I made it to final round interviews at two of the big 4 but unfortunately didn't get either role. Both rejections came within 48 hours of the final interviews with generic feedback which was similar to each other and had something along the lines of 'strong candidate but just not the right fit'. Has anyone actually gotten useful rejection feedback or is this just code for something else because what am I meant to do with this?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yeah, I feel like recruiting is a lot like dating. No one is going to be honest with why they’re rejecting you. A lot of “it’s not you, it’s me”

likefunny

Funny but true haha

like

Did you get the name of the recruiter and their contact information? I had 30+ rejections before I was hired and my luck changed when I reached out to the recruiter and eventually she advocated for me to a partner for a different role.

Also, did you get email addresses for the people that interviewed you? I would reach out to them with an email saying thank you and I received a rejection but genuinely loved the team and would love to know what I can do to better so I can reapply with better credentials for the future. I’ve learned more senior managers are career coaches and/or happy to provide guidance when they can.

I did this for a different big 4 company and used the feedback to strengthen credentials and resume for the future. Their feedback also helped me eventually land the role I have now for a different firm.

like

I think following up is a sign you care. I would send an email, follow up in about a week or two if you don’t hear back. If you don’t hear back, THEY weren’t worth your time anyways and you don’t want to work with people like that anyways. Respect goes both ways and just because you didn’t get a job doesn’t mean you’re not qualified or can be in the future.

like

An honest feedback is not possible often because it could lead to lawsuits. If you didn't get the role, no worries. You will eventually land a great job.

like

And that's fair. If you prepared well and delivered well, then that is what's in your control.

like

I was thinking the employers are frowning at my age.

like

Too old

like

Honestly you may never really know.

like

Sometimes they don't have any besides a feeling. So there might not be much to say. Make sure you ask questions, show that you prepped, and always send a thank you after an interview.

like

If you worked with a recruiter or have contact info of an interviewer you can reach out and ask for genuine feedback.

like

If you want to talk yourself out of asking for it, then there you go, don’t ask. You’ll never know if they have any feedback for you to improve on unless you ask.

like

You dodged a bullet, some would say

like

I just got let go from a job i didnt even start because i wasn't a good fit.... was supposed to start the 26th... a friend of a friend babby momma probably needed a job....

like

What do you think changed? Why would they suddenly retract the offer?

At least you’re getting interview calls. I’m not even getting interviews despite applying to many places.

like

It’s really rough out there at the moment, have to just keep applying and something will come good for you eventually

Strong candidate but likely someone with a connection got it.. it’s not enough to be good right now

like

Yes I’d say so! Anyone vouching for you helps because even if you’re crushing interviews, there will be a bias towards a candidate that someone has recommended since they will then know how they actually work

like

What level are you and do you have any big four experience previously?

Related Posts

Hi All

Need career guidance
Qualifications: b.com graduate; MBA in Finance and Marketing
Campus Hire at Deloitte
Profile: Engagement Financial Advisor
Years of experience 4 years

Please guide

like

Hi Fishes,

How's the AVP post in azure domain for
HDFC Bank Mumbai?
What should be the salary bracket one can hope for this position?

YOE - 11+
Tech - Azure Cloud Stack

Any feedback or insights will be greatly appreciated.

Mindtree culture is detoriating day by day . No clarity on hike and appraisal even though mail have been sent regarding this since Dec 2021 . Disgusting HR head practice who joined from CTS . How come they don't abide by what they communicate and keep silence without any update for delay .
Shameful . Feeling Disappointed. Has joined this company 11 months back with hopes for longer and fruitful association but will resign soon . Pathetic company Mindtree
Whats your opinion about your org ? Tq

like

How long does it take in tcs to complete the bgv? When can i know whether it is completed successfully or not?

like

My LWD is 2nd July 2022 and I got offer letter from TCS in March. Can anyone let me know when will I get the joining letter from TCS?

like

Anyone got onboarding today 19th Oct 2022..? Bangalore location..?

like

36 F Black NYC Divorced, 1 tween. anyone want to get to know one another better?

likeuplifting

The learning and design content I write belongs to the company where I work. Am I able to add and/or share my work in my portfolio? Is it acceptable to create some generic content to demonstrate my skill set?

like

need just one like.. plz?

like

Anyone hit this morning on the Jordan birthday restock?

What are your thoughts on Porsche’s consulting subsidiary? Would it compete with T2 or T3 when it comes to industrials and automotive?

like

Hi fishes,

I got a offer of 26lpa(23.5 fixed and 2.5 variable) from genpact and 21 lpa (20 fixed , 1 joining) from epam, not sure which one should I join. Please if someone can advice me which i should join keeping ressession in mind. Thanks in advance@

like

Mercedes-Benz Research & Development India Hello.
My job application status in portal says it is under review since one month but I haven't recieved any calls or mails. Does it mean I am still in consideration or they have put my candidature on hold?
Daimler Truck Innovation Center India Daimler Mercedes-Benz Research & Development India

like

Is DC a competitive office to get into for McKinsey?

like

Anyone in Southwest Florida know of Healthcare worker relief funds that are legitimate? Fort Myers and the surrounding areas were devastated and many critical workers have lost everything. Hospitals are evacuating and staff are moving away from whatever is left of their homes…please advise

like

If you had to describe your dating life in one word, what would it be?

like

90 Days notice period has 2 phases.

Initial phase - Candidates struggling to get interview calls.

Ending phase - Companies struggling to match a higher offer.

30 days notice period can really solve everyone's struggle.

like

Any thoughts ? My H1B transfer is in process and I’m trying to understand if it even makes to sense to get PTO paid out after the hike

Post Photo

I'm working in the US under H1B, I got a chance to face an interview for another company. My current company started the PERM application also and results will be out within the next 3 months. Is it okay to transfer my H1B to a new company? Can my H1B transfer be denied? How long will my green card application delay if I move to a new company and start to apply for a green card from scratch?

like

Additional Posts in Job Searching in Accounting

Does anyone know the Manager and Senior Manager salary bands for Global Mobility Tax in London at Vialto Partners, EY, KPMG & Deloitte? Also would be great to know what the typical sign-on bonus is for these grades. Thanks

likesmart

Is investment accounting a good career path? Looking for any insight to the role, career progression, exit ops, etc. I got the opportunity to work at a very well known wealth asset management company as an investment accountant. I do enjoy finance as well. Pay is very good so I’m wondering if I should take the opportunity?

like

After every busy season, I think about leaving public accounting and/or the firm. I have 5+ years in tax. Anyone switch to audit/consulting from tax? Two busy seasons a year, with barely anytime to chill in between is exhausting. Anyone in private looking to hire someone with a background in federal tax?

like

If you’re a Canadian looking for a Junior accountant role (0-2 years of experience in accounting) in tech, shoot me a DM

Primarily remote roles

Is $100K good for a supervising senior at a mid sized firm?

like

Recently got my CPA license in August & considering leaving public accounting for Industry. Should I expect my new role to pay for my CPA license renewals/AICPA membership/CPE classes? These things add up &I feel like should be considered when transitioning. Thoughts?

like

Looking for a remote/hybrid job working on Global Information Reporting (FATCA/CRS). Prefer to be in house. In the NYC/NJ/CT area. I would appreciate any leads. Thanks!!

like

I am looking for a lower stress, mostly remote, part time job. Any recommendations? My background is corporate Income tax. 10 years experience.

like

Out of curiosity. How would a company view a potential candidate who has a period of unemployment to study for the CPA. I am considering to start studying for the exam but I know I would need to leave my employer in order to give 110%. I am contemplating the idea of at least passing one part while employed. Then leaving my employer to study FAR. I am considering to leave my current employer anyways, so it’s more of how my future employer would view that lapse.

likehelpful

Hi all,

Do firms match offers from other Big 4s for campus hires? I’ve received a campus offer from both
KPMG and EY. I’m more interested in the EY offer, but they are paying 3k less than KPMG.

Would it be a bad move to let them know about the other offer and try negotiating? I feel it wont make a difference in the long run, but at the same time I don’t want to leave any money on the table if possible.

Thanks!

KPMG EY PwC Deloitte

likefunny

I interviewed at KPMG on 11/14 and got a verbal offer the next day but since then waiting to hear from them. Been following up continuously but the partners are not replying it seems. In the meanwhile i have an offer from BT offering 90k for 4 yrs of experience which seems to be fair. I am just unsure whether to accept the offer as I was waiting for kpmg reply as I want B4 on my resume which apparently is a big deal. Is BT also good on resume for future employers ??

likehelpful

About to interview with Neuberger Berman, hadn’t heard of them before. Anyone have any thoughts on their culture and WLB?

like

Is senior manager level in an investment bank(RBC ) lower than manager level in big 4? If yes , which title will be same to manager level in a big 4?

like

How many PTO/Vacation days do you usually take off a year if your employer offers unlimited PTO/Vacation days?

I just started a new job and this is the first time I’ve ran into this. It sounds nice but at the same time I hate the lack of direction. Help!

like

Currently applying to a government position for the army corps of engineering. Does anybody have experience working for the government?

like

I’m thinking of applying to UnitedHealth Group as a senior accountant. The position is fully remote. Does any know what it’s like working for them? Also, does anyone know what the compensation looks like for this position in Arizona? Thank you.

like

Deloitte Tax is hiring experienced professionals at all levels. Depending on experience, you can be promoted during hiring process (i.e. Senior 3 getting hired as a Manager).

DM me if interested!

like

Hey everyone, Withum is still hiring entry-level staff accountants (audit and tax) with the start date of November 2023, experienced associates, senior associates, and more!
The firm is currently number 22 in the nation based on INSIDE Public Accounting. AMAZING culture, good wlb, and really nice people (at least in the nyc office). Please message me directly if you’re interested!

likefunny

I currently work as a senior accountant in Nashville. Is it possible to go to public accounting?

likefunny
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal