Anyone else getting pretty harsh feedback on your candidacy as a whole from Maria at applicant lab? I feel like I have a doable shot at my target schools based on gpa, gmat and essays but every time she reviews she suggests I have no chance. It’s been pretty discouraging.

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Who’s Maria? What’s applicant lab? Stop using janky people for help. It can be massively discouraging and unhelpful. Have faith and believe in yourself. Accept feedback with an open mind but make a call as to whether it’s a good fit or not. Don’t listen to everything your consultant tells you.

like

No one has a straight shot at any of these schools:
- Harvard
- Stanford
- Wharton (if you have really good stats, you’ll likely get in because it’s a huge class and they’re big on checking boxes in all quantitative criteria like gmat and gpa, etc.)
- Kellogg
- Booth
- Tuck
- MIT

I’ve seen insane profiles get rejected from each of these places, which indicates that they’re not just looking at raw stats. Just look at how much the average GMAT has fluctuated from year to year. They don’t care about having a class with the highest average gmat. Your stats are not the end all, be all with these schools. You have to demonstrate fit.

If you have solid scores, 3.5+ gpa, 730+ gmat, 3-5 years of work experience, you’ll most likely get admission at Columbia, Yale, NYU Stern, Fuqua, Carnegie Mellon Tepper, etc. UCLA, etc.

likefunny

You don’t need to look at one-off cases. Stats speak for themselves.
1) Tuck has a 35% acceptance rate. Columbia is at 18% and that’s even with a class size 3x bigger. Seems like Tuck rejected you to protect their yield or you were truly just a terrible cultural fit.
2) Cross admit data shows that CBS shares the highest percentage of admits with Wharton, Sloan and Booth, consistent with its M7 peer group. The same could not be said for Tuck, which has the most cross admits at Darden, Yale, Duke, Cornell, Ross and lastly, Kellogg in that order. SM1 is a clear outlier. Only Haas from the T10 has as many M7 peer schools from the cross admit data as the test of the M7.

Most of my peers from HYP undergrad had minimal interest in applying to Tuck. The ones who did unequivocally ended up choosing any M7 over it. On the contrary, I know many of the same peers who were rejected from CBS even with >730 GMAT and >3.7 GPAs, so I can hardly say it’s a straight shot.

Tuck is a great program. But to say that it’s a super elite school is just false, especially when deriding CBS as a “straight shot” school in the likes of Tepper, Fuqua, Yale....

Before you ask, I am also a Wharton alum. I was rejected from CBS but did not apply to Tuck.

likesmart

Their job is to make you believe your application is garbage and you have no shot without their help. I’m sure she told you even tho you’ve no shot but if you take a few more sessions with her she can help you put together something stronger which is completely BS. Don’t listen to some rando! If you’ve good stats, a strong narrative and story and great recs, you’ll be fine and will have a shot. It also depends on the school, if it’s GSB, no one has a a straight shot there

like

I dropped her services as she proved to be completely unhelpful and spending half of the allocated time to:

1. Tell me the app is garbage
2. Try to convince me to apply to schools that are way below my profile and stats (MBB, 750+ GMAT)

Every feedback is important as soon as it is constructive. If you feel hers is not, then just move on.

like

This is so weird... I have same or slightly lower stats and I haven’t heard anything like that from her

The truth is it’s impossible to know how you’ll do unless you see the essays and recommendations. Admissions committees like a good story. Of course high gpa and gmat help, but they need to believe the story

like

Someone else said that on here, is she getting overwhelmed with the additional review given the application influx? I’d do free consultation from some reputable admissions consulting firms and ask them your chances to compare against (use the reasons she gave you for a weak application), just to get some more data points.

Is this for the Sanity check btw? Do you at least feel she’s giving you constructive feedback to improve your chances? I have my sanity check w her coming up, getting concerned now lol.

like

See what happens, for me it was a pure waste of time

Related Posts

Why does EY not sponsor internationals working under CPT for one day masters program? Can we all ask for the firm? Or at least provide a better GEOC program.. They will send us to a random country..

like

I’m a defense-side employment attorney with 5-7 years of mid- to large firm experience. What would it take to pivot to an employee relations-type position? MBA? MHRM? Come as I am?

like

I have been in Risk Advisory for about 5 years but I have been feeling extremely bored with the work and I am currently contemplating my next career move. What are realistic career opportunities for me excluding technical accounting, internal audit and compliance? Would obtaining an MBA help my career prospects?

like

Hi Fishes, I've 2.25 Years of experience in SAP Basis, but I've lost interest in the same due to not receiving proper training, inability to practice on customer's system and shifts. I'm looking forward to go for MBA/changing technology, which one would be a better option? In case of the latter can you guys suggest lucrative technologies which has little/no coding and can definitely give good packages? I've tried changing jobs in Basis for nearly one year and didn't get through. Please help me.

like

Hi fishes,
I am currently working as a Data Science Analyst in Amex and would like to make a switch to Fraud detection/Credit risk modelling in future.(not in a hurry but would like to start preparing for the same)
How should I go about preparing for it? Is MBA the only course?
My current tech stack is Python, Pyspark, Hive, SQL, ML, DL(specifically NLP based). I have already done MS in CS from IIT Kgp.
I am confused mainly cause the tech stack requirement is similar to my role in the company.

like

Anyone leave big 4 to pursue a PhD not in accounting (another business field)? Who did you ask for references? Did you find that big 4 experience helped your application?

like

hi all! using a moniker for privacy reasons - i’m a graduate consultant at a boutique shop in Sydney ~3 months of experience after a bachelors in business from UTS (graduated earlier this year). my 485 expires in Oct 2024, and i’m keen to stay back after that - can anyone who’s been there done that share some things that i can start doing to help my chances of being sponsored? this might include things i can do on the job as well as other options like networking.. thanks!

like

Any consulting firms hiring new grad students ?

like

Any good books for someone trying to understand the business side of marketing? Just got my review an they're asking I bring more of that MBA mindset to projects I'm on.

like

Odd request, but does anyone have a post-TCJA international tax law school outline that I can connect with?

like

Anyone heard of/done the PowerMBA? How was it? Was it worth it? Should I just go to proper b school, overpricing & all...?

like

Taking my GMAT in 7 weeks. Just finished the large Kaplan book and have done 2 practice tests so far. What should I do next? Worth investing in a GMAT tutor? Getting 600 on practice tests but want a 690~.

like

How important is the prestige of the university where you do your undergrad?

like

Anyone go from a congressional or govt affairs background to an MBA program?

like

What are everyone's thoughts on executive MBA vs. traditional MBA? I'm currently pursuing a traditional MBA but sometimes I wonder what could've been 😅

like

I’m a recruiter who would like to eventually pivot to HR but I don’t have an HR degree. I’m considering pursing a Masters degree however am torn between HR or Org Psych/Org Development. Would love to hear folks’ perspective of either degree!

likehelpful

Is the international BA diploma worthwhile? My company offers but wonder if other qualifications such as AWS would be more worth while?

like

Who has a LLM from USYD? Would like to know your experience. I am starting first semester 2023 as a full time student and working. I have heard from friends doing a LLM full time whilst working (not at USYD though) that it is achievable but very time consuming.

like

Are there any other 2021 grads who feel super let down about their MBA experience due to the global panini? I ended up taking a safety job in consulting because of it and I’m miserable. I have asthma and couldn’t take the risk to build my network in-person when things were peak awful, but now I feel like I missed out on something critical

Hi,
I have just completed my high school and want to pursue my future in IT but I am still confused whether to go for data science diploma or networking or cybersecurity diploma ..I am not really good at maths and i am unable to decide for the fields due to lack of my knowledge and confusing information on the internet.. is it anything anyone could suggest

like

More Posts

Anyone looking for an apartment in LIC?

like

Bain & Company Looking to exit industry and enter the consulting field. Would anyone be able to provide a referral to Bain & Company? Would love to chat beforehand.

Many thanks!

helpfullike

Really curious to know if you gain a different amount of knowledge depending on if you work for a union or private. Does anyone have any input?

like
like

I haven’t seen such a good head slice since Equilibrium, or the first Underworld movie.

likefunny

Numbers in excel...

Post Photo
likefunny

So. MBA from a top 20 program (if that matters), working in the southeastern US with 10 years experience in private practice and hospital administration. Salary thoughts?

like

Hey all
Will any company allow an employee to join the Territorial Army while working?
TA requires at least 3 months of mandatory service every year.

like

So i have adhd and really bad anxiety. Seeing a physchiatrist that will likely put me on anti anxiety meds.

Has anyone with adhd here gone on anti anxiety meds without treating the adhd, and if so how did the meds affect concentration and memory?

like

EY fish - can anyone of you please share INSZOOM link? Currently traveling and need to access it. I don’t have access to EY laptop

like

Can someone help me understand (or point to a detailed resource) that highlights differences between IBM Infosphere, IGC, Information Server and Business Glossary?

like

Hello Friends, I have 2 questions please help to clarify.

I am joining in CTS on September last week so when i will be considered for appraisal ?

And also for variable compensation I will get in this March right? For this we don't need to wait for a year I guess.

like

Hello fishes

I am currently working as a SCM analyst for auto company. I now have a offer from a company for role of IT systems analyst. The JD is like I will be designing information systems that are appropriate for user needs. The user here are the production plants.

I want to know if this will be a wise move from my end who solely has been on the SCM side.

Any advice team?
YOE 6
Tech stack :
Inventory mgmt,
MRP/MPS,
SQL

like

Tops? Message me, I’m free this weekend lawlz

funny


Am I the only one who fears a third world war is among us? I've been studying the circumstances that led to WW1 and WW2, and let me tell you, we're not as far as they were. I hope the better judgment of people avoids such a catastrophic outcome.

like

Is there a legal or corporate law team in KPMG or other big 4s where they hire LLBs or Company secretaries? KPMG Deloitte EY PwC KGS

like

What are Senior Managers in the southern CA area making right now? Considering a relocation.

like

Tl;dr “Ask Daddy”

Billing hours to client be like...

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

Are you saying leadership seminars don't work?!?!

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

Did you use admissions consultants? Who was it and was he/she worth it? Advice on selecting one?

like

Anyone heard of/done the PowerMBA? How was it? Was it worth it? Should I just go to proper b school, overpricing & all...?

like

Taking my GMAT in 7 weeks. Just finished the large Kaplan book and have done 2 practice tests so far. What should I do next? Worth investing in a GMAT tutor? Getting 600 on practice tests but want a 690~.

like

Opinions on the INSEAD-Wharton Alliance?

like

Has anyone here gotten the Consortium Fellowship with the help of a consultant?

like

Anyone selling magoosh access? Both math and verbal

like

Does anyone have a good recommendation for Verbal tutor? Native English speaker scoring in the high 30’s / low 40’s and looking for some help

like

On MBA resumes, how should I describe my company? Work for a company that the ad comm probably won’t know. What details should I include?

like

If we take the GMAT online, does it actually take a full 7 days to get the results? Or do you have unofficial results immediately after?

like

What is the obsession and appeal for MBB among MBA grads? Is it really that amazing - from afar it seems like it may be romanticized (maybe not the right word) among applicants. I know it’s way better than the work I do now, so I’m not knocking MBB at all. It’s super impressive. Maybe a better way to phrase it is that MBA applicants seem to have a fairy tale view of consulting as a whole. I get the impression that people think a job in consulting is a magic ticket anywhere

like

I know that people say it’s all about story, but with a certain gpa/gmat score is there a “floor” that you’re safe on? For example would someone with 4.0/780 (not me) be pretty much assured at least 1 M7? Or is there a reasonable chance that all M7s will reject them? Or is their floor just lower (T15 for example)?

like

Anyone here have experience / know anyone who did the Luxury & Fashion Retail MBA @ NYU Stern?

like

do schools even consider the IR and AWA sections if they dont factor into score?

like

Have a 30minutes free consultation session with Stacy Blackman next week. Any preparation required on my end? I mostly want to get their thoughts on applying in R1 vs R2 for HSW given COVID deferrals

like

My manager asked me to help sprint this proposal. I’m out in 6 weeks. How do I kindly tell him to GTFO

like

Targeting 2022 matriculation and will be recruiting for tech. Currently at IBM tech consulting and have an offer to lateral to non-D big 4 tech advisory. What’s the best move for both MBA application and MBA recruiting - stay or leave? TIA.

like

Sponsored folks, where do you plan to intern during bschool?

like

Folks. Any advice to the question: tell me about a time when listening changed your perspective. I don’t even know where to start brainstorming - what are they trying to assess here?

like

Started as consultant, then promoted to SC. But my responsibilities were pretty much the same. Should I break these out in my resume as two separate roles with separate descriptions?

like

Leadership role in my state university’s alumni group vs leadership role at my firm’s early career group? Want to develop ways to show leadership for MBA applications in a few years. Thoughts?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal