What would you do? (You have $0 in savings)
Scenario I: $120k base + signing $20k bonus
Scenario II: $150k base w/o bonus

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

$150. Your bonus is gonna get taxed up the wazoo but you should do the math on actual take home pay and timing of it

like

I still can’t believe working professionals don’t understand that bonuses aren’t taxed differently than base comp. Smh. 🤦

like

$150k base all day

like

Do you need money today? If yes, consider the value of repaying an additional loan against the value of a signing bonus today. A1 is correct and incorrect. The bonus will be taxed highly upfront but you will get what's owed back to you when you file taxes later. So prepare to only receive ~50% of that figure net upfront. Otherwise the two options are effectively:
1. $140K this year, $120K each year following
2. $150K into the future
If money today is no issue, the clear answer is 2 if money is the only deciding factor

like

Are you expecting to get annual raises and bonuses as a % of income? If so- go with the higher base

like

Choose the higher base, unless:
(1) you live in a geography where bonus is not taxed/less taxed than base
AND
(2) you plan to work for 1 year and disappear

like

Alternatively if you need money up front (for say moving costs or down payment etc) if you don’t want to take a loan AMEX Gold let’s their members do a “plan it” for more expensive charges at a very low interest point.

For me I did this when I moved out of nyc and had to pay some move expenses and new security deposit, put them on the amex and did the plan it (so that i did not owe it all on the next statement) then over the next 2 months once I got settled I just went in and paid the whole thing off very easily and only got charged maybe 5% interest. Just another option if they let you use a credit card for some stuff and you’re in a pinch

like

Similar to this, the Chase Freedom card has 0% interest for the first 14 months or something like that, so you can spread the cost of moving expenses for a year over no interest. I used this when I first started as an associate out of college for moving expenses

like

You’ll feel the higher base long after you’ve spent the signing bonus

like

Scenario II all day everyday. Your sign on bonus will be ~14k at best after it’s taxed. And you will make that up with the 150k base within 6 months (excluding. Tax from your take home salary biweekly - 26 payments a year). Assuming you stay at your firm for 3 years you would have lost out on almost 80k, just because you wanted a sign on bonus (again excluding tax from your monthly take home).
Soooo I guess my question is, do you really need the sign on bonus for anything?

likesmart

Sheer numbers: 150. I would consider growth potential for both roles. Career is a long term game

like

$0 savings? You need to be slapped 🤦🏼‍♂️

likefunny

Maybe they were paying off debt 🤷‍♀️

like

pick the better job. these are functionally the same from a comp standpoint.

like

Bonus is a one time payment. A salary can only go up. Take the 150k.

like

I would need to know previous results and bonus structure.

What does your debt look like? And are you concerned about getting out of debt asap?

120 base w/bonus. Where is this so I can apply too? Lol

$150k

You’re keeping an extra 30k a year. Like are u kidding? Hunker down, don’t spend too much money on doordash and entertainment for a few months, build some savings and there u go

Related Posts

We have worked hard and invested into our respective professions!! i find it insulting what is being offered as far as compensation!!!

likesmart

Hey Folks can anyone tell me what hike we can expect from Senior 2 Year 1 to year 2 as progression in Ey gds in coming incremental cycle.

like

I recently switched to a developer role in a product based company from a support engineer for past 4 years in a service based company. I got a good hike as well.

Since I did it I think anyone can do it. Let me know if my experience can be of your any help.
Happy to help!

likesmart

Can anyone set light on starting salary of JD/ tax LLM (GULC), for associate in Big4 tax controversy and dispute resolution?

like

Hello Sharks,
I have recently got an offer from a real estate IPC for associate consultant, offering 7 LPA which is 33% hike Approximately on my current CTC,
Is it worth taking this offer?
Location is Gurgaon, can I survive easily in such a place with this pkg?
Please help!

like

I do sales for a major engineering firm. Focused on new business and exploring new markets. Last year I was in the top 50% for order intake, and first in number of projects won along with number of new customers. I think this is extraordinary given the effort it takes to win new business.

For next year my goal increased by 2.5X, and less of what I bring in counts towards that target. I really enjoy my job but I will essentially be getting a large pay cut. Lost in what to do besides quit??

like

Hi Fishes, Just wanted to know what is the salary band of associate 2 in Tax profile? Location is either Kolkata or Bangalore or Hyderabad.

Honasa (mamaearth) - what is the salary bracket for manager media position?

like

I have 5 and half years of experience. I am senior frontend developer on career level 10. My primary skill is ReactJs. My current ctc is 14lpa and with 21% variable pay. Am I underpayed..??

like

How much can i ask for Principal Product Manager IC4 at Oracle Analytics Cloud (under OCI)?

Yoe- 8
Cctc- 18 (have an offer from Thomson Reuters for 28)
Oracle Oracle India

like

Hi all, I have been in social services for about 2.5 years now. Initially as a Case Manager and now a Care Coordinator. I currently make $25/hour while living in San Diego, CA. Does this pay seem fair to where I live/the job description?

like

Do we have salary advance policies in the big 4s either in Indian or global offices?

like

Asking for wife who's also in banking. If she got ~$100k in signing bonus in 2019 for 1 year commitment in CA and started FT in July 2020, assuming she leaves before July 2021, can her employer claw back full amount in California? Some say it's much tougher to do so under CA law but wonder if anyone has any insights. Banks won't likely care about analyst signing bonuses, but associate bonus at EB with diversity bonus can be significant. If she quits before, she won't be going to another bank.

like

Hi guys,

Is it better to go for lead ba role cloud consulting company or scrum master in product based company?

CTC is almost same. Looking for career growth, learning wlb..please help with pros and cons.

Current role : lead ba
YOE : 5

like

Hello Fishes,
I joined Cognizant in July, but have setup my Goperform goals around October due to late project onboarding.
Will I be eligible for default hike after the new rules of appraisal?

like

Hi I joined bosch recently,

still I have not got hike letter from HR.

when will I get Annual salary revision letter?

BTW I joined in july.

like

How is the work life balance in Citi?

Here is the scenario: Have 2 offers from IT MNCs and 1 from Citi. Citi's offer is the highest. Almost 5 lakhs diff in the fixed component. Although money is important, but I am also seeking a little balance with life. I was previously in ZS Associates and to be frank, life was hell. I am not looking to relive that phase again.
What are the daily actual working hours?
Shall I join Citi or let go it for a lower package offer?

Seeking honest advice here.

likehelpful

Hi Guys, Any idea on the hike % for 2021 EOY appraisal for respective rating??
And also any updates on when it will be communicated??

Hi,

I have 2 yoe. My current CTC is 5.76. and in hand 5.61.

I am looking for a company where I get decent work life balance and a good hike. Can you suggest me an organisation for the same.

like

Any advice for asking for almost a 30-35% raise. I recently got an Office Manager position and I wanted to renegotiate my pay. It's a brand new location with branches nationwide. So for a few months I had to do everything myself since I was the only one in the office at this location. I did extremely well and everyone's told me I've been doing a great job. The company has been telling me I'm going to change and get different responsibilities over time.

like

More Posts

What’s the normal bump from entry level consultant to next step up? Ibm seems to be from 73 —> 90

Curious what other firms offer

like

Anyone have experience between choosing between an Industry position or making the final push (manager/SM level) for partner? How did you finally decide to go one way or the other and do you have any regrets?

I think I want to try someone new, and have an offer, but am having a bit of paralysis in making the move knowing the income/ partner lifestyle that I could be passing up…

Open to any thoughts and advice.

like

Do infosys still ask for 60% throughout academy for experience people as well?

like

Hi fishes,

How do I prepare for data science roles at FAANG?

likehelpful

How are onsite opportunities in Target ?

Hi, anyone here working in Lululemon Bangalore?

like

I am at salary negotiation phase with accenture hiring team. Somebody give me pro tips to fetch more CTC.

like

Hey flocks ,

Greetings..!

Few of benz employes have Udemy & Orally access , for few MBRDI flocks don't have Udemy . any idea how to get udemy access.

Thanks in advance.!

Thanks in advance.

Looking to make a change from Canada (Toronto) to Dubai. Any thoughts or Big4 Cloud Consulting roles in the ME? Deloitte is generally the global leader. Any thoughts on Digital/Cloud Transformation in MENA?

Anyone in MBRDI can you tell me what will be some of the food served there. I'm in wfh.

Hi all, i am working in product based. We are having requirements for .net full stack with angular. Kindly message me if interested. Location Bangalore

like

Looking for a good bluetooth headset, any reccos techies?

like

Is Mercedes Benz (BRDI) and Daimler Truck (DTICI) both are same? If not, Is it good to join DTICI as a consultant? Tech Stack: Java, Spring Boot - 2 YOE, Considering mainly Job Security, wlb, Career Growth. Would someone please clarify these doubts. Daimler Truck Innovation Center India Daimler

like

Hi,
I'm currently having an offer from BlueOptima and Cohesity and am conflicted between the two.
I have offers in the SDET profile.
Cohesity Inc is providing me MTS and @BlueOptima is providing SDET-1.

Glassdoor reviews more of less place the two companies almost equally, and the package being offered by the two is almost in the same range.
My preferences include:
Learning opportunities in the role.
Company's work environment.
Company's growth prospects, are also a consideration.
YOE: 2 years

like

Hey everyone! This bowl is geared towards all those open-mind professionals who love to cut loose when they’re not focusing on their careers. Any fun stories involving colleagues?

likesmart

Looking to sneak 2 days in first weekend of December with my wife. What would be the preference if you had to pick between Abasin or Loveland?

After completing 20 years as a Law Enforcement Officer with the Feds and on the way getting a JD and passing the Bar… trying to transition to an Immigration Attorney position… easier said than done!

like

Anyone for rough numbers for Counsel at Google in Chicago? Any downsides to being located in Chicago?

like

We have worked hard and invested into our respective professions!! i find it insulting what is being offered as far as compensation!!!

likesmart

Hey Folks can anyone tell me what hike we can expect from Senior 2 Year 1 to year 2 as progression in Ey gds in coming incremental cycle.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal