Hi everyone,

I’m currently evaluating two offers and would appreciate some guidance from people who have experience with either organization.

Offer 1: EY – 26 LPA (Consulting role)
Offer 2: Shell – 29 LPA (Corporate / operations-related role)

My background is in supply chain planning and digital supply chain transformation, and I have around 4 years of experience. Both roles seem interesting but come with different career trajectories — consulting vs industry.

Which to choose ?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Shell role is better both in terms of pay almost a 10% hike on the EY offer and the industry. As the consulting industry is undergoing some structural changes. Shell or the oil industry seems promising with opportunity to travel outside. If you can tell more about your background and past jobs, decision can form.

I’m a team lead in SC in a manufacturing industry and spent 4+ years in the same firm. Now evaluating to get into tech consulting or into ongc for next step. Aspiring to become a business lead position in future.

Your suggestions taken ! Thanks

Related Posts

What is the salary range for a Product Manager in the Atlanta area? I have 3 years of experience as a Product Specialist and have been offered a Product Manager role but don’t know how much to ask for. It’s in fintech. Any insight is appreciated!

like

Hi, I recently got offer for retail banking IA function in JP morgan. This is my first move from public accounting and was wondering if IA is the way to go. Anyone working in similar role how are you finding it? What sort of career opportunity can IA offer?

like

Hello Everyone,
Need referral for Manual + Automation Testing with Work Experience of 3+ yrs, Please help for any job opening in your company.

like

Looking for infrastructure manager role, having 15+ years of experience with knowledge on microsoft and dependable products. Pls help. In notice period

like

I everyone,
I have been selected for the associate position but till know I have not received my offer letter from legato company please suggest when can I except my offer letter discussion has happened on jun 27?

Wondering if anyone can give insight as to what salary range is for an insurance compliance role as an IC3 or similar?

like

Joined Accenture strategy team! Happy to help if anyone needs a referral:)

like

Any interview tips for Project Manager roles in software development? I was moved to this role about 2 years ago and soon looking to jump to another company, but unsure of what to focus on talking about. I’ve tested the waters and the feedback from one interviewer who was generous enough to provide it was that I made myself sound like a technologist rather than a PM because I was too focused on the product and it’s details instead of the project management details.

like

I am having doubts regarding shifts in project and job role in Societe General.Can I ask these questions to HR or it will lead to closure of my candidature as they might feel he is having issues with this?

Anyone have a capital one venture x referral?

like

Any openings for associate product manager (Entry level position)

Location: Bangalore

like

Which one to go for a 2.9 yrs of experience with no hands on for the role hired between KPMG and IBM?
Technology-Azure IaaS
KPMG- 10.7
IBM - 10.2+1.4 JB

like

Is it wrong that I’m just not into PE/VC? It seems to be the most desirable exit for most people that I work with. The work seems like it’s not a good fit for me but it feels crazy to pass up trying to get that amount of money when there really isn’t a realistic alternative to that amount of wealth (and I do want that amount of wealth).

like

Anyone hiring helpdesk positions around SLC?

like

Got a referral to BCG and still haven’t had anybody follow up to screen or interview me. It’s been two weeks now. Lol do I give up all hope? How long does this usually take?

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like
like
like

More Posts

Just started a new Data Analyst position in which I have constant meetings with senior leadership and executives. I have a bad habit of giving too much background info and not getting straight to the point. I just feel like every little detail is important (even though that’s not always the case). Any tips for breaking this habit or just become more efficient with advising?

like

Hi connections , anyone working with Barclays ? Need a refferal.

like

How did you get started in your career as an FA? I work in the home office and have been an assistant to an FA before. I have a network, I have ambition, I have credibility and connections at my firm..

Hello all, I am a fresher and have joined TCS in 2021. I have worked with mainframe and a bit of Salesforce. Now I am not enjoying the work here as I feel myself stagnant. Apart from that I am not that much inclined towards coding. Can you all please suggest me that shall I make a switch now? And since I am not interested in coding, what are all other options I should look for. Please help me out.

like

What is highest salary offered for associate level at cognizant ? Will have hr discussion tomorrow Cctc is 21lpa fixed yoe 4. Cognizant Infosys Tata Consultancy

Doing FET with my husband; we just found out our ideal egg donor has available lots! It has been a struggle to find a compatible donor, but it looks like we made it!

like

What are the best books/blogs/online resources to boost your organizational change management skills?

like

Hi Doctors,
Can a man die of schezophrenia if he do not take medicines?
Exp : 6 yrs, kava, spring boot, microservices and aws.
Curr Comp: Concentrix,
prev Comp: Citi, Fiserv, TCS and Accenture.
Thanks!

helpfulfunny
like

Type of work in Deloitte ops transformation in health care. Is it just tech?

likehelpful

I got selected in Infosys and offer was about to get release today but at last minute suddenly today infy HR told I was interviewed 5 months 20 days before in infosys so they cannot proceed now as 6 months cool off period. I am AWS cloud architect with 10yoe. For just 10 days difference they are stopping my offer even when I can join immediately in a week.. Please help in this situation what to do

How practice premium is given in the monthly payslip

like

What is the cheapest electric company these days?

Just a quick tip for everyone traveling - always take a picture of your receipts.

like

*Hiring SDEs for Google* *Only Female*

Requirements:
1) Should be Female.
2) 2+ years of software engineering experience. No freshers or interns.
3) Proficient in either C++, Java or Python.
4) Proficient is Data Structures & Algorithms.
5) Bachelor’s degree.

If interested, please comment or dm. If you are a male, I am sorry but feel free to refer this post to any female SDEs you know.

PS: Only female because Google is not hiring any men for SDE roles as per internal memo from top leadership Google

like

Hi all, what’s a good career path after consulting? Where would you all go as your next step?

like

Hi all! I’m an Australian citizen (currently living in the US), and am moving to Sydney in August. I currently work at Accenture in the US with 2.5 YOE. How would you suggest applying for jobs/networking? While I’d be happy to stay at Accenture and transfer, I’m also open to other firms as well. Any leads are greatly appreciated!

like

Can anyone help me find a site on Oracle EPM cloud? I guess there used to be a page where you could plug in metadata around business industry, revenue, number of users in finance... And then it would give the business case/value of implementation in dollars. It was an interface that had plug and play functionality. Anyone know what I'm talking about?

like

Hello Fishes,

I have been thinking a lot lately about job change. Afraid of layoffs and recession hitting soon. Should be worried about these layoffs and recession that is across the corner.? My exp is 5yrs java fullstack with devops tech stack. Pls do let me know your thoughts. Appreciate any suggestions.

like

What sort of opportunities are available in Canadian government for commercial insurance professionals?

like

Additional Posts in Offer Negotiations

Hi Fishes,

What is the average salary in Germany for SAP Integration Architect with 11 Years of Experience

like

Hi,

What will be in hand salary

Post Photo
like

I am associated with an investment bank in mumbai for 11 years and total exp 13. I have two interview going on one in mumbai and second in bengaluru, almost last rounds. How much hike should i expect frm both of them. My current fixed is 18lpa

UI dev - 5 year’s experience. Help me in choosing between 2 offers comparing all factors. Evoke - 19 LPA. TCS - 15 LPA

What are the benefits for a new joiner at Nvidia? do they provide macbooks for employees at work?
What are the perks?

How is Nvidia salary compared to other semiconductor companies like Intel, QC, AMD for verification roles?Intel Corporation Nvidia Qualcomm Arm Analog Devices Samsung

like

Hi All,, Has anyone joined UST - PTEC (equifax) company recently for pune or other locations? Can someone please provide review of the same. Thinking to join the same on 30th dec.

Please respond.

like

YOE 15+
IBM 34 LPA
Global Logic 39 LPA
PM Role, Bangalore location.. which one should I choose? Please let me know.. IBM is not ready to negotiate.

LTI or Sears holdings
Which one is good to join
LTI - 33 lpa + 1 joining bonus
Sears- 35 + 1 joining bonus
Stack- GCP data engineer
I have joining on this coming Monday.

like

Do you know what is the worst and heart burning job in this IT world????

Being a HR earning peanuts and giving every Tom ,Dick and Harry 20 plus offer letters .....need to know actual HRs opinion on this ?

likefunnyuplifting

There was a time i got 7 lkh offer and i was over the moon, back in 2014. Now have offer of 30 lkh, still not happy.

likefunny

Hello folks,
What is expected package for 8.8 YOE, Oracle Apps DBA?

Hi All,
Tata Consultancy TCS or Vodafone (VOIS) -- Same CTC
Stack:- ETL Testing, SQL, UNIX and GCP
Location:- Pune
Looking for WLB, job security and learning Opportunities
YOE:- 8 year's
Please suggest me

like

Hi,
Can I re negotiate salary after accepting offer at
Infosys? I am also holding other offers. Can I negotiate or counter offer again ?

Hey everyone,

I need your suggestion on the negotiation process .
I have got an offer from Meesho with base pay 15 LPA, and expecting an offer of around 18 LPA from a good Bangalore based company.

I wanted an offer of around 20-24 lpa ..how should I negotiate that ( also got feedback that interview rounds went really well) ?

Work ex : 1.9 years

like

Please help me unlock dm, i need 11♥️

like

Hi All,

i am .net dev with 3.3 yoe have offer of16 lpa (service) and my current company (product) is trying to retain me with 14 lpa its been 1.2 yrs in my current company. Tech stack is good over here. What should i do ? b please suggest.

like

What does this mean DTCC ? I have applied previously and it was the same later it was no longer under consideration.

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes ,

Below is my salary breakup .. can someone please let me know how much in-hand i ll get..

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes, Need 11 likes to use the DM service. Can you guys please help?

like

Hello guys,
Today I had salary negotiation with
Capgemini , they are offering 15 lpa with 10% variable. I feel this is a bit low based on current market standards. I asked for 20 initially, but they are not willing to go beyond 15 without any counter offer. HR flat out rejected 20 saying business will not approve. what is the max they will give after providing counter offer? And if i join around November, when will i be eligible for next appraisal? They are offering c1 band.
YoE 6
Tech golang

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal