but there is no automation framework in my organization. Kindly suggest.

like

Hi, I have 6 years of experience as a developer and have offers from, Harman Connected Services(WebAPI Developer - 20 LPA), Bank of America(Senior Developer II - 20 LPA), Siemens(Desktop developer-20LPA), NSR Information System(Senior Software Engineer -20LPA), Tech M, Cognizant, Kellton Tech, FIS Global, Mind tree. Packages are in the range 20+. Which company should I join for good projects and good wlb?

like

May be a noob question. What agency titles feed into different C-Suite positions in the wider industry? Do creative titles most commonly set one up for a CMO position? How about account side?

like

How much will be in hand salary if Barclays gives a CTC of 25 LPA?
Is the employer contribution towards PF deducted from the CTC?

like

Dear all,
May I know what is the variable pay cycle in barclays ? Iam joining this November..pls advise

like

Which one better option interms of saving more money
1 lac Tech M in hand salary in hyderabad
Or
1.6 lac in hand tcs onsite salary in Budapest ?

like

Additional Posts in Litigation & Arbitration

Hello, second year commercial litigation associate here looking for a recruiter. Preferably Suffolk County or eastern Nassau County. Any recommendations?

like

Any plaintiff’s attorneys on here from St. Louis? I might make the switch over from defense. Curious how much you all are making per year if you’re comfortable sharing. I’m trying to get an idea whether leaving the billable model and stress behind is worth the lower annual salary. Thanks!

like

When a recruiter emails you at work, how do you respond? I feel like it’s stupid to use my firm email for that, but it seems like when I forward to my personal email and reply there, I never get a response?

Hello. I currently work in-house as a Legal Operations Manager. I am working on a project to expand our network of law firms.

Any recommendations of boutique law firms in CA that have experience in commercial litigation for retail/fashion/apparel/home companies? Specifically consumer class action, unfair business practices, false advertising/17200, data privacy.

Thanks for your recommendations.

like

How many dispositive motions is a lot to write in a month? I’m a first year and I’ve done three MSJs and two MTDs (including a complex 50 page one) and I feel absolutely drained. That normal?

like

There’s been some turnover over the last six months at my firm, and I have taken over more files. I’m having a hard time getting ahead of briefing schedules and have been asking for extensions on a lot of recent briefs. In my practice area it’s never really an issue or objected to. However, I feel guilty that this is still happening. Any tips for getting over this?

like

Best big law firms for white collar defense?

like

I feel like this is the busiest billable December I’ve had. Anyone else absolutely swamped with work this month?

like

I feel so dumb for not knowing this answer, but what is the difference between Rule 14, Third party Complaint and Rule 20, permissive jointer? My client, defendant has an indemnity agreement with an entity that is not named in the suit and we want to bring them into the case.

like

I work for a small firm (about 20 attorneys) and make 90k. I’m coming up for a raise discussion in a couple of months but don’t know how to go about it/what is reasonable to ask for. I bill about 35 hrs/week at 400/hr, so I think I deserve a bump, especially considering the posture of the market. Any advice/feedback from similarly situated associates or partners at similarly sized firms?

like

Insurance defense deductions - Billings wants to write off my time because I worked more than 10 hours in one day. What are some ways to avoid cutting my time?

likehelpful

Insights into Andrews Myers in HTX?

like

I work in a firm that is known for litigation defense. I’ve been developing my own plaintiffs practice as well. I am able to pay the bills with my hourly defense work, which gives me time to focus on a handful of high value PI case a year on contingency. I was recently negotiating a case and was told part of the reason the claims rep/OC was jerking me around was because they didn’t see me as a plaintiffs attorney. Is there any way to change this perception or does it just come over time?

like

I’m getting great experience, several big newsworthy cases, lots of depositions, lots of legal writing...

And I absolutely hate it. The hours are miserable. I just want a 9-5. My ambition has been sapped away.

like

Have an opportunity to finally get out of insurance defense. But not really sold on the firm. Could finally get out of ID, but then could also end up at another place I really don't like. Def want my next firm to be long term as I've jumped around.

like

Is sticking up for yourself even worth it? My boss is always on my ass as if I’m constantly missing, or about to miss, deadlines. I’ve never missed one. I’ve received the same damn lecture/email about monitoring all case deadlines a hundred times. I always just professionally explain that we’re not about to miss any and discuss the progress. Well, I’ve about had it and am ready to go off. I’m sick of basically being told that I’m not doing my job. How should I address this issue?

like

In house insurance defense comp. What’s the highest paid and lowest paid companies? Which companies give bonuses? Please provide yoe and salary.

like

Curious what a big law lateral (4th year) signing bonus may be? If I get an offer, this will be my first big law job, so I have nothing to compare it to.

like

LOUISIANA-specific:
If I attend my client’s deposition along with a legal assistant/law graduate (bar admission pending), are they permitted to participate (object, redirect) under my supervision or would that be unauthorized practice of law for them?

Been trying to suss this out for WEEKS.

like

Who here has jumped firms a lot? How many firms and what year are you? I'm worried about long term my resume looking like I'm a mega flight risk. I have solid reasons for each jump but just tired of jumping and worried. It's hard to find that long term firm.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal