Salam everyone, family went and proposed to a woman back home in the MENA region(I am based in the Bay Area in the states), they asked for 20k usd plus gold as the dowry. But it’s throwing me off, I still have to pay for all the application fees for the visa and even her flights here which I’m ready to do. But the dowry doesn’t feel right. Am I overreacting?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You work in consulting in the Bay Area and are looking to get married but don’t have $20k for mahr? If so, you may have bigger issues to sort out first before taking on the lifelong financial responsibility of having a wife/family. You want a woman to move across the world for you away from her family and friends, but are concerned about $20k and some flight costs?

likefunny

Agree with VP1 - Interpreting Islam based on convenience has become fashion of the day

No you’re not overreacting - speaking from experience having married my wife from there. The MENA region has a warped sense of dowry, with figures like 50k seen as the norm. They live in their own little bubble and large dowries are seen as a flex. And just like the rest of the world, everyone thinks that Americans are walking around with wads of cash.

I went through this same process and had to deal with her uncle who humiliated me repeatedly that I “only” offered 10k - which all my friends in the U.S. offered their wives. The men started questioning, like the people above, if I was even ready for marriage, if I could support my wife etc. even though I make 300k+ a year. I almost had to furnish my W2 and flash my watches to show that I make money, because that’s what they respect in MENA. They don’t care about anything else about the clothes you were, the car you drive and the watch you were.

I ended up talking to my wife who was okay with whatever I offered. Her mother and aunts were also modest and religious enough to understand that mahr is a gift, not a declaration of wealth or love, and they were able to talk some sense into the men of her family. We literally “benchmarked” across multiple families to demonstrate we were not being cheap or unreasonable. The 50k figure didn’t even come from her but rather her uncle. So it ended up working well, but I was prepared to walk away if it didn’t because I wasn’t going start my marriage off with a list of demands that is not realistic for a household in the west. A mahr is ultimately a gift. If there’s concerns about whether I can support a spouse, that is a different conversation to haggling over a gift.

Yes, it’s her right to ask for whatever she wants - but Islam teaches us that mahr should be modest and ensuring it does not become a financial burden for the groom or restrict marriage. The point wasn’t that I couldn’t “afford” 50k, but that it would drain our savings and hurt us from saving up towards a house in the next year or so. We’re literally in a fishbowl here where something like 20k in mahr, isn’t the norm when household salaries in the U.S. are 80k. And if we normalize high mahr and lavish weddings, marriage only becomes more inaccessible to the less well off.

likeupliftingfunny

What's bothering you? Dowry is wife's right as per Islam and you cna have a conversation about it. She can even allow you to pay it over time.

Move to USA is an administrative expense and obviously falls into you. Later in life would you say that dear wifey, pay for your own tickets back home out of your dowry money?

like

$20k usd + gold!! I mean if OP is earning well and has huge savings, maybe but still it feels too much to ask for.

Gosh may this type of man never find me. Talk to your future wife!

likefunny

Thats fair, inshallah your future spouse is better and more well off than me. But I did speak to her, it’s all out of her hands as her father does not want her involved in that conversation. She was mad as she knows about all the other costs I will incur with the visa, all the back and forth flights to not stay away for her for long as the visa process is long, and everything else.

likesmart

Related Posts

Hello everyone!
I recently found out that I was being paid less than everyone in the team (more than 25% gap to more expe teammates, around 15% less than new hires)
We all had the same responsibilities, I consider I even had a heavier workload (talking in past tense since I very recently made an internal move).
Things to consider:
On a work visa
Non-white
Non-male
What would you recommend doing?
Keeping it to myself?
Speaking up? How? With who?

-TIA

likesmarthelpfulfunny

Hi Fishes,

I have worked as a contingent employee in JPMC in one of their project.
After how many days can I apply for a permanent role with them ?JPMorgan Chase

Does American Express gives the Diwali gift ??
Amex

like

Priority Pass (through my CSR) cancelled their relationship with the lounge in my home airport all of the sudden. That was a huge benefit of having the card for me. Anything I can do with Chase?

like

Does AmEx take codility test for hiring? Anyone who can share some insights?

Hi Amex peeps, how much time does it usually take to declare the results of 1st round of interview for lateral hires?

Thanks in advance 😊

like

I have a valid coe and visa of Japan how to search jobs in Japan from India

like

Hi, i am currently working as a Head of Digital Marketing in B2B space in Toronto. I am hoping to relocate to US for vetter pay and opportunity, Can i apply for job from Canada itself or now companies are hiring from US only. I can get TN visa.

Any feedback is appreciated, thank you

like

Anyone ever decided against joining a firm after accepting an offer and their HR initiating tier 2 visa sponsorship? Appreciate burned bridges but are there any legal/visa implications?

like

Is it normal in Amex that managers (leaders) are arrogant and doesn’t give a damn? Or is it just me with a sheer bad luck!

like

BIA Briefs: I’m an associate at an immigration law firm. I determined that immigration isn’t for me So I gave the managing partner my 2 weeks. He wants me to wrap up some BIA briefs before I leave however I’m reviewing the record for a lot these and I’m seeing that a lot of the arguments for Asylum, Withhold, and CAT are incomplete. How I’m going to argue that the IC abused its discretion or misapplied the law when we made a facially insufficient argument for relief?

What do folks think about the Uber credit card? I already have CSR and citi double cash. Worth getting it?

like

Need to get precheck/global entry. Should i get a credit card that covers this and cancel in a year, or should i pay it myself?

like

Where do people go after Visa?

like

I currently have 13 years of experience as .NET backend developer and I am looking for jobs in JPMorgan Chase/ Morgan Stanley/CITI. If someone can help me with referrals it would be helpful.

like

Anyone knows about the base for chase PCA?

like

Is it okay if I get fired from D after my H1B transfer for the new employer gets approved ?

I have a job offer in Australia and the company is offering to apply for a TSS visa for me. But they can't give me any idea on timeline. I've heard anything from a month to 9 months. Has anyone here gone through this and knows how long it would take during Covid times?

like

More Posts

Due to financial reasons I will be passing away

likefunny

I’m interested in joining a networking / professionals club in the city to meet other ambitious people in industry / banking / consulting. Anyone have a good experience with any groups like this? Thank you in advance :)

like

T20 spoiled ODI batting behavior.

like

What can i expect from Product Specialist role in freshworks? Like salary, perks, hikes, role progression and work life balance?

like
like

Any idea how much to charge for a 1 min video for gofundme page? Its for a nonprofit that is starting out. Its basically an interview and someone telling his story to camera,

Any M&A tax practices out there that will allow remote/mostly remote work in the future? Where?

like

What tax issues uncovered during tax DD can affect the FDD report?

like

Priority Pass (through my CSR) cancelled their relationship with the lounge in my home airport all of the sudden. That was a huge benefit of having the card for me. Anything I can do with Chase?

like

Anyone have experience with Nomos? Don’t have a lot of exposure there but a client recommended looking at them. Scrolled through their selections and loved the Lambda but it’s way out of my range.

Friend lives in Moscow, Russia and friends with a Sr manager of multiple rolex ADs in the city. Apart from the usual DJs, literally the only thing they apparently have in the entire city is a single Submariner gold TT. Crazy. And here I was thinking that I can outfox the waitlists

likefunny

White watch Wednesday. Loving this look!

Post Photo
like

Any good options?

like

Hey everyone, I’m a new investor and would love feedback on my portfolio. I’m looking more for longer holds with maybe a couple short plays just to stay in tune with the market. Any advice on improvements is very welcomed! So far I’ve kept slightly in the green thanks to JPM but want to see those larger gains everyone talks about.

Post Photo
like

Does AmEx take codility test for hiring? Anyone who can share some insights?

Did anyone attend the Salesforce world tour in London today?

Not sure if cringe… thoughts? Just seems odd but we also all have our own way of coping…

Post Photo
like

Which are Employee perk & benifits at BNY ?

like
likesmart

Additional Posts in Muslim Consultants

Haha it's a mix of product management, project management, product development, consulting work, technical stuff, analytical stuff. Literally anything the project needs to succeed haha

like

Jummah Mubarak Fam 💚

like

Anyone has used hydration pills to get through fasting? Is it helpful?

like

Chewy TUMS: These look so good but its not clear to me if its halal. How do you determine from these ingredients? Especially when the first ingredient is alcohol ammonium which i know its not alcohol but any clarification on these ingredients would be appreciated!

like

Any Saudi folks here? Alf Mabrook!

likeuplifting

After I eat sehri, I just want to lay down while my stomach looks like a mountain. Then I become so lazy to get up for fajr. Shaitan is locked up, it feels like I’m the shaitan, don’t wanna get up ...

funnylike

Thinking this is the year i iA find someone, prayers for all of us single 🐟 wanting to take that next step!

like

Any tips for having to attend a team lunch and a separate happy hour while fasting? Outside of Ramadan happy hours aren’t awkward bc I’ll just drink soda or something. However, now do I just sit there and stare at them when they are drinking/munching on their lunch ? 😂

like

Hijabi challenges/experiences in workplace?

like

Anyone here work at Tesla? Have a few questions about culture and work expectations

like

I know this probably isn't the bowl for this.

However, I rather reach out to the good folks here than have to rely on matrimony apps.

29 M, at NYC/NJ. Indian born, been in USA for 6 years. Work as a Director in M&A.

Looking to meet a like minded individual.
Anyone out here looking and in the same boat as me?

like

Jummah Mubarak Fam ☪️💚

like

36M here and I find beards / facial hair absolutely cringe. I feel like everyone has just gone for the 'I can't be bothered to shave' look for convenience. Especially desi guys, it's like a uniform now.

Anybody else feel the same?

funnylike

Age? Gender? Location? Fav food for suhoor and iftar? GO!

like

Anyone willing to give a referral for IBM and Deloitte canada, I am a new grad and looking to start my career in consulting

like

How do you single 🐟 find time to meet people and get to know them when working these crazy hours? Feel like I'm putting that part of my life on hold due to my job, and it's kind of freaking me out 😣

like

I started investing in Vanguard Mutual Funds and and did some research online today and it seems like we can’t do that and it might not be halal. Does anyone have any insights here?

like

Salaam, unsure if this is the right bowl, but does anyone have any recommendations on books that discuss the history of Pakistan? It’s formation, etc. Thanks

like

Any tips on where to buy cotton that’s not from Xinjiang? It seems like all cotton comes from there ?

Have bad allergies and need to wear 100% cotton.

like

Is working for a company that sells haram (Bank financial products, Walmart liquor products, etc) haram? Looking at an exit opportunity and part of (<10%) of their products are alcohol as a B2B seller. I want baraka in my earnings and want some help understanding this. Jazakallah

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal