Partners, directors and senior management: when giving an interview, how do you decide whether the candidate is a good fit? Are there things you look out for? I’m deciding between 2 candidates who are both equally qualified and personable. Only looking to hire one. What to do here

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

if you are not sure, ask them to have coffee with others in the team and get a more rounded perspective.

like

Go with your gut. Who do you see yourself working better with? Who is likely to impress more and add more value in the long term?

like

I consider how they would be in my team, would they get on with others? Have they got traits that are similar to low performers?

like

If both are equally qualified, and both are good cultural fits then I’d go for the one that is more eager / wants the job more. Likely to get a more dedicated and invested colleague

like

Simple, do inki, ponki, donki, poo.... Whoever lands on Poo gets the job to do...

Thanks all!

???? I’m hoping that you have a role and level competency framework, and your interviews are about gathering evidence of competence level and not ‘fit’ which is laden with opportunity for unconscious bias.

Yeah so as i said, both equally qualified and competent and personable

Related Posts

Hello, I’m wanted to move back to London. Can someone recommend a few good consulting recruiting firms to reach out to? Thanks!

like

Does anyone here work at PWC as a Salesforce Dev? Hows the work environment? interview process? Salary to expected considering 5 YOE? Any help info is greatly appreciated.

like

Hello Fishes,
I received a call for interview from Deloitte. However I don't have all the skills/exposure mentioned in JD. Has anyone cleared an interview with similar scenario in big 4?

like

Any insights or tips for CMAAS senior associate interviews?

like

How to fake my resume with project which I have not worked?

like

For in-house counsel roles, does firm prestige matter? For example, would the fact that an applicant is from Sullivan & Cromwell vs, say, White & Case matter at all, or is it much more about experience/interview? Does it matter as much as law school credentials? Assuming a mid-level corporate associate seeking to go in-house.

like

Over the last couple of months I’ve interviewed for a number of jobs and made it to second and third round interviews but never got an offer. My last interview was on Monday and I got feedback that I did not get selected because it did not seem like I was a a team player. Ive got three interviews coming up and l am wondering how I can improve my chances of getting an offer. Any ideas are welcome. I need a new job like yesterday.

like

JPMorgan Chase recently introduced a policy change to increase the notice period to 60 days. I'm a 602 and resigned recently and yet my LWD is showing up as 30 days from now. Anyone recently resigned can confirm if they are facing the same or new policy is in effect. This is causing confusion with the next companies I'm interviewing with.

like

Orally accepted a job offer that I’m excited about, but have another interview this week for a different job. I didn’t realize the first offer would come so quickly! Should I cancel the interview this week or go through with it? Small legal community- people talk.

like

I have cleared technical interview at @EXL and have also given another round of interview with VP.

Q1. How long does the VP round feedback take normally?
Q2. What are the next rounds/discussion to expect if I clear this round?
Q3. What is the level and salary that I should expect for a BI developer role at 6 years experience?

Anything else that I should keep in mind during the interview process that helps me land better role/salary? TIA.

like

I’m looking to apply to LEK soon and haven’t updated my resume since undergrad. I’m struggling on how to fit my ZS experience into just a few bullets and would greatly appreciate some tips. Would any one be willing to DM a resume that they used to lateral to LEK?

like

I like to apply for Product Manager roles at Amazon since I like the role. I have done front office CRM (SAP) implementations for Fortune50 clients through Accenture.
It is more of sitting with users to understand their process and map it to CRM suite and build additional features to map their specific processes.
I have also worked on sales, BD and functional spec creation for new features.
Can I count these as Product Management experience while applying for Amazon or other Faangmula?

like

Quick question.
I was a contractor for a big company and they just let me know that my last day is December 30th. I got this position thanks to a recruiting company that has been great and gives me benefits.
Should I:
- Continue working with the recruiting company, hoping that they will find another position for me? (as they told me they will, and when they applied me I started working with my current company within 2 weeks)
- Work with the recruiter + apply for jobs on my own?

like

Hi all, NEED REFERRAL in Accenture ⚠️
~ Analyst Roles ~

(Navi Mumbai or Mumbai office, priority in that order)

For more background I'm a Fresher with internship experiences in major startups.
Please help since I've been applying for jobs for over 4 months and no progress yet.

like

I have 6.8 YOE in compliance as financial analyst. how much CTC can I expect in UBS If applying for AO level.

Hello Fishes,
Can someone please guide me regarding the interview process at
Tavisca? How many rounds are there and how to prepare for it?
Thanks. Tavisca JPMorgan Chase

like

Top ESG recruiters?

Next week I’m having my first lateral interview as a junior associate. I’m very nervous because the group with whom I’m interviewing works with life science/tech clients and the attorneys have strong science/tech backgrounds; and I do not. However, I am very, very interested in transitioning to this practice. And I reaaally want this job because it’s at my dream firm. How would you recommend preparing for the lateral interview?

Looking for case partners, have final rounds with 2 MBB in 2 weeks (Preferably candidates in similar situations)

like

How does this resume look, as I have been applying and not hearing back, is it because I graduate in 2023?, Also I am at an internship right now but I know the return offer won't be good only 60k even though I will have my degree and CCNA

Post Photo
like

More Posts

like

Is there anyone who is into market research ?

Hey guys.. can someone help me with the salary bracket for Manager at EY tech consulting ? Position is in the US

like

I need guidance - was able to sell work through relationship. All I have is my LLC and a bank account. No infrastructure, no HR set up, no legal document. Who should I reach out to get help?

like

Anyone here know specific dedicated sites, channels and communities focused on Product mentorship?
Looking to build lasting mentor and mentee relationships on all things related to product, strategy, leadership and personal, work related issues advice

like

So, I just joined a startup. No processes, no clear strategy, just one goal: selling. Getting leads. When ever I try to build a strategy, they (founders) swamp me with blablabla stories and not a single action plan. Is this the usual at startups? Also,no real company culture. At all. No HR. I am reaaaally struggling to get a sense of belonging here. What should I expect?? Tia

like

Hey I am working for a start up company that aims to train people to become a tech sale and get blind referral. I am now struggled to source target users, and I really appreciate if someone could offer some advice please! Thank you!

like

Guys what should be the salary for AP? 15 yoe

Hi folks

I am currently serving notice of 2 months and left with 15 more days. Suddenly my HR contacts me that they want to relieve me in 2 days when it was agreed mutually at the time of resignation that they want me to serve full notice. I do not want an early release. What should I do now?

Please help with your suggestions

Any exciting NFT drops coming up in the next couple of weeks? Particularly looking for smaller projects on the Ethereum blockchain. Latest mint was Avarik Saga

like
like

What is the appetite for tax policies consultancy in North America?

Question: Why did you sign up to join the Latinos in consulting forum?

Post Photo

What are your favorite restaurants in Chelsea and West Village? Friebd is coming up for a week and we’d like to do an extensive food tour of the area. Looking for anything from a quick bite to fine dining. All recs greatly appreciated!

like

Does anyone have advice/ experience with disclosing or advocating for your ADHD support needs in highly toxic environments? Or getting formal disability accommodations?

I’m on a VERY toxic project where I really need accommodations but I am scared there will be repercussions if I personally disclose my ADHD like I have on past projects.

I submitted an HR request for accommodations and it’s been ignored for over a week.

I really can’t take another week of spending every day crying.

PwC EY Deloitte KPMG I've just landed a Senior Associate role with PwC as a recruiter.

How much are recruiters making across the Big4 to use in my negotiations?

like

Hey everyone! Any Group Account Directors in the SF area looking for a new gig? Freelance or full-time? Please DM me - my small indie shop is looking for you :)

like

Has anyone done/heard of the Morgan Stanley 3 year program? If so, what was it like?

like

Do you ever think that this is a futile process?

like

Restlessness has overgrown me 🙄

Post Photo
likefunny

Additional Posts in Londoners in Consulting

like

Hi fishers! I have offer and signed contract with Deloitte UK and my start day is in the beginning of April. I need skilled worker visa, and we haven’t applied yet for that. Screening and onboarding is in progress. Immigration team doesn’t reply since reached me out 1st time. How much time does it usually needed to go through the whole process? How many days take for visa to be approved since application?Deloitte

like

Is it true that EY pays no bonus to most practitioners?

like

Has anyone got a recommendation for a professional resume service? Especially for Data Science / tech?

like

Any recommendations for a coach (or even therapist) to help work through some career issues?

like

Hello, I’m wanted to move back to London. Can someone recommend a few good consulting recruiting firms to reach out to? Thanks!

like

Anyone have any idea what a senior strategy consultant at HSBC pays? I’ve had a browse through glassdoor but would be good if there’s someone that has received an offer etc to give a more accurate idea. TIA

like

How difficult would a move from Southern Europe strategy tier 2 to London strategy tier 2 be?

like

Anyone from Publicis Sapient willing to chat and provide a referral for SC role?

like

How long does it take for you all to commute to work normally? I am moving to Woking soon and am looking to land a consulting gig in London. It will take me 10-20 min to get to the train station, and from then on the train to Waterloo takes 30 mins. Not sure if that’s going to be too long a daily commute by UK standard?

like

Looking for referrals in London/UK. Currently I don't have work permit and would need company sponsored visa. 5+ years of experience in IT, present location is India, any help would be greatly appreciated.

like

Hey fishes, aside from the obvs candidates (fjord, Ideo, snook, deloitte digital, ey Parthenon, pwc consumer bit), who else is doing good work in the UX research/service design space? UK/Europe based.

like

Hi All, I am planning to move to a rival firm but have a notice period of 2-3 months in my current month. Has someone done something similar ?

like

What is the culture at KPMG London, especially for strategy roles and sustainability?

likefunny

Moving to London in September - looking for a place to live! Any recommendations on neighborhoods?

like

Has Bain London started rolling out interviews for Associate Consultant (Experienced hire)?

I have not heard for a long time so wanted to check.

like

Hi there, I’ve been told that Deloitte (London, UK) is going to make me an offer but haven’t heard back and it’s been over two weeks. The recruiter mentioned it would be around the “m2 grade”. Any idea what this pay range is? … I have 3 YOE working in NHS finance and have applied for a position in Risk Advisory, public sector. Curious what life at Deloitte is like? Does a work life balance exist?

like

McK & BCG Folks - Any news on salary increases in your London office? Do you think it's likely there will be a compensation increase by end of year or do you think they'll just offer a COVID retention bonus and leave it at that?

like

Any suggestion on relatively cheap neighbourhood for a mid 20s couple in london? - - Preferably less than 30 mins commute to Green Park/ bloomsbury/ holborn area.
- Would prefer not to have to worry about being stabbed on the street.
- balcony or a garden would be nice
- dont care about schools etc, wont have kids for a while

Would 15k per month be a bit too low to live somewhere that ticks the above conditions?

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal