How do interviews go about comparing notes after interviewing with multiple people ?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I sat in on one with my manager and all the interviewers basically gave their pros and cons, what stood out, and mostly debating level they'd be brought in at

Usually notes are attached to the candidates file. Personally I do the interview, write up my notes and initial recommendation. I’ll check the other interviewers notes or talk with them directly if I’m on the fence for some reason - like they could potentially be aligned to 2 different groups

We all meet after the interviews are over, and then we each go around and share our impression of the candidate. Then, if everyone is mostly aligned and how they perceived it, we will make a pretty quick decision. If there's less alignment, then we'll debate and think about the context. If we're aligned in terms of our impression, but not really sure if they'd be a good candidate, then we'll keep sharing what we heard in the interview to see if there's anything that can move the needle.

Related Posts

Hello Fishes,

I am a Mechanical Engineer with 4+ years of experience in Gas Turbine (civil large engines).

I am looking for a job change and have come across many opportunities at Siemens Energy Pune.

Can anyone refer me as I am not getting any response after applying at company's careers portal.

like

I am a young professional... But every job interview I’ve had so far pretty much just wants to know what kind of person I am. They are as interested in my leadership/communication as much as they are in me talking about my experience.

(“Real jobs” in accounting, finance and private equity.)

Is this how it will always be? Or is this predominantly because I am in lower positions at this point in my career?

like

Hi fishes,
Can anyone please guide me what to prepare for second round(managerial round) for java developer.

like

Hello Everyone ,
I recently got interviewed jan 22 2022 for QA position with tcs got shortlisted and uploaded documents very next day after 1 week got salary breakup(Feb 1) , when can i expected offer letter?

like

Hello Friends... How long does it take for the HR to come up for a discussion or offer.... In SAP, SAP labs..

I have cleared all the rounds on 9th June, 2022 and awaiting HR round and offer proposal...

Kindly shed more light...

I was so keen on this position... Now I am worried.... Disheartening after almost 5 rounds...

like

LinkedIn always tells me to message the recruiter when I apply for a job. Is this ok/normal to do?

like

Best podcasts, YouTube, TikTok, or um books for interview prep for consulting?

like

What firms in the Philippinesis advisable to apply for a consulting position? kindly provide me an answer

like

Had given the first round of interview. This is my current status. What next?

Post Photo
like

Would anyone familiar with the Meta interview process be able to help with the questions below?

Is there an “acceptable” amount of time you can take between your recruiter screen and the next round of product sense interviews? Does it matter if you’re interviewing for a specific team?

like

Has anyone who interviewed R1 for Stern heard back yet? I’m seeing initial decisions we’re supposed to go out 12/1 but my application still says “we hope to release your decision shortly”

like

Are FAANGs on a hiring freeze for software engineers?

like

Any views on rescheduling first round interviews? Is it frowned upon?

like

The biggest lie you've told during a job interview? And did you ever get caught?

like

Had an interview yesterday and the interviewer wanted to understand what I did - even 1 month gap between jobs - from 2009 to present 🤪 Not interested in the job anymore tbh

likefunny

I have an informational interview with a director of a consulting firm. I’m currently in banking. It’s just been 6 months at this job for me. It’s too slow for me. How do I tell this director why I want to work with him and justify why I want to leave my current firm just after 6 months? I’m an analyst and the role I’m targeting is also analyst level role

like

I have a second interview tomorrow. I already spoke with the partners and now I’ll be speaking with some associates. Any tips on what I should discuss and what questions should I ask?

like

Hi friends! I need some help, I’m currently a Junior Product Manager completing PM/PO/Scrum work and managing the product E2E.
1. My product hasn’t launched into the market so I don’t have KPIs, what other points can I use as achievements on my resume?
2. How likely is it for me to land a PM role with 10 months of experience?
3. Does anyone have any referrals to health tech companies (preferably remote)?

like

DONT JOIN EY INDIA

PATHETIC EXPERIENCE

HR ARE UNPROFESSIONAL DONT CARE IF YOU JOIN NOT JOIN

I AM SO GREAT FUL THAT I HAVE NOT JOINED SUCH USLESS UNIT

I have cracked 4 interview so posting genuine opinion here.

like

More Posts

What should be ideal salary for the AWS DevOps Engineer having 3.5 YOE having tech stack AWS, Terraform, Gitlab/GitHub , Jenkins/gitlab-runner, Prometheus/Grafana. Seeing the demand as per market.
Pls suggest for service based as well as product based

like

Anyone have feedback on in house attorney positions with Mercury Insurance?

like

Anyone work as or been offered a position for an associate product engineer at Target Corporation? The Glassdoor salaries are way higher than my offer and I’m trying to determine what is accurate.

Anyone want a free chefs plate box? They sent me an extra one that I can’t have. Includes three different meals for two people (total 6 portions). Location: downtown.

like

Can anyone tell what’s “Pre-Hire Engagement Program-Business connect at PwC”?
And what kind of questions I may expect, in case they ask?

like

Have interviews set up at FAANG co and getting good signals, for a position that was posted widely (all across US) but not remote. Haven’t broached the subject of location yet. Would you (1) early on clearly state that you’re not open to relocation but that you would be open to visiting a big office once or twice a month; (2) not say anything now and wait to get an offer and ask for an exemption; or (3) something else?

like

Has anyone’s (pre covid) full time travel engagements said anything about what to expect in the coming months/year?

like

Hi, I have an offer from Deloitte India where LTA is shown as part of CTC. Can I get this amount as monthly or I can only claim this in March (year end). Please help existing Deloitte employees. . Urgent. Thanks a lot. Deloitte India Deloitte USI Deloitte

likehelpful

Tired of your job and want to come to KPMG Cyber Services? Drop me a burner here.

likefunny

Hey all! Need a couple book recs for an upcoming beach trip.

Looking for a great non-fiction, relating to travel or world history (not just one moment in time). Could also be about the marketing world or memoirs of a business leader kinda thing.

Fiction wise I also like fantasy, paranormal, and romance. Some fave book series are the Black Gryphon from Mercedes Lackey, Game of Thrones, and From Jamaica Lane series. Similar books?

like

I’ve got a friend in Dubai who has experience in IB and VC at junior levels (in London and Dubai) and would like to break into consulting. He’s at a small cap VC at the moment and works not that challenging, and he wants to break into MBB or tier 2 for strategy. Anyone happy to look at his CV?

like

Is this what winning looks like? #MAGA

like

Best consulting firms (including boutiques) if you want to do product design/development

like

Hi all, I am new to cognizant with 3 yoe. Got selected in Verizon account. If anyone knows about this account can u pls comment how the work life balance will be? and the pressure in the project and working Timings

I’m interviewing for a community manager role with a creative agency tomorrow. Anyone have tips specifically for CM/Strategy roles?

like

Is there anyone from pega profile un IBM? Want to know about work env, work pressure as well as work life balance. Please need some suggestion. Good to join or not

Applying for a job at Aha! Feeling very passionately about this company and was wondering if there are any recruiters who can help to recommend me for the position.

like

Just moved to NYC. 28 M Desi looking to make friends in the city.

like

Hi guys. I need a reference in CGI . I'll provide the job id. Please help

What is it like to work in a design and development team in sap labs as full stack abap developer?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Best exit ops you have seen peers take? (Company, salary, any sweet perks, etc)

likehelpful

How much does a credit score of 760 vs 790 make a difference in a mortgage interest rate? I’m buying a house soon-ish when for inexplicable reasons my score dropped 30 points. 🤨 Follow up qn (tbc)

like

We use Deloitte India for a number of parts of our delivery. Recently I have seen some unethical practices that violate labor laws and do not align with Deloitte principles. My manager says it isn’t my problem as they are a vendor but I can’t help thinking I have an ethical responsibility to do something. Any advice as to how to approach this without being fired?

likehelpful

Happy July 4th long weekend, ya filthy animals!!!

like

Here I come Europe !!! Bye bye to America and visa !!!

like

How does one get the courage to eat alone at a restaurant? Deathly afraid

like

Best city to live in USA? Want to move to a new place, biggest factors are nice weather, cost of living and having a city feel with access to good health care, fitness, food, entertainment, transport

likefunny

Fed folks: what's getting a TS/SCI clearance involve?

like

Working at Deloitte soon! I read the benefits but I’m still a student and don’t really understand what benefits are good and just mediocre. Is the benefits and rewards at Deloitte ACTUALLY good? Any tips to maximize on the benefits? Advice for a new grad hire plz 😭

like

Only thing making staying on a Thursday worth it is the hotel is having a Halloween party...free cotton candy, pop corn, beer and snacks

Post Photo
like

Any fellow type B’s have advice for maintaining sanity while working under an intense type A? Feel like I’m losing my mind here...

like

Had a quick question to people who have applied for Schengen Visa. Which application form do you have to submit when you appear for the interview? The offline pdf form that you fill up, print and sign

like

Any fish can provide insights about the privacy and infosec practice in Álvarez & Marsal?

like

Houston downtown JW vs Westin.. Thoughts?

like

Does EY reimburse for internal travel? Eg team meetings ? About to join EY and may have to travel in the first month. Also, is driving an approved mode of transport and get mileage reimbursement ?

like

Honest question here-hw do I work better with Indians who come over frm India(on-site) to client?My patience with them is at an all time low since they jst dnt gt the methodology & hate owning anythng

What are the best consulting companies in the US focused on Sustainability, either Strategy or Ops?

likefunny

What is normal for associate raises and bonuses? Got 3.2 increase in salary and around same for bonus. Feel like I got shafted. Original salary is around 55,000. Need some different perspectives.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal