Hi everyone,

I’m currently evaluating two offers and would appreciate some guidance from people who have experience with either organization.

Offer 1: EY – 26 LPA (Consulting role)
Offer 2: Shell – 29 LPA (Corporate / operations-related role)

My background is in supply chain planning and digital supply chain transformation, and I have around 4 years of experience. Both roles seem interesting but come with different career trajectories — consulting vs industry.

Which to choose ?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Shell role is better both in terms of pay almost a 10% hike on the EY offer and the industry. As the consulting industry is undergoing some structural changes. Shell or the oil industry seems promising with opportunity to travel outside. If you can tell more about your background and past jobs, decision can form.

I’m a team lead in SC in a manufacturing industry and spent 4+ years in the same firm. Now evaluating to get into tech consulting or into ongc for next step. Aspiring to become a business lead position in future.

Your suggestions taken ! Thanks

Related Posts

Any PwC manufacturing folks here (Reliability/Maintenance or Prod Development). Looking for referral and also some advise on level (Mgr v Sr Mgr).

like

Anyone able to provide a referral for KPMG Life Sciences in NY?

Hi- I’m an hourly AA, been on the role for 6 months now and it’s my first AA job. I did not get a raise when I took the job because it was technically a demotion ( I was a team leader at a contact center). I assist two VPs and now they want to add a third because they’re looking for the “ 3:1 ratio “. Should I ask for a raise? Is this normal? I know another AA that handles 3+ people but idk if she’s hourly or salary. Any thoughts?

like

Dear Folks,

Can someone refer me into Microsoft, for Azure DevOps role. I have 5.5 YOE

like

Hi all, I am looking for Salesforce QA opportunity. I am having overall 8 years of experience in IT industry including 4 years experience into Salesforce. Please refer me if any openings in your organization.
Thank you in advance.

like

Does anyone else just not even want to be a people manager anymore?! The amount of work this is taking, I’m just so over it. In addition to them piling on my work (which is a full time job) the people management stuff is just as much a full time job that no one in management seems to take into account. I have tried countless times to explain this but I end up burnt out, everyone suffers including me. I just left one role bc of it and now this new role, same thing. I’m over it.

like
like

Looking for a legal counsel role, with focus on commercial contracts (MSA, software license, M&A).

like

Looking for referral for VoIS open position. Can someone help

like

Wondering if anyone can give insight as to what salary range is for an insurance compliance role as an IC3 or similar?

like

Does Zoom have an employee referral program? If yes, can someone refer me to an open position? Please reach out if so. Zoom

like

I recently graduated with a degree in Finance but feel like I want to work in a tech related role and wish I would’ve gotten a CS degree. I work at a SaaS company built on Salesforce and was wondering if certifications would be enough to be considered? I’m looking at Business Analyst or Product Mgmt

like

Anyone looking for a referral for open roles at Confluent let me know

like

Hi All,
Could any one help me with the CP round for Data Engineering role at
Thoughtworks .They have shared some Github link but i am not getting anything .Thoughtworks

like

I’m new to the country. This is a bit out there but where do you get an abortion? Do you need a referral through your GP? After that is there a long wait?

like

I had a google referral from privacy counsel for a privacy counsel role that I met all the qualifications for and I didn’t even get a screener. Feeling a bit confused. I just got an offer from another FAANG company but feeling perplexed by this rejection.

Hi. I have applied for a job in an academic setting for a leadership role in cancer research. Duties would have me responsible for a small team of research nurses as well as other managerial duties for the department. I have been a research nurse for 3 years now, but I have no experience applying for a salaried position or a role in leadership. What sort of salary would be appropriate to ask for? I know that I should aim high and let them counter, but how high exactly? Thanks I’m advance

like

Is investment accounting a good career path? Looking for any insight to the role, career progression, exit ops, etc. I got the opportunity to work at a very well known wealth asset management company as an investment accountant. I do enjoy finance as well. Pay is very good so I’m wondering if I should take the opportunity?

like

More Posts

3 fan art images... 8 character close up and a 10pg comic in blender 1 a month. While creating assets to sell and posting. And writing and getting certifications. MERRY HOLIDAYS AND HAPPY NEW YEAR.

like

How is it going in Canada? How is the job scene?

Thinking of switching employers. Do you think bigger retail stores (the ones that have several locations) are easier or harder to work at than little hole-in-the-wall grocery stores (which is all I've ever done)? It seems like the larger chain stores would have more downtime, but I'm wondering if anyone could give some input.

like

Not sure if I have to laugh or cry

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Hi there, I'm a self taught software engineer with almost 3 years of professional experience and have 3 companies (full-time) in my resume.

I'm thinking of moving forward now. So, could you please tell me what the job market would look like for me? And what things to consider while applying?

Thanks!

likehelpful

How much will be Gratuity ?
No. Of years served : 7

Post Photo
like
like

How is the life and work culture in the exl?

like

Any BCBA’s in the Memphis area? I’ll be relocating there soon and testing. Looking to meet others in the field!

Are there any pharmacists here who transitioned out of retail?

Does anybody else think this $2 trillion bill is ridiculous? I understand the why and benefits etc, but just like at a certain point isn’t this all just funny money? Playin w/ money no one really has?

like

Which NFT stock is worth for long term or quick profit. TKAT, YRV, HOFV, OCG

like

I need advice. I moved into product management under a year ago to an early stage startup. The first few months went well, but the last 5 have been chaotic. It feels like we’re becoming more sales led, there are too many pivots (I expected some) our roadmap is becoming influenced by sales/ceo. Essentially, we’re trying to do much. It’s happening so much I’m starting to lose confidence in the company/strategy. It’s also causing me anxiety…

like

Hi ,

I am very much interested to know if IBM India has any node js projects?
Has any one have any experience of working on node.js /express.js or MERN stack developer at IBM?
TIA

IBD Nordics members?

like

Thoughts on CohnReznick - Data Analytics practice

like

Qualcomm or Cisco ?
YoE : 5+. Tech stack: C,C++, DS & Algo. Both are offering the same CTC.

like

Why do SOME women in leadership positions hate all other women? Just heard my director has rolled off 80% of women on her projects. I may be next...

like

I just got laid off — anyone else get hit this round? ☹️

like

Booked UA biz, PHI-ORD. Delayed and re-routed PHI-IAD-ORD in economy (but still on original ticket). Will PQMs be based on the actual/longer routing at 200% fare class bonus?

like

Additional Posts in Offer Negotiations

Hi guys

Please tell me what my in-hand salary will be for Infosys

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes

What would be the in hand monthly salary of 12lpa?
Thanks in advance.

What are the benefits for a new joiner at Nvidia? do they provide macbooks for employees at work?
What are the perks?

How is Nvidia salary compared to other semiconductor companies like Intel, QC, AMD for verification roles?Intel Corporation Nvidia Qualcomm Arm Analog Devices Samsung

like

Hi,

Which company is better with respect to WLB?

KAS services india pvt Ltd(KMART)
Ralph lauren


TIA

like

Hi friends,
Currently im having 11.2 pa fixed offer yoe 3.5 as system administrator. Is it good offer or i have to try any other please suggest.

like

How much does Citi offer for
Role: C12
Location: Pune
YOE: 9
Profile: Data Steward

like

Hi All,, Has anyone joined UST - PTEC (equifax) company recently for pune or other locations? Can someone please provide review of the same. Thinking to join the same on 30th dec.

Please respond.

like

Hi Fishes … I have 3 years of experience in mainframe operations as System Engineer , now I want to switch my job profile to Business Analyst/ Operations Analyst …. Skills - Power BI, Advanced Excel ,SQL … CCTC- 8 LPA … let me know if anyone can help / refer … Suggestions are also welcomed for how to switch career

like

I'm holding an offer from MakeMyTrip and another offer from OlaElectric. Ninjacart is willing to make me an offer. But they're saying that they'd discuss the offer only after the other company that I'm interviewing with has come up with an offer first. There's been a delay from HRs of the companies in a similar way. How do I urge them to send me the offer letter without sounding pushy? I had reached out to some of the HRs myself. Would that be too awkward if I accept & back out their offer?

like

Hi All,

i am .net dev with 3.3 yoe have offer of16 lpa (service) and my current company (product) is trying to retain me with 14 lpa its been 1.2 yrs in my current company. Tech stack is good over here. What should i do ? b please suggest.

like
like

Actually, I gave Interview for BackEnd Developer @ Itilite. I was selected in the interview process (2 Tech DSA Based + HR) and got a mail stating that our interview panel is really impressed with your domain related expertise in order to proceed with offer negotiation please submit your documents. Now after 2-3 days of document submission, they came up by saying they cant move forward with my candidature.

I am still amazed how can they do this after asking my documents.

like

Hi guys, Would you please let me know which company to choose from Continental Automotive or Akamai.

Since two months back i joined Bigbasket as its WLB is worst and I don't like it.

like

Hi fishes,
I'm not getting call for interview when i tell them i have 3 month NP. What should i do in that case to get first offer letter?

like

1.10 yoe in react front end, cctc 4.58, offer from startup 8.3, how much infosys give? Any guess? Infosys

like

Hi All, please provide your inputs.
Which of the following opportunity is better in terms of learning opportunities, technical and career growth.

1) JP Morgan, Banglore - 18 LPA (fixed) - Apache spark, Java.
2) CITI, Pune - 21.7(fixed) - C10, Java+Angular full stack developer role
3) Barclays, Pune - 18.5 LPA (fixed) - BA3, Java backend developer

Experience: 4.10 yrs
My current location is nearer to Pune.

TIA!

like

I have received an offer of 5lpa + 1lac night shift allowance from Capgemini for the designation of Associate Consultant. I have a few questions if someone can answer - 1. Am I being paid correctly according to this designation? 2. How are the annual appraisals at the organisation and about how much % of hike does one receive on an average. Capgemini

Ps- I have 2.5 years of exp

like

5th September is my last working day at Infosys. Yoe=4+ yrs
Tech= aws devops
I hold an offer of 18LPA from KPMG with joining date of 7th September. (Wfh)
I applied at Workday on 15th May and went through 7 technical rounds of interview and received a verbal offer letter of 21LPA (hybrid)
Now apparently their technical panel "forgot" about the interview and wants to have a discussion again as 8th technical interview. HR says their joining date will be 19th September.

Should i join KPMG?

like

Hi,

What will be in hand salary

Post Photo
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal