I am currently a Senior Associate 1 (Post-MBA grade) promoting to Senior Associate 2 this July in Strategy&, I have just received an offer to join Bain at the Senior Associate Consultant level.
Should I take the offer or negotiate for Consultant level? This will mean a 40+% decrease in compensation in my first year. Will it be worth it long term?
-------
Reposting from Consulting Bowl to get MBB input

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Congrats on the offer! Brand isn’t worth a 40% drop IMO. Definitely negotiate: start with base and move to sign-on bonus if needed. Good luck

like

Why did you interview at the pre mba level in the first place?

like

I interviewed for consultant level, but was offered SAC

like

If you interviewed for consultant but were offered SAC then no I wouldn’t try to negotiate up. I’d take it, and perform. Maybe ask for a bigger signing.

like

If you plan to stay 1-3 years, not worth it. If you plan to stay over 3, then worth it. (The demarcation line may be 2.5)

likesmart

^this is probably the best advice

100% must negotiate to at least consultant level

like

If you perform well, it's possible to get the SAC -> C promo in six months

like

From a compensation perspective, the payback would likely not materialize. This decision must be made as an investment in your personal happiness if you think Bain will provide you more than what have here in terms of day to day work, exit opportunities, culture, etc.

Consultant level or burst

Related Posts

Anyone Hiring or willing to refer for a new role Within industry/strat consulting for TMT (Telco,Media and Tech)

Background : 8YOE (7 for TMT)
4 years in telco strategy (industry)
2.5 years Ex MBB
Currently at Boutique (TMT focus)

LOCATION: UK/London
Thanks!

like

Partners, what are some of the most memorable and effective ways/reasons your team has asked for more comp? If someone is a high performer/emerging talent, what is the typical comp increase you’ve approved?

like

Which company between FIS Global (19 LPA including variable) and EYGDS ( 20 fixed + 10% variable) is better to join in terms of job security and work life balance ? FIS Global EY

like

What is the usual hike percentage one should expect after RT?

Is BA Continuum and Bank of America a separate entity in terms of IT operations? I know In India it's BA Continuum, but I find reviews for both BOFA and BA Continuum in Glassdoor. So getting confusedBank of America BA Continuum India Pvt. Ltd.

How is the company EY india or Ey LLP for Salesforce developers.
Yoe 4

I want to understand about working hours and work pressure.

I have heard few members saying that EY India gives a lot of work pressure and no work life balance,is that true??

When compared to Capgemini, Cognizant,Wipro and TCS ,is it worth joining EY INDIA in terms of wlb

like

Slalom fishes. What is a big4 md equivalent role at slalom? Any idea on comp?

Hi fishes, Tata Consultancy Tech Mahindra IBM Can someone please help to understand how much should be in hand as per below CTC breakup? Without any tax declaration? Also, on my cctc I have declared 70000 pa as hra so if I continue with just this much declaration then what will be inhand?
CCTC 7.5
YOE 5.9 (TOTAL) RELEVANT (4.10)
TECH CYBERSECURITY (IAM)

Tata Consultancy Tech Mahindra IBM

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes & Sharks,

What will be the in-hand salary? Please guide.

Post Photo
like
like

What is the salary range in Accenture for Level 7 in the Applied Intelligence Team? Job location - Bangalore

like
like

Isn’t 100k base pay too little at a boutique asset mgmt firm? 4 yrs buy side experience, started at the same firm straight out of college.

like

Accepted a role with 80k of equity at a late stage start up with 4 year vest. If they IPO, do I wait for 4 years to get all?

like

Does anyone know what redundancy packages firms have been offering in the last 6-12 months? Looking for comparisons

like

I am in a dilemma choosing between Wolters Kluwer and S&P Global(IHS). Any suggestions? Salary and role are the same.

likehelpful

I am a UX designer who has completed a Google certification program along with a resume and professional portfolio. However, I’ve struggled to find a job (remote). Any advice or resources I could use? Or are there any employers currently hiring and are interested? I’d be happy to hear from you.

like

How much % raise they usually offer for the one getting promoted from 601 —> 602?

Also, how much % raise one can ask for?

like

Can anyone working for DT’s ARA or PwC’s CMAAS tell me what does their job specifically include, hours and exit opportunities?

like

Hi All,
I have experience in Automation testing UI and API. Looking for a Remote job.
Please do share if you came across any such opening. 11.9YOE and immediate joiner.
CCTC 11.6.
Also what can be my ECTC?

like

More Posts

You may not know what you want for Christmas this year, but your home sure does! Here is a Holiday wishlist we wrote up that will be a treat for your home this year:

🎄New paint job
🎄Video doorbell
🎄New windows
🎄A deep clean
🎄Solar roof

Your house has been good this year, splurge a little and give it some love back!

#JDTeam #homebuying #homeselling #realestate #chicago

What’s up everyone!! How have y’all’s agencies been doing in COVID? Do you find your businesses have changed product mixes in the last year?

All AA flights delayed in LGA

like

Any recommendations of places to stay in Porto and / or Lisbon? Thanks so much for any help!! : )

like

Does KGS provide shuttle services in Bengaluru?

Is bakery still hiring strat director?

funnylike

Hi ,

I have 5 years of experience as a .NET Full stack developer. I am holding offer of 21 LPA and I had HR discussion with Mastercard.

HR is not ready to share the exact budget they have (weird!! because HR usually give the idea of how much they can offer )

HR is asking me to expect something on top of the current offer I am holding.

The opening is for L8. How much offer I should expect from mastercard??

like

Do you bill late night waiting time? It's 1am now and only reason I'm staying up is to wait for the printer to provide a revised OM so I can review that our changes went in properly and sign off. Do I bill the time between now and when I sign off? Just curious how you all treat this time.

like

💆Self-Care Thread!

What is one way you care for yourself as an educator?

Drop it below to help another user!

helpfullike

If serving notice period now, will i be applicable to receive the hile letter?

like

Hi, I want to apply for UX Designer role Accenture. YOE: 1
Help me understand the process.

like

I need help with my interviewing skills

like

Is the office operational now?

like

Hi, how long will it take to gain expertise in react , given that I know angular very well?

like

I’m have a new theory about why juniors always feel like idiots and wanted to see if anyone else thinks this makes sense. I’m a third year, and am the most junior person all of my teams (generally me, a senior or two, and a partner or two), and I always feel like I’m messing something up. Is this just because I never get to work with other juniors and don’t see the mistakes they make, and that it’s relatively normal? And FWIW I went to HYS and I’ve had a clerkship so it’s not like I’m not smart

like

Got a job but it doesn't start for another two months can I just quit now and work at Rita's Water Ice until my new job starts? My senior is so mean it is honestly just funny.

like

Dear Fishes,

Could someone let me know which is better to join IBM or deloitte USI both are offering same package?
Experience: 3.10 years
Role: Automation testing with selenium and Java

like

Hi queers, queens and everything in between 💕

like

I’m a scheduler in a major hospital, see my position in other departments being advertised as remote available. How can I successfully negotiate WFH? I’d like to cut down on my 44-mile one way commute.

Background: I’ve been in my position for 1 yr. I have 20 yrs military experience, bachelors in Business. I took an entry level $15/hour job to get my foot in the door. I’m actively looking for a promotion. But 44 miles plus gas & business casual clothing on $15/hour is killing me.

like

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

Had a final round at BCG last Friday. After the interviews they said that the would release results today. Then I got an email today saying they will only give the results on the next Friday. What could have happened?? I also know some people how interviewed on the same day as mine and got a rejection email today.

like

McKinsey 🐠: how much did you practice before your case interviews? (i.e. how many weeks / months in advance, how many hours per week, etc?) any tips on most effective ways to prep as an experienced hire coming in at the associate level? (No MBA or finance background so may need some extra prep to learn key concepts / terms)

like

How bad is it to sound shaky during the case interview? I got everything right and nailed the math but I feel like I sounded like I was about to cry even though I was confident 🤦🏻‍♀️

like

Bain & Company Are consultants for the CPG practice area/having CPG clients travelling yet? McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company

like

Why are is implementation a separate application for McKinsey? Speaking in mba recruiting terms

like

In my application to McKinsey, do I include past unpaid internships as Work Experience?

like

Do you always need an MBA to get into MBB?

likefunny

Fellow MBBers, any of you think the banking raises will trickle over to us (110k starting) or nah?

like

Hi - I have an upcoming conversation with BCG Partner next week. I had reached out to her to understand experienced hire opportunities. What can I expect during this call? My goal is to get an interview.

like

What’s the difference between manager and senior manager at Bain and how long from Consultant level?

like

Those who exited MBB, what were your options? I know I don’t want to stay in consulting and feel like trying industry soon. Most of my background is in finance and strategy.

like

How much does the case bot case matter for Boston Consulting Group? Heard that people where able to make it to the next round even failing it?

like

If a senior partner referred me, and I still haven't heard back after 4 weeks, what could be the reason as to the delay? Am I not getting an interview?

like

What’s the standard RTO (return to office) plan for MBB as of now?

like

I have my first round interview (phone case) with McKinsey tomorrow. Any tips on what to expect with the phone case? Will there be an introduction (elevator pitch + why McKinsey?) or will they jump straight into the case? It’s only 30 mins.

like

Got offered a role at a Middle East office at BCG - haven't accepted yet.
Anyway that I can transfer to a north American office (my current location) before I join? SO can't move to Dubai and while applying they didn't interview me for my current location just for the Dubai one.

I understand this may be a big ask, and I'm happy to interview again if need be.

like

Had my final round last week at McK and still haven’t heard back. Resisting the urge to ping the recruiter until at least next week.
As an aside, I sent thank-you notes to all of the interviewers but didn’t hear back. None bounced back so I’m hopeful that I got the email convention right. Send me good vibes!

like

Have a R1 with BCG but the HR said in the invitation that their first start dates for Consultant are in 2022. Is this normal? Can this be negotiated?

like

Re-invited to interview at BCG but also want to cast a wide net and apply for Mck and Bain. However got rejected last year this time at the resume screen stage. I’ve changed firms since I last applied (to a well known boutique) - is this sufficient or am I still frozen?

like

McKinsey 🐟: does your ops practice heavily prefer people with practical experience instead of current operations consultants from other firms? As an ops consultant from another firm, what would be the best way to lateral into mck ops?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal