Received a less than stellar feedback for a short project I was on. I didn’t get any ongoing feedback throughout the project so I feel completely blindsided. MANAGERS PLS DON’T BE THAT GIRL/GUY !!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

As a manager group, we used to hear this all the time. Turns out, in an attempt to not be total dicks, people couldn’t recognize when they were receiving feedback because we would cushion the blow and try to give it a positive spin when possible. We had to explicitly tell people when they were getting feedback to fix it. Think about the job - nobody ever told you anything at all about your work? They straight up reviewed every document/workpaper/deliverable, never asked a question and never talked to you about anything? That seems highly unlikely and you would probably be complaining about the horrible engagement rather than the feedback in that case

like

That’s so true! I hadn’t thought of that perspective

like

If you aren’t setting up regular touch points during the project, you should. Always.

likefunny

Yeah you need to pull it out of them - but better you learned this in a smaller / less meaty project than on a 5 or 6 month engagement

like

Plus that way you have backing to fight the review if you can show you had multiple sessions to collect ongoing feedback and never received any directionally negative feedback you could correct

like

I had that happen twice, once from a client and once from a sm. Talk to me people

like

It was about a month long and we had regular check-ins on progress throughout each week so I felt confident there wouldn’t be any surprises! I guess from now on I need to explicitly say the words “do you have any feedback for me” ugh

PWC1 - so weird, your post did not appear for me until just now! I definitely understand what you are saying. This was a document review project, super easy shit. My inventory of documents wasn’t reviewed until the last week even though I sent it in every few days and continued to ask how to standardize the data and more more info on the criteria for review. The feedback I received today would have changed the way I populated a number of columns had I received it earlier!

Did you need to request feedback? For small projects I tend not to.

What do you consider a bad review? What ratings in LEAD?

EY2- I definitely regret requesting it now! This cycle I had one project wrapping up (SM who I reported to was laid off), a couple weeks unassigned, then a few weeks of business development work, so I felt like I needed to request from this one

EY4- I got an “often” for quality and a “usually” for personal leadership. The often is what rattled me, I think I’ve gotten a couple of “usually” over the last year or so but usually along with better responses

Yeah, often and usually aren’t necessarily a bad review I would say, but depends on who you ask

That happened to me during an internship so I went with a different firm.

I think people just don't understand the LEAD rating system. It's a short project, and I'm assuming that it isn't terribly complex. You're basically meeting expectations with those marks.

Related Posts

like

Hello All,

Have a few questions regarding IBM Joining, HR response is strangely lacking and so does in the slack(prejoin channels). Hoping can be cleared here..
a) I've been told virtual onboarding is no longer a thing.
How many days does in-person onboarding activities occur?
b) HR Informed,"After onboarding is complete, can get perm WFH based on project or extension of WFH as IBM is flexible"
Is this true? Can managers extend/grant remote for a month then let us transit to remote model?

like
like

Hi fiserv,
How is bench policy in mphasis. I have heard that if you are more than one month on bench, you will not get salary till you are not assigned with any project. Is it true.

like

How yo check "base location" and "work location" in TCS offer letter? Will TCS follow this after joining and project allocation? Or will they force to transfer? (*considering the situation when it will be back to office)

like

How is Capgemini Mc Donald's project

Been on a project for 2 weeks and thinking it’s not for me. The manager is kind of rude when I ask for help/direction, but he always says to ask if things are uncertain. He always has this condescending attitude and just keeps telling me that he expects more of someone at my level, C. I just keep feeling anxious that I’m not meeting expectations and feel reluctant to ask for help. Anyone in the same boat?

like

Hello All,
I got selected in kpmg india and its been more than a month ,I hv not been alloted any project, what should i do ,should i keep my options open outside?do they lay off?

like

How’s Dell Project in EY India ? Any one in this group have an ideas on this? Kindly do needful

Happy Friday! Looking for an associate healthcare project management position in the south Florida area. If you’re hiring please contact me!

likesmart

How is the project for 'Tyson' client?

like

I keep starting huge projects or hobbies and being intensely into it for about 10 days/2 weeks, after which I forget about it and the project just lays around my house for months until I get interested in it again or I toss it out/donate it. It was fine when I was living alone but my partner is seriously frustrated with how messy the house gets and how much I spend on supplies for these things. How can I be less impulsive OR how can I stay motivated past the 10 day mark?? TIA

like

Larsen & Toubro Infotech I’m selected as a blockchain developer in LTI Hyderabad. HR is not disclosing the Project name. Are there good projects in Hyd location for blockchain? Please help me.
Thanks in advance.

Larsen & Toubro Infotech.

like

For startup founders/people with a successful side project: How did you get the idea/inspiration for your business? I’m currently working at a Series B startup and my end goal has always been to found my own startup, but I graduated from college 2.5 years ago and I still have not had any great ideas cross my mind. I do spend a fair amount of time brainstorming. I don’t want to continue working here forever, but I’m struggling to generate that “this is it” idea to build a company for. Any advice?

like

I have been approached with an opportunity at JP Morgan Chase for their private client advisor role. The book is about 30M all in. I am currently an experienced hybrid asset manager wholesaler and have experience in advising as well. Curious about the opportunity with JPM and if it’s worth it. I currently make about 160k and if JPM would give me a high draw for the first 3 years to build, and if it’s feasible to sustain that 160+ there.

like
like

Hi fishes!
Just joined an FP&A team with no prior FP&A experience and suffering with a heavy impostor syndrome. Can you please help me with what makes a high performing FP&A analyst?

My background is in project management for finance, model governance and RRP; Business Admin Grad - Major in Finance.
Thanks!

like

Hi.. I have received an offer from a consultancy stating for 3 months i will be on their payrol as infosys as client and after 3 months i will be moved to Infosys payrol with permanent wfh. I have other offers with wipro amd capgmni both with same package. Please help me if i can trust the consultancy and go for infosys option

like

Looking for a project manager for the next 6 weeks

like

TD Bank Private Banking/ Private Client? What’s the real comp structure? Glass door says $150,000 to $200,000 base with $150,000 to $300,000 commission/bonus.TD

like

More Posts

For those who use via fairly often: do you tip your via drivers?

like

SO excited about the new iPhone 14! I currently own an 11 Pro Max and never really upgraded because this one was still fine, but I feel like I want something newer. Has anyone purchased the 14 yet?

like

Sure is a lot of “herd mentality” going on with the Trumpets. It’s called stupidity 🤡

Post Photo
likefunny

New to 7th grade, any websites you recommend for ELA

like

Any urgent business analyst opening for 8.3 YOE?in bangalore?pls DM me.or comment

like

Does UBS provide any welcome kit?

like

How do referrals work? Do you apply first or wait for the referral, then apply? Looking for a tiktok referral.

like

What is L2 interview in coforge? Will it be more of a technical round or some Senior Manager regarding other aspects?

like

Does anyone have motivating/good sales books to recommend?

like

Finally a bowl of like-minded people! I love reading but finding it’s so hard to find people to discuss what I read.

like

What album can you listen to with no skips?

like

Any Canadians here who were on TN that applied for GC? Any caveats to be aware of during the application process? How long did the whole process take for you?

like

Can you negotiate with your consulting firm on green card sponsorship? entry level out of college

like

Any openings for freshers for BCA in CTS.. is Genc is still in progress?

like

Having 3yoe should i resign and then start look of jobs or wait till i bag the offer and then serve 90 days notice

like

Hey Fishes

I got an offer from gaming company @pragmatic play Hyderabad for SDE 1.
Not sure how the company work culture and work life balance and all.

If anyone has idea. Please do help.

Thanks in advance.

like

Hi fishes, I am a backend developer , my current CTC is 18 LPA. I am looking for new opportunities , I have 2 offers one was 24 fixed and then i waited for sometime and got 34 LPA (32 fixed). Should I wait more and look for more opportunities or should I join. I don't know how much compensation should I get at 3.2 yoe. Plz suggest.
ps: tier 1 college.

like

Hi Fishes I am in a complex situation, please help me out..

I got an offer with TCS and initially selected joining date as Jan 2.. but current org released me in 1 month instead of 3 months.. I asked TCS HR and others for early Onboarding but they didn't respond well..

After that I got one offer and joined immediately. But now I don't like to work here as I have to go to office all 5 days mandatorily, also role is slightly new to me.

How can join in TCS on the selected date ?
Any possibility?

like

When we get appraisal in hexaware what is the avg hike people getting in hexaware

Boston BioTech

I'm in the final round of interviews for two internal positions - both vertical. One has FTE's (my first such experience) and the other a much broader scope vs my current role

I had interviewed externally for a role on par w the internal roles, at a smaller and less established company. They confirmed +20% was in their range

How do I push back on my company if they offer less than that, if I do want one of those roles? Without a pay scale, what is the best way to approach?

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

Best way to casually come out to coworkers?

like

Is IT audit as bad as people make it out to be?

like

Started calls at 6AM and still have hours of work to do.... what a week!

like

For those of you who are high performance - were you top students as well?

like

Anyone have tips on passing REG? I gotta retake it. First time through, I read through the book and did MCs. What worked for you guys? Anyone do the Becker skills practice?

like

do any of you have a problem where it seems like somebody has been going through your workdesk while out of the office? it seems like almost every morning I come in, something is not where (cont'd)

Waiting for an offer, do they check references before or after giving offer? And normally how long after interview will I hear back?

like

I heard New Senior Program is canceled for this year. 👀

like

Anyone have the Jabra headphones? Are they worth it to purchase with the firm discount or wait until we get them for free?

like

What is the average salary for a controller data analyst role in industry?

like
likehelpful

Is the CFE pretty easy?

likefunny

Anybody ever used your internal firm Bio/Profile (obviously scrubbed for client info) to apply to other B4? Finding its a lot easier to convey value and understand my background with my bio.

like

FAANG is now MAMAA (Meta, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon and Alphabet)…Whoa Mama! As if there weren’t enough acronyms in our lives. Happy Friday All!!!

funnylike

What is parental leave at RSM? How many weeks at 100% pay, partial paid, and unpaid?

like

Two offers: (1) big 4 technical accounting in financial services and (2) technical accounting for a well-known PE firm helping their portfolio companies. Same compensation and benefits. Advice please!

like

Aside from pwc, are there any other big4 that are offering fully remote positions for external or internal audit? Don’t see any remote positions on the career pages.

like

Has anybody passed their CPA but still has their Becker login? Help a brotha out please?

like

Received an invite from EY last week saying they want to have an office visit this Fri. I confirmed and didn't receive finalized time/logistic even now. Are they just usually this slow or what?

like

I am thinking of moving to the Miami area from NYC, can anyone give me info on the job market and what the salaries are like there.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal