Is it a bad move to accept a lower paying job with a higher title? Going from current title to IT Manager at a bigger company and about $16k less.

likefunnysmarthelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Honestly titles are just ego at the end of the day. The only real point of promotions for me is the earning potential so easier choice for me is higher pay rather than higher title. Are the benefits better for you though?

likeupliftinghelpful

Untrue. If you get a better title, then the job after this job may be a better job too because they will see that you already held the position of IT manager. It’s the long game.

likesmart

If this job will give you the experience of the IT manager which allows you to move to another company later and earn much more then yes. If it’s a title but no experience upgrade then no it’s not a good move. Think about the next step and ask :” would this move enable me (in one year) to get another IT manager job somewhere else with a a substantial salary upgrade ?

like

I managed teams of a dozen plus while in customer service because it was the only way to make any money in that space. I moved to IT and make a lot more NOT managing anyone. I'm not sure you could pay me enough now to go back and manage people... and for less money? That'd be a hard no. But to your point... if it's going to allow you to make more in the future go for it. I just realized my happiness not having to manage other people was the better fit.

likehelpful
Recent IconRecent

I did the opposite. I took a step down in title, but gained a 30% pay increase.

like

Same here..

like

Titles don’t mean a thing. Speaking from personal experience

likehelpful

Depends on industry. In the IT world helpdesk, technician, analyst, admin, engineer all have kinda specific meanings. But titles like Vice President don't mean diddly....And cause people to think more highly of themselves than they should. and don't get me started on the paragraph-length job titles no one cares to even finish reading!

nah brother, unless entire comp package + benefits are worth it as well. but title alone? no

like

I took a job with less responsibility for more money. M9 to I10. For me it's all about staying out of debt, taking care of my family, and building retirement wealth. If you are doing it to get the experience, I'm sure there are management opportunities where it would be more lateral monetarily for you. Check other opportunities before taking this one.

like

16k is nothing, think big picture if the role is for you. If you ask they will match it.

like

I am a big fan of an Excel spreadsheet with two columns: pros and cons. For all the people saying that titles don’t mean anything, I hear you but it’s the first thing that they look at on a resume when they’re scanning it under 60 seconds. Forget about keyword data pull. For me it’s generally the scope of the position and the money - that’s all. If I’m making less, the only reason is the pros have to outweigh enough to be able to justify it in one sentence.

like

If you want a title, start your own company and make yourself CEO title. Otherwise, stick with the place that pays you more, bro.

like

Reminds me of a guy who thought titles were meaningless and owned a pub. So he called himself the CEO of the pub.

Call me anything u want, just give me more money.

like

The most lucrative strategy is generally to take the lowest ranking position for the highest possible value. This increases your overall earning potential before you cap out and have to find a new gig to increase it.

Note: value is subjective and I value $$$. Sometimes you sacrifice $$$ for stability, good healthcare or to add something to your portfolio because of your values.

like

No way lower pay for a title,
that's like elon musk saying Im going work for NASA

like

I was offered 15K less to go from software architect to manager of engineering. Pushed back and ended up 5K lower. It gives me two good paths now though. Architect and Management to move forwards with.
Like it or not, titles matter. When that shows up on your resume, it stands out.

like

Less is not better. The company is the one giving you the title but not the worth.

like

If you can use it as a stepping stone on your resume. It may make sense in the long run.

like

Depends what your reason is for working. Mine was always to earn money. The more the better.
However if the lower paying job can lead to a much higher salary, the temporary hit might be worth it

like

Mate, title names are just another reason to put a load on your plate, stick with your worth and look around. As even with a promotion you still won't reach your current wage package, unless you are being pushed out or being made redundant, stay put. Everything around this time of year Hiring wise is little or far between. Wait till February to start looking. I hope this helps

like

Don't do it. Titles don't always mean the same thing at different companies. So you're taking a paycut for a title that may not actually gain you anything in the future.

I'd say pass on it

like

As someone who's reviewed resumes for years, titles matter when getting in the door no matter what everyone else here thinks. We all know it's SO much harder to get the first assignment at a new level but once you're there for a year or two, suddenly you have a flood of recruiters for that job on LinkedIn.
I took a minor pay cut (same salary, no equity) for my first EM job which led me to being recruited for FAANG management roles 2 years later and eventually landing one. It's all about where you want to go.

like

This can be a good move or a bad move based on your personal circumstances and goals.

Is that pay not essential to your immediate plans? Future raises, promotions or taking that title and experience to another shop to get the better money is a common and great plan, especially if you just need the experience to get you there.

If the title would be nice in the future but you need the money now, look for better money opportunities regardless of the title and get the title later.

In my personal experience, technical expertise and experience in individual contributor roles (Senior and lead technical roles) commonly can pay more than lower to middle, semi-technical or non-technical management jobs.

like

Related Posts

How do you all role out your ERG

like

I’ve been in my current position (Bookkeeper) for 4 years now. I’m highly interested in taking the PHR, and I’m wondering if I would qualify for the 4 year HR professional job requirement to be eligible to test for the certificate. I work for a small business, therefore I do all the on boarding paperwork/payroll. Any advice is appreciated.

like

Thoughtworks Actively for various Engineering Roles !!!!

Use Below Form to send your resume for referral.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdteOWrQAQkcsYHcGd4WgxX3ggZHC3Clprg8zfa3YPVf3hZnw/viewform?usp=sf_link/

for more information, look at the attached image.

Link is broken ? No worries, you can find my email ID in the below image. Send you updated resumes with the area of preferences.

Post Photo
like

Would anyone be willing to provide a referral in the quant trading industry. Much appreciated!

like

Good afternoon!
Calling all LPNs!
Could anyone share their pay rate, current position, experience level and basic location?
Trying to get a feel for how much we are generally getting.

Thanks in Advance.

likehelpful

Is it fair to say once you’re an LS consultant you can always fall back to a tier 2,3 firm? For context I’m looking to go from consulting to a hospital implementation role.

like

Any recommendations for a coach (or even therapist) to help work through some career issues?

like

Please explain if we get internet reimbursement outside the CTC?? Not the tax exemption part . I have heard we get 1200 per month for internet . Is it true ?

like
like

What city do you work in?
What’s your title?
Salary?

like

What's the salary range for D2 - Program Manager position in CG??

like

I'm working as Senior Test Engineer with 5 years of experience in manual and now want to become Scrum Master. I'm confused that whether I'll be able to make it or not as SM because I don't have any experience in same. Please guide and help.
How much package can I expect after switch as SM?

like

Employees at TCS took this line seriously 😹.
After getting mails of working from office.
Putting papers and more are searching for new companies.
Attrition rise to 21.5+
Will increase more...

2025 only 25% in office wali scheme ka kya hua 🙌
25 din me paisa double wali scheme nikali ye to 😹

Post Photo
funnylikesmart

Base/Equity expectations for Series A Fintech (non engineering leadership role) in the Bay Area? 10 YoE. Thinking about a move but trying to understand the risk/reward.

like

Can you leverage RSUs ( has not been vested) to negotiate

like

EY Business Transformation Senior Consultant Salary 5YOE (only 1 in Consulting) Tier 1 city?

like

Hey, incase you are interested in SALESFORCE referral for any openings , send me your resume and details at zeuskype@gmail.com

Full Name :
Phone number:
Country phone code:
Email id :
Linkedln link :
Job id :
Why you are fit for this role:

like

Hi Amazon ,
Can you please explain the difference between technical program manager vs non tech program manager

like

Does anyone have experience going from industry to public? I have 4 years of experience and I’m waiting on my last CPA score. Everytime I look at job postings, they seem to require public experience

Hi All,

Any openings for Documentum Admin at pune location ?

More Posts

Senior Associate salary for coms role? 5 YOE. Starting the interview process & seeing a huge range depending on what people are working on and don’t want to lowball myself. Thank you!

like

Anyone know what’s going on with hiring in Customer & Operations? Will end of fiscal year mean more aggressive hiring in October?

like

Hi I am a software professional with around 12 years of experience. I am currently working at D. Can any one please refer me to KPMG?

like

Im a hoarder but i like all my stuff. Its overwhelming.

like

One I was proud of

Post Photo
like

I have an offer in hand from 1 org and negotiating with another for a better pay.
However the other organisation is asking to share the offer letter.
Should I share?

like

Hi Fishes,

I have been offered an on-site opportunity for Toronto, Canada. What should be the decent yearly pay in Canadian dollars that I should ask for ? I have around 6.5 yrs of experience.

like

Hi all, what salary range would be good for Head of Content (UX writing+ content strategy + direct reports) who reports to VP of Product at a series B, fully remote fintech company?
(MBA, 5+ years experience)

Who’s head of BA at Translation NYC? I heard the place was a mess a few years back but want to be optimistic and send my CV in.

I got an offer at Nokia, and my new manager said that she wanted to put me in the higher salary bracket however the HR insisted that we lowered the range. That caused me to receive a much lower salary than expected. Should I renegotiate even when my manager said that she tried giving me more. Does HR really play that big of a role in this?

like

Best alts to buy during the dip? Thinking about OMG, XVG, XLM, DGB

What’s a reasonable base salary for a startup BD associate? Series B, solid funding, and currently sitting at 3 YOE in strategy consulting

like

Recs for golf lessons? Once things are open of course.

like

In DC for Labor Day weekend with the bf. What are the fun clubs/bars here that we should try to hit up or any other cool events?

like
like

11/27 Check In 🙌🙌 What’s everyone up to today?

likeuplifting

How much hike and bonus did everyone get at PWC India??? Seeing mad gratitude posts on LinkedIn

like

What are people's thoughts on corporate Treasury roles, fortune 50.

What is the general compensation like and the career path after analyst? Is it more stimulating than FP&A? Does Treasury have desirable exit opportunities or do people typically continue the course and climb the company ladder?

like

How did you decide your speciality in Cybersecurity? Did you naturally gravitate towards one area?

like

What are the range of salaries for a Sr. Buyer who does the contract during the Procurement process? Remote so any range would help.

I was a logistics specialist E-5 in the Navy, then was a Manager at Amazon for 3 years, now I have 2 years with contract experience through IT software purchase.

I feel I'm being underpaid, and would like to see what some of the salaries are.

Thanks,
Mike

Additional Posts in Tech

Hey!

I am starting a job at
Capital One soon as a senior software engineer.

I was wondering if people enjoy working as a SWE at Capital One? I’ve heard good things, but am curious to hear what others think.

like

I saw someone else do this, so imma give it a shot. Lately, I’ve been applying to iOS developer roles and I’m getting TONs of calls and callbacks from HR and recruiting managers, but then when my resume gets pushed to hiring managers they seem to often get peeved at how little years of experience I have with the title “iOS developer”…
which is fair, and to show my credibility I published my first app last week, but I’m still getting similar messages from recruiters this week. Idk what to do??

Post Photo
like

Been working at my company as a new grad for almost a year, but don’t see myself in the team that I am in (working with Salesforce) for long term. Interested in frontend dev and have been learning on my own. Manager says chase doesnt have much React opportunities. Is it possible to make a switch when I barely have experience? Are there companies that will hire by seeing that I am willing to learn and am interested in frontend even tho I don’t have much experience with it yet?

like

Equifax What is the salary bracket for 6 years experience candidate at Equifax in Atlanta and also St Louis?

likefunny

Once you get into a FAANG company, is it better to stay where you are or move around? I’m a dissatisfied with my current job but I have vesting stocks, work 9-5, and people to know and respect me. I am the sole provider for my family and value quality of life and stability. I have some interview requests from other FAANG companies that I know pay more but I worry about starting over. Anyone switch companies and either regret it or are glad they did?

like

Hey Agency Owners, how did you started your journey from freelancer to agency owner?

like

I can’t understand, why in the big tech: data scientist = software engineer?!!!!! It is not… and it is huge disappointment when you ask for data scientist who can improve your results that you are not satisfied with, but you design all your technical interview around SE

like

I have accepted an offer for the role of Director of Data Science & Analytics and I'll be working with old colleagues. I am very excited. I haven't given notice yet because I am waiting for the background check to complete, but my boss just asked me about traveling to a meeting in November. I start at the new job Oct 25. I'm really struggling for how to respond. If I were not leaving it is absolutely a meeting I should be at. I don't want to respond with a lie. Any dvice on how to respond?

likesmart

Apologies if it is off topic.
My brother has over 20 yoe in electric and 10 yoe in solar engineering including owning his own small solar company. He is looking to relocate to US or Canada. Can anyone provide any lead on which companies provide sponsorship? H1B or Canadian work visa. Thanks!

like

Any CLT,NC businesses looking to hire for a Junior level Full stack developer / Junior Front-End Developer/ Technology Associate /Systems Engineer entry level / IT Support Engineer??

like

Hi all! Looking for some advice please!
I am looking to stir my career into a Project Management role. I have some work experience in managing IT Projects but don't have the title. Is working towards a PMP Certificate worth investing time and money in worth it or should I just apply for a PM role?
Thank you in advance!

like

Was asked for a system design follow up interview with Meta, any advice? What conclusions folks draw when called for a follow-up?

like

So I need help ! I received an offer for director position at pharma. How do I negotiate my offer? They are asking if I will be moving away from stock options, bonus and vacation. Can I lie about my bonus even though I have already received it? Will it convince them to give me a signing offer? Let me know please

like

Cont. from Previous Post 3 mos 8 rounds: Thank you for your interest in NR. We appreciate the time you took to apply for the CSM position. We were very fortunate to have a strong group of applicants to consider for this role and have recently filled this position. Unfortunately, because this role is no longer available, we will not be moving forward with your application. We will hold onto your application, and if a position opens that closely matches your skillset, we may contact you.

How much does a support advisor make at shopify?

like

How is mechanical engineering at places like Microsoft Google Facebook (Meta)? How's work life balance and salary, compared to the defense industry?

like

How easy is it to move from an investment bank firm to a tech company?

like

Hello all, I'm in the tech industry (networking and networks security) currently in France and considering moving to Canada in a couple of months. I was wondering about how much time in general i might spend searching for a job there, and is the french/europeane experience is taken into consideration in canada?

like
like

Hi,
I just want to understand how the recruitment works here in Canada. I applied for quite few openings but nothing is clicked so far, even Though my profile matches quite all criteria. How much a referral can work here, I tried to reach people in LinkedIn but most of the times I won’t get an answer for my ping. I literally feel annoyed and distressed. Can you please pour your ideas how we can actually search for a recruiter in LinkedIn and how to approach and how to atleast get single intervie

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal