{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Offered full-time at McKinsey (mid-sized city, hometown) and Bain (large city) out of MBA program. Generalist roles for both, comp is the same. Moderate interest in PE post-consulting. Thoughts?", "post_id": "5d9be98b8cb7f7001c0452c5", "reply_count": 49, "vote_count": 6, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

Offered full-time at McKinsey (mid-sized city, hometown) and Bain (large city) out of MBA program. Generalist roles for both, comp is the same. Moderate interest in PE post-consulting. Thoughts?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Go with the firm that you felt the most comfortable in. 1. The people will determine how long you last at the firm and what kinds of relationships you’ll leave with. 2. Nobody ever lost out on a job because they were a Bain alum vs. a McKinsey alum. “Quality” of person is largely the same, and at this point the alum networks are so large it will feel the same on an individual basis.

like

I chose Bain over McK even with no interest in PE — the culture is just hands-down significantly better here. Here, people are smart and know how to have a good time; at McKinsey, my experience was that they were only the former :) if we’re talking alumni network, I’ve seen firsthand how powerful the connections are. McKinsey’s might give you thousands of people who will send a short response to your email, but former Bainies will give you a tour of their office, do practice interviews, and become real mentors just because you’re from Bain.

like

Hello, I have a round 1 with Bain coming up, mind if I DM you?

Recent IconRecent

Mck, stronger overall brand and alumni presence (in case PE interest wears off), and very strong presence in PE as well. Mck is also global staffing and COL in a small city can be a plus depending on your life situation. Are you pre or post MBA? If post, did PwC sponsor your MBA?

like

We do PE too. Pretty good at it. If it's just a "moderate" interest, you can try out everything else at the firm and either switch to something with a strong interest or go deeper into PE.

like

BCG2- Didn't connect level to quality, but now got it. So either Mck is over generalizing, VP friend population is not truly representative, or PE folks aren't as value smart or just follow herd mentality. Chances are a bit of each is true. Reality is OP would probably be fine at any MBB, but Mck is still percieved as the gold standard across several topics/industries.

McK because of 1) alumni network, and 2) if you’re just moderately interested in PE, there’s a larger variety of projects at mck (bc of scale difference) that you can do if you find out PE is not ur thing. But I’m probably biased 🥴🥴 honestly can’t go wrong w your choice

like

Yea I’d say Bain if the PE interest is more than passing, if not then McK. Also about to interview at both so plz teach me your ways haha

like

Strong PE interest go Bain, anything else Mck but tbh you can’t go wrong with either!!

Bain has very good training programs . The best in the mbb. Plus a hike staffing model which I think is a plus. Look at the culture of the company and the people that your going to work with. Should not be a problem getting a job in pe. Mck does 25% of all pe cases in the market. Either should be good from a career standpoint. Go with the company you would fit in culturally

Guidehouse knows what their talking about

Related Posts

Any HR / Human Capital Consulting 🐠 have an HR certification (e.g., SPHR)? Worth it?

like

I will be joining EY India by next week, just need few suggestions. EY have offered me almost 225% hike on my current CTC but all is in fixed part no Variable or joining bonus they are ready to pay. Should I try asking for Joining Bonus as I have heard the BIG 4's pay minimum 1lakh joining bonus to lateral Hires. NOTE : I am just 2+ years of experience ! EY EY India

like

What does an MBA start with in management consulting in Big 4 in the US? Say the person is hired as a Senior Associate.

like
like

Waiting for official offer from EYP in their legacy TAS group at mid to senior range of Director level. Does anyone know what signing bonuses look like these days? I know I can wait for the offer but my firm usually pays out a retention bonus that matches the signing bonus. Trying to start my list of pros and cons vs staying or leaving. Thanks in advance.

like

If you’re happy where you are and are not necessarily looking to change jobs, what would make you seriously consider going somewhere else? How much more, salary wise (in %), would make you seriously consider leaving? What else would you look/ask for?

like

EY-P strategy folks, have your CCL leads scheduled comp calls? Or just that email (If you got one) plus radio silence?

like

Hi Fish, I'm a functional SA at my current gig. May be looking to entertain the typical recruiter knocking at the door every 3 months or so asking if I am looking to make a move. Current comp is ~140K, soft-HCOL area. Any advice on open roles that either you enjoy or would recommend applying for at the mothership? TIA

like

Is FRM or CFA a better certification?

like

Interviewed with the UK firm and just heard back on the compensation. 44k Pounds. Fair enough? Or am I being taken for a ride. Above salary is for a Senior 1

like

What should be the next certification that I should get? I have the CFE. I’m targeting the CFCS and the ACAMS as the next ones that I should get. Any thoughts on which one I should get 1st? Pros/Cons

like

What’s the average pay and sign on bonus for a risk and finance consultant at Accenture?

like

Is there anyone who has relocated back from USA to India? What would be a comparable compensation for 160,000 USD Equivalent salary? ( PS- I have the standard world bank PPP value, want to assess based on market numbers)

like

Serving notice period, and seeking for more job opportunities, skill Business analysis, 8 YOE, BE+MBA, less than 3 months NP left. Please comment in case of any opportunities in your org. Any m or Sm

like

I have a potential opportunity in VC/PE but would have to take a significant pay cut for 2 years. Is giving up salary for 2 years worth the potential and equity opportunity down the road?

like

Has anyone experienced or negotiated with a shop buying out their bonus as a condition of employment?

like

Optum Insight vs CVS Health. What’s the better company to join in terms of growth and opportunities? Anticipating similar offer from each (slightly better comp from CVS)

like

any CAMS (anti money laundering)cert holders? what was your study plan like?

like

Anyone take courses/get a degree from Harvard Extension School? Experience? Was it worth it? Are you also able to build a network? Realize it’s not like an MBA, but that doesn’t fit my life now .

funny

Yo. Consulting manager job in SF at Deloitte, in studio. What is going salary?

like

Additional Posts

like

Have any women been passed over for partnership and believe gender played a role? How did you handle it?

like

Which T2 has the best culture in the pandemic environment. Why? What works well? Deloitte, Strategy& (PwC), LEK, Oliver Wyman, EY-Parthenon, Accenture, Kearney

like

Any recommendations for a new office chair for work from home?

like

Besides salary and benefits, what do you look for when finding a new job?

like

If I have a Delta voucher from a cancelled business flight do I have to use it for another Deloitte related flight? Or can I use it for personal travel?

like

What's the best career move after being an Enterprise AE?

like

Management consulting vs strategy consulting vs data analytics vs audit . How would you rank each of the following and why in terms of exit opportunities and potential salary?

like

Grant Thornton Tax manager or KPMG Specialist 2? I got a few offers recently, and now have to make a decision between Grant Thornton Tax manager or KPMG Specialist 2. GT has higher salary and position, while KP's people are really nice and professional during the interview, besides it's hard for me to say no to a Big 4 opportunity. GT is focusing on enterprise and high net worth taxes, while KP is focusing on energy mining industry tax and tax provisions. Hard to make decision!

like

What’s the interview process for experienced hires at BCG?

like

Male fish, I’m hoping to get your perspective here. I’ve been chatting with a guy from a dating app for about a month now. We used to text pretty frequently in the beginning but since our first zoom date, the texts are now maybe 3 times per day at most. (Continued in comments)

like

What do you think about Growth Hacking? I am a Digital Marketing Specialist but I'm very fascinated by this world. What divides a DMS from a Growth Hacker? You think it makes sense to make a role change like this?

like
like

Hi All. I am a Mom-to-be. Have ample of time to plan for the arrival. Looking to learn from the experiences of new parents here. Please share your experiences around: 1. Support system at home (during and after maternity leave) 2. Joining the workforce back after maternity leave. I have frequently seen women change companies after maternity leave. What changes at workplace?

like

Considering requesting a promotion from Senior 3 to manager (otherwise will have to go) Already doing manager roles, and don't want to go through another year without the title and appropriate comp.

like

What’s the best job in terms of an work life balance, high compensation and interesting work?

like

Looking for mentors in FAANG, MBB, and other Big 4. DM me please. 😀😀

funnylike

Would you wait for your company to initiate green card and wait for 10-15 years before your GC becomes current? Or, you use your Canadian PR and get pay cut, stay in cold weather, get citizenships

Is anyone available this weekend or Monday for a mock interview? It’s for a product sense interview (PM). Willing to throw in a Starbucks gift card

like

Dear Drogo5 peeps. How long did it take to produce the facebook covid work? Start to finish. And what was the budget?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal