Is it a bad move to accept a lower paying job with a higher title? Going from current title to IT Manager at a bigger company and about $16k less.

likefunnysmarthelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Honestly titles are just ego at the end of the day. The only real point of promotions for me is the earning potential so easier choice for me is higher pay rather than higher title. Are the benefits better for you though?

likeupliftinghelpful

Untrue. If you get a better title, then the job after this job may be a better job too because they will see that you already held the position of IT manager. It’s the long game.

likesmart

If this job will give you the experience of the IT manager which allows you to move to another company later and earn much more then yes. If it’s a title but no experience upgrade then no it’s not a good move. Think about the next step and ask :” would this move enable me (in one year) to get another IT manager job somewhere else with a a substantial salary upgrade ?

like

I managed teams of a dozen plus while in customer service because it was the only way to make any money in that space. I moved to IT and make a lot more NOT managing anyone. I'm not sure you could pay me enough now to go back and manage people... and for less money? That'd be a hard no. But to your point... if it's going to allow you to make more in the future go for it. I just realized my happiness not having to manage other people was the better fit.

likehelpful
Recent IconRecent

It sounds like more responsibility with less pay. But if the overall package is better or it sets you up for future success, maybe?

As long as it’s room to grow financially with the position

Negotiate

It depends on many factors. Where you are in life, can you afford a pay cut? Does the new company offer a better position with more opportunities. Will things benefit your career and life?

Weigh up the pros and cons.

I made a career change in which I took a drastic pay cut. But the benefits for me in doing so out weighed the financial side. A few years of struggling to get by, I'm now financially better off and have a better work/life balance. I can't say what's the better option, only you know what is best forvyou

job title is representing ego. It depends on how many time you can successfully asked your boss for rising your salary.

Titles don’t matter. I got a senior PM title but I got 35% paycut. I didn’t have any choice as I didn’t have any other job offer. However this role looks quite decent on the resume, so I believe that I will have a much better paying job after this one.

I think it may be a bad move, the higher your title the less chances for vertical improvement and the longer it could take to get promoted, if on top of that you're getting a lower salary it means it will grow less.

Yes it is bad. Don’t do it. Someone tells you otherwise don’t listen.

It‘s not about tags. It’s about what’s your value and how you are valued by your company plus how you contribute to the company

This is very true!! I totally agree!

I'd have to see a lot of extras about the job: great working environment, new skills, written promises of more money, stock options.

I love what I do, I really do... but I am always quick to point out that I'm not in this business for my health. If I'm taking a significantly smaller paycheck, there are going to be extenuating circumstances that would explain why.

I did exactly this. A $30k cut but a higher title. Because in the future employers will just see the title which has a much higher range over $50-100k more, so it should in theory make levelling salary when moving on again in a year or two much more likely. Time will tell!

If you’re into books, look into the book “Decisive” by Chip and Dan Heath, in just the first chapter it gives a great overview/framework for decisions like this. Good luck!

Are you going to be working more for less money? What place will you like more, don't move if you like the people at your old job. Will the move make you happier.

I started as a Desktop support, and now I'm a CIO and couldn't feel worse about it. I hate doing this job and not still talking to the people and fixing their computers. Even as CIO, it's a glorified manager with more responsibilities, and it sucks. Pay is better, but I'd rather be Desktop again and have less stress.

Hope this helps you figure out what's best for you.

Depends can you pay bills with the title? Cash is king

You only take lower pay to escape to bad job or to switch career track into something where you aren't highly skilled yet. You don't lose money to get a different title. That will take you years likely to recoup the loss in pay. Not worth it in my opinion. Find a different / better paying job. They are out there. Current market should start improving in a few months.

The title is irrelevant, but there are certainly times when accepting a lower paying job is the right move. A few years back I took a 10k paycut so that I could work a job that worked better with my going back to school to get a degree. I think in the long run this will be worth it.

lower paying job with higher title doesnt make sense .. the only time I would consider lower pay would be when i change career from one stream to another (for career growth)

Titles don't put groceries on the table. It may take you several years for your compensation to rise to the level of your current job.

Yes, it is a bad move unless they are offering you alternative compensation that will pay adequately for that position. The title usually comes with additional responsibilities and that is the reason it is expected to pay more. To have more pressure for less money is a bad deal.

Related Posts

Hi
Can someone refer me in Citi
If there is an opening for analytics position

Skills: Python,SQL,excel,sas

Yoe: 2.3

like

What is the average salary for a senior design engineer - java at Schneider Electric for 5 YOE?

like
like

How difficult is it to lateral to other areas of tax without prior experience in the area? (Ex: Income tax planning to estate planning, corporate tax to exec comp, or estate planning to controversy work, etc.) Assuming you have an LLM or a couple years of experience in your first tax area.

like

Level 10.1 how much hike and vpay?

like

For 7.3 lpa fixed what would be the in hand salary... please help

like

Hi fishes, Can anyone please give expected CTC for senior business analyst at Swiggy ? Also a breakup of different components will be useful. Yoe 3.5. thanks!

In hand salary?? plz help

Post Photo
like

I bought a house in the suburbs of Chicago at the top of the market. I ended up moving out of state in 2017 and short-selling. I am now interviewing for a VP Accounting role with the mortgage company that got shafted by the short sale. If I get the job offer, can they/will they see this on my credit report? Can they pull the offer due to this? Should I tell them before we advance further?

like

Hi!!
Recently I applied for the SOC role in IBM. Cleared all the rounds. The HR was offering me 5.7 lpa. I asked for more. HR said she would check and get back. Hasn't replied to my calls since the last 4 days. Should I expect a call?
Current CTC: 4.5 lpa
YOE: 2.5

like

Hi friends please help me to choose following Real page 27 lakhs fixed cgi 24fixed+1l variable pay + 1 lakh joining bonus 10 yoe Please help me to choose good one interms of web and job security

like

How much I can expect in hand.

Post Photo
like
like

13 LPA fixed for Package Specialist. Is it good for a 3.2 years exp candidate? How much can we expect in hand?

like

For a SAP BODS consultant with 7 years of experience, what should be the package in current market?

like

For SAP Is coding knowledge required ? If not then are non coding sap roles are in demand in India also please share how will be the future and pkg ..thanks

like

Why does the recruiting process after passing all interviews stall? We are at a standstill in salary negotiations and I am losing momentum joining? Common problem?

like

Hey fishes,

I am in discussion for a Manager level (Most probably M2) in the Deals advisory role at KPMG India. What compensation (fixed and total) should I be expecting? Thanks in advance for your inputs.
YoE: relevant - 6+, total- 10
MBA: Tier 2 IIM

like

Hi Fishes, Can someone please refer me for lead Analyst position in Wells Fargo, Bengaluru location. I have 8+ years of experience with SAS and SQL as primary skills and need to relocate to Bengaluru. Thanks in advance.

like

Hi Fishes, If I join Bank of America (BA Continuum) on October 1st, will I be eligible for hike in coming appraisal. Bank of America BA Continuum India Pvt. Ltd.

like

More Posts

Anyone work with AI at a macro level? I am trying to understand how AI is consumed today within software? I would guess software companies use cloud providers AI solutions followed by open source and then maybe through smaller providers, proprietary AI and APIs. Anyone has deeper understanding of this?

like

What’s FDD like at Bain, BCG, or McKinsey?

funnylike

What do you guys think about BitTorrent ?

like

Hi everyone! What do you want to accomplish this week?

I have been searching for job from quite a long time and all I have seeing HR/Panels asking for
1. Number of implementation projects done.
2. Work experience on S4 Hana.

And if I don't have atleast any one of these, I will not be considered.

Is it really that important ?

Being joined as a fresher - Is it really something that I can decide whether to be in support or implementation project ?

Is upgrading of ECC to S4 Hana in my hands ? And the difference is really that vast ?

like

Hey guys confused between FRACTAL and NAGARRO?

FRACTAL hire for 6 week training program then Project and Nagarro directly for project.

Having 4 year's of experience, looking for good wlb, job security, stability and good work for Data Engineer role.

like

Just registered for WAATBP end of this month and am looking forward to it!

like

I am 7yrs into fed gov consulting after a postdoc at NIH (PhD, MBA), not doing LiSci work which I misses. Recently moved away from DC and want a change in career - can someone told me more about the career trajectory of CI? Is it join the firm and “climb the corporate ladder”? Thanks!

like

I got an offer from Natwest. My current company is accenture and they are offering me to promote as an assoc manager if i take my resignation back. Shall i consider it? What whould i prefer Nat west or promotion in Accenture. How much hike accenture gives while promoting? Any inputs?

likehelpful

Please help Fishes

Post Photo
like

H1B 🐟 - If alt traveling on fridays, which city do you charge your time to? My visa doesn’t technically allow me to work in the city that I am alt traveling to.

like

I made a switch from marketing to another function within IBM, somehow it's not going well people wise. Looking for marketing operations, Ecosystem (Channel) program and business ops roles. Do DM if you come across any roles in your circles. Thank you

like

Fresh out the box.

Post Photo
like

HI! Everyone, I’m new on this group , i want to make some new connections and get some solid relationships build here. If anyone else wants to do some virtual handshakes, reach out and connect

like

Anyone suggest how is the variable payout in Congnizant?

like

If anyone is hiring in Canada please kindly give my partner a chance. The wait, dilemma and uncertainty is taking a very big toll from us.
-He got almost 5 years of project management, bid management and proposal management experience for a construction consultant company.
-He got experience in Primavera, got excellent statistical analysis skill, can use python for constructing ML models,
- He is proficient in RFP,RFI,RFQ for construction projects as he got BSc in Civil Engineering and MBA. 🙏🙏

like

I think Alexa is my best friend.

like

How is Microsoft's Customer Value Engineering team? How is the work culture, work life balance and growth opportunities?

like

At a tech company with less than 50 people and $6 M Revenue. Our current maternity and paternity leave policy is not good for attracting talent. 12 weeks for mom only 4 weeks paid and no time off for dads. Curious to know what policy other companies have, and can you let me know size and approx rev of company?

like
like

Additional Posts in Tech

Recently joined Meta and want to give back to the community that’s been a huge support.

DM for a referral if you find an open role that interests you and you meet the listed requirements.

like

This weekend flew by smh. Can't believe it's about to Monday already

like

So I need help ! I received an offer for director position at pharma. How do I negotiate my offer? They are asking if I will be moving away from stock options, bonus and vacation. Can I lie about my bonus even though I have already received it? Will it convince them to give me a signing offer? Let me know please

like

How do referrals work? Do you apply first or wait for the referral, then apply? Looking for a tiktok referral.

like

l am currently a rising junior in
college interning this summer at
Amazon as a Business Analyst. I
would really like to break into
product management and believe in
my 5 weeks so far I have shown skills
to back that up. Would it be
acceptable to ask my manager to
recommend me for a product
management internship next
summer? My midpoint meeting with
my manager (and his manager) is
next Friday

like

how long does it traditionally take at Amazon for a TPM to go from L5 to L6? I know Amazon prices itself on merit promo but there must be some average length of time if anyone knows!

like

When a private company is acquired, can preferred shares and RSU’s legally be paid out in a different price per share?

like

I was contacted by a recruiter with a job in the EV market, which is something I've been wanting for a while. Im at a comfortable point in my current position where I can do my job very easily, change would mean starting from zero again. What should I do? Any advise?

like

I've been interviewing with some companies, and now I have to decide between JPMorgan Chase and Globant.

Globant is more innovative, and has remote work. I will enter to work with a Sillicon Valley startup based in San Francisco. The tech stack is React, Nextjs, AWS, and a serverless architecture.

JPM is semi remote, and less innovative. The tech stack Java, SpringBoot and AWS. But I'd do more migration tasks, like dockerize projects and pass them to kubernetes. What would you choose?

like

Started at a big firm in July with high hopes- in the career path I wanted and I would be joining with other new grads.
After onboarding, it’s as if my team forgets about us every day. The training is non existent, there doesn’t seem to be any initiative to invest in new hires, my manager scolds me for not knowing enough yet gives no direction. I don’t want to waste time (colleagues mentioned it doesn’t get much better from here). Do I embrace the suck or look for other opportunities?

like

My company, Pegasystems, is agressively hiring for Senior Solutions Consultant (presales) positions nationwide. If you are interested in working for an amazing company with market leading products and a great culture, please message me. Happy to discuss further. Assuming you are reasonably qualified, I can provide a referral as well.

like
like

Anyone looking for a job? Shoot me a message if you want to hear more about the following role
- senior computer engineer
- senior account manager
- software engineer (also principle engineer)
- senior product owner
- senior account manager

These roles would be at a progressive company changing the game in the wealth management space. This company owns a suite of wealth management software products used by some largest financial organizations. DM me, I'll tell you more.

likehelpful

Just wanted to know how much a resource promoted to SA from A will make in Chicagoland area Vs a resource traveling from India to US in the same designation as SA in cognizant. YOE 11years.

like

What are the most lucrative industries to move into from Tech? Is the transition easy?

like

Anyone have experience taking the GCP Machine Learning exam?

like

Has anyone rented office space over the last year so that you didn't have to be stuck in your home all day? Was it worth it, or did you just feel lonely there?

like

Does Coinbase send welcome gifts / swag to new hires during the first week?

funny

Are FAANG companies really the place to be for SWE’s? I want to work for one but I’m worried about culture & work/life balance.

like

In case anyone is looking to get into product management, I came across this image which shows some books you could read to get into the role.

P.S: I saw this on Linkedin posted by Dr Milan Milanovic. So all credits to him!

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal