{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Is this just happening with me?\nEverytime the panel says explicitly to me that I am a great match for the role and that they are passing positive feedback for my next round, recruiter goes Mia for reasons unknown 😢😢 How will I ever get out?!", "post_id": "61788650cd3ccd00340772a8", "reply_count": 9, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "5ae4a4f739e7cb001391ec8b", "bowl_name": "Consulting Exit Opportunities" }

Is this just happening with me? Everytime the panel says explicitly to me that I am a great match for the role and that they are passing positive feedback for my next round, recruiter goes Mia for reasons unknown 😢😢 How will I ever get out?!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Hang in there and keep trying

like

The panel may be BSing you. Nobody wants to tell a candidate that they won't advance.

Umm they dont really “have” to share the feedback in the interview, let alone positive feedback.. Ideally the recruiter would do it after the interview is completed. It is ok to interview and find out its not the best match.. both ways.. It is bs indeed 😒

Have you tried following up with the hiring manager? They could be BSing you but some recruiters are truly terrible - like to the point where I don’t even understand how they are employed.

Thank you A1. I tried this and the recruiter responded in exactly 60seconds. I am going into the next round now!

uplifting

Related Posts

I feel like I'm in a rut and ready to exit consulting, but I'm lost at what industry roles I should go for. I've focused on business transformation & process improvements roles CONT

like

MBB manager in Life Sciences: struggling to find a good exit. VC/PE - feels like consulting toolkit not really useful, and I’m competing with analysts. Big pharma - in my country too pharmaco not hiring consultants. Startups - don’t sponsor visa. Feels stuck! Any ideas/advice?

like

Is there an easy way that i can sell photography and stuff on nft markets without paying a big initial fee like open sea asks for? Maybe solana or Ada nfts? Or isn’t flare supposedly doing that too? I’m wondering there a platform where i can launch ultra cheap nfts of my mediocre photography and web art that may soon blow up? And then is there any point to this if i don’t have a social media following? Will anyone buy my stuff?

like
like

AMERICAN EXPRESS India is hiring for below role: Software Engineer- Hadoop, Pyspark- (Req ID -21029748) JD screenshot is attached. Kindly DM me if interested

Post Photo
like

Those who applied to BCG through referral recently - how long before getting a response on interview invitation or not? 2-3 days, 2 weeks? Experienced Hire, associate or consultant level.

like

Posting on my wife’s behalf - We recently moved to the US and she is currently looking for a good role in HR consulting. She has previously worked with KPMG, McKinsey, Korn Ferry and WTW in Talent and Org. consulting practices in India for about 12 years. She also recently cleared her SPHR certification. It will be a great help if anyone can refer or aware of any job openings in NYC area. Thanks!

like

Can someone explain to me why there’s a one year policy on applying to an agency? Like if I applied on my own and then 6 months later a new position opens up and I apply through a headhunter, what does it matter? Especially now.

like

Moving to San Francisco. Where are some less expensive, family friendly areas outside the city within a 45min or so commute?

like

Working as Consultant at Cognizant Business Consulting now, I am being offered a role of Senior Business Analyst as a contractor for 1yr, initially for 6 months in Deloitte IN. I am a bit skeptical with this Contractor thing. Can someone guide me please? They say I don't have prior Big 4 consulting experience and hence this role.

like

 STRATEGY JOBS! Part 2 Social Media Strategist - 2-3 years social media strategy. Production agency experience a plus. NY, Chicago, ATL or REMOTE * Strategy Director - NYC but Remote a possibility - major retail/e-commerce mega client. Please send resumes to JOBS@LASERTALENT.COM and write the name of the job that interests you in the SUBJECT LINE of your email. THANK YOU!

like

So I went through recruiting at ACN and the recruiter said they want to go forward with an offer. We discussed some numbers and she said she'll get back in a week. It's been 2 weeks and now I'm getting total radio silence. I was referred for the role and the guy who referred me also got a mail stating that they want to move with the offer. Anyone got any idea what could be happening?

like

Consulting gods are watching over you when your plan is leaving out of T in ATL

like

Hi 🐠! Class of 2017 here and found out yesterday that I’m being held back a year (as a 3rd year instead of 4th). I feel totally blindsided / actually cried on the Zoom. I’ve reached out to partner-mentor in other groups and they explained that this isn’t a demotion but an opportunity to have more time to acquire mid-level skills before being thrust into that role & failing. I GET that but I feel this is something that should have been messaged BEFORE the review. Such an erosion of trust. Advice?

like

Hi! May I get a referral to slack? I'm learning to not sell myself short even tho I'm a boot camp grad. I've seen a couple of boot camp grads land at amazing companies and I'd love for my life to change like theirs.

like

My wife is pregnant. Do the general courtesies of telling your manager/work beginning of 3rd trimester still apply during covid/work from home? Her industry has been hit hard and her job has been doing furloughs and layoffs. We can get pretty far without telling due to WFH but don’t want to put her boss in a bad position either.

like

Looking for Job change !! Come and Join Accenture . DM me for referrals.

likehelpful

Delayed at LGA? Why ? Getting the ice off the plane exterior. But hey, that means I can feast on the iPad breakfast ;)

like

Chances of flying out of DCA today?

like

Suggestions on the airline to fly from LAX to the east coast 4-5 times a month? AA is clearly not up to par... it's impossible to get upgraded, the equipment leaves a lot to be desired... thanks fam!

like

Additional Posts

If you got two offers, one at an MBB firm and the other in PE (buy side, lower MM) which would you take? I acknowledge they’re different fields but I have two offers and don’t know which path to go down. Asking for personal opinions.

like

I am 1.5 years postpartum, but due to diastasis recti still look 4 months pregnant. A) Any advice from moms who went through this? B) In the meantime, fashion advice for covering it up?

I feel like I'm in a rut and ready to exit consulting, but I'm lost at what industry roles I should go for. I've focused on business transformation & process improvements roles CONT

like

Any recos for a therapist who: - is in BK/manhattan - takes Oxford Health - is good for treating social anxiety - is female (preferably but not a game changer) ?

Would love to hear from the folks who live in KY and voted for McConnell. KY is ranked 44th for healthcare, 45th for fiscal stability and 7th overall for childhood poverty...are these good rankings for you? Do you all just hate children and money?

likefunny

Where do you start looking for new jobs if recruiter are not helpful? I’m bit lost in the process…..and not sure how to proceed. I tried to search for like top 50 fintech startup/healthcare startup….any tips? Thank you!

like

Hello all, just joined. I use a lot of ed tech in my classroom and would love to connect and exchange ideas with others.

like

A while ago I graduated college and went to a digital marketing agency for an internship. Two months later I was hired as an analyst. The person I was reporting to resigned almost immediately leaving me with the keys to a $10m retail account during Q4. I was in performance marketing. I learned a lot during this time but I didn’t know what I was doing and had no oversight (or help). It got ugly and I eventually left for another agency where I was on a supportive team. Does this happen a lot?

like

Folks who moved from MBB to a top-tier tech firm (E.g. FAANG): how does the talent compare between the two?

like

Any online courses recommendations to crack the FAANG product management interviews?

like

I’ve seen some of my colleagues update their LinkedIn profile with their promotion. Is it too early for that?

like
like

This question is for all the unvaccinated folks*… how do you think this pandemic will end? *unvaccinated because of personal choice, not because of medical reasons

likefunny
like

Why is Alaska Aor / Virgin America’s point system so confusing?!!

like

AMERICAN EXPRESS India is hiring for below role: Software Engineer- Hadoop, Pyspark- (Req ID -21029748) JD screenshot is attached. Kindly DM me if interested

Post Photo
like

Those who applied to BCG through referral recently - how long before getting a response on interview invitation or not? 2-3 days, 2 weeks? Experienced Hire, associate or consultant level.

like

Any thought on Havas these days? Also I have an interview with AisleRocket, is the online reviews pretty accurate? (fyi the reviews are shitty)

like

Hey all. Thinking about applying to ECG. Would love to get connected to someone who’s willing to share their knowledge. 3 years of public sector hospital healthcare experience and finishing up with a masters of healthcare management in august.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal